Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is UK so child unfriendly?

783 replies

bezabez · 28/08/2021 08:08

Hi! I am foreign person living in the UK for the past 15 years.

I have noticed that the attitudes towards children are really strange in this country. Generally kids aren't accepted to be kids. They are expected to be quiet (ish) if out and about eg in a restaurant or a cafe, women don't breastfeed often in public (UK has the lowest rate of breastfeeding in the world) and they are expected 'to do as you're told' - that's a weird expression in itself tbh and to behave and never show a wild side. If on a train or other public spaces people tend not to engage with them even with babies (where I'm from there would be talking and smiling and general admirations) or tthey make faces, huffing and puffing etc if the children 'misbehave'.

Also parents complain A LOT about having children, sometimes as a form of a banter as these are socially acceptable jokes. Especially during the holidays.

On top of that there aren't many affordable childcare options or things like holiday camps and clubs (I know they exist in bigger cities sometimes but it isn't the same).

Overall it's no place for young people!

Does it come from the Victorian 'kids are to be seen not heard' thing?

Again where I'm from kids are celebrated as the future here they are mostly treated as inconvenience.

OP posts:
ViceLikeBlip · 28/08/2021 10:10

I think this might be specifically a London thing. Ps I'm a teacher, and never once have I heard a teacher complain that parents in the UK are too strict, and expect unrealistically good behaviour 🤣🤣

Sashimiandhisthunderpaws · 28/08/2021 10:10

@Hardbackwriter I suppose if the younger children are used to a routine with bedtime at 7 they will be tired and play up in the the evening. But it also depends on the dynamic of the group are the adults engaged with the children or are they left to their own devices and messing around.

I’ve always been quite flexible with DD5 bedtime and routine. Now as a single parent, we spend quite a lot of time with the grandparents and other older members of extended family so she is used to mixing with adults and attending not child-focused places. I don’t have any problems with taking her to restaurants in the evenings. We were in a hostel on holiday and we’d be in the bar until 9. I wouldn’t tolerate bad behaviour or getting under people’s feet though.

TempleofZoom · 28/08/2021 10:08

@fizbosshoes

The only thing I would say is that on the rare occassion I took my kids on public transport when they were very young and in a pushchair or pram, almost no one ever offered to help. (I know they are my own children and my responsibility) I was even talking on the platform with a man I knew from the same church while we waited for the train, and as soon as the train came he said "nice talking to you " and walked up the other end to get on leaving me to get the baby in the pram onto the train by myself!

Now I am really conscious of it and if i see a parent on their own with children i always offer to help.

I dont really understand this. Walk to train, tilt pram up a few inches, push onto train. What help would you need?
DarlingFell · 28/08/2021 10:08

DH and I have a holiday home in France and it is child friendlier than back home BUT French children ARE better behaved and quieter than British kids so are more easily tolerated!

EmeraldShamrock · 28/08/2021 10:04

I think it is generational issue.
After a certain age there should be a no child zone housing area for those who want it.
It isn't only the UK.
I grew up around here.
I know parents who raised 8/9 feral DC in their time who have a fit if a ball rolls past the garden these days or the DC laugh loudly or play chasing on the street.
It is so rude of them, ageism towards DC.
I'd love child free housing estates send the curtain twitches there.
Most long-time residents are moans some love DC chat with them.
The estate has been build up from 100 homes to hundreds plus apartment blocks.
Ireland needs retirement estates.
So we can all be happier.
PS I bring my DS off 7 hours a day so he doesn't disturb the neighbours.
I'm conditioned to care for some reason. Hmm

Howareyouflower · 28/08/2021 10:03

@CeeceeBloomingdale

I take my children to wild open beaches or countryside to run free, they are expected to sit through a meal in a restaurant. I breast fed in public and in over 4 years of it cumulatively no one ever said anything or even looked disapproving . The UK has people living on the whole quite close to each other so I teach them to be respectful and quiet when it might disturb other people. I live in the north and completely disagree about people not engaging with children, it's very normal here but there is definitely a north south divide.
I agree with this. When my children were young I gave them plenty of time and opportunity to run, play, shout, be wild. But when we went out to a restaurant, they were reminded when we went in, that other people were in there for a nice quiet meal, and wouldn't want to be disturbed. They were happy to sit and eat, and to talk. When I was childminding and fostering, and we went to a cafe, the children knew that was my coffee break, so we had a routine where they would happily sit with a drink and a biscuit and look at books and chat, whilst I looked at a magazine. People often engaged with them and me, because everyone loves a well behaved child. When we went to the park they could run wild and make noise.
StrangeToSee · 28/08/2021 10:02

I think it’s partially because many parents in the U.K. raise their kids with no rules or boundaries, so a lot of children are disrespectful to adults (eg interrupting conversations, shouting to get what they want, not respecting elders etc).

In countries where children are brought up in large multi generational families there seem to be more rules and cultural expectations, eg grandparents/aunts/uncles help to enforce boundaries. Children are taught from a young age when it’s appropriate to run around shouting and playing wildly and when they need to sit quietly, and there are consequences for getting it wrong eg acting out at a social event.

Obviously many U.K. parents do this too. But many don’t.

BeeFloof · 28/08/2021 10:01

@GintyMcGinty

I don't feel where I live in the UK is not child friendly.

Loads of places to go.
Loads of public events for families with children.
Cafes and restaurants galore
I breastfed everywhere and anywhere and never had a problem

I had no problem with childcare although it was eye watering expensive

Breastfeeding rates are appalling but that is due to lack of support rather than no where to feed.

Agree with this! I breastfed mine two until they were 2.5. I fed them in public and apart from one single occasion (two older ladies whispering and scowling at me in an IKEA cafe!) I didn’t get any negative looks/comments.

Childcare is definitely hideously expensive. My youngest has finished nursery this week and I’m so pleased we don’t have those fees to pay now,

Melissa1771 · 28/08/2021 09:59

I agree. I live in Hong Kong and have noticed that people are so lovely with my toddler here. They expect him to act like a small child, and they engage with him. In the U.K. we fawn over babies and after that kids are treated like an inconvenience. Yes parents shouldn’t allow wild behaviour to the extent they can control it but also there’s little recognition in the U.K. that small kids are learning and training and not fully developed yet.

Also here there are amazing playgrounds everywhere.

BungleandGeorge · 28/08/2021 09:58

@Hemingwaycat

I breastfeed mine walking down the street sometimes and I don’t personally notice but DH notices I get stared at a lot. I’m not bothered at all, I’ve breastfed all over the place because it’s my baby’s food but people do gawp like it’s a weird thing to do. Our overall attitude towards breasts needs to change, they’ve become overly sexualised.

As for other things, I agree we have a Dickensian attitude towards children. Stems from the seen and not heard, it’s almost disrespectful to allow your children to make any sort of noise in a public setting which is inhuman.

I’d be wondering about the trip hazard rather than anything to do with breastfeeding!
Hardbackwriter · 28/08/2021 09:56

@Hemingwaycat

I breastfeed mine walking down the street sometimes and I don’t personally notice but DH notices I get stared at a lot. I’m not bothered at all, I’ve breastfed all over the place because it’s my baby’s food but people do gawp like it’s a weird thing to do. Our overall attitude towards breasts needs to change, they’ve become overly sexualised.

As for other things, I agree we have a Dickensian attitude towards children. Stems from the seen and not heard, it’s almost disrespectful to allow your children to make any sort of noise in a public setting which is inhuman.

I would try not to stare but I would look if you were breastfeeding while walking down the street, in pure admiration! I've fed in public many times and in some quite odd places, but despite trying in a sling I've never managed doing it on the move.
Iimaginethiswillbefun · 28/08/2021 09:55

I think the UK is set up to include children as much as possible.

I think the difference is we don’t necessarily paw over other peoples children.

When I went to Portugal when DS was a baby someone took him out of his high chair and walked round the restaurant with him because he had ginger hair. I didn’t actually like it too much.

Same for when I was alone in Spain and Greece with him and my two dd’s they kept touching their hair and faces because the girls were white blonde. They didn’t like it. It made me paranoid to constantly have my eye on them.

France when ds and dd were little didn’t have a single high chair and at one restaurant I had to tie dd to an adult chair to secure her in with a hoodie all while we were stared and tutted at because she was making a noise.

I do smile at kids in the supermarket or if if a child is staring in the queue I say hello. But I wouldn’t touch them it’s not appropriate.

Also I do expect kids to kind of be well behaved in restaurants I can’t bear them charging around inside it’s dangerous and not fair to the staff.

The Uk isn’t child unfriendly it’s childcare affordability unfriendly.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 28/08/2021 09:55

Hmm, I am from one supposedly child-friendly country and have lived in another (Italy). It's more complicated than you are suggesting, OP. Yes, Italians will always smile at babies, whereas some Brits will greet you as if you're holding a dog turd. But facilities for the kids in the UK are generally much better - there is a reason why the Italian birth rate is so low! If you think it's hard work pushing a stroller around London, try any Italian city - no dropped kerbs, stairs everywhere, no family toilets (Milan a slight exception)

All the Mediterranean countries with a child-friendly reputation do have boundaries on where you can take kids too. There are unashamedly adult spaces and I think this helps with tolerance of kids in family-friendly areas, because adults have a choice.

vivainsomnia · 28/08/2021 09:52

I travelled in many different countries as a single mum when my kids were little. I rarely needed help, only maybe to help carry luggage. I had help on a casual basis in the UK as well as foreign country. What I have found is that most people are very helpful if you asked politely and kindly.

What I had almost every trip is people commenting on how well behaved and charming my kids were. They only were because I planned every hours of the trips. Everything was on a schedule and therefore under control. I interacted with them, quietly, and also made sure they had plenty to keep them busy.

What I often see in journey with kids who misbehave is parents who just can't be bothered to entertain, interact, watch over their kids. They speak amongst adults, are on their phone, or just standing there doing nothing. they let their kids gradually misbehave more and more until they shout at them to pack it in, if at all. Kids behave for 2 mns and start again. They have nothing but screens to occupy them which are either very noisy, or they get bored with after a few minutes.

letsmakethishappen · 28/08/2021 09:51

I’ve lived elsewhere too and this isn’t true OP. In the UK children come first while elsewhere children come last. Kids are shouted, slapped etc where I come from while here that’s abuse. The breastfeeding in public thing is cultural where I come from women’s boobs are out breastfeeding no one complains it’s the norm while here you have to find a place to to hide to breastfeed which I found very strange at first but again it’s the culture.

user1493494961 · 28/08/2021 09:51

Nowadays, it would be considered very odd to give a stranger's children excessive attention.

PallasStrand · 28/08/2021 09:50

I agree with some of your points, OP, including the one that it’s about fundamental attitudes, not facilities — I have a nine year old with whom I’ve lived in three countries, and lived in others before I had him. I also think it’s perfectly possible for a culture to be simultaneously child-obsessed and intolerant of children’s presence apart from in a few mandated spaces — and for childcare to be seen as an expensive individual problem, not an important service the state should provide affordably and at a high-quality level. I can’t find the post again, but I think a pp had a point that children are still seen in the UK as a ‘women’s thing’.

I think Mn exemplifies at times a certain kind of perma-tutting intolerance toward child behaviour. One friend of mine with two children with additional needs stopped coming on here because she said that lengthy threads full of judgement about ‘misbehaving’ children in restaurants or supermarkets made her feel worse when dealing with hers having a meltdown in public because she now felt she understood what was behind the glances, or some of them.

Hardbackwriter · 28/08/2021 09:50

[quote Sashimiandhisthunderpaws]@MissJeanBrodiesprime exactly. You can take children to Macdonalds or Harvester. But god forbid taking them to the local Indian/Italian after 5.

We would take DD to restaurants on Edgeware Road and other Middle Eastern restaurants. It was common to see families with young children in restaurants eating at 10pm. Restaurant staff are normally welcoming but the daggers from other customers when the only thing DD was breathing when it was mainly British diners. Grin[/quote]
Tbh I do inwardly sigh when I see a child under about 7 at a restaurant in the evening. Because I have literally never seen this end well or pass without the child becoming a complete nuisance to others at some point.

Hemingwaycat · 28/08/2021 09:49

I breastfeed mine walking down the street sometimes and I don’t personally notice but DH notices I get stared at a lot. I’m not bothered at all, I’ve breastfed all over the place because it’s my baby’s food but people do gawp like it’s a weird thing to do. Our overall attitude towards breasts needs to change, they’ve become overly sexualised.

As for other things, I agree we have a Dickensian attitude towards children. Stems from the seen and not heard, it’s almost disrespectful to allow your children to make any sort of noise in a public setting which is inhuman.

Wagglerock · 28/08/2021 09:49

My baby gets loads of fuss when we're out. Tbh it's getting a bit exhausting. Maybe you're not giving out the right vibes.

I'm always excited to see a puppy though. Puppies are mega 😍

lifehappened · 28/08/2021 09:48

@bezabez

My op is about attitudes not facilities. The last sentence sums up my point.

Pets are more cherished/respected.
If there was a baby and a puppy in the same place at the same time I can guarantee that the puppy would receive way more attention than the baby.

It doesn't matter which country I am from but it is a country in Europe and I have traveled around different European countries and really it is the UK (mostly England) that stands out with this attitudes. All the people arguing really prove my point.

Personally I think it is sad.

How does "all the people arguing prove your point?" Because some people experience a different thing to you and have the nerve to say so that's means you're right? That makes no sense
TempleofZoom · 28/08/2021 09:47

@ActonSquirrel

I would expect a child (who is old enough) to have been taught there is a time and a place

They can run riot in a park, on the beach, their own garden, etc etc

They must not in a restaurant or cafe or or shops or where their behaviour would be a nuisance or disturb others enjoyment.

That's just good parenting not being child unfriendly

Completely agree with this. Children need to learn to behave appropriately in different settings. Basic parenting imho. Im not particularly interested in other peoples DC and wouldnt help unless asked directly or saw someone in distress. Holding doors open etc is basic manners applied to everyone.

I find it odd that OP thinks UK is not child friendly , it is but no one likes poorly parented DC.
I think thats the issue OpWink

Sashimiandhisthunderpaws · 28/08/2021 09:46

@MissJeanBrodiesprime exactly. You can take children to Macdonalds or Harvester. But god forbid taking them to the local Indian/Italian after 5.

We would take DD to restaurants on Edgeware Road and other Middle Eastern restaurants. It was common to see families with young children in restaurants eating at 10pm. Restaurant staff are normally welcoming but the daggers from other customers when the only thing DD was breathing when it was mainly British diners. Grin

middleager · 28/08/2021 09:45

@Benjispruce5

You can’t use the experience of one man to inform your whole opinion of a culture!
I'm not. I am asking if smacking in some countries is considered usual/acceptable.
Caramellatteplease · 28/08/2021 09:45

@UneFoisAuChalet google pgl for something similar.
Also cadets (air, sea and army) brownies, guides, scouts, cubs etc

I can guarantee that the puppy would receive way more attention than the baby.
Eh?!
I dont expect other people to be cooing over my children. They would have hating being taken off by someone they didnt know when younger, neither would they have liked to be fussed over by waiters. The best waiters are unobtrusive and service us without needing to notice they are there overmuch. If I'm at a restaurant with my child or children it's because I want to spend time with them. Not some random waiter well never see again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread