Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Clarks Issue

180 replies

stardust22 · 28/08/2021 13:48

Purchased school shoes for my 12 year old about 2 hours ago.

In store appointment booked, feet measured, sales assistant took us over to see shoes for his size. We said we wanted lace ups as in Yr 8 now.

Picked out 2 pairs, sales assistant showed us a different pair of slip on shoes with faux laces/elasticated laces. She explained other people cut the original elasticated laces, take them out and put new normal laces in meaning you can tighten them up more.

She came back with the shoes to try on including the slip on elasticated laced ones. (We had issues with the 2 we chose, so no good.) We then tried the slip on ones, after trying them on and having them fitted the sales assistant noticed when putting back in box one shoe was a 3 ½ and one was a 4. She rectified this then my son tried them on again, had them fitted, walk about etc. He then said I have got 2 right shoes on. The sales assistant went off to rectify this, came back made sure both same size and a left and right shoe.
The shoes were quite loose but she explained once the elastic laces cut and taken out we could replace with normal laces so would be tighter.
We buy new laces at the till at the same time as buying the shoes.

We get home, I sit down, cut the elasticated lace in the one shoe and try to take it out but the laces are attached at the top of the shoe inside the leather and the lining! My husband tried pulling the lace out but it won't budge. Even if we manage to get the elasticated lace out there isn't a hole at the top for a new lace to go through so we'd have to make a hole.

I don't know what to do now. I have tried phoning the store for advice but no answer as they are very busy.

The shoes were £48 and we can't afford to buy a new pair.

I should have looked properly but going on the advice given I just snipped the lace, pulled it and then saw the issue.

Is there any point in trying to speak to the store for advice?

I'll try to attach a photo.

OP posts:
ElfAndSafetyBored · 28/08/2021 18:34

I think Clark’s has gone down hill of late.

They measure my sons feet, tell me the size, go out back with the shoes he likes from stock then come back and say ‘we don’t have size # but he will be OK with size # because these come up small’.

What’s the point in having his feet measured? All they want to do is sell shoes. (Obviously).

No professional pride.

Blossomandbee · 28/08/2021 18:22

Glad you got a refund OP, ridiculous advice from the shop assistant.

I'm not a fan of Clark's or the quality (or choice) but unfortunately they have the monopoly in many towns. My Dc all have big and awkward feet and we can't get shoes in their sizes in most place and nowhere else does fitting.

Lotusmonster · 28/08/2021 17:57

Wow. Refund given but sent away with a flea in your ear and negative publicity to a wide audience. Can we add Clark’s to the ‘brands I won’t buy” thread?!!!

Wineandroses3 · 28/08/2021 17:45

I used to work on the children’s dept at Clark’s , one of the reasons they’re so expensive is your paying for Childrens to be fit - this is part of the of the service and why you pay more, so I would do as others suggest - take them back cos you’ve been sold children’s shoes that don’t fit. I would ask to speak to the Manager as i really doubt it’s company policy to be telling customers to cut the shoes to adjust them in order to make them fit ! They should fit when you walk out the shop. Sometimes if a parent chose to ignore they shop assistant advice they would write on the receipt that they had not been “fit checked” so if the customer brought them back due to poor fit they wouldn’t get a refund.

MockneyReject · 28/08/2021 17:35

Any use, OP? Or, anyone else?
www.startriteshoes.com/logic-black-leather-black-boys-riptape-school-shoes
After several disappointing experiences with Clarks, we gave up. The worst were a beautiful looking pair of Navy sandals - I say 'pair', but they were so shoddy that I had to pick the closest two shoes from 4 boxes, to even get anything like a pair, because the stitching was so inconsistent. Then, school shoes so big that he tripped over the empty toes, despite my making it clear I didn't care about 'growing room' - I wanted them to fit NOW, while they new, rather than in 6 months time, when they we're so knackered, they needed replacing, anyhow!
Whilst Startrites are a bit more expensive, and by no means 'trendy', they are better quality and a consistently better fit.
I ordered these in 3 and 3.5, last week, for my (smallish)11 year old. They arrived (within 3;days) and are perfectly ok, neutral looking, decent quality, uniform rule-abiding school shoes. The velcro tab makes them a bit more adjustable.
Both pairs were too big, mind, so I've now ordered them in 2 and 2.5. For reference, my son's Adidas trainers are s3. Start rites def. come up big.
Whatever; even if the 2s are too small and need to be passed on, I still have 3 year's worth of inoffensive school shoes for £54!

AllTheSingleLadiess · 28/08/2021 17:30

Clarks fitting is rubbish so I go to John Lewis instead who are miles better. I've had success at Charles Clinkard too

Quisto · 28/08/2021 17:24

I bought a pair of shoes for my son from Treads on line. Free delivery and free return and guaranteed to last a year. He was so pleased with the last pair that I've just got the next size up for this year.

mrcow · 28/08/2021 17:23

3 children here and after (many, many) years of using Clark’s I’ve given up and now go to M&S.

I find them very good quality. I just check the fit myself. My children are happy. They are cheaper than Clark’s and so much less hassle!

Peanutsandchilli · 28/08/2021 17:14

We've always done well with Hush Puppies. My daughters are going into years 7 and 9 and I haven't had to buy them any new school shoes this year as the ones I bought last September are still in perfectly good condition (and their feet have stopped growing so quickly!) We used to do ok at Clark's but they haven't been great, recently. I have bought them for my 4 year old but I got some for £20 from a different website (last year's stock) so I don't feel too bad if they get wrecked or fall apart!

BikeRunSki · 28/08/2021 17:12

M&S school shoes. Game changer.

BikeRunSki · 28/08/2021 17:09

@toolazytothinkofausername

Clarks are the worst for school shoes! I have no idea how they are still in business Hmm
Agreed
Dbank · 28/08/2021 16:59

Just buy a hole punch and put it down to experience.

Callmecordelia · 28/08/2021 16:58

Not all Clarks are the same. The Clarks in Deal is a franchise and a family business, and we had a great experience there recently.

caramac4 · 28/08/2021 16:49

I highly recommend Charles Clinkards if you have nearby store. I only shopped once in Clarks and the assistant was brought out shoes and trainers...there was an offer if both were bought. Even though I told him shoes only when he mentioned the offer. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Cccc1111 · 28/08/2021 16:46

What @BlackberrySky said. I used to work in one of the other chains fitting kids shoes in my teens. There is a lot of teaching tricks to fudge stuff. And yes I was on commission then, all the chains paid commission then, I doubt that has changed now. I’m a pain when I get my ds fitted because I still remember all the tricks, and how to check the fit for myself too, it’s a handy past job!

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 28/08/2021 16:31

I went into Next a few weeks ago and they had A3 printed sheets in the kids shoe section that you could take away with you. Just put them on the floor against the wall and have them stand on them and you can see the size and width. Really handy, free, re-usable and worked really well.

Then sainsburys for shoes and some trainers for PE.

TruJay · 28/08/2021 16:31

I’ve just ordered some pairs of kickers from Footasylum for them both and will see how we get on. I’ve ordered them a pair each but in two sizes 🤦🏼‍♀️ Fingers crossed at least one pair fits.

Kerplunkk · 28/08/2021 16:12

I buy DS kickers - not the boot type but they do shoes too, wallaby or trainer style but smart enough to pass in senior school.

Thebookswereherfriends · 28/08/2021 16:08

I always get my daughter measured at Russel and Bromley and then buy somewhere else. Last year she really liked a pair in Sainsbury’s and they lasted really well and she found them super comfortable. Only cost £18, too!

Authenticcelestialmusic · 28/08/2021 16:07

I think the sizes vary in Clark’s. I always buy work shoes from there and vary between a 4.5 and a 6. Unless the shoes sizes are exactly the same between styles how can the foot measuring devices be accurate?

Schuh use measuring devices but again I’m not convinced a size 10 DM is the same size as another size 10 shoe brand.

ElephantOfRisk · 28/08/2021 15:58

There are decent fitting guides on youtube (even clarks ones...) that show you how to fit shoes. I'd have a watch and fit yourself. Next usually have some decent shoes, mine also had Kickers which were good (bought when on sale on Amazon)

TruJay · 28/08/2021 15:57

@2reefsin30knots They look fantastic! Thank you. They start in a size 3 and dd is a 1.5, well she was measured today as that. I will check crocs site and see if they have anything similar in a smaller size. Thank you for your help.

If no luck though, I’m seriously considering getting a black pair of crocs and she can wear them for school. At least then her feet have some protection during the day at school and she’ll just wear her crocs wellies for the school run as it gets colder/wetter and then switch into crocs when she arrives.

Like you say, their ability to learn is not affected by footwear. It’s also harder for her as with such a break from school during lockdowns and summer break she’s been barefoot/crocs for so long now, it’ll be hard getting her back into shoes anyway.

FabianK · 28/08/2021 15:57

@BlackberrySky

I bought those exact shoes in the same size for my 12 year old last week. They are not loose in the fit at all, nor are they meant to be. It sounds like the sales assistant was very poorly trained - not knowing about the shoe, getting the wrong size and feet, and of course that ridiculous advice about cutting the elastic out! It is so annoying when they don't have what you want (on your case lace ups) so they try and fudge it with what they do have. If you had ordered the ones you wanted she wouldn't have got her commission so I wonder if that's where her "advice" came from.
They don’t get commission. They are paid hourly
RocioMartinez · 28/08/2021 15:56

I just bought my DC a pair of Doc Martens school shoes. They were £60 for a size 5 (the largest size they do for kids). They look robust like a normal pair of chunky lace-ups, and we've finally found something for her extra-wide feet.

CasparBloomberg · 28/08/2021 15:54

If you can’t find a trusted local shoe shop, then I highly recommend Treads after awful experiences with Clarke’s. Online but their customer service is superb (free delivery and returns, plus quick to deal with queries about sizing) and the shoes are just brilliant. Look new forever rather than trashed in a term!
www.treads-shoes.com/