Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope to buy half of the downstairs flat's garden?

66 replies

buyingourfirstflat · 28/08/2021 07:57

DH and I are first time buyers and we have just had an offer accepted on our first flat. It's a one up, one down house conversion and both flats share the freehold.

I've been reading up on freehold mortgages and have realised they are harder to get so we might not even be able to proceed! But ignoring that for now...

We are hoping to purchase the upstairs flat which doesn't have a garden. The downstairs flat owns the garden, but it doesn't get used - you can see this and we have been told it too.

In a perfect scenario we would love to be able to own a section of the garden that we could fence off so its private from the person below - we were thinking we could offer the owner below money for it and have it changed on the freehold? Has anyone ever done this before and is it even possible?

Failing that, has anyone ever been in a similar situation with their neighbour and come to an agreement about just using the garden without changing ownership?

We are FTB so really don't have any idea what is even possible in legal terms, so any advice you could offer would be appreciated.

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 28/08/2021 09:31

As pp said you can ask to rent or to buy but unless they are unhinged they will say no.

If you want a garden rhen you need to try to buy a property with one. This idea is ludicrous. No one wants to be in their home with the neighbours in their garden, what a loss of privacy and encroachment. Never mind future issues when they come to sell.

It doesn’t matter if they use it or not. It’s like asking if you can rent their living room as they are at work during the day.

buzzandwoodyallday · 28/08/2021 09:30

If you would like use of a garden, then you really do need to buy a property with a garden. Did lockdown teach you nothing? Outside space is massively important. Don't buy a property without it, as even if you buy it now, you may not be able to resell it at a later date.

Carboncheque · 28/08/2021 09:27

’At the moment presumably they can walk around naked in most rooms and no one would see’

Well, that’s a whole new reason not to ‘rent’ their garden Grin

FlumpsAreShit · 28/08/2021 09:15

I would wait, save more and then go for a flat with a garden if that's what you want. Moving is so expensive and after this you lose all the FTB perks. Don't buy as soon as you can but buy for longevity.

seven201 · 28/08/2021 09:15

I think it's unlikely they'll say yes. At the moment presumably they can walk around naked in most rooms and no one would see. That kind of stuff matters I think. There's no harm in asking though. We had a london basement flat with a really long thin garden, just as we're about to put it on the market a corner neighbour, the one right at the end, asked if he could buy the end bit of our garden. We would have sold him a few metres (for the right price) if he'd asked just six months earlier.

Bouncebacker · 28/08/2021 09:11

I’ve not heard of that happening - I would suggest buying a flat with a garden, also - share of the freehold won’t be a problem for the mortgage as long as it’s properly set up - it’s very common in London - we have owned three flats with share of the freehold.

Carboncheque · 28/08/2021 09:02

I don’t think that they’re being a CF. They’re being naive. They’re offering to pay the owner rent for the right to make the neglected garden a lovely space. The owner could sell or stop the arrangement at any time. They’d be adding value to the neighbours flat and paying for the privilege. It could work out for them but the potential for them being screwed over is really high.

Gizlotsmum · 28/08/2021 09:01

I think you need to consider that you won’t be able to use the garden. Do you still want the flat? If they do let you that is a bonus but shouldn’t be assumed.

onelittlefrog · 28/08/2021 08:58

It's possible but you'll have to offer a LOT of money.

If they give up half their garden, it could substantially reduce the value of their property, so it won't be easy to persuade them.

They may be more likely to agree to access rights or even to rent a part of the garden out to you.

tortoiselover100 · 28/08/2021 08:56

If I were you I would offer to maintain the garden in exchange for using it. Then over time, maybe suggest buying?

BikeRunSki · 28/08/2021 08:55

@BikeRunSki

It has been done. DBro owned a downstairs garden flat in S London. The upstairs flat owned the far end of the far end of the garden. The garden was separated by a fence. It was an end terrace, so the garden had side access.
Forgot to say…. This was already in place when DBro bought the flat, and both halves of the garden were a decent size.
BikeRunSki · 28/08/2021 08:54

It has been done. DBro owned a downstairs garden flat in S London. The upstairs flat owned the far end of the far end of the garden. The garden was separated by a fence. It was an end terrace, so the garden had side access.

Whinge · 28/08/2021 08:48

@PurBal

Even if they agreed to let you use it subsequent owners might not. If you want a garden don’t buy the flat.
This /\/\

There's so much potential for this to go wrong. If you want a garden then you need to buy a property with a garden.

Weirdwonders · 28/08/2021 08:48

I’m getting CF vibes from this post. You can’t assume to rent or have use of it in any way. It’s not yours. If you want a flat with a garden buy one. It sounds like you’ve already set your sights on it.

PurBal · 28/08/2021 08:46

Even if they agreed to let you use it subsequent owners might not. If you want a garden don’t buy the flat.

custardbear · 28/08/2021 08:44

Renting is a good idea if you can't buy but bear in mind if they change their mind or sell all bets may be off on the garden front so beware

Cherrysoup · 28/08/2021 08:43

Find somewhere else to buy.

Carboncheque · 28/08/2021 08:42

’If you value a garden Buy a flat with a garden included’

This ^

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 28/08/2021 08:41

They might agree, if they never use it and would rather have the money.

I’m sure it’s been done in an area where we have a 1905 maisonette, one of just two. There are a lot similar in the area (SW London) and were evidently all built with private small gardens/outside spaces, split in half with access for the upper one down a flight of steps, usually from the kitchen.

However through nosing a lot on Rightmove I have seen a few where the garden is double the size and belongs solely to one or the other.

Especially since Covid, though, any outside space is more highly prized so TBH I’d be surprised if anyone agreed to it. There is also the factor of privacy and potential noise right outside their back windows.

CatandBat638 · 28/08/2021 08:37

If you value a garden
Buy a flat with a garden included

Or buy a flat near to a park or open space

Doubledoorsontogarden · 28/08/2021 08:33

Go and view more flats before committing to this one.

Pipersouth · 28/08/2021 08:29

Be prepared for them to say no to everything. We used to have a communal garden and it’s one of the reasons we moved as I hated having people sunbathing/ smoking/talking just by our windows and with no rights to stop it. I would definitely say no to anyone asking for access (even paid) to a private space even if I didn’t use it sorry I know it’s selfish!

Notcontent · 28/08/2021 08:27

I think you need to assume that you cannot have access. Even if the neighbour doesn’t use her garden, she might not be keen for others to use it, because of privacy and noise issues.

daisypond · 28/08/2021 08:25

I’ve realised I know someone else that just gradually acquired use of the garden over time - they had access from an upper external staircase. But the lower flat never used the garden or did any upkeep. It eventually became just my friend’s garden- not legally, just through use. Everyone was renting, so there was no question of ownership.

Bimblybomeyelash · 28/08/2021 08:25

If you want a garden then you would be unwise to buy a flat without one!