Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be Bossy About My BILs Health?

88 replies

Fucket · 29/08/2021 08:28

My BIL, lives alone has a girlfriend of sorts (he never lives with his partners, just cycles through them every 1-3 years), had a health scare 2-3 years ago. He had sores on his feet, and couldn’t walk far, was told he had an enlarged heart with fluid build up. He was also told he was pre-diabetic. This was all on private health with his employer scheme. But then he quit his job and left that scheme and has started with a different health insurance provider. I think this is relevant because I don’t think notes get shared, and I don’t believe BIL has been to see a GP.

BIL told us 2-3 years ago it was an infection with his heart that had caused it. His sores seemed to have disappeared and we assumed all was well.

Fast forward to Covid we didn’t see him in a year at least. He told my DH (his brother) that he’d got a hernia around his belly button and was seeing a consultant about operating.

BIL tells DH they won’t operate because BIL has heart failure, possible liver failure, ascites and fluid in his abdomen and around his lungs and heart. He’s going to see a heart consultant once private referral from one doctor to the other goes through. In the meantime we now see BIL in the flesh at my son’s birthday party. Whereby he is gaunt in face, and arms, but a huge belly. He looks dire. I prepare a raw salad for BIL which everyone can eat but he insists on ordering a pizza (because my son wanted takeaway pizza for his birthday). He ate a massive pizza. He’s off out to a party today with his girlfriend.

I want to call BIL tomorrow and find out exactly what steps he’s taking to protect his health. He just tells DH he knows he needs to change his diet, but will wait to see consultant first. I doubt BIL has told his girlfriend about all this because I refuse to believe any sane, caring woman will allow her boyfriend to continue drinking and partying with such serious problems.

My FIL is ill, and both he and MIL don’t know because BIL doesn’t want to worry them.

DH is telling me not to get involved. My thinking is, I don’t care if I upset BIL because he is seriously ill and might respond to someone willing to help them think about hospitals and doctors appointments.

I have done similar with my father before he got a partner, buried his head in the sand and used to ring him daily and nag him to see a GP and get him to go shopping and buy healthy food. My father was depressed, and couldn’t think for himself properly. DH thinks I’m not to try. When DH speaks to BIL he seems to dance about the issue but never really has a direct conversation about it. I don’t think DH is taking it seriously either, he wanted me to buy beer for his brother for the party and I point blank refused to.

So AIBU to ignore DH and telephone BIL?

I wanted to speak with BIL alone in person at the party but my kids wouldn’t give us any free time to do so.

BIL is 50 btw and mostly lives on takeaways and never exercises so I cannot understand how he has gone from being overweight to how he is in 18 months of not seeing him because of covid restrictions without something seriously wrong with him.

OP posts:
Fucket · 29/08/2021 11:06

BIL saw a consultant without referral for a hernia. They scanned him, and found all the health issues I have stated. He has never seen his GP. He has been told to see a heart consultant. As someone has already said, if he sees a GP they will know exactly who and where to refer him to, and possibly sort something in meantime? Who knows. I don’t. The consultant did what BIL paid him to do, refused to treat him quite rightly as his heart wouldn’t stand an operation, and said he needs to be referred to a heart consultant.

OP posts:
seven201 · 29/08/2021 11:04

I don't know. My BIL died in his 40s of a heart attack and was probably morbidly obese. I wish I had talked to him. Then my sister wouldn't be a widow at 40 and his young kids might still have a father. I think you should call him but go gently.

TeaandHobnobs · 29/08/2021 10:52

OP I understand where you are coming from, and you want your BIL to be well, but really, this isn’t your fight.
Have a listen to the podcast series “A Thorough Examination” with the Van Tulleken twins - explores how one twin’s weight problem is also in part due to the nagging attitude of the other twin.
We have this same issue with MIL and money - more than 10 years we’ve been trying to get her to change, and we have finally realised that nothing we say is going to make a difference; it is like a brick wall. I know it hurts to see people you care about suffering and not willing to help themselves, but it is their life. (And I say this as someone whose adored DDad died from terminal cancer because he wouldn’t go to the GP earlier…)

sammylady37 · 29/08/2021 10:48

@Fucket

His consultant has told him he can’t help him as he needs to see a heart specialist. That he won’t operate on him before then. So no, I don’t think the consultant does know more than a GP will. I think a GP might say, look you have liver problems, you have heart problems, you have ascites and a hernia you need to do x, y and z. Maybe some medication for the fluid retention. Waiting for a referral and doing nothing seems like hoping it will go away.
The GP can coordinate his care, refer to each specialist etc.
PallasStrand · 29/08/2021 10:47

@Fucket

I have never bossed him around in front of people. Where did I say that? I want to call him tomorrow when he is alone and I can have 1-2-1 chat. I overhear conversations I am not part of them. I ask DH why did yiu not ask him about x,y,z? Is why i feel if he won’t ask him I will.
And you really think that a ‘bossy’ phone call from you is going to ping a lightbulb on over his head, when sores, enlarged heart, inability to walk far, and more recently, a necessary surgery had to be withdrawn because of heart and liver failure didn’t have an impact?

You also have some very peculiar ideas about GPS vs consultants.

Fucket · 29/08/2021 10:46

His consultant has told him he can’t help him as he needs to see a heart specialist. That he won’t operate on him before then. So no, I don’t think the consultant does know more than a GP will. I think a GP might say, look you have liver problems, you have heart problems, you have ascites and a hernia you need to do x, y and z. Maybe some medication for the fluid retention. Waiting for a referral and doing nothing seems like hoping it will go away.

OP posts:
sammylady37 · 29/08/2021 10:37

@Fucket

I have never bossed him around in front of people. Where did I say that? I want to call him tomorrow when he is alone and I can have 1-2-1 chat. I overhear conversations I am not part of them. I ask DH why did yiu not ask him about x,y,z? Is why i feel if he won’t ask him I will.
Do you honestly think you are going to say anything that will be a lightbulb moment for him? Do you think the consultant(s) he has seen have not spoken to him about his condition? Do you think he’s blissfully unaware of his situation? Tbh, I think you are doing this more for you than him, so that you can tell yourself you did all you could etc.
toughdaay · 29/08/2021 09:53

OP I understand how you feel. My DDad has a very similar list of ailments. He knows he has to make changes, although I suspect it's probably too late for him now. He used to run marathons but since he met his wife they eat junk and drink far too much. He has heart failure, kidney problems and diabetes now. I had to come off his Facebook because I couldn't bear watching while he was at the pub drinking every night. He had a stroke and was in hospital. While I was there visiting his wife left so she could go to the pub with her friends. He won't ever change and I have almost accepted that. I suspect it's the case for your BIL too. It's awful to watch though. Don't nag him, there's no point.

Fucket · 29/08/2021 09:38

I have never bossed him around in front of people. Where did I say that? I want to call him tomorrow when he is alone and I can have 1-2-1 chat. I overhear conversations I am not part of them. I ask DH why did yiu not ask him about x,y,z? Is why i feel if he won’t ask him I will.

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 29/08/2021 09:37

I think being 'bossy' is a step too far but given your relationship you cna have a private chat as a friend.

Confusedandshaken · 29/08/2021 09:37

He is a grown man who is entitled to make his own choices about girlfriends, lifestyle, diet and healthcare. They clearly aren't the choices you would make but that's completely irrelevant. Step back from this and focus on your own life.

Palavah · 29/08/2021 09:33

However, if you want to call one-to-one and offer support (and it has to be support, not nagging or bossing) then do so. But please stop bossing him about in front of other people.

Palavah · 29/08/2021 09:31

@Fucket

I want him to see his GP. I think he ought to be seeking Their advice instead of paying to see consultants who won’t be trained in other aspects of medicine. It’s all well and good waiting to see a heart consultant but shouldn’t someone be thinking about getting his ascites under control especially if he has a hernia? He has no medication.
What makes you think the consultant isn't a qualified doctor? He is seeing medical professionals. He has an inoperable condition. He is an adult in full mental capacity and has a right to live his life as he chooses.

If I had a terminal illness and you'd tried to force me to eat a raw salad i didn't want when everyone else was eating pizza which I wanted to eat I'd have told you to fuck off.

magicstar1 · 29/08/2021 09:27

Call him. I don’t care if men are supposed to look after their own health....if you’ve spotted something, then talk to him.
My mother has basically saved my dads life twice. She knew his cough sounded different and book a GP appointment for him....he had very early lung cancer. An op but no chemo and it was gone.
She did the same with picking up on his oesophageal cancer...again an op but no chemo etc.

parietal · 29/08/2021 09:26

This is not just one call, it is potentially long term support (or long term nagging depending on which way you look at it).

So if you do that first call, I think you should explicitly offer the support. Describe how you helped your dad & ask if he wants the same kind of help. And if he says no, respect that.

user1497787065 · 29/08/2021 09:18

Go ahead and give him a call. What a lovely SIL you are to care. I can't believe how many posters have told you to mind your own business.

Fucket · 29/08/2021 09:13

Oh good 17to35 that is my fear. And yes diet changes may not be enough now. The scans he had said he had signs of cirrhosis, and all this fluid. But as that consultant wasn’t a heart specialist he could only refer him elsewhere.

OP posts:
17to35 · 29/08/2021 09:10

Your poor BIL sounds like he has end stage heart failure from your description alone.
He needs urgent medical care if he isn't receiving it already. I don't know if you are in the UK?
Pizza/salad is neither here nor there. Nagging is irrelevant. He is obviously a very sick man.

Fucket · 29/08/2021 09:08

I want him to see his GP. I think he ought to be seeking Their advice instead of paying to see consultants who won’t be trained in other aspects of medicine. It’s all well and good waiting to see a heart consultant but shouldn’t someone be thinking about getting his ascites under control especially if he has a hernia? He has no medication.

OP posts:
PepsiHoover · 29/08/2021 09:06

You can lead a horse to water, OP. My PIL have had health problems for the 20 years I've known them. Pair of them are on death's door and still ignore the constant nagging for DH to look after themselves.

Do you have the full story OP, or does DH know more? I ask because a relative had terminal cancer and I never actually told my DH it was terminal because the relative asked me not to.

FWIW, if I knew I was very seriously, possibly terminally, ill then I would also be chugging back the pizza and beers instead of salad too.

Fucket · 29/08/2021 09:05

Yes it was a FaceTime call. Kids were milling about in background, I was there too. This is why I know all of it. He hasn’t told his parents, he FaceTimes DH everyday. His girlfriend has a very ill mother, they don’t see each other very often, I know because these conversations are had on FaceTime often. It’s weird because I don’t actually like having conversations over FaceTime with people, but I accept DH and BIL are comfortable enough for me to hear their conversations (99% about sport).

OP posts:
sammylady37 · 29/08/2021 08:59

@Fucket

Ok I won’t be bossy. If DH is the only person who knows and by extension me, we are the only two people who can be supportive and suggest changes. I suspect he has not told anyone else because then it makes it real, and they will, by extension want him to change his lifestyle too.

We don’t live close by so we can’t be round their stacking his fridge for him. So talking to him is all we/I can do.

Notes about my tone are taken onboard.

Do you know he hasn’t told anyone else or just think so? If he hasn’t told anyone other than his brother (who has ‘by extension’ told you, incidentally did BIL know this info was going to be passed on to you?) then it suggests that it’s something he (rightly) considers private and personal. You thinking you can bulldoze in, control what he’s eating, offer unsolicited advice, wanting to ‘stack his fridge’ is overbearing, unwelcome and ultimately unhelpful. You’re not his doctor. He hasn’t asked for your help. There’s likely to be many things going on here about which you are clueless.

You remind me of a colleague who was talking about another colleague. The first woman is a very fit and slim woman, goes to the gym daily and really watches what she eats. She’s in great shape. The second woman is morbidly obese, I would think she weighs in the region of 27/28 stone. She cannot walk on the flat for 2 minutes without getting breathless. Her joints are sore all the time- she will spontaneously volunteer that info. The first woman was suggesting someone close to the second woman should ‘just tell her to go for a walk every evening, it would make such a difference’, either ignoring or being unaware of many issues including the complex psychology of morbid obesity and weight loss, the impossibility of this woman doing exercise, the fact that diet is more likely to lead to weight loss for her, the joint pains, inevitable ‘chub rub’ and shortness of breath etc, the mockery she would face etc. The intentions may have been good but the execution and delivery certainly would not have been.

I suggest you back off and let this man deal with his health issues with the relevant professionals.

PallasStrand · 29/08/2021 08:57

Well, now I know who those NHS ads addressing women about nagging their husbands into having prostate checks are aimed at. The whole attitude infantilises adult men and turns women into their mothers. I expect DH to manage his own health.

Fucket · 29/08/2021 08:54

I suspect I may get nowhere. Have gone through similar with my own mother who died at 55. Maybe that’s clouding it. I couldn’t stand back and watch her kill her self without trying to get her help. She ignored it too. There is a point, granted, when you have to accept you can’t fix people. But I did help my father, being on the phone checking up on him, he got through his problems and I regularly talk to him about his appointments, diagnosis, prognosis, next steps (he has a different health issue now so lots of medications etc).

OP posts:
Fucket · 29/08/2021 08:49

In my experience of life. FIL wouldn’t see a doctor for years - BIL father - ended up going to hospital because he could no longer urinate. MIL is on his case and manages his appointments. My own father, my own grandfather, all had women looking after them.

Even DH I have to nag to book himself a dental appointment.

It shouldn’t be that way, but it is. Clearly BIL and DH have learned from example and as much as I don’t think it’s right, I care enough to know if Women in men’s lives didn’t care about their health they’d be worse off.

OP posts: