Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pay the childminder

255 replies

Surelyunsure21 · 28/08/2021 23:20

Hi all,

I am hoping to get some advice on a very tricky situation. DP and I have always seemed to find it impossible to find good reliable childcare and as a result we have bit the bullet and put both our DC (aged nearly 3 years old and 18 months) in nursery over 3 days. They are due to start next week which is lucky as I start a new job on Tuesday, it is my dream job so I don’t want anything to mess it up.

Previously to this we have had a childminder for the last 10-11 months however she is highly unreliable.. DP started a new job in February and he was hoping to pass his probationary period this month.. since May the childminder has been incredibly unreliable to the point where on the days where he is working from home he ends up looking after the children, in between working. His job is a lot more flexible for this.. my previous job was in a contact centre so it impossible to even grab a drink when it was not scheduled.

The childminders excuses were always legitimate and obviously there would be no payment for the days they didn’t do but we didn’t mind paying.. we’d rather have smooth childcare than none. The one issue with payment and it was a little something was that they insisted on getting paid for bank holidays even if we didn’t need to send the children (which we didn’t) and if we wanted or needed too it was double fee. We never sent them but we just thought the whole process was ridiculous.

So long story short the childminder has been that unreliable in the last few months that it nearly cost my OH his job. They have chosen to extend it for 3 months but he cannot work from home anymore and he basically doesn’t get any privileges for 3 months (it’s better than being fired though)

I’m due to start a new job and he’s in a probationary which should have ended and we’ve just put our house on the market too sell and move closer to my new job so obviously cannot afford for anything to screw it up. I sat down with OH and we rang a few nurseries in our new area and one had space to take them from next week so we signed them up and paid the deposit.

We then text the childminder to advise them that we would not be requiring their services any longer as they have been so unreliable they have nearly cost my OH his job and that as a result of this we would not be returning them in September and we would not be paying anymore money.

OP posts:
Surelyunsure21 · 29/08/2021 06:20

@Mindyourbusiness22 I don’t want to not pay anything. I am happy to pay 38% of the 4 weeks notice minus the days she owes us so £132.. or she can keep the money she owes us for August and leave it at that

OP posts:
Mindyourbusiness22 · 29/08/2021 06:03

[quote Surelyunsure21]@Still1nLove we aren’t happy to pay for days when she doesn’t take time off.. we either ask for the fee to be returned for those days or she will ask for an occasional day extra so she doesn’t lose out on too money which sometimes when I’ve got housework to catch up on or something I will agree too or I will accept overtime with work. I’ve stopped doing that as of late though because it was making payments messy.

I am not overreacting but August’s payment was only £200 for our fee because she has taken that much time of in July which we paid in advance for.

I’m not happy about the Bank holiday rule because no one else I know works like that. She should charge double for taking the children but nothing if she doesn’t take them.. we shouldn’t have to pay for her being contracted that day but still not taking them.[/quote]
Of course you need to pay for bank holidays, you should also need to pay if you don’t send your child for whatever reason, I assume this is all in the contract?

This is the CM livelihood, she needs to cover herself. You would need to pay for these instances in a nursery, at least you do where I stay.

Lifeisforalimitedperiodonly · 29/08/2021 01:55

I think your offer of paying 38% of the notice is reasonable. I wouldn't feel like paying her one brass farthing more than that. The times her boiler broke and she had a leak - she should still have had your children. the only times she was reasonable was if she was sick or the covid stuff.
Let's face it - if I only worked 38% of my contacted hours for work, because of leaks and broken boilers, I'd get the sack.

NumberTheory · 29/08/2021 01:52

38% of days is utterly ridiculous. “Legitimate” reasons or not, that is not a way to run a business and in your position I would probably be telling her she would need to take further action if she felt you should actually pay notice as you feel her service was so poor she was already in breech.

BlackShadowCat · 29/08/2021 01:02

I understand that you are angry and upset and it's a very frustrating situation but I think you would be better to pay the full amount minus the 4 days from August. She can easily take this to the small claims court and I suspect she would win her case. Is it really worth all the extra stress and hassle? I think it's better just to pay up and be done with it all.

Surelyunsure21 · 29/08/2021 00:46

@Driftingblue and minus the days owed for August.. so £132?

OP posts:
Surelyunsure21 · 29/08/2021 00:45

Without too much of a drip feed the reason he has got into trouble was that she demanded the children take another COVID test even though they had taken one a couple of days earlier. We had run out and I said they took one a few days ago and do you really need another one doing even though they have no symptoms (she doesn’t make us test) she said she wouldn’t take them unless they had it (her household has all recently tested positive anyway) DP went to get tests.. took them to beds when they wed negative and then set off to work. He started at 10 as he can start anytime between 8 & 10 and then he finished at 5PM in order to get back for childcare. He didn’t approve leaving earlier with anyone but he always logs on and does extra in evenings so one thing he got pulled up for was that.

He knows he should have just asked to unexpectedly work from home but he wanted to make a good impression (obviously backfired 🙁)

OP posts:
Driftingblue · 29/08/2021 00:44

Ignore the bank holidays.

For the termination notice, I would offer her 38% of the fee.

Surelyunsure21 · 29/08/2021 00:40

@Potatwoah I’m not trying to swan off without paying anything.. she currently has 5 days she has been paid for and not worked. I am happy for her to keep this and go our separate ways. It is over £250 so she should just accept that otherwise I would be advising her that she will get 40% of the four weeks minus of the 5 days which is £132

OP posts:
Surelyunsure21 · 29/08/2021 00:36

She has only worked 38% of the contracted days which even though some months we had got the fee back. The only month we have asked for the full fee back instead of offering other days has been the fee for August. She worked so little in July that the fee for August was only £200. She has since had a further 4 days off work so owes us 4 days.

Every other month we have tried to accommodate extra days so she wouldn’t lose the fee. For example in May she worked so little that she asked for extra Wednesdays when I am not supposed to be working to cover her fee so she didn’t need to take it out of June’s pay.

She was unreliable again in June though but it got worse by July to the point where she was basically off for the whole month for one reason or another & the fee for August as a result was small to pay those days back. I’ve had my half sister here 4 days this month to watch the children whilst I try and work around them and it’s so stressful.

I got signed off work from stress at the end of the June and through July because it was so bad. I didn’t tell her I was off though because I just thought she would easily keep dropping them. Bearing in mind her notice was usually 1/2 an hour before I was due to start at 8AM

OP posts:
Tataru · 29/08/2021 00:33

Sound a bit bonkers if she's done so little of her days! DD is at nursery and she's never missed a day. It's open all year except two weeks at Christmas, no extra for bank holidays (but yes you would have to pay if you decided not to send them that day, just like any other day).

It sounds totally untenable to have childcare that is so unreliable. I can't work out who owes who what, though, but if she's really been so unreliable and has at least been paid for the work she has done, I think she's got a bit of a cheek to demand the proper notice (which it seems unlikely she'll be able to fulfil on her end anyway).

Potatwoah · 29/08/2021 00:28

@Surelyunsure21

She is self employed and we don’t get invoices. We have a proper contract and it obviously states the days we are sending children and the hours and most months we’ve tried to be good to her by giving her extra days so we have family for one day and I look after them on another day so occasionally like June she hardly worked for Repairs to the boiler etc. & I was given the opportunity for lots of overtime so that month I didn’t get money back because she had done extra days in order to keep the money even though I didn’t actually need her services. I just took overtime after she asked to have them for extra time so the fee wasn’t returned.

I was fed up with all the sending of fees back etc so that month I agreed. I thought it may improve in July but no and that’s when I just said whatever days she is off I am asking for the fee back because it is too difficult fo maintain what with her being off so frequently.

The real hard hit was my other half realising that because childcare had flaked so much he had days were his productivity was so low because he was watching the kids as well that they were extending his probationary period and when we worked it out. We were shocked at how it was

It was your choice to agree to her doing days you didn't actually require rather than a refund, and to be honest she probably thought in that case that as you'd still had x days over a month you were largely content and okay with shifting things about. Your DH is probably in trouble for not being open about it, if he just hasn't been doing any work and keeping his head in the sand hoping they won't notice im not surprised. Did he have a conversation with them about having to work with the child home as no other option? Obviously it's not ideal, but it's nothing new, especially for many women. I very much doubt you'd have any comeback from not paying her, but seems really crap to not try and come to any sort of arrangement and just swan off.
Newmumatlast · 29/08/2021 00:27

[quote Surelyunsure21]@captainpillows and working 38% of the contracted days since May is not a breach? My OH nearly lost his job which meant there would be no payment anyway[/quote]
I'm confused. You say she has only worked 38% of the contracted days but you haven't paid for more than 38% have you? From your OP it sounds as though you've only paid for what she has done. So the issue seems to be that there are contracted elements you still need to pay which you aren't, such as the notice period. If I'm right about all of that then I think you'll have to pay. Perhaps offer part payment to settle and each walk away on the basis she poorly performed during the contract which is why you've no choice but to end without the notice period (which i presume is right though I'm not entirely clear why you couldn't give notice if she has been under performing so long)

Surelyunsure21 · 29/08/2021 00:26

Our debt if we owed it would be £420 and that is with taking the 4 days from August that she owes us off and not even recognising that since May she has only worked 38.8% (this is the accurate amount however we’d round it up to 40% for goodwill)

OP posts:
Surelyunsure21 · 29/08/2021 00:24

So after that month I stopped agreeing*

OP posts:
Surelyunsure21 · 29/08/2021 00:22

She is self employed and we don’t get invoices. We have a proper contract and it obviously states the days we are sending children and the hours and most months we’ve tried to be good to her by giving her extra days so we have family for one day and I look after them on another day so occasionally like June she hardly worked for Repairs to the boiler etc. & I was given the opportunity for lots of overtime so that month I didn’t get money back because she had done extra days in order to keep the money even though I didn’t actually need her services. I just took overtime after she asked to have them for extra time so the fee wasn’t returned.

I was fed up with all the sending of fees back etc so that month I agreed. I thought it may improve in July but no and that’s when I just said whatever days she is off I am asking for the fee back because it is too difficult fo maintain what with her being off so frequently.

The real hard hit was my other half realising that because childcare had flaked so much he had days were his productivity was so low because he was watching the kids as well that they were extending his probationary period and when we worked it out. We were shocked at how it was

OP posts:
AnneElliott · 29/08/2021 00:20

Does she have other kids with her op? I'm sure the other parents also weren't happy about 38%!

I don't think she's being fair about wanting 4 weeks notice when she's been so unavailable. I think you have made a fair offer.

I remember from my childminder dispute (she wanted us to sign a new contract with new dates and we said no. She thought we had to take it and then give her 4 weeks notice) that the childminders union thing only help them recover money if it's over a certain amount. Might be worth finding out what that is and making sure your 'debt' is less than that.

Potatwoah · 29/08/2021 00:19

How often*

Potatwoah · 29/08/2021 00:19

@LemonSwan

38% of contracted days is piss poor.

Just say no. If she takes you to court so be it but I cant see it happening as she sounds in breach of contract before you were.

I also think she's self employed - technically/legally I don't think childminders are anymore - they might be classed as employed. But IMO if you set your own terms, set your own rates etc then you are self employed. Self employed people don't get paid when they are sick, the boiler breaks, etc. etc. and an employed person would have already been fired.

I would be very surprised if any childminders had any sort of clauses regarding hownodten they can close their settings. Yes it's crap and absolutely doesn't make them a good childminder, and causes a load of disruption for parents; but the only real terms usually relate to not charging if they close, and it sounds like OP essentially receives that money back in the next invoice. That said, I agree its extremely unlikely she would go to court.
Shamoo · 29/08/2021 00:17

Legally OP you owe her the full amount for the notice period. Potentially, you also have a claim for breach of contract for her continued cancellation: depends on the validity of her reasons and the terms of your contract.

I agree that the best approach is to say that you aren’t willing to pay the entire 4 weeks based on an assumption she would be fully available in that period as she hasn’t been for months. If she sues you, you will countersue her for breach of contract. However you would rather avoid it getting that messy and therefore you are willing to offer a settlement of paying her the 4 weeks at the rate she has been performing to date (38%), and therefore £x amount (£y amount having already been paid which she is currently due to refund you).

LemonSwan · 29/08/2021 00:14

38% of contracted days is piss poor.

Just say no. If she takes you to court so be it but I cant see it happening as she sounds in breach of contract before you were.

I also think she's self employed - technically/legally I don't think childminders are anymore - they might be classed as employed. But IMO if you set your own terms, set your own rates etc then you are self employed. Self employed people don't get paid when they are sick, the boiler breaks, etc. etc. and an employed person would have already been fired.

Surelyunsure21 · 29/08/2021 00:14

£132*

OP posts:
Potatwoah · 29/08/2021 00:12

If she was upfront about having to pay for bank holidays, and if she technically is open and offering her service and you're choosing not to send your child in then its fair enough she charges. I don't have to work bank Holidays so i made sure to choose someone who didn't work them, so they'd never be open and charging for them, that's your fault and I expect nursery will charge too.

It sounds like the days she isn't opening you are getting money off of the next invoice, so although appreciate its been really challenging, you aren't out of pocket. Have you spoken to her before about it? Why didn't you look for another setting sooner? I can see why youd leave her, but it's shitty not to pay notice and to try and justify it.

Surelyunsure21 · 29/08/2021 00:11

The weekly fee is £180 so should be £720 so 40% is £432, the daily fee is 60 so x 5 days (absence has been 2nd, 3rd and 5th, 24th and 25th) leaves the amount as £192.00

OP posts:
jelly79 · 29/08/2021 00:08

Did you express your dissatisfaction along the way to her?