Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is UK so child unfriendly?

783 replies

bezabez · 28/08/2021 08:08

Hi! I am foreign person living in the UK for the past 15 years.

I have noticed that the attitudes towards children are really strange in this country. Generally kids aren't accepted to be kids. They are expected to be quiet (ish) if out and about eg in a restaurant or a cafe, women don't breastfeed often in public (UK has the lowest rate of breastfeeding in the world) and they are expected 'to do as you're told' - that's a weird expression in itself tbh and to behave and never show a wild side. If on a train or other public spaces people tend not to engage with them even with babies (where I'm from there would be talking and smiling and general admirations) or tthey make faces, huffing and puffing etc if the children 'misbehave'.

Also parents complain A LOT about having children, sometimes as a form of a banter as these are socially acceptable jokes. Especially during the holidays.

On top of that there aren't many affordable childcare options or things like holiday camps and clubs (I know they exist in bigger cities sometimes but it isn't the same).

Overall it's no place for young people!

Does it come from the Victorian 'kids are to be seen not heard' thing?

Again where I'm from kids are celebrated as the future here they are mostly treated as inconvenience.

OP posts:
ADreadedSunnyDay · 29/08/2021 10:57

@PrivateHall
I don't want to hijack this thread but in my experience there is very little pragmatic and practical breastfeeding support. I had contradictory and confusing advice from HV, Community midwives, hospital midwives, breastfeeding clinic, GP. Not one of the health professionals actually diagnosed the real issue which was lactose intolerance.

Goldbar · 29/08/2021 10:57

But in a carrier of some sort they tend to take up far less space. There are often threads about the size of buggies or "taking up the coffee shop with huge buggies" etc hence why I would always use a carrier. Feeding doesn't matter but I'm not sure why bf triggered you.

It didn't (not relevant but I bf my DC until 20 months). But I'm amazed that it seems incomprehensible to some parents that, regardless of how they choose to feed and transport their children, some restaurants may not welcome them. It may have nothing to do with the space the child takes up but more that the restaurant does not welcome the noise and disruption caused by young children.

Macncheeseballs · 29/08/2021 10:57

Privatehall, that's interesting, so then the hurdle to overcome is to get women more comfortable with the idea of bf infront of others

Buttons294749 · 29/08/2021 10:54

I think a lot of it is interacting with children in even the least offensive way might invite abuse by the parent. I was in the supermarket and heard someone say to DC1 "don't hit your brother" (both in trolley) instead if tearing a new one I told DC off for hitting their sibling but a lot of parent would object.

PrivateHall · 29/08/2021 10:52

@Jangle33

Who would want noisy children running round a restaurant, I really don’t think that’s acceptable in any country including the U.K.
I have to agree! Though I must admit I prefer it to hearing Peppa Pig loudly on their tablet haha!
breadwidow · 29/08/2021 10:51

I can really see where the OP is coming from. Children are certainly well catered for in terms of facilities in the uk but I think that is because they are seen as needing to be kept separate from adults. There is less acceptance of them being around adults/in places that are seen as 'for adults', like restaurants especially in evenings. In Spain for example you could go out to dinner at 9pm with kids and it would be fine, no one would think it's odd. In the uk you'd get looks (unless it was some where in a big city with mainly non British clientele!), even if your kids were well behaved. This is obv related to the fact people eat later in Spain but I do think there is more acceptance of kids being part of life in Mediterranean countries in particular.

I was talking to DH about a connected issue this morning. I love in central London and we take our kids to eat out a lot - no where posh more like China town and other mid priced places, Usually Asian, & mainly at lunch time. As a result of going out regularly our kids are pretty well behaved in restaurants. Some of my friends with kids rarely do this, and as a result rarely eat out. I suspect it's is because they live in the suburbs, with fewer 'ethnic restaurants', as it's these places where kids are always welcome. Interestingly these restaurants do not lay on special stuff for kids beyond high chairs (you never get a colouring pack or kids menu in China town) but the staff just accept kids will be there, which is all I want.

PrivateHall · 29/08/2021 10:50

@SmidgenofaPigeon

He breastfeeding rate is low because there’s crap all support in the early days for it, not because women don’t want to feed their children in public.

Teaching children boundaries and how they should behave in public is no bad thing. The park is a great place for them to let off a wild side. A cafe or a train, not so much.

Lack of affordable childcare is the fault of the government, and that is a big problem. Do you have a good system where you are from for affordable childcare?

This isn't true, the reason for low rates of bf are complex. It is much more to do with cultural expectations. Lots of visitors coming in, mum feeling she can't bf in front of them, baby getting passed around everyone so staying fast asleep etc is definitely a part of it.

As a midwife, the first lockdown was amazing for me to see the impact of that - no visitors meant I spent 4 months not having to refer any babies back up for jaundice, weightloss, etc. Our bf rates were amazing - but alas it all reverted back at the end of lockdown. Given that staff shortages meant the bf support would have been poorer at that time, I think its fair to attribute it to the lack of visitors.

There is a major cultural issue here - bf is simply not seen as the norm. Formula and bottles are everywhere. Siblings don't get to see babies bf so it isn't assumed to be the norm by them growing up. It isn't talked about generally or learned about in school. Family and friends are constantly pressuring women to give the baby a bottle to make them sleep longer.

It is easy to blame midwives I know, but believe me that view is far too simplistic and gets us nowhere. BF rates in Ireland are similar to Northern Ireland - Ireland doesn't even have community midwives, no one comes to your home to help you. NI does have community mw with at least 3 long home visits, more as needed. America has good bf rates yet also no postnatal care. You have to pay a couple of hundred pounds there just to hold your baby skin to skin after a section! There really isn't evidence to suggest that support from a HCP is the one key to improving bf rates.

Sirzy · 29/08/2021 10:48

I don’t think most people think kids are an inconvenience. Personally I have taken DS to a whole host of places since he was a baby with no issues at all.

I was out last night listening to some music in a lovely town centre market and there was a massive range of ages from babies up in there. Some children having a lovely time dancing around, certainly no sign of them being an inconvenience!

monogoo · 29/08/2021 10:46

It was the "breast-fed, sling-carried" in conjunction with the "inoffensive" . Babies are capable of being a disturbance however they are fed and carried.

But in a carrier of some sort they tend to take up far less space. There are often threads about the size of buggies or "taking up the coffee shop with huge buggies" etc hence why I would always use a carrier. Feeding doesn't matter but I'm not sure why bf triggered you.

bezabez · 29/08/2021 10:41

@HalzTangz

For me, no matter whether you are an adult or child, in public areas everyone should be respectful of each other. So behaving in restaurants or on trains should be done by all. As another poster said, parks are great for letting children run wild, as are soft play areas etc.

OP you need to remember not everyone wants to coo over your baby, or talk to your children. I don't do do this in the UK or any other country. They are you're children that you chose to have, no one else is obliged to interact with them or put up with their noise when trying to travel or dine out anywhere

The point of this thread is really Why are children in the UK treated by adults (not all adults it is a generalisation) as an inconvenience and not as a treasure? All kids, any kids. Not mine personally, all of them.

Nobody answered this or made a valid point. People focus on behaviour in restaurants or how many soft plays/ play parks there are. Further proving my point that it may be a child centric country where facilities are provided as a way to separate children from adults which isn't child friendly, it is adult friendly.

Not the point. The point is people's attitudes, Kids= inconvenience. Why?

OP posts:
Goldbar · 29/08/2021 10:39

It was the "breast-fed, sling-carried" in conjunction with the "inoffensive" Hmm. Babies are capable of being a disturbance however they are fed and carried.

monogoo · 29/08/2021 10:35

breast fed, sling carried babies.

I love this phrase . It has a very superior ring to it! Sort of like organic, corn-fed chicken.

What on earth is superior about a bf baby in a sling? Why has this annoyed you?

I always took my baby in a carrier if we were going out to eat, less crap to take up space.

Feelingmardy · 29/08/2021 10:31

Bottle-fed babies can also be carried in slings and mine were very quick to settle with a bottle. Much quicker than some of my friends breast-fed babies. Not all but I didn't see a correlation between feeding method and how quickly hungry babies settled.

Macncheeseballs · 29/08/2021 10:30

Jangle33, so you call the perfectly natural and temporary stage in a babies life when it can get all its food from one source, it's mother, - 'the mother taking over'? Blimey, and there was I thinking I was just looking after my kids, but no, I was taking over

HalzTangz · 29/08/2021 10:28

For me, no matter whether you are an adult or child, in public areas everyone should be respectful of each other. So behaving in restaurants or on trains should be done by all.
As another poster said, parks are great for letting children run wild, as are soft play areas etc.

OP you need to remember not everyone wants to coo over your baby, or talk to your children. I don't do do this in the UK or any other country. They are you're children that you chose to have, no one else is obliged to interact with them or put up with their noise when trying to travel or dine out anywhere

SoupDragon · 29/08/2021 10:25

Of course a breast-fed sling-carried baby is an entirely different proposition to a bottle-fed, buggy-transported horror. How silly of restaurants not to realise the distinction!

Well, there's a big difference in the amount of stuff they come with. A buggy takes up a lot of space.

EverybodyIsInteresting · 29/08/2021 10:25

They just take up next to no space and rarely make a murmur

Bwahahaha. I wish someone had told my breast fed sling carried daughter that she should barely make a murmur! I freaking wish.

HoldingTheDoor · 29/08/2021 10:23

What happens if you put a formula fed baby in a sling? Do they spontaneously combust?

karmakameleon · 29/08/2021 10:20

@Goldbar

breast fed, sling carried babies.

I love this phrase GrinGrinGrin. It has a very superior ring to it! Sort of like organic, corn-fed chicken.

Babies like this tend to be inoffensive and don’t usually inconvenience anyone apart from their mothers

Of course a breast-fed sling-carried baby is an entirely different proposition to a bottle-fed, buggy-transported horror. How silly of restaurants not to realise the distinction!

There’s nothing superior about it. They just take up next to no space and rarely make a murmur. When they do, they are quick to settle.

I’ve also had a formula fed baby in a pram (my last couldn’t breastfeed and I couldn’t carry him) and I can see why he wouldn’t be easy to accommodate in a restaurant and why his presence might impact others.

ofwarren · 29/08/2021 10:09

@Alonelonelylonersbadidea

I've lived in 7 different countries, all over the world, and spent a lot of time in others. As a parent.

Hands down worst Switzerland.
Hands down best China.

UK is somewhere in the middle.
My opinion is for sure different from others but it's my experience.
I have lots of kids and I absolutely expect them to be well-behaved in restaurants and theatres etc. it's learning basic respect for others.
I also absolutely expect to be able to breastfeed in public without issue. In UK I have.
I don't think UK attitudes indicate a lack of liking for kids just a lack of interest and frankly this makes sense. I am not interested in other people's kids either!

Just out of interest, what makes you say China was the best? I know nothing of their culture.
Alonelonelylonersbadidea · 29/08/2021 09:58

I've lived in 7 different countries, all over the world, and spent a lot of time in others.
As a parent.

Hands down worst Switzerland.
Hands down best China.

UK is somewhere in the middle.
My opinion is for sure different from others but it's my experience.
I have lots of kids and I absolutely expect them to be well-behaved in restaurants and theatres etc. it's learning basic respect for others.
I also absolutely expect to be able to breastfeed in public without issue. In UK I have.
I don't think UK attitudes indicate a lack of liking for kids just a lack of interest and frankly this makes sense. I am not interested in other people's kids either!

Goldbar · 29/08/2021 09:55

breast fed, sling carried babies.

I love this phrase GrinGrinGrin. It has a very superior ring to it! Sort of like organic, corn-fed chicken.

Babies like this tend to be inoffensive and don’t usually inconvenience anyone apart from their mothers

Of course a breast-fed sling-carried baby is an entirely different proposition to a bottle-fed, buggy-transported horror. How silly of restaurants not to realise the distinction!

ilovesooty · 29/08/2021 09:47

@daisypond

It was the sheer entitled attitude of this woman to think she should be able to sit and watch a show IN COMPLETE AND UTTER SILENCE that I really found unbelievable.

Am I missing something? Of course you expect to watch a show at the theatre in complete and utter silence. That’s what I would expect too.

I expect to watch a play in silence too, unless it's a pantomime or similar.
Hardbackwriter · 29/08/2021 09:31

If you look back at my post you’ll see I started phoning ahead and plenty of places (when asked) didn’t want breast fed, sling carried babies. Babies like this tend to be inoffensive and don’t usually inconvenience anyone apart from their mothers

Did you describe the baby as 'breastfed, sling carried' to the restaurants?! If so I really wouldn't have wanted to give you a table either, as you sound like you're going to be a smug nightmare who would think the baby was 'just gurgling sweetly' as they screamed the place down. And I have a six month old (my second) who has been in a pram about four times ever, so much is my devotion to the sling, and has had even fewer bottles (mostly because he hates them) - but I'd never suggest that as a 'breastfed, sling carried baby' he was some sort of superior breed who would never annoy others! He actually is a very easygoing thing (though I wouldn't bet others' evenings on him staying quiet) but his brother, also breastfed and sling carried, knew how to cause a scene as a baby...

marmaladehound · 29/08/2021 09:13

@ofwarren well the thread is not talking about abuse and absolute illegal acts taking place against children.

But on a day to day level we are not a child friendly country. Most of the comments on here verify why... talking about controlling children, children been quiet etc. I am UK born and bred, and in this respect we are not child friendly compared to other cultures that actually value children, clearly not the ones you are referring to, which tbh is going off on a tangent on the point OP is making.