Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School has banned Kickers shoes! I have bought them for DS. AIBU to to let him wear them and start a fight with them if they try to sanction him?

417 replies

CarefulDriver · 29/08/2021 17:48

DS is starting secondary school next week. The school uniform regulations on the school website dictate that they wear black shoes (no trainer like shoes). Fine.

I bought him a pair of Kickers as I wanted comfy shoes which will last him most of the year. I know from previous experience with DS1 and 2 that the ‘businessman’ style shoes don’t last if they’re playing footie at break! Most of the DCs at their school wore Kickers and so did they once I caught on.

Chatting to friend who’s DC is also going to the same school yesterday and apparently the school has banned shoes with visible branding on which Kickers have. This is not on the main school uniform webpage which is what I checked to get his uniform but on a sub page for new Yr7s which I had read but only skimmed over the uniform bit as assumed it was the same as the main page.

I spent £68 on shoes, which IMO are common school shoes, he may not now be able to wear. He won’t be wearing out of school either obviously! I got them online direct from Kickers with a 14 day return policy which has runout now.

WIBU to just send him in on his first day in them?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Totallydefeated · 29/08/2021 21:28

gosh, £26 for an acrylic cardigan for a 6 year-old is indeed shockingly expensive. My son’s private school jumper with logo is only £10 and there is only one shop it can be bought from.

I know!! You can imagine how I reacted when DD lost hers halfway into September last year! I was like a dog with a bone until it got found!

annacondom · 29/08/2021 21:27

The trouble is that if you defy their rules, it's your DS who will suffer the consequences. I've seen a little girl in tears on her first day at Secondary because the Head told her off for something similar re footwear. Wasn't her fault, poor kid. Your best bet is to get out the black pen. Unless you can sell them on, what choice do you have?

Totallydefeated · 29/08/2021 21:26

Just follow the rules set by the school YOU have chosen to send your kid to.

Wow! Where in the UK do you live where you have a real choice of school, ie you get your pick of schools, all of which are equally good, so you are able to differentiate solely on uniform policy and are guaranteed to get a place at that specific school?

I’m sure we’d all love to know!! I know I would, because where I live they all have virtually identical ridiculous policies.

Biancadelrioisback · 29/08/2021 21:24

@Heyha

The crux of this is the fact that the shoes seem to comply with one uniform list on the school website but aren't acceptable on another version. It will come down to the timing and communication of the change as to whether the OP is being unreasonable or not.

At one school i worked at we did indeed lend out permanent markers for kids to scribble out white Rockport logos on otherwise spot on shoes. This was during a period of uniform change too so we'd gone from plain black anything to plain black shoes- scribbling out the white was a compromise many parents who'd bought shoes with white bits on were prepared to make. It died down after the first couple of weeks.

It's hard because technically they don't comply with either. They aren't just black shoes. They are black shoes with red and green writing on and tags. But, if I searched for black school shoes online, kickers do come up. And if it wasn't for me using this site, I wouldn't necessarily know these wouldn't be acceptable as they are (to me) clearly school shoes and pretty much black. I would class these as black shoes. But I can also see why they don't comply because they aren't fully black.
HaveringWavering · 29/08/2021 21:23

@Totallydefeated gosh, £26 for an acrylic cardigan for a 6 year-old is indeed shockingly expensive. My son’s private school jumper with logo is only £10 and there is only one shop it can be bought from.

Merryoldgoat · 29/08/2021 21:23

@FrippEnos

No, it’s the ridiculous no branding rule that OP is rightly pissed off with.

Kickers are durable and fit well. Those little tabs would’ve been fine at my school.

They also weren’t so ridiculous to think that expressing some individuality would somehow affect learning.

I work at a private school. The head of English has a pierced nose and was wearing green sparkly DMs before end of term.

The boy pupils have utterly insane hair from long as a rockstar to Mohawks.

The RS teacher wears DMs and studded jackets.

The bursar wears leopard print a lot.

The Assistant Head wears skinny trousers a lot.

The pupils are among the best performing in the Borough and go to the top schools when leaving.

No one is looking at the shoes they wear.

Lightisnotwhite · 29/08/2021 21:22

Blackmail! Seriously gave a word. You are free to hone Ed or send your child to a non school uniform school - list here
non school uniform thread

And it’s not ruining a shoe to black out its branding. What happens to its amazing abilities as a shoe. Nothing. It’s just not worth £68 ( sort of the point).

Totallydefeated · 29/08/2021 21:20

Agreed, but they can at least reduce the pressure on poor families by banning ludicrously expensive brands. When I was at school, the poorest kids often had all the name brands, their parents would get it through catalogues and be skint all year paying it back. The poorest families are the ones who feel the most pressure not to show how poor they are.

I agree with you in the main and wouldn’t want to see kids competing over Air Pods and the latest phone, though it’s sadly inevitable and will happen outside of school even if reduced inside it (it’ll never be stamped out entirely even with the strictest of policies). But Kickers are practical.

At my DD’s state primary, the uniform can only be bought from John Lewis, so no getting cheap generic items from Sainsburys or Asda and the logo-ed items are v expensive - £26 for an acrylic cardigan for a six year old! Now THAT makes me cross, as it stops poorer families buying cheaper versions. And I resent paying it myself as I feel ripped off. The one saving grace is that there are frequent second hand sales at school.

Karlee30 · 29/08/2021 21:20

I would send him in them. By brand I assume they don't mean Adidas, Nike etc? Not kickers? It is a brand of course but I would say very suitable for school shoes. Bleddy ridiculous rules.

HaveringWavering · 29/08/2021 21:19

The crux of this is the fact that the shoes seem to comply with one uniform list on the school website but aren't acceptable on another version. It will come down to the timing and communication of the change as to whether the OP is being unreasonable or not.

@heyha the OP has said that the part of the website she followed said “black suitable shoes”. She has bought black, green and red shoes. And now she thinks that it would be child abuse if a teacher pointed this out.

Heyha · 29/08/2021 21:16

They did this AFTER we'd had the conversation with the parents of course, we didn't just vandalise the shoes!

thebeatingofthedrums · 29/08/2021 21:14

I dunno, if I'd paid £68 for a pair of shoes, I wouldn't want to deface them either, regardless of the brand. I had a look at the shoes, and I think it would be quite fiddly to cut out the small tags without accidentally then slicing through the leather where the stitching is. I wouldn't recommend it.

I don't like the logo at the back, but there's no way to cover it without visibly ruining the shoe - I mean, it's a black nail polish job.

If it was as simple as cutting off one little tag, I'd recommend it, but here you'd need a bit of skill, and you'd need to permanently deface the shoes. Which are new. It just feels wrong spending that amount of money on something to then deliberately ruin it!

Heyha · 29/08/2021 21:14

The crux of this is the fact that the shoes seem to comply with one uniform list on the school website but aren't acceptable on another version. It will come down to the timing and communication of the change as to whether the OP is being unreasonable or not.

At one school i worked at we did indeed lend out permanent markers for kids to scribble out white Rockport logos on otherwise spot on shoes. This was during a period of uniform change too so we'd gone from plain black anything to plain black shoes- scribbling out the white was a compromise many parents who'd bought shoes with white bits on were prepared to make. It died down after the first couple of weeks.

NotMeNoNo · 29/08/2021 21:14

I vote for snip off the little tabs (no function) and as pp said a bit of black tape on the back, or you could get a cobbler to glue on a small leather patch. It's not defacing, it's worth it to alter them because the alternative is having to buy totally new shoes.

FrippEnos · 29/08/2021 21:14

@Merryoldgoat

But do you realise that there will always be a dress code for pupils to follow?

That’s fine.

When I was at school it was:

Black jumper or cardigan
Black skirt or trousers
White shirt or polo shirt
Black shoes

Zero issues.

If kids are bullied for not having the latest stuff THAT’S what needs dealing with - not isolation or detention for fucking labels on shoes.

Interestingly its the black shoes rule that the OP is complaining about.
RumpoleoftheBaileys · 29/08/2021 21:12

This is batshit.

There is nothing wrong with those shoes. They look durable and exactly like a pair of school footwear (what else would they be used for?)

Whilst they have red and green on, those parts are minimal and not distracting.

I'm with the OP - the idea of using a pen to colour bits in is ridiculous.

BuggerOffAndGoodDayToYou · 29/08/2021 21:09

@BuggerOffAndGoodDayToYou

Kickers were specifically banned in my DCs secondary schools. One a state grammar, one a state comprehensive. Both DCs now adults….
…and DD did have to wear custom orthotics in primary and the first few years of secondary. She always wore Clarks shoes…..
Ponoka7 · 29/08/2021 21:08

"Just follow the rules set by the school YOU have chosen to send your kid to."

We don't all get to choose. We pick three schools and are allocated a place. All three schools could have the exact same nonsensical uniform rules. Such as no boots, but no lockers, yet we want children to walk to school. Some people only really have one choice of school, depending on were they live.

@AlfonsoTheMango, parents are blackmailed by the use of isolation (emotionally damaging) and expulsion. There have been parents who've had to get the press involved so their DDs can wear trousers, or their black child wear their hair a certain way. So let's not pretend that some schools don't have control freaks on the board of governors, or as Heads.

For those saying that there's help for poorer families, the only help Is second hand uniforms, collected by local community groups, in some areas.

sjxoxo · 29/08/2021 21:08

I don’t have DCs at school but when I was at secondary Kickers were common place - we never thought they were a ‘cool’ brand like Nike or Jane Norman (at the time!!)- they were seen as just boring but comfy long lasting school shoes? I’m a bit surprised to get the impression from this thread they are ‘cool’ and expensive! If they are £68 as stated previously in this thread, is that really expensive for a pair of shoes that will be worn every single day of the school year for a whole year? I think that’s good value.. or at least fairly normal for the wear & tear? Let’s take work shoes got example- I think most people spend £25-100 on various pairs of shoes; and wear these across different days at work across a year.. I expect the average is more than a £68 spend? I understand not everyone can afford that but didn’t realise they are seen as a status symbol with a price tag of £68.. xo

fabulouslyglamorousferret · 29/08/2021 21:07

For anyone that is looking for decent school shoes - look at 'Treads' indestructible shoes. Typically fashion conscious DCs have worn these throughout high school and they truly are indestructible!!

simitra · 29/08/2021 21:07

This kind of stupidity will continue until the majority of parents band together and start to lash back and refuse to be blackmailed.

alexio · 29/08/2021 21:07

If it's not on the website/uniform information just say you had no idea about the 'no kickers rule' and that you won't be paying for another pair of shoes as they are smart black shoes that the policy states.

Lightisnotwhite · 29/08/2021 21:06

@Totallydefeated

It seems that the main criterion for schools when deciding what they will deign to allow pupils to wear is whatever they really don’t want to wear - I.e. let’s see what pupils want to wear and make sure we say they can’t wear that.

Kickers seem like eminently sensible school shoes to me - robust, weather-proof and good for feet. Far better, more practical and hard-wearing than flat, thin business-man shoes that are uncomfortable and bad for feet. Why would you want to force growing feet into shoes that are worse for them?

When flares were in fashion, schools complained about them and banned them - too wide - then when skinnies were in they didn’t like those either - no longer too wide but too skinny. No mini skirts, but no long skirts either. Basically, they seem to want all the girls dressed like Margaret Rutherford playing Miss Marple and all the boys looking like a bank manger from the 1950s. Why????

All the stuff about level playing fields sounds plausible but just doesn’t work in real life. Kids can tell when somebody has less money regardless of uniform and bullies always find something to bully about.

Similarly, the tripe about going to another school if you don’t like the uniform policy is further bilge that sounds plausible but is completely impractical. Try finding a school with a sensible dress policy and see how far you get, they’ve all fallen hook, line and sinker for the uniform ideology.

It all just seems like a massive ego trip on the part of HTs, rather than anything that might actually benefit pupils. Or perhaps some way of forcing pupils to conform, so they grow up to be good little worker bees, rather than anybody who might think for themselves or question the status quo.

I just wish we could grow up in the country, take this silly focus off appearance and focus on what should be the real business of school life - learning.

Yet if you let kids chose what to wear they all wear much the same thing because they are little conformists. Be it boho charity shop style or Canada Goose knock offs, Kickers or Doc Martens or whatever else is doing the rounds.

At least school rules gives them something to rebel against.

Sirzy · 29/08/2021 21:03

Ds has custom made orthotics. The best fit shoes we have have found are some boots from Clark’s. My nephew also has orthotics and and wears the same boots as they fit him too

Thevoiceofreason2021 · 29/08/2021 21:01

You didn’t read the rules. Send the kickers back and buy a school approved pair.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread