Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex won’t let me move away

157 replies

Fomo41 · 27/08/2021 17:57

I’ve always wanted to live in the countryside-always. I’d love to move just over an hour away from where I live now. Problem is, my ex says he’ll stop me as we have 2 DC together and says ‘he has things in place legally to prevent the move’. Can he actually stop me? It would be England to wales but only an hour or so drive

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LittleMysSister · 02/09/2021 12:13

@SpareBread

Is it likely to be different if the dad does not have 50/50 care but has EOW and half holidays?
This would be different because an hour's drive is still doable under those conditions, it doesn't make a huge difference at all.

But if you've got 50/50 or any time with the children during the week, then a 2 hour round trip to get them to school in the morning and trying to fit that in with your own job too is pretty much impossible. It effectively means the 2nd parent is cut out of weekday time with the children.

Garriet · 01/09/2021 23:00

@Goldbar

I guess a dad with EOW might be much less likely to want or be able to have the kids to live with him. So unless he was willing to be primary carer, he can't realistically stop the other parent moving if they decide they're determined to go (since any court order would only apply to the children not the parent).
This is it really, though it’s still essential to have this conversation about consent, mediation and ultimately a court order. If it was already EOW however and the move was only an hour away so the usual pattern of time wouldn’t be affected, it’s much more likely that the court would grant permission if it came to it.
converseandjeans · 01/09/2021 21:23

Are you in Bristol? Lots of nice areas in the outskirts.

Despite how much you don't like your ex, it sounds like the children do. So I don't think it would be fair to uproot them away from him.

He's probably jealous of your new relationship.

cherish123 · 01/09/2021 21:10

If the area is horrible could you not move somewhere closer that is a nicer area. It would not be fair on the kids or your ex to be that far.

Goldbar · 01/09/2021 20:36

I guess a dad with EOW might be much less likely to want or be able to have the kids to live with him. So unless he was willing to be primary carer, he can't realistically stop the other parent moving if they decide they're determined to go (since any court order would only apply to the children not the parent).

SpareBread · 01/09/2021 20:04

Is it likely to be different if the dad does not have 50/50 care but has EOW and half holidays?

Garriet · 01/09/2021 20:01

Think of it this way: in a 50/50 arrangement, Dad suddenly ups and leaves with the kids one day and moves far enough away that he has to enrol them into a different school (behind mum’s back) and this is also far enough away that mum won’t be able to take them to school so has to reduce her time with them to weekends only.

It’s exactly the same scenario. You’d (rightly) expect a judge to return the children to mum in this situation, so this is no different.

Garriet · 01/09/2021 19:57

@SpareBread

you are correct, but the judge can order the children to move back, and would be highly likely to do so if there is a 50/50 arrangement in place and one parent unilaterally decided to move with the children.

How would that work? If mum as already moved, she won't be moving back to the old place, so where would the child move back to? Really it would mean the child would have to go and live with the dad.

Yes that’s exactly what it would mean. Dad’s home is also the children’s home, and there’s a 50/50 arrangement, so it’s very likely that the children will be ordered to return to dad’s care while mum makes her argument as to why they should be allowed to move. The court may then give permission for the relocation, but the reasons would need to be substantial (and if mum moves without going through the proper channels then that would count against her).
SpareBread · 01/09/2021 19:41

you are correct, but the judge can order the children to move back, and would be highly likely to do so if there is a 50/50 arrangement in place and one parent unilaterally decided to move with the children.

How would that work? If mum as already moved, she won't be moving back to the old place, so where would the child move back to? Really it would mean the child would have to go and live with the dad.

Garriet · 01/09/2021 18:56

@Fomo41

We have a custody agreement that was written up by a solicitor(a friend of his I think and it looked like it had just been copy/pasted off google!) and there’s nothing in that about moving away…
It probably wasn’t relevant at the time.

It would be a very quick process for him to apply for a Prohibited Steps order.

SpeedRunParent · 31/08/2021 16:24

[quote Gariffe]@SpeedRunParent it’s nothing glamorous. I bought a static caravan with inheritance about 6 years ago[/quote]
Fair enough.

ghostyslovesheets · 31/08/2021 14:52

Maybe sell your current home in a war zone, sell the lovely little holiday home and buy something in a nicer area that's still local to their father.

Children have a right to the relationship with their dad.

MissJeanBrodiesprime · 31/08/2021 14:02

It’s vital you get proper legal advice on this. This sort of thing is a minefield.

Hankunamatata · 31/08/2021 13:35

Wouldn't you need his agreement to change schools?

seaandsandcastles · 31/08/2021 13:26

YABU. It’s not in the best interests of the children to move them away from their other 50/50 parent.

TeaSoakedDisasterMagnet · 31/08/2021 13:22

@Fomo41

We have a custody agreement that was written up by a solicitor(a friend of his I think and it looked like it had just been copy/pasted off google!) and there’s nothing in that about moving away…
Please tell me you got this checked over by your own solicitor and didn’t let him control you this way too?
DynamoKev · 31/08/2021 13:12

@gogohm

Unfortunately the court will take his side - you moving away will prevent him seeing his children 50/50 so it does not facilitate the children maintaining the relationship with their father. A compromise such as 30 minutes is more likely to be accepted as that's a normal after school journey and you can keep them at their school
Why would that be "unfortunately" ?
gogohm · 31/08/2021 13:07

Unfortunately the court will take his side - you moving away will prevent him seeing his children 50/50 so it does not facilitate the children maintaining the relationship with their father. A compromise such as 30 minutes is more likely to be accepted as that's a normal after school journey and you can keep them at their school

Gariffe · 31/08/2021 12:52

@SpeedRunParent it’s nothing glamorous. I bought a static caravan with inheritance about 6 years ago

vivainsomnia · 31/08/2021 12:11

He controlled every aspect of my life for a decade and now he’s potentially controlling me still
He is not controlling you. You having children and doing what's best for them is. You said you always wanted to move to the countryside but you still opted to have two children before doing so. You went along with the 50/50 arrangement, assuming because you felt it was best for the children.

You cant suddenly disrupt everything for them just because you are not living your dream of a house in the countryside. Make plans for it to happen in the future if he still means so much to you then, but in the meantime, your children stability comes first.

LittleMysSister · 31/08/2021 11:49

@NailsNeedDoing

What sort of compromise can he offer though? If you move away you move away and there’s not much he can do about it, so what can he do to compromise. The only space for compromise is if you reassure him that you will do all the drop offs and pick ups, but as you’re the one choosing to move, that should be a given anyway.
Why would he offer a compromise though? If he has 50/50, he probably feels things are ideal for him as is. There is no compromise he can offer except accepting less time with his children, which he might not be inclined to do.

I guess the only other thing he could do to keep it 50/50 is to have the children extra in the school holidays, but that will only really if he's solely bothered about the CM he'd have to pay. I think for most people extended time in the holidays doesn't make up for the lack of daily involvement in their children's lives. Also OP would need to be OK with not seeing her children for a couple of weeks at a time over the holidays, which many wouldn't be.

Not saying he's right for obstructing OP from moving to a nicer area, but I'm sure most parents would feel the same if their ex wanted to move and take the children with them when they had been used to 50/50.

NailsNeedDoing · 31/08/2021 10:44

What sort of compromise can he offer though? If you move away you move away and there’s not much he can do about it, so what can he do to compromise. The only space for compromise is if you reassure him that you will do all the drop offs and pick ups, but as you’re the one choosing to move, that should be a given anyway.

SpeedRunParent · 31/08/2021 08:02

@Fomo41

They are 7 and 10. The area we live in is riddled with crime and antisocial behaviour a d is only getting worse. We have a holiday home near to where I’d like to move, and it’s a much more pleasant area with significantly less crime. I don’t want my children to grow up in an area that they don’t feel safe, falling in with the wrong crowd(which I know can happen anywhere, but the chances increase in a very built up area like the one we live in currently). I want their childhoods to be happy and worry-free, not having police sirens waking them in the night, neighbours wielding machetes at eachother.
If you can afford a 'holiday home' how on earth can you be living in an area where neighbours are wielding machetes at one another?
Garriet · 30/08/2021 23:58

In your circumstances it sounds like you’d be better off moving without giving him advance notice. Legally you can do so, though morally it might feel a bit questionable. A judge cannot order you to move back.

@nugget396 you are correct, but the judge can order the children to move back, and would be highly likely to do so if there is a 50/50 arrangement in place and one parent unilaterally decided to move with the children. Have seen this exact scenario. Your advice is poor advice, and the OP should ignore it.

Fomo41 · 30/08/2021 23:44

We have a custody agreement that was written up by a solicitor(a friend of his I think and it looked like it had just been copy/pasted off google!) and there’s nothing in that about moving away…

OP posts: