Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School has banned Kickers shoes! I have bought them for DS. AIBU to to let him wear them and start a fight with them if they try to sanction him?

417 replies

CarefulDriver · 29/08/2021 17:48

DS is starting secondary school next week. The school uniform regulations on the school website dictate that they wear black shoes (no trainer like shoes). Fine.

I bought him a pair of Kickers as I wanted comfy shoes which will last him most of the year. I know from previous experience with DS1 and 2 that the ‘businessman’ style shoes don’t last if they’re playing footie at break! Most of the DCs at their school wore Kickers and so did they once I caught on.

Chatting to friend who’s DC is also going to the same school yesterday and apparently the school has banned shoes with visible branding on which Kickers have. This is not on the main school uniform webpage which is what I checked to get his uniform but on a sub page for new Yr7s which I had read but only skimmed over the uniform bit as assumed it was the same as the main page.

I spent £68 on shoes, which IMO are common school shoes, he may not now be able to wear. He won’t be wearing out of school either obviously! I got them online direct from Kickers with a 14 day return policy which has runout now.

WIBU to just send him in on his first day in them?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
RosesAndHellebores · 30/08/2021 17:08

@MadameMinimes I think you are cherry picking with that letter. Rupert Brooke wrote beautifully. Not sure if he was state educated though.

RosesAndHellebores · 30/08/2021 17:05

I've no idea what "tute" or "plodge" mean. A "bop" is a dance I believe. A kid is a baby goat and I'd have been displeased if any of my children's teachers had referred to kids.

My mother, who is nearly 85, whilst not keen on technology has been having her coffee mornings and playing bridge on zoom. MIL a former deputy head of the same age, won't use a computer.

I regularly have to write letters about complex issues as part of my role. Emails are expected to be grammatically correct.

Blossomtoes · 30/08/2021 17:01

The Royal Mail will confirm that alomost nobody writes letters anymore

Letters may not be sent through the mail, they’re still written as or attached to emails.

Now many of your grannies can master Zoom, Instagram or Twitter?

None of mine because they’re long dead. Since when have Insta or Twitter required or been an indication of a high level of literacy? I can master them and I’m old - it’s hardly rocket science.

Jaysmith71 · 30/08/2021 16:55

The Royal Mail will confirm that alomost nobody writes letters anymore. Formal documents are typed on computers that come with spelling and grammar checkers as standard if you want that sort of thing.

This "Golden Age" has always been a moving feast. It wasn't in the 70s when the Black Papers were claiming that the children who had only an elementary education were nearly 100% lieterate. This 'fact,' it transpired, was the product of parish marriage registers, which proved that nearly everyone could sign there name.

Nor was it in the 50s when the military complained that there wasn't enough time to get the many illiterate recruits functionally capable of reading and understanding Queen's Regulations, as in two world wars and the Anglo-Boer War when the first post 1870 schooled recruits were as illiterate as ever.

Now many of your grannies can master Zoom, Instagram or Twitter?

MadameMinimes · 30/08/2021 16:53

I’ve attached an example of a World War One letter to a soldier serving on the front line. You’ll note that the English is far from perfect.

School has banned Kickers shoes! I have bought them for DS. AIBU to to let him wear them and start a fight with them if they try to sanction him?
MadameMinimes · 30/08/2021 16:46
Hmm

You really are scraping the barrel if you’re taking issue with the word “kid”.
Weirdly, I bet you’d have no issue with “tute”, “plodge” or “bop”.

RampantIvy · 30/08/2021 16:45

But today we no more need to write letters than we need to draw an oroc on a cave wall.

No, but many people have to write literate and professional emails for work. I'm in Yorkshire, and one of my colleagues writes as she speaks - "we was", not "we were". I cringe with embarrassment as these emails go out to customers and suppliers Blush

Blossomtoes · 30/08/2021 16:45

But today we no more need to write letters than we need to draw an oroc on a cave wall

Don’t we? No businesses send letters any more? We don’t need correct spelling and grammar for reports? We’re not judged on the correct use of language on our CVs?

RosesAndHellebores · 30/08/2021 16:44

Had no kids Blush. We all had children.

RosesAndHellebores · 30/08/2021 16:41

@MadameMinimes. Indeed not. My grandmother, mother nor I had kids either. I'm trying not to cringe too much at your notion that there has been no dumbing down.

Grandma: 1912
Mother: 1936
Me: 1960
My DC: 90s. They received superb educations but not wholly state I'm afraid

Jaysmith71 · 30/08/2021 16:40

Well, No. Young people today do not speak like Trevor Howard and Celia Johnson in 'Brief Encounter.' And they surely cannot write letters like people used to write letters when people wrote letters. But today we no more need to write letters than we need to draw an oroc on a cave wall.

And I checked the internet, where one 'correct grammar' page solemly intoned that 'could of' was, quote, "A error." (Sic)

Blossomtoes · 30/08/2021 16:40

In all seriousness, you just cannot compare the standard of education that she left school with to what kids get now

You’re right. It was far better. My friends and I discussed this recently. We all think we were the last properly educated generation. Some of us left school in 1969 after O levels, the rest in 1971.

MadameMinimes · 30/08/2021 16:40

I use “could have”, my grandmother uses “could of”. Make of that what you will.

MadameMinimes · 30/08/2021 16:36

My grandmother was born in 1940. Perhaps standards declined significantly between 1896 and 1954 when my Nan left school. Grin

In all seriousness, you just cannot compare the standard of education that she left school with to what kids get now.

RosesAndHellebores · 30/08/2021 16:34

I also disagree @MadameMinimes - I am talking about present day graduates and their basic literacy and numeracy are woeful - even if they have a 2:1 from a post 92. Our DC went to an outstanding primary, cofe, leafy suburb. Crackers were:

At Christmas there was a 100 extra dinners served
Guage as a spelling which when I corrected it to gauge was marked wrong
x on the vertical access
The children going into year three will need a small pencil case, containing a 12 inch ruler Hmm

Do not ask me to detail some of the comments written in reading records by TA's dinner ladies who seemed to have disproportionate authority in the classroom.

Similar to Blossomtoes my grandma was never expected to work but wrote beautifully, was a human calculator, spoke reasonable French and perfect horse. My grandfather arrived in the UK in 1921 as a Russian refugee and wrote and spoke perfect English.

DH's side were working class. His grandad went down the mine on his 14th birthday; his grandma trained as a nurse. Both wrote perfect English and had excellent mental arithmetic.

None of our grandparents had any formal qualifications but they were significantly better educated than many of today's graduates. Recalls young chap who temped for me a few years ago having just graduated. "What did you read at university" I asked. "Oh, I'm not a big reader"Grin

RampantIvy · 30/08/2021 16:26

I disagree @MadameMinimes as well. Blossomtoes is right.
The school leaving age was earlier but they learned how to spell correctly and how to use grammar correctly. Adding up money was harder pre decimal currency as well.

School children 100 years ago might not have had the breadth of education that our children have but what they learned was very thorough.

How many times have I seen "could of" instead of "could have", borrowed instead of lent, apostrophes used for plurals on mumsnet and elsewhere? This kind of grammar was drummed into us as children (I went to primary school in the 1960s, and secondary school in the 1970s).

I am not so rude to point these grammatical errors to posters, but I admit to cringing inwardly.

SoupDragon · 30/08/2021 16:26

The fact is that the current generation of young people are more literate than mine.

I don't think that is true at all. "Could of" and other similar horrors being prime examples.

Blossomtoes · 30/08/2021 16:18

I totally disagree @MadameMinimes. My grandmother was 12 when she left school in 1896. I have some of her letters - perfect spelling and grammar. My parents would have been well over 100 now and my mother left school at 14, not only was her spelling and grammar correct but she explained the use of the apostrophe to me, having pointed out I used it incorrectly!

The breadth of education was undoubtedly less in time gone by but the emphasis on the basics meant a very high standard of literacy.

MadameMinimes · 30/08/2021 16:09

The fact is that the current generation of young people are more literate than mine. The number of children leaving school unable to do those things is lower now than it was when I left school. My generation is more literate than my parents’, who are more literate than their parents’.
My grandfather was functionally illiterate and my grandmother has always considered herself bookish for a working class woman of her generation but doesn’t have a good grasp of grammar (was/were, there/their/they’re, of/have etc) in her written English. My parents’ and grandparents’ generation in my family have a far worse grasp of grammar than the younger generation. I can say that fairly categorically, based on their Facebook posts alone.

This rosy idea of a bygone past where academic standards were better is a myth. More people left education in the past unable to do the things you talk about. The economy required far fewer people to have those skills back then though. Yes, secretaries needed those skills, but the number of secretaries was very small compared to the number of people who worked in manual labour jobs or factories. Many of those people were functionally illiterate a couple of generations ago. Now we are expecting pretty much everyone to have these skills and work in jobs that require them, so we notice the deficiencies, even though in mathematical terms a far smaller proportion of people are unable to do them.

Jaysmith71 · 30/08/2021 15:53

It must be stated that the "Kids Today Don't Know Nuffing" narrative has been going at least since Aristotle.

Now we could get into a discussion of what constitutes 'correct' grammar and according to who, (or whom?)

In the words of Bye Bye Birdie, "Why can't they be like we were? Perfect in every way? What's da matter wid kids today?"

RosesAndHellebores · 30/08/2021 14:49

@MadameMinimes can you explain then why most post 92 graduates I interview cannot construct grammatically correct sentences, use I and/or me correctly, or work out 60% of salary including LW and pro-rated annual leave, when provided with the full time amounts.

Unfortunately the poor literacy and numeracy are ingrained and it doesn't matter if a student is following an intense GCSE curriculum if the basics are being so neglected and nobody cares or notices. By the time we get the graduates they would be offended if we were straight with them because they have been led to think they are such high achievers. Regrettably, they are too often very poorly educated albeit very well qualified. Secretaries in the late 70s would not have been able to hold down a job with such poor foundation skills.

BluebellsGreenbells · 30/08/2021 14:43

The kids going to university unable to fiction must surely lie at their parents door?

Over indulged teens who’ve never held down a job and have no idea how to cook or book a doctors appointment later can’t be laid at schools door?

Unable to string a sentence together? Who teachers them the art of conversation? Home?

FrippEnos · 30/08/2021 14:06

@user1471447863

What is not factual is that teachers do not "work for you".

If teachers did work for you, you would be legally responsible for their terms and conditions.

You may contribute to teachers wages through taxation but you do not employ them.

MadameMinimes · 30/08/2021 13:28

The idea that education is “dumbing down” is patently untrue.

My GCSE and A Level students are working to a much higher academic standard than was the case when I was at school. They work harder, spending far more hours studying than we did in the early “noughties”. The curriculum in my subject (history) is absolutely packed now, with some really challenging topics. I just don’t recognise this “dumbing down” that you talk about.

user1471447863 · 30/08/2021 13:27

@FrippEnos

Remember your taxes pay their wages - they work for you.

Stupid has entered the building.

@FrippEnos ok then clever clogs which part isn't factual?

Is it not us, through taxation that fund schools and ultimately pay teachers wages? I dont think its a grant from Bill gates or anything?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread