Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School has banned Kickers shoes! I have bought them for DS. AIBU to to let him wear them and start a fight with them if they try to sanction him?

417 replies

CarefulDriver · 29/08/2021 17:48

DS is starting secondary school next week. The school uniform regulations on the school website dictate that they wear black shoes (no trainer like shoes). Fine.

I bought him a pair of Kickers as I wanted comfy shoes which will last him most of the year. I know from previous experience with DS1 and 2 that the ‘businessman’ style shoes don’t last if they’re playing footie at break! Most of the DCs at their school wore Kickers and so did they once I caught on.

Chatting to friend who’s DC is also going to the same school yesterday and apparently the school has banned shoes with visible branding on which Kickers have. This is not on the main school uniform webpage which is what I checked to get his uniform but on a sub page for new Yr7s which I had read but only skimmed over the uniform bit as assumed it was the same as the main page.

I spent £68 on shoes, which IMO are common school shoes, he may not now be able to wear. He won’t be wearing out of school either obviously! I got them online direct from Kickers with a 14 day return policy which has runout now.

WIBU to just send him in on his first day in them?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
AO33 · 31/08/2021 07:28

Find it hard to believe a school that allows football to be played at break would not allow a pupil to change their shoes into trainers! Even from a health and safety point of view (which I think is also ridiculous) they would have no leg to stand on of injured whilst playing in school shoes

MadameMinimes · 31/08/2021 07:24

@whatbigfeet What about these? www.treads-shoes.com/boys/school-shoes/turin

www.treads-shoes.com/boys/school-shoes/milan

@AO33 In a lot of schools they wouldn’t be allowed to change into trainers at break nowadays.

user1496146479 · 31/08/2021 07:22

@CarefulDriver

They have the name on the heel as well in big letters in bright green and red as well as the tag on the front though.

Why should I have to deface a brand new pair shoes just because of a stupid rule they’ve just brought in Angry.

Kids have been wearing Kickers to school for years!

Why do we have to put up with this crap?

If they have that much colour, then they don't meet the criteria of being 'black' ....
AO33 · 31/08/2021 06:32

The same shoes as last time and tell him to wear his trainers to play footy in.

whatbigfeet · 31/08/2021 02:44

My 13 year old son has men's size 11 shoes. School don't want anything branded and I can really only get smart men's shoes. Last year the sole came off his first pair within two weeks as he was playing football at lunchtime. I've got to buy him some this week and have no idea what to get!!!!

Lightisnotwhite · 30/08/2021 23:43

@RosesAndHellebores

But industry/commerce doesn't need post 92 graduates who can think critically. It needs literate and numerate young people post GCSE or A'Level who may be able to develop critical thinking skills as they mature.
Do you think they might be children brought up in a regime they don’t agree with and decide clothes are a bollocks way to decide worth …..

or the be the system mums don’t agree with and feel forced to buy £68 shoes to kick off at the repressive state.

RampantIvy · 30/08/2021 23:27

@Volhhg

Yeah send him in with them. Don't be a scared and blindly follow pointless rules, bad things can only come if this subservient fearful attitude. As if banning branded shoes or any uniform policy really does anything to address the extreme social inequalities in the UK? It doesn't even touch the sides and seems to me just a some kind of mindless control. I dread to think of the attitude of a head teacher of a secondary school who has the time to even think up this kind of rubbish
It's all very well being a confident adult to question silly rules, but for a nervous 11 year old being told off in front of everyone for wearing the wrong shoes it will be extremely nerve wracking and unpleasant.
Volhhg · 30/08/2021 23:09

@mnistooaddictive

I’m a secondary teacher. We get forced to check shoes and get passive aggressive emails if a member of senior staff finds a member of our tutor group in the wrong shoes. For me it is the path of least resistance. I’m not getting down on my hands and knees to check but if I can see obvious logos as they walk in or when I’m stood at front of the class I will do something about it. If the locus can easily be seen from 2m away they will not be allowed.
Wow what an awful school culture for children to be educated in
Volhhg · 30/08/2021 23:04

Yeah send him in with them. Don't be a scared and blindly follow pointless rules, bad things can only come if this subservient fearful attitude. As if banning branded shoes or any uniform policy really does anything to address the extreme social inequalities in the UK? It doesn't even touch the sides and seems to me just a some kind of mindless control. I dread to think of the attitude of a head teacher of a secondary school who has the time to even think up this kind of rubbish

spongedog · 30/08/2021 22:58

@MadameMinimes

The idea that education is “dumbing down” is patently untrue.

My GCSE and A Level students are working to a much higher academic standard than was the case when I was at school. They work harder, spending far more hours studying than we did in the early “noughties”. The curriculum in my subject (history) is absolutely packed now, with some really challenging topics. I just don’t recognise this “dumbing down” that you talk about.

Offtopic. But I dont agree with you at all. I work in a school, non-teaching but invigilate - I have mostly invigilated Science and Maths GCSEs. They are Mickey Mouse in their simplicity. I am appalled. For total transparency, I do have a Maths degree and an associated professional qual - so I am "mathematical", but even so. I am shocked at how low the standard is. They are nothing like as complex as my O levels.

I can accept that these exams would be tricky for students whose grasp of English isnt good. But no wonder international companies (financial services, City) try to recruit international students (including Scottish) as a preference over English educated students.

FrippEnos · 30/08/2021 22:44

@user1471447863

Phrase it how you like but, teachers do not "work for you" in either context.

As for nitpicking detracting from the thread. don't post BS and you won't get picked up on it.

user1471447863 · 30/08/2021 21:25

@FrippEnos you seem to be conflating the terms 'works for' and 'employed by', someone can do the former without being the latter.
Your MP or local councillor works for you but again is not employed by you.
Your nitpicking is detracting from the point of the thread though.

@GivenchyDahhling yes i am aware that teachers also pay tax, i am also aware that some parents will not currently be paying any tax or have ever or be ever likely to contribute any. Just as some people will pay extremely large amounts of tax yet be childless.

Anyway schools efforts would be better spent looking for holes in children's shoes rather than visible branding or looking for the child who is wearing shoes 2 sizes too big as their parents won't be able to afford multiple pairs as they grow. Or maybe enforcing their bullying policies should children pick on others for not having the right brands, or maybe instilling in them earlier that bullying is completely unacceptable and just not done in this school? It might be a tad hypocritical for them to take that moral high ground though when they themselves bully and harass pupils over what they are wearing when this is outwith the childs control? no?

Most of the rest of the civilised world hasn't gone to pot any worse than us by letting children go to school wearing jeans and a hoodie or even a Kickers logo on their shoes.

Totallydefeated · 30/08/2021 19:26

follow the rules or choose a different school.

Oh, all the readily available good schools with sensible uniform policies that magically all have place available at them?! You don’t live in the UK, do you?

Carrysymons · 30/08/2021 19:14

YABU. Not the school's fault you failed to read the uniform information properly. Secondary school is not the same as Primary, follow the rules or choose a different school.

AO33 · 30/08/2021 19:10

First of all, the whether the rule has just been brought in or not, it is clearly a rule. You admitted you didn’t read the page fully so that is not the fault of the school.

The reasoning behind not having ‘branded’ footwear is so pupils who may not be able to afford shoes in the same price bracket are not left feeling left out. So rather than complain over your failure to read the uniform rules, consider the children who can’t afford the footwear and the reason behind the school having such rules. Good on the school for looking out for all pupils!!!

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 30/08/2021 19:06

@RosesAndHellebores

But industry/commerce doesn't need post 92 graduates who can think critically. It needs literate and numerate young people post GCSE or A'Level who may be able to develop critical thinking skills as they mature.
Disagree. Employers want it all now. They're not prepared to invest in people or training. If you don't have what they want from day one, they get rid of you or don't recruit you in the first place.

It could actually be a silver lining of Brexit/covid that they have to invest in training from now on because they can't just recruit from overseas.

Blossomtoes · 30/08/2021 18:50

@RosesAndHellebores

But industry/commerce doesn't need post 92 graduates who can think critically. It needs literate and numerate young people post GCSE or A'Level who may be able to develop critical thinking skills as they mature.
Exactly this. And the jobs aren’t available for all those graduates. There are many Amy Johnson equivalents working in call centres.
RosesAndHellebores · 30/08/2021 18:47

But industry/commerce doesn't need post 92 graduates who can think critically. It needs literate and numerate young people post GCSE or A'Level who may be able to develop critical thinking skills as they mature.

Jaysmith71 · 30/08/2021 18:37

@RosesAndHellebores

But the person at the 50th centile in 1920 didn't think they were entitled to a graduate entry job.
Given there were about five self-awarding universities in England at this time, hardly surprising.

Take the case of Amy Johnson, bright working class girl from Hull who graduated with an Economics degree from Sheffield but found no one would let her take a job outside the typing pool.

MadameMinimes · 30/08/2021 18:28

I’m just going to copy/paste. Will live to lost have I.

“The economy required far fewer people to have those skills back then though. Yes, secretaries needed those skills, but the number of secretaries was very small compared to the number of people who worked in manual labour jobs or factories. Many of those people were functionally illiterate a couple of generations ago. Now we are expecting pretty much everyone to have these skills and work in jobs that require them, so we notice the deficiencies, even though in mathematical terms a far smaller proportion of people are unable to do them.”

Economy geared towards graduate jobs = more graduates and fewer coal miners. Number of literate adults can go up, without going up quickly enough to meet demand.

RosesAndHellebores · 30/08/2021 18:20

But the person at the 50th centile in 1920 didn't think they were entitled to a graduate entry job.

RampantIvy · 30/08/2021 18:19

@Blossomtoes

Don’t apologise *@RampantIvy*, never apologise. Both the bloke and I are massive grammar pedants and it gives us enormous pleasure.
Grin
Blossomtoes · 30/08/2021 18:16

@MadameMinimes

The sort of person at the 50th centile in 1920 would have likely been a coal miner, factory worker, manual labourer or similar. They formed the bulk of the employed male population in the 1920 census. I don’t think I’m saying anything controversial by saying that a graduate today, even one from a post ‘92 university (shock, horror), is more literate and better educated than the average coal miner or factory worker in 1920.
Surely that depends on how you define better educated?
Blossomtoes · 30/08/2021 18:14

Don’t apologise @RampantIvy, never apologise. Both the bloke and I are massive grammar pedants and it gives us enormous pleasure.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread