Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner 'shit at explaining things'

132 replies

COLLIESHANGLES · 28/08/2021 21:11

Her words not mine, this is what she said when I asked her why she is like this.

I adore her, I really do!

And I already suspect I am being unreasonable but wanted opinions.

I like to talk, I will talk about anything for hours. I like to talk quite deeply about everything, she does sometimes but not often. She'll engage more when she's had a few wines!

We're long distance too which makes this more prevalent I feel, and she's quite a closed book in many ways. But if she says she wants to go somewhere and I ask why 'I just do'.

If she tells me she likes me in a certain dress and I ask why 'I just do'.

If she is sentimental and I ask her what's made her feel that way 'Just 'cause'.

This is in speech or in text.

We have a stereotypically beautiful mutual friend. Partner told me she feels I am nicer looking than her. I asked why (genuinely intrigued as to what she may say about that) 'you just are'.

'Why do you like doing XYZ?' 'What makes you prefer here to there'
'I just do'.

I want to know more about her and why she has the views she has because I want to get to know her better. It drives me nuts.

Would it you?

OP posts:
OnwardsAndSideways1 · 28/08/2021 21:57

Surely the OP is only asking 'why' though as usually people volunteer information more readily. I just think either you are conversationally compatible or you are not. I do know someone who has a very monosyllabic husband, she dreads going on holiday with him, but they get on very well as a family and seem to work well as parents together. I think it depends how strong everything else is, personally this would be my idea of hell as I like to have lots of conversations, not all the time and not about everything, but the inability to have even one every now and again just wouldn't be enough for me.

TiredButDancing · 28/08/2021 21:56

Op, don't take this the wrong way but you sound exhausting. You want to analyse and go into intense detail about why she likes a particular dress on you?! You say you could talk about anything for hours.... I'm guessing that includes why you find someone attractive?

I'd rather rip out my own fingernails with a hot poker.

DH and I can spend hours talking about big things - we have an ongoing discussion about racism and sexism for example - but quite honestly a conversation about a nice dress or finding someone attractive would never take more than about 30 seconds.

romdowa · 28/08/2021 21:50

I agree with pp , your constant "whys" would drive me utterly insane. 3 year olds ask why all the time.

Hekatestorch · 28/08/2021 21:47

Also op, why son asks 'why' all the time. It really drives me potty.

Some people don't mind it. But for people who aren't bothered by over analysing something, the constant 'why' becomes old very fast.

FlumpsAreShit · 28/08/2021 21:45

I'm a chatty Cathy but someone wanting evidence for every trivial view I have would be incredibly tiresome! So no, in answer to your question your DP wouldn't drive me nuts I but I think you might Wink

OhWhatFuckeryIsThisNow · 28/08/2021 21:44

I have never in 40 years, asked my dh why he likes something. I don’t think he’s ever asked me. We ask about preferences. We might say “I like that material or style, colour or flavour” we just accept that that’s what we like. It doesn’t need to be analysed.

Hekatestorch · 28/08/2021 21:44

You are like my dp, except has just accepted this is how I am.

To try and explain where I am coming from this is my example.

I find dp Incredibly attractive, like when he walks into a crowded room my stomach jumps, sexy. I can't pin point what it is though.

When he asks why, I can't say exactly what it is. He is tall, but I don't don't find all tall men sexy. He has dark hair and dark eyes and olive skin again, I don't fancy all men with those features.

He isn't classically, model like handsome. But I think he is gorgeous. I even find his walk sexy. But he just walks. He finds it a bit embarrassing and me saying 'the way you walk is sexy' makes him self conscious. Something about him, to me, is really sexy. But I couldn't narrow it down to exact things. Him, as whole, is very very sexy. And to be fair, I am not bothered about spending time disecting it. I just do.

He can't see it, so wanted to know why. But now just accepts, that I think he is sexy and his happy with that.

billy1966 · 28/08/2021 21:42

@titchy

I like to talk, I will talk about anything for hours. I like to talk quite deeply about everything,

She's not you..... ^^ to be honest would drive me as mad as her lack of description drives you. Maybe you're just not compatible. 🤷‍♀️

You are not compatible and your constant why's would piss me off and bore the arse off me in equal measure.

Asking why constantly is inane and would probably turn some off.

3 year olds constantly ask why, and it is considered by some as a deeply trying stage of their development.

I would cut it out and limit your why's to appropriate rather than random topics.

Good luck.Flowers

Noroiscoming · 28/08/2021 21:40

Do you really want to know her opinions or do you just want to pick them apart? My ex is like this, will ask my opinion on something just so he can tell me I'm wrong! Or will ask what I think just so he can then tell me what he thinks.

I'm not saying that's what you are doing, but it is something to be mindful of. My ex has adhd so will dominate a conversation with endless monologues disguised as questions. I've learned to grey rock now as giving detailed answers to everything zaps my energy and makes every conversation a chore.

LeonieSims · 28/08/2021 21:40

Not sure how OP is fishing for compliments by asking why her partner likes a certain dress on her or why her partner decided she's more attractive than a friend.

Most of her examples seem fairly simple... "How come you prefer X (to holiday in Wales) over y (to holiday in Spain)... Or "Why do you like doing X (horse-riding)? How can you not know why you enjoy a certain activity or place over another Confused

RamblingJenny · 28/08/2021 21:38

Same situation, you need friends/family who are of a similar nature to fill that void and love your OH for their own special qualities.

LeonieSims · 28/08/2021 21:36

Hm. Some things can be hard to communicate or pinpoint. Like, she might like you in that dress but can't figure out what part of the dress it is (colour, length, sleeves) that makes you look so good in it (and it's probably a combo anyway).

But, if she says "I don't like winter" but can't explain why, that's a bit odd. Dark days, cold weather, more rain, snow, not festive, doesn't like bulky winter clothes... Really easy to think about.

Aprilx · 28/08/2021 21:33

You sound exhausting to me, I would be bored and fed up with having to explain every single like or dislike send in some of your examples it sounds like fishing for compliments. I think you and I would not be compatible and I think it is the case with you and her too.

bluebeck · 28/08/2021 21:32

Tbh she sounds fairly dull.

This does come across as a compatibility issue Sad

Regularsizedrudy · 28/08/2021 21:32

Your constant ‘whys’ would do my head in and I wouldn’t know what to say either

GrandmaSteglitszch · 28/08/2021 21:30

Why, why, why - sounds like an annoying toddler.
Asking better questions is a good idea, or commenting rather than asking anything e.g. "I like you in that dress", "Thank you. It's my favourite colour."

Starting conversation about things that are slightly more weighty than your dress or your looks could be good too.

Cuddlyrottweiler · 28/08/2021 21:29

Some people aren't good at language. That way that we turn an abstract feeling or thought into words is actually quite insane. And how do you even know that we're calling the same feeling the same word?

Cherryana · 28/08/2021 21:28

I have this dynamic with my DH. He hates my ‘just because’ answers. It drives me up the wall that he always wants reasons and explainations.

So here is my explanation as it’s multilayered:

  1. I think ‘because I think that, like that etc is enough of a reason. My opinion is enough in itself.
  2. I hate questions - in my family growing up to ask questions was equal with being not trusted.
  3. Due to cock-eyed upbringing where no open and curious conversation was allowed (see above) I am super skilled at ignoring/squashing my feelings and thoughts and don’t really know what I think or feel on the spot. So just because …is a blocked response because I have an instinct but no reason.
DrSbaitso · 28/08/2021 21:26

If I got that (the latter part) I would be happy!

Does she not communicate her love and attraction for you? Is that the issue?

As a classic overthinker I do understand this, but some people are just happy with "I like this" and don't need to soul search as to why.

TheChip · 28/08/2021 21:26

It doesn't sound like you are compatible.
I grew extremely bored and frustrated when in a similar relationship. Its not their fault though, it's just a difference in personality. A difference you may or may not be able to handle. I couldnt.
It always felt like they were uninterested and dismissive of what I wanted to talk about.

Try wording things differently as a pp suggested. Hopefully that works.

COLLIESHANGLES · 28/08/2021 21:24

@SwedishEdith

How long have you been together? This just sounds like hard work for both of you if it's like this most of the time. You're conversationally incompatible.
About a year. Obviously with long distance and covid I guess it isn't really a year in fairness.
OP posts:
COLLIESHANGLES · 28/08/2021 21:24

@DrSbaitso

Some people don't think through reasons in this way. You need to accept that's how they are.

My husband is something like this. Loves me in this dress. I ask why. He just does. Come on, give me a reason. "I can't give you a reason, I just love the way it looks and it makes me happy you're my wife, what more do you want?"

What more do I want?

If I got that (the latter part) I would be happy!
OP posts:
SwedishEdith · 28/08/2021 21:23

How long have you been together? This just sounds like hard work for both of you if it's like this most of the time. You're conversationally incompatible.

DrSbaitso · 28/08/2021 21:22

Some people don't think through reasons in this way. You need to accept that's how they are.

My husband is something like this. Loves me in this dress. I ask why. He just does. Come on, give me a reason. "I can't give you a reason, I just love the way it looks and it makes me happy you're my wife, what more do you want?"

What more do I want?

COLLIESHANGLES · 28/08/2021 21:22

@AaronStampler

Try asking better questions! It seems your wide-ranging "why" is too open ended for your partner.

Instead of a plain "why do you like it" you could ask "what's your favourite part of it" or "what does it remind you of" or "tell me about a time you came here before" or "do you think there's any time you might prefer X" or whatever. This requires a bit more effort from you, but does also demonstrate you're listening rather than just batting the conversational ball back to her.

True. I have done this sort of thing before. I am not used to people like her I suppose, none of my family or friends are.

Thanks-yes, I will try that!

OP posts: