Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To step in when someone is yelling at their child…..

105 replies

Dandy008 · 27/08/2021 15:47

My friend and I went to the zoo today.

A mother in front of us in the cafe, had 3 children with her, she was also with another adult female who had two children with her.

There was a young girl in her pram, I would’ve said around 2ish (maybe younger) who was crying and screaming.

My son does this often so it’s nothing new to see a child crying in the pram.

However, the mother very abruptly, told the child to shut up and go to sleep.
The child was getting really upset, and reaching to her mother.
The mother grabbed hold of the child’s arms, pulled her towards her and said “shut the f*ck up and go to sleep”

The child was clearly distressed but not once did the mother take her out of the pram or offer any comfort.

She began talking to the other adult referring to
her own younger child as a “little twat” who needs to go to sleep. (Meanwhile, said child was becoming more and more upset)

The child threw her dummy on the floor and the mother said “well that can f*cking stay there”

Her other two children were sat eating and there was no interaction from the mother to them, but the younger child was still very upset and the mother repeatedly was shouting and swearing at her.

Both my friend I began to feel really uncomfortable with how this situation was escalating and especially because the child was so upset and the mother seemed to be getting angrier with her.

I was going to walk over and ask if she was okay or if there was anything I could do to help her, but before go the chance, someone else went over to her.

They didn’t offer her help but began to tell her off and threaten to call the police.

There was a bit of a heated argument the staff came over to diffuse the situation.

I wouldn’t have gone over to argue or tell the mother off (as much as I wanted to) but more to step in to offer support…

Is this a thing? Is it reasonable to do this?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
dottiedodah · 28/08/2021 08:53

I would have been unhappy to see this as well. Probably best to let staff sort it out . Some time ago a woman who smacked her dc in a car park was visited by ss. Someone had taken a picture of her reg plate and reported! She is obv struggling so could do with some help from ss I think

Dandy008 · 28/08/2021 08:46

@lllllllllll

Let’s hope the police came

I really hope so too. Thank goodness that person was there and had the backbone to call them. Too many people just turn a blind eye to this sort of thing.

@lllllllllll

I wasn’t turning a blind eye, and it’s nothing to do with guts.

I was with my own son, who’s only 18months old.

This woman was aggressive and clearly wound up.
My intentions were to go over but not to just start threatening her with the police or causing her to become even more angry.
I wasn’t about to put myself or my son in a position that could become dangerous for either of us.

OP posts:
lllllllllll · 28/08/2021 06:09

Let’s hope the police came

I really hope so too. Thank goodness that person was there and had the backbone to call them. Too many people just turn a blind eye to this sort of thing.

AngelDelightUk · 28/08/2021 06:05

I think I would’ve made staff aware, and possibly security. Let’s hope the police came

KeyWorker · 28/08/2021 04:17

It’s all very well marching over and intervening but you have no idea if you are going to make the situation worse for that child. For example, the poster who swing her car round the car park to shout to a boy to “tell his teacher” could very well have easily had an extra beating once home for daring to think about telling the teacher about his mother. If you humiliate the abusive parent in front of their child you may just make things worse for them.

Whatagreytdoggo · 27/08/2021 22:45

That's so sad :(

NoNoThankYou · 27/08/2021 22:16

Poor baby, and poor you OP. I can imagine how distressing that would be to watch and not be able to do anything about it to confirm that our little girl. It breaks my heart even in the second-hand re-telling.

For what it's worth, I don't think there was any way of intervening that could have done any good in the moment. I agree with others that if there were a next time (heaven forbid) and you could safely record, then report to the police, that's probably what I'd do. Even if I couldn't record I'd quietly report to the police.

So horrible, I'm sorry. Flowers

Thatsplentyjack · 27/08/2021 21:17

Your mistake OP is thinking this woman is stressed and will benifit from someone acknowledging how difficult it is to parent sometimes. That approach doesn't work with people like that because then it makes them think what they're doing is fine because you are being nice to them. Sometimes people like that need a shock and to be threatened with something g actually happening to them (because that's all they care about).
Sending your child over would be fucking ridiculous. Sorry but that's honestly one of the worst ideas you could have come up with.

QueenHofScotland · 27/08/2021 20:57

I witnessed similar in a shop and decided to call the Police (non emergency number)

The adults were being aggressive, I was shopping alone and didn’t feel comfortable approaching them.

I work in a profession linked to child protection and did not feel able to walk away.

Not sure what “support” I could offer in this situation. Wouldn’t hesitate to offer a mum support if they were struggling with a young child - even a smile and an acknowledgement that parenting is hard. What you’ve described does not sound like one of those situations. The mum is being abusive - whether she is stressed or whether this is the norm - she needs to be challenged

Danikm151 · 27/08/2021 20:45

I saw something similar on the bus. Mom was just shouting at her children and other children with her. From your description it could have been the same person.
I felt so bad for the little girl and would have loved to say something but I was with my son so had to think about the repercussions.

It’s so hard because you can’t imagine treating your own children that way. Just have to hope there is some support in place.

LowlandLucky · 27/08/2021 20:18

port1 I didn't work it out, it what i dealt with for many years.

MilduraS · 27/08/2021 20:11

Her attitude seems awfully similar to the mother and boyfriend who were recently convicted of killing her little girl. If a mother could speak to a child like that in public they could be much much worse at home.

something2say · 27/08/2021 19:26

And, beware the 'smoothing it all over' approach. Well done, they are quiet now.

Wait until they get home.

Don't smooth that over....

Clarkey86 · 27/08/2021 18:59

Some people are disgusting human beings.

I would quietly record it on my phone and then go and speak to the manager of the cafe and ring the police.

They absolutely will do something about it - particularly given evidence. We recently had a CCTV shot posted by the local police looking for a women who had been identified by a member of public hitting a child in a supermarket.

The person who said people shouldn’t stick their noses in is just as bad. EVERYBODY has a civil duty to look out for small children. Everybody.

SausageRollFan · 27/08/2021 18:54

I'll never forget taking my 3 yo son to a speech and language clinic for a group with several other families. One mum sat there bitching about the fact they had to be there, how inconvenient it was, how unfair it was in her sons siblings and how it was all because her sons fault because he wouldn't talk, all said to her son.

Shelovesamystery · 27/08/2021 18:49

Maybe sent my own kid over with a cake or doughnut with instructions to ask the mum if it’s okay and then used that as an opening to start a conversation.

Oh stop it! Honestly 🙄

GertietheGherkin · 27/08/2021 18:44

@BeenThruMoreThanALilBit

See, I think threatening to call the police isn’t always the right thing to do. It escalates an already fraught situation. The mother was not calm or rational. Threatening someone in that state will rarely lead to peace and understanding descending on the situation.

I know it’s different when you’re at home and can think clearly, but I think I would have caused a distraction of some sort. Something that might have appealed to the child in the pushchair. Maybe sent my own kid over with a cake or doughnut with instructions to ask the mum if it’s okay and then used that as an opening to start a conversation. My kids are tough little cookies and I would have deliberately sat close by given the woman was in front of me in the queue.

Or, possibly, having sat close by I might have dropped something that grabbed the mum’s attention. Broken her conversation with her friend, been a bit chatty and eventually asked about the 2yo.

Both of these could have diffused the situation there and then, but yes, the worry is always what’s happening at home. Children just need to be tired or hungry or hot, parents just need to be harassed or stressed or tired …. It’s important not to jump to conclusions, but it’s also important not to let a situation pass you by. It’s all instinct, I think. You need to be there to know what your spidey senses are telling you.

So some mother is abusing her child? Effing and jeffing like a good 'un? And you'd send your child over with a cake to try and diffuse the situation? Hmm
Somethingsnappy · 27/08/2021 18:43

[quote Merryoldgoat]@Somethingsnappy

No, but I don’t believe it’s commonplace and I don’t believe people with better choices make the poor ones described.

It’s no accident I didn’t have children young even though on paper I would be a prime candidate for that life.

I was encouraged to do well at school, encouraged to want better and to want a solid normal life which I now have.[/quote]
But this isn't about you (not intended unkindly). Some people really do (hopefully more rarely than may be guessed at, given the parenting of some people) have children just in the hope or expectation of financial gain. The poster that said that didn't deserve to be criticised quite so vehemently.

IncessantNameChanger · 27/08/2021 18:41

If the mum was upset or seemed stressed then yes I would offer support. But a swearing mouthy bully? No. There is nothing anyone except the services can do to help her child.

thesplashing · 27/08/2021 18:40

My husband was recently out driving and there was a toddler lagging behind his mum on a pavement with his reigns dragging behind him, bawling his eyes out, sunburnt to a crisp with no sun hat or top on. Mum in front of him a long way up the road swearing on the phone ignoring him. DH was in a big queue of traffic two lanes across and told me when he got home. I felt like jumping in my car and driving around to find the poor soul.

This type of behaviour needs to be called out by the community and reported to the police. Makes me think of Baby P, Kaylee Jayde Priest. The more adults that report little things like this the more likely an accurate picture is built for the authorities. It's not invasive or nosey to protect abused children.

Brighterblighter · 27/08/2021 18:32

Sounds awful op...

Rosebel · 27/08/2021 18:29

Wouldn't it have been better for the person to just call the police? Rather than exposing the children to more swearing and shouting? They might have had good intentions but I'm pretty sure they knew it would just make the situation even worse.

Streamside · 27/08/2021 18:22

Judging by all the responses, it would be really useful to get details of what the police and social services would recommend.

Merryoldgoat · 27/08/2021 18:18

@Somethingsnappy

No, but I don’t believe it’s commonplace and I don’t believe people with better choices make the poor ones described.

It’s no accident I didn’t have children young even though on paper I would be a prime candidate for that life.

I was encouraged to do well at school, encouraged to want better and to want a solid normal life which I now have.

Penistoe · 27/08/2021 18:17

Maybe sent my own kid over with a cake or doughnut with instructions to ask the mum if it’s okay and then used that as an opening to start a conversation

Why would you put your own child anyway near someone abusing their own child. Just wow.