Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School has banned Kickers shoes! I have bought them for DS. AIBU to to let him wear them and start a fight with them if they try to sanction him?

417 replies

CarefulDriver · 29/08/2021 17:48

DS is starting secondary school next week. The school uniform regulations on the school website dictate that they wear black shoes (no trainer like shoes). Fine.

I bought him a pair of Kickers as I wanted comfy shoes which will last him most of the year. I know from previous experience with DS1 and 2 that the ‘businessman’ style shoes don’t last if they’re playing footie at break! Most of the DCs at their school wore Kickers and so did they once I caught on.

Chatting to friend who’s DC is also going to the same school yesterday and apparently the school has banned shoes with visible branding on which Kickers have. This is not on the main school uniform webpage which is what I checked to get his uniform but on a sub page for new Yr7s which I had read but only skimmed over the uniform bit as assumed it was the same as the main page.

I spent £68 on shoes, which IMO are common school shoes, he may not now be able to wear. He won’t be wearing out of school either obviously! I got them online direct from Kickers with a 14 day return policy which has runout now.

WIBU to just send him in on his first day in them?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
theemperorhasnoclothes · 30/08/2021 13:06

Interesting responses. I suppose as with everything different people / schools have different experiences.

My feeling on rules is that it's fine as a parent to challenge direct to the rule makers and question why the rules exist and question where exactly the line is drawn, but it's not ok to just send your child into school knowing you're breaking the rules - no matter how idiotic you may think they are.

Totally different matter if it's the child breaking the rules!

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 30/08/2021 12:39

It always seems to be this particular brand at the centre of the 'back to school' rows. For this reason alone when my child goes to secondary they are one I'll be avoiding.

FWIW, I'm vehemently anti-uniform. It has zero to do with educational standards, and it sticks completely in the craw when serious misbehaviour like bullying is routinely ignored and the victims end up suffering twice. America, Scandinavia, the European continent and pretty much everywhere else seems to function amply well without it, and many of these countries have a higher level of RRR achievement than we do here in the UK.

But them's the rules, innit?

I believe unquestioning, uncritical adherence to nonsensical rules, together with a dumbing down of educational standards isn't great for anyone. (The dumbing down isn't the fault of the kids, BTW; one generation isn't miraculously more stupid or intelligent than prior ones, and they can only work with the rubbish systems put in front of them). But the dumbing down is real. I'm a university lecturer and see at first-hand the damage done in the pre-16 sector. We have to undo all this once they arrive in higher education, rather than do what we are actually there to do: the point of HE is that it builds on something. Many arrive without the ability to string a cogent sentence together.

The draconian guidelines regulating today's schoolwear is beyond ridiculous, and I do feel for the teachers who have to police this utter nonsense. In the meantime, I sigh and go along with it because it's only the children who will suffer otherwise, and it's the conventional (ridiculous and unnecessary) norm in this country.

spongedog · 30/08/2021 12:39

@HavelockVetinari

The reason schools ban these shoes is that many families can't afford almost £70 for school shoes - secondary schools are the worst for brand snobbery, and I remember kids without the "right" shoes/coat/bag being teased constantly.

You can obviously afford them, but there'll be lots of families who can't. And a family who can afford £70 shoes that likely won't last a year due to puberty growth can afford to replace them with Clarks etc.

I had to replace my son's shoes this summer as I bought online and they didnt fit. The 1st pair £70. Replaced them with Clarks (as we managed to get a proper fitting session) - £55. So not a huge difference in price.
FedUpAtHomeTroels · 30/08/2021 12:13

They look like nice shoes OP.
I'd get a black sharpie and colour over the red and green bits and use them anyway.

MadameMinimes · 30/08/2021 11:52

@theemperorhasnoclothes I am a teacher and senior leader in a school. I know that is the theory, but I really think it’s nonsense. Our students have no problem sticking to bigger rules. If anything, I think they behave much better when they get the sense that we don’t have rules for the sake of having rules. They understand that we’re a lot more worried about them being polite and working hard than what they wear.

I’ve had three HTs in my time at the school. Under the first, uniform was much stricter and academic performance nowhere near as good. Our school improved academic standards massively by choosing non-negotiables carefully. Whether kids have little green tags on their shoes doesn’t make that list. Working hard in class, being respectful of staff and your peers, treating others with kindness, wearing the uniform, not doing anything dangerous or disruptive are all non-negotiable. Having exactly the right shade of navy tights or having a small logo on your black school shoes, not worth worrying about.

TSSDNCOP · 30/08/2021 11:46

I just showed them to my 14 yo.

His take:

No way would I get away with them, I'm not getting them am I?
The colours are helpful for people who can't tell their lefts and rights
All my friends have Clark's

FrippEnos · 30/08/2021 11:41

theemperorhasnoclothes

Would be interested in a teacher's view on this.

Its not so much that its an easy win for the school, but an easy rule to break with no real consequences for anyone.

I always thought that if pupils were busy breaking these rules they generally don't try and break other rules as its an easy win for them.

RosesAndHellebores · 30/08/2021 11:40

Mine are older now but DS's London day school had an expensive blazer and trimmed Jersey. Trousers and shirts could come from anywhere. I don't recall shoes being a problem, everyone just bought plain black lace ups - is that a problem nowadays?

DD's cofe state in Yrs 7/8 was similar to her independent thereafter. Except for the kilt. Both were about £500. My only beef was why it was necessary to have blouses with a coloured stripe which were £37.50 for two. They did however last for years and I know are still being worn by a little sister.

It's an age old issue. When I was at school it was all about dark green socks in the rain so the splashes didn't show; now it's logis on shoes. Surely the key issue should be the protection of and development of healthy feet regardless of shoe colour/writing on them. I recall at the cofe dd having a very modest pair of stud earrings confiscated due to rules. The rules were small stud earrings. A tiny knot not exceeding 2.5mm fell into that imo therefore I think it's largely a power issue and one that is not always dealt with fairly across the board with lary dc or favourites often escaping the rules.

Whilst never having an issue with uniform, some of the pettiness was unacceptable and imo French children in their jeans, jersey/hoody and trainers look far better than the average English schoolchild in a rolled up skirt, ankle socks and polyester blazer. There is no way that cheap wannabee tailored clothes ever look anything but cheap. One would really expect those who run schools to know that.

FrippEnos · 30/08/2021 11:38

Remember your taxes pay their wages - they work for you.

Stupid has entered the building.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 30/08/2021 11:30

[quote MadameMinimes]@CecilyP Spot on! Enforcing uniform rules is an easy win. You can get compliance relatively easily if you are happy to spend the first couple of weeks of term calling parents and putting kids into isolation. Once that settles down you’ll end up with very high levels of compliance.

The question is, what purpose does it all serve in the end? What educational advantage is the school buying for their students with that investment of staff time? Staff time is a precious resource. We wouldn’t to want to waste a whole load of it in September, when staff and students are fresh and some of the best learning takes place, on dealing with students who are wearing the “wrong” kind of black leather school shoes.[/quote]
I'm guessing that enforcing an easily enforceable rule early on and sending the message that the rules are there for a reason and will be enforced results in better adherence to all the rules and is perhaps why it's done. Freeing up staff time to teach later on.

Would be interested in a teacher's view on this.

CecilyP · 30/08/2021 11:15

Why on earth do kickers brand their shoes so prominently? I hate this in general anyway. They must know loads of schools won't allow it.

They've branded their shoes in this way for over 40 years, why should they stop now.

Of course they do it because it signals the cost. Surely they try and make at least one or two styles more school friendly? I would expect they'd still exchange them if asked.

Why would you expect them to do that? Why are Kickers rules less important than school rules?

MadameMinimes · 30/08/2021 11:14

@CecilyP Spot on! Enforcing uniform rules is an easy win. You can get compliance relatively easily if you are happy to spend the first couple of weeks of term calling parents and putting kids into isolation. Once that settles down you’ll end up with very high levels of compliance.

The question is, what purpose does it all serve in the end? What educational advantage is the school buying for their students with that investment of staff time? Staff time is a precious resource. We wouldn’t to want to waste a whole load of it in September, when staff and students are fresh and some of the best learning takes place, on dealing with students who are wearing the “wrong” kind of black leather school shoes.

CecilyP · 30/08/2021 11:11

Just looked at Treads, these are the only ones available in DS’s size but will they be classed as trainers do we think, despite clearly not being 🤔?

Given that they are described as trainer style I would imagine so... are you determined to undermine every school policy or just the shoe/uniform one?

Looking at a shoe on a website, as suggested by another poster (then thinking that they possibly won't be acceptable) is in no way showing any determination to undermine school policy. What made you think it was?

theemperorhasnoclothes · 30/08/2021 11:10

I am sure the school would be happy to discuss and / or clarify their rules with you OP. However just sending your DS in wearing something that may not be acceptable when you have actually read the rules and know about this potential problem is disrespectful to the school and unfair to your DS.

I do sometimes wonder if schools have ridiculously tight rules in some areas just to identify the families who think rules don't apply to them.

Why on earth do kickers brand their shoes so prominently? I hate this in general anyway. They must know loads of schools won't allow it.

Of course they do it because it signals the cost. Surely they try and make at least one or two styles more school friendly? I would expect they'd still exchange them if asked.

But as others have said, some permanent marker / black tape would solve the problem.

over2021 · 30/08/2021 10:53

[quote CarefulDriver]Just looked at Treads, these are the only ones available in DS’s size but will they be classed as trainers do we think, despite clearly not being 🤔?

www.treads-shoes.com/boys/school-shoes/brooklyn[/quote]
Given that they are described as trainer style I would imagine so... are you determined to undermine every school policy or just the shoe/uniform one?

over2021 · 30/08/2021 10:49

@CarefulDriver

They have the name on the heel as well in big letters in bright green and red as well as the tag on the front though.

Why should I have to deface a brand new pair shoes just because of a stupid rule they’ve just brought in Angry.

Kids have been wearing Kickers to school for years!

Why do we have to put up with this crap?

Probably best he doesn't wear them anyway- they don't sound like secondary shoes to me.

Fwiw my DD's school is super strict about shoes- she would be put in isolation until she had the correct uniform. Probably a weeks' exception for Y7s but not the best start...

CecilyP · 30/08/2021 10:48

c) Following the school rules is part of “basic manners ,kindness tolerance”. You don’t just do what you want in life because you feel entitled to.

You've banded all rules together which has completely missed the point of what the PP was making. enforcing uniform rules is relatively easy. Enforcing things like basic, manners and tolerance, not so much.

Debetswell · 30/08/2021 10:46

I like the shoes.
They look smart and sensible unlike the idiots that make the rules.

TeenMinusTests · 30/08/2021 10:39

I blame Kickers myself.

If they are meant to be school shoes then they shouldn't make them with bright red and green logos on them.

Though having looked at the website, these appear to be 'adult' and there is a separate 'school' section, so maybe those aren't so visibly colour logoed.

Lightisnotwhite · 30/08/2021 10:32

I think they do it because it's so much easier than working on important things like raising academic standards and turning out children who understand basic manners, kindness and tolerance.

a)They aren’t mutually exclusive.

b) There’s no point in a non branded uniform policy, or no hoodie policy or skirts to knee policy or whatever else they have if you don’t actually enforce it.

c) Following the school rules is part of “basic manners ,kindness tolerance”. You don’t just do what you want in life because you feel entitled to.

dalrympy · 30/08/2021 10:30

You have a lot to learn about Secondary School and the pettiness of many rules.

Having said that, most schools say no kickers, no Air Force ones, no yellow stitching DMs etc.

It's hard to know how strict they actually will be. Ours says none of the above but usually only crack down once or twice a year. They are especially strict at the start of term though.

I'd stick them on eBay and get some plain ones. Plenty of options out there.

Newmum29 · 30/08/2021 10:27

Those shoes are fine, send him in them and deal with the school if it comes up. Be polite, say you didn’t know but you won’t be replacing them until you can afford a new pair.

Jemand · 30/08/2021 10:17

Some Headteachers and senior leaders are really obsessed with uniform though. I think you’re right, they think that it will raise standards somehow or that Ofsted will be impressed by it. I really don’t think either of those things are true

I think they do it because it's so much easier than working on important things like raising academic standards and turning out children who understand basic manners, kindness and tolerance. They perceive discipline as being something that will appeal to parents, and they also perceive that parents like uniform. The latter in particular is becoming less and less true, but it seems to be taking time for headteachers to realise it. Let's hope the new government guidance, when that idiot Miller gets around to releasing it, will improve things.

CecilyP · 30/08/2021 10:16

Id e-mail Kickers or whoever you bought them from and ask to return if theu are unworn and still being sold full price.

Will save yourself a lot of drama.

OP can ask but Kickers absolutely do not have to agree to it! They have their rules too and their rule is a 14 day return period which has already passed.

CecilyP · 30/08/2021 10:12

they're put in plimsoles apparently - not sure which the kids would find more "abusive"). They're pre-empting this type of stuff.

What do they do if you actually send your kids in plimsolls?

At DD's school they would have had detention or an isolation. I agree that schools are ridiculous about uniform rules.

So plimsolls are allowed to be warn if they're provided by the school for pupils who turn up in the wrong shoes. But they are against the rules if you come to school in them yourself. Crazy!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread