Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What the hell do we do?! (Potential trigger warning)

303 replies

Ninhurt · 29/08/2021 16:42

Dsd has just disclosed to me that she thinks she has been abused. BUT (and I few like a complete monster for saying this) it doesn’t really add up and I’m not sure what to do. I used to be so sure I’d instantly call the police but the details are extremely fuzzy.

For instance dsd said that she thinks a teacher from a hobby when she was younger ‘did something’. She doesn’t know what, and doesn’t remember anything happening. She also said she can’t remember the name of the teacher, then later on said that her older sister had googled him and that he had left the country. She then again said she didn’t know his name (then how did her sister google him?)

She has also named a teacher at her primary school that she said she also thinks ‘did something’. But again, she can’t remember anything that may have happened? Just that she ‘has a feeling’. And she said he hugged her once in the staff room?

Dsd is 19. DH is absolutely distraught and wanted to phone 111 for advice but dsd says she doesn’t want to because she can’t actually remember anything happening. She is absolutely adamant that we can’t tell her mum, but we can tell her aunties and Nan?

I’m not an evil stepmom, we actually have a really good relationship, and I feel awful, but I can’t shake the intuition that this isn’t quite true. Again, I don’t want to think this, but it’s almost like she’s enjoying ‘punishing’ her dads side of the family with this.

DH says we have to leave it (but he and his side of the family are in a complete state). I think we should call the non emergency police number for some sort of advice as you never know. And if it (whatever ‘it’ is) is true then this teacher is now a deputy head at a primary school?

DH and dsd are both very against this idea. I feel extremely unsettled and am worried about dsd wondering what else may be wrong (as I don’t think she’d make something like this up flippantly).

OP posts:
HerRoyalRisesAgain · 30/08/2021 17:20

That clearly isn't what anyone is saying. However, I don't believe any other poster has had a hazy feeling or memory yet on that basis been able to name specific people, been known to make false accusations about others (ie OP), been noted by a counsellor (and evidenced by actions towards her DF) to have a manipulative personality type, and made strange requests for certain family members she isn't close to to be told instantly.
Everyone projecting their own experiences onto the thread, please stop it. It isn't helpful to the OP.

I had exactly that experience. I knew who had hurt me, but no actual memories of the abuse until years later, and I've already said that on this thread.
Also, what's to say OP hasn't lied about how she's treated DSD? If we're just flinging around that women can lie what's to say its not this woman lying?
Regardless, DSD needs therapy and support. She needs someone to say "I believe you" and help her work through it.

QuarantineQueen · 30/08/2021 17:20

@HerRoyalRisesAgain the 'apologist nonsense' was initially aimed at me. And I certainly have not called her a liar. I have said there are several possibilities and no one should rush to judgements given how complex the case is. And that things should of course proceed on the assumption she is telling the truth.
However, it appears that any recognition that there is more than one possible answer to what is going on - even when borne out of our own professional and personal experiences - is 'apologist nonsense'.

QuarantineQueen · 30/08/2021 17:17

@HerRoyalRisesAgain

yes i have read the thread thank you , and it doesnt change my opinion of it all one bit. theres a lot not adding up, an awful lot really Ok so those of us with vague feelings and hazy memories that "don't add up" are we all manipulative liars too? Or just this particular young woman?
That clearly isn't what anyone is saying. However, I don't believe any other poster has had a hazy feeling or memory yet on that basis been able to name specific people, been known to make false accusations about others (ie OP), been noted by a counsellor (and evidenced by actions towards her DF) to have a manipulative personality type, and made strange requests for certain family members she isn't close to to be told instantly. Everyone projecting their own experiences onto the thread, please stop it. It isn't helpful to the OP.
HerRoyalRisesAgain · 30/08/2021 17:15

must be only horrible evil men that lie then

No one has said that. If you'd read the thread properly you'd see we are saying that the way to support this clearly traumatised young woman is to believe her and help her seek therapy, regardless of if its true or not. Thats not for anyone to judge, its for OPS DSD to work through with a professional. Coming on and calling her a liar will help no one.

EmergencyHydrangea · 30/08/2021 17:15

@JustLyra

No wonder men get away with as much as they do.
Right? I am disgusted by some of the responses here
leavesthataregreen · 30/08/2021 17:14

I feel awful, but I can’t shake the intuition that this isn’t quite true.

This is very common because a lot of women reporting historical abuse sound veyr hazy and unsure of themselves. They don't present clear facts with confidence. Try to bear in mind that abusers set up scenarios of doubt and grey areas so that victims are silenced by self doubt or others' disbelief.

It is likely that she is remembering something that felt wrong at the time or feels wrong in retrospect. It may or may not count legally as abuse but please trust that her confusion and worry are genuine.

JustLyra · 30/08/2021 17:13

No wonder men get away with as much as they do.

QuarantineQueen · 30/08/2021 17:13

As I said, there's a lot of projection on this thread.
I have experience in this area and although I agree in general accusations of sexual violence are true (and those excellent stats are about all cases) once you add the specific features of this case (historic, vague feeling and no memory but able to accuse more than one specific man, clear emotional blackmail and manipulative behaviour, and known false accusations about the OP) it begins to sound far more like those few cases where it isn't true. I'm not saying it's definitely a false memory or a lie at all - and certainly counselling etc should progress on the assumption it's true because it might be - but given all the details it would be foolish for any professional to not have an open mind.
OP, however, just needs to support her DH whilst being wary of her own position.

chaosrabbitland · 30/08/2021 17:11

[quote HerRoyalRisesAgain]**@chaosrabbitland* I'll refer you to @thedancingbear* post on the stats of false accusations.
Oh, hang on, I've done it for you. It's almost never: www.open.ac.uk/research/news/false-accusations-sexual-violence

You are helping no-one with your ill-informed apologist nonsense.[/quote]
thing is im not the only one on this thread commenting who is saying they feel that what shes saying is not true , so theres no need to get in a twist everytime someone comments the same . just because im a woman does not mean i have to read something like the ops written and write , omg that sounds terrible , yes yes , shes telling the truth ,god forbid in this day and age we cannot disbelieve someone of our own sex , must be only horrible evil men that lie then

HerRoyalRisesAgain · 30/08/2021 17:09

yes i have read the thread thank you , and it doesnt change my opinion of it all one bit. theres a lot not adding up, an awful lot really
Ok so those of us with vague feelings and hazy memories that "don't add up" are we all manipulative liars too? Or just this particular young woman?

chaosrabbitland · 30/08/2021 17:07

@HerRoyalRisesAgain

personally its all so vague it would be a miracle if it were true .

Have you even read the thread? Many many of us only had or have a vague feeling, before the memories came back, if they ever did. It's an extremely common trauma response to suppress those memories

yes i have read the thread thank you , and it doesnt change my opinion of it all one bit. theres a lot not adding up, an awful lot really
HerRoyalRisesAgain · 30/08/2021 17:05

@chaosrabbitland I'll refer you to @thedancingbear post on the stats of false accusations.
Oh, hang on, I've done it for you. It's almost never: www.open.ac.uk/research/news/false-accusations-sexual-violence

You are helping no-one with your ill-informed apologist nonsense.

chaosrabbitland · 30/08/2021 17:02

@HerRoyalRisesAgain

No ones saying its impossible she's lied. We are saying that the only way to help this clearly troubled young woman is to believe her and support her in finding a suitable therapist. Whatever happened to believing victims? Me too?
its all very well , but if she lying about these 2 men she cant even remember the name of , and she decides to go one step further and take it to the police , its possibly 2 innocent men having their lives ripped apart by the fabrications of a teenager without a shred of evidence , they will still have to be questioned by the police and all the rest of it . sorry but i dont think its fair and i dont think in this particular instance with the vague details shes coming out with she should automatically be believed , she does sound like she needs some kind of help though ,
HerRoyalRisesAgain · 30/08/2021 17:01

personally its all so vague it would be a miracle if it were true .

Have you even read the thread? Many many of us only had or have a vague feeling, before the memories came back, if they ever did. It's an extremely common trauma response to suppress those memories

chaosrabbitland · 30/08/2021 16:57

@FatLarrysBand

It's nothing to do with whether she's 'behaving as she should'.

She couldn't remember the name of her abuser. Her sister, however, managed to Google him. Now, she either managed that because she did remember his name, or because she managed to put sufficient detail into a search engine to find him - and would have got the name at that point. So his name is now known, one way or the other. But she can't recall it. That simply doesn't make sense. That in tandem with all the other things OP has aid, makes me think she may be lying.

I'm afraid I reject the idea that if someone thinks they have been abused - they have been: or indeed that anyone accusing someone of sexual abuse must automatically be believed. And, happily, so does the Criminal Justice System.

i believe the same , its ludicrous i think in this instance to even give her accusations the time of day , if thats even what you can call them , it seems more like oh i will come out with this vague stuff and see how much it sets everyone off in a tangent , and its worked shes got a bit of attention it seems , personally its all so vague it would be a miracle if it were true .
Princessandthepeas · 30/08/2021 16:53

@thedancingbear - Thank you.
Some of the responses on here are really sickening to read.

thedancingbear · 30/08/2021 16:42

[quote Princessandthepeas]**@QuarantineQueen - “She could be outright lying… it happens more often that you think”.

How often? Can you back this up with figures or give me a link to the research you’ve got this from please ?

“When it does happen it’s often by teens who are unstable and manipulative” - again, where are you getting this from?[/quote]
Qute. @QuarantineQueen, can you provide some stats, please, on how often allegations of sexual abuse are false?

Oh, hang on, I've done it for you. It's almost never: www.open.ac.uk/research/news/false-accusations-sexual-violence

You are helping no-one with your ill-informed apologist nonsense.

nothingcanhurtmewithmyeyesshut · 30/08/2021 16:39

Idk. As I said upthread, having been in that situation I want to believe her and my first instinct is to believe her but too much doesn't add up.

I think she is lying to manipulate you. Whether she is lying about being abused at all or just about the perpetrator, who knows?

This insistence that all her family know except for her mum is odd. Does her mum have a partner? How is her relationship with him?

But tbh the more you post, the more I think its all bollocks and she is deeply disturbed. She clearly has no problem lying about things that you KNOW to be false so I'm inclined to think the rest is made up too.

Princessandthepeas · 30/08/2021 16:36

@QuarantineQueen - “She could be outright lying… it happens more often that you think”.

How often? Can you back this up with figures or give me a link to the research you’ve got this from please ?

“When it does happen it’s often by teens who are unstable and manipulative” - again, where are you getting this from?

thedancingbear · 30/08/2021 16:36

[quote QuarantineQueen]@thedancingbear well he does? How else is he going to best support his DD? And the OP did her best with her DSD, was rebutted and has become a target herself so best to leave it to DSDs dad and professionals.
However, she can still support him in supporting his DSD, and in coping with it himself. It must be awful to hear your DD say she has been abused.
Nothing misogynistic about it. I'd be saying exactly the same if the sexes of the parent and stepparent were reversed.[/quote]
This isn't what you posted. Your 15.59 post is predicated on the idea that the daughter is probably not telling the truth. And centres the feelings of her father.

As countless others have noted on this thread, whatever happened to 'we believe you'?

QuarantineQueen · 30/08/2021 16:23

@thedancingbear well he does? How else is he going to best support his DD? And the OP did her best with her DSD, was rebutted and has become a target herself so best to leave it to DSDs dad and professionals.
However, she can still support him in supporting his DSD, and in coping with it himself. It must be awful to hear your DD say she has been abused.
Nothing misogynistic about it. I'd be saying exactly the same if the sexes of the parent and stepparent were reversed.

beastlyslumber · 30/08/2021 16:19

I agree. it's the man who needs supporting in this situation.

For absolute fuck's sake.

He does need support in order to support his daughter. OP is best placed to give that support and needs to step back from her DSD as she has now become a target.

There has been some good insight and advice on this thread. Resilience set out a very clear approach that could be super helpful.

Getting angry and insulting people seems like a waste of time and is no help to OP or her stepdaughter.

colouringindoors · 30/08/2021 16:11

Even if this young woman has BPD (or EUPD, as it's more commonly called by the MH teams where I live) that doesn't mean that what she is saying is false.There's a significant correlation between SA and B/EUPD diagnoses.

And I'm coming across an awful lot of clients whose diagnosis has been changed from B/EUPD to Complex PTSD, because of these links.

Exactly. Many in the MH/CSA/VAWG are clear that BPD diagnoses are overly given to women and girls who have experienced abuse and trauma.

DSD needs good quality trauma support.

thedancingbear · 30/08/2021 16:06

@QuarantineQueen

There is a lot of projecting going on on this thread. There are a few possibilities here OP: 1) She is telling the truth and has some kind of very hazy feeling/memory. Given how hazy it is, it is extremely unlikely that both the teachers she mentions were perpetrators. It may not even be one of them, but someone else altogether. 2) She could think she is being truthful but actually nothing happened, she has put 2 and 2 together and made 7. She sounds very unstable which could either be caused by abuse or have caused her to search for a reason and subconsciously create false memories. 3) She could be outright lying. I know pps who have been victims of CSA won't like this suggestion, but it happens more than you think. When it does happen, it is often by teens who are unstable and manipulative - which both her counsellor has noted and she has clearly acted manipulatively towards your husband and outright lied about your actions. Whatever it is, keep an open mind and support your husband the best you can. If she is going to lie about you, I recommend you step back. It must be such a difficult situation but it sounds like you have done everything right and done your best to support her. Flowers
I agree. it's the man who needs supporting in this situation.

For absolute fuck's sake.

owlbethere · 30/08/2021 16:02

I would get her some therapy.