Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Discrimination against single mothers?

65 replies

thepeopleversuswork · 27/08/2021 13:50

There was an interesting thread on here a few days ago about the pluses and minuses of being a single parent. A few posters said they felt stigmatised for it. I don't, personally, but it got me thinking about the sorts of low-level discrimination and disadvantage which single parents experience and what can be done to change it.

Rather than direct stigma, which I'm very lucky not to suffer from, the worst thing for me is the way men in particular who do domestic jobs for you try to take advantage of you being a single woman to overcharge you and generally pull the wool over your eyes.

I had a bloke the other day who I asked to do some work on my garden and he tried to charge me an absolutely extortionate amount of money basically for some garden clearance. I'd told him what my budget was, he went over it half way through the job with some very implausible excuse, tried to mansplain to me why he couldn't get the job done to time and budget and then demanded cash upfront half way through it (on a Sunday when I was going on holiday in half an hour).

Apart from being expensive and irritating, the worst thing about it was my being absolutely certain if I'd either been a bloke or been married or had a bloke living with me there's no way he'd have had the nerve to try this on.

I think quite a lot of people (mainly men) who do jobs like building, maintenance, decorating, anything to do with care etc, see single women as sitting targets for this sort of thing. There's an unspoken expectation that if you're daft enough not to have a bloke around to deal with then you've got it coming.

Curious to hear if others have got other examples of this. Not necessarily breaking Equal Ops legislation levels of discrimination, just low level shittiness.

OP posts:
Noodledoodledoo · 22/10/2021 14:43

I deal with most of the 'tradespeople' we use in our house, mainly because I am part time and around when they come.

I have never felt I am being treated differently, also had my own house and lived alone for 10+ years and never felt it then either.

I am prepared to challenge them if I think its daft, get multiple quotes etc.

Using garages, I have bought multiple cars, haggled the prices, dealt with repairs, services etc all alone, never been ripped off. Knowing a bit about what is going on helps, ask questions do some research before agreeing to stuff.

MamsellMarie · 22/10/2021 14:29

I have a friend who has disastrous dealings with workmen - she is married but always tries to barter them down, argues the price.
Whereas I always want a recommended person and ask the price, get other quotes (though that's not easy these days) and decide to go with it or not. I would never negotiate the price I would just look for someone else.
I have been scammed by someone I assumed was locak (local yellow pages - turned out to come from much further afield. But you learn from your mistakes.

forinborin · 22/10/2021 14:24

Have to agree with you there as well. There’s almost an expectation that your child with be naughty a year away and stupid.
And when your child has SEN - after being referred consistently by nurseries, private therapists, health visitors from the age of 2, going through a full diagnostic process and getting an official - it is still dismissed as being bad parenting, and... oh, he just needs a male role model to behave. This last one came from a teacher.

NavigatingAdolescence · 22/10/2021 14:24

@Threearm

As a woman I won't go to a car repair garage or anything relates without a man with me. It's brutally obvious there they try it on.
Have literally never experienced this in over 25 years of car ownership. But then, I do understand how they work and can do a lot of it myself. You don’t have to be helpless.
LobsterNapkin · 22/10/2021 14:21

I think some people don't like to hire single women with kids because they feel they can't be as reliable or flexible in work. I suppose they might feel the same about single dads, but I think that's rarer.

I don't totally agree about the gardener scenario. I think some tradespeople who are dishonest are happy to take advantage of anyone who doesn't know a lot about the trade and what to expect. I've certainly seen a man who was contracting for some work be taken advantage of because he wasn't handy himself.

It seems women are somewhat less likely to be handy than men so maybe these guys will try it on more with women, hoping to gain an advantage. Whereas if they get it wrong, they will be revealed as frauds, so they might be more careful with a man who they suspect might be handy. I think that's more about working the probabilities than sexism though.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 22/10/2021 13:32

Hmmmm

I’m a little unsure

I’ve just had loads of work done, but have made sure to be very clear on what I want and keep bringing people back if needs be. Comes a bit down to how firm you are I think.

LaurenFS · 22/10/2021 13:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

trappedsincesundaymorn · 27/08/2021 17:32

Going anywhere that screams "Kid's go/eat free", then you read the Ts&Cs which state "kids go/eat free when accompanied by 2 adults".

That used to wind me up no end.

EmotionalSupportBear · 27/08/2021 17:25

i get around the car issue by being savvy.. i know how much the parts cost, and i have friends who are mechanics (just too far to go for work) and ask them what they'd charge

The trick with ANY tradesman is do your research so you don't get screwed over.

The rest.. yeah, it does piss me off, i don't put up with it though, i'm polite but firm and i dont let anyone take advantage.

WorraLiberty · 27/08/2021 17:07

Apart from being expensive and irritating, the worst thing about it was my being absolutely certain if I'd either been a bloke or been married or had a bloke living with me there's no way he'd have had the nerve to try this on.

You couldn't be more wrong IME.

I've been married for 20 years and lost count of the amount of piss-taking tradesmen we've told to jog on.

This is where your local FB group might come in handy, we've had plenty of excellent recommendations from people (both male and female) who regularly use certain people.

newnortherner111 · 27/08/2021 17:00

Is there or has there ever been a single mother in the cabinet, or at least one whose children were of school age?

simitra · 27/08/2021 16:22

Many years ago went with my nephew to buy a computer. It was the kind of shop you might call a "box shifter". All the assistants were busy so we waited our turn. When one became free a man (who had entered the shop after us) tried to jump the queue. He had seen us there and knew we were next but just nabbed the assistant. I told the assistant we were next and to the man I said "You will have to wait your turn. We were here before you arrived so you know its not your turn next". He looked astounded. So astounded that he walked out of the shop rather than lose face. My nephew often talks about how I had a dismissive "edge" to my voice when I told him (not asked him) to wait his turn. I enjoyed that.

thepeopleversuswork · 27/08/2021 14:57

@Freddiefox

Its funny you mention this: I haven't really had this sort of stigma and god help anyone who used the term "broken home" in front of me.

It's more the unconscious or semi-conscious stuff that is a real problem for me. Workmen over-charging or assuming you're daft. Employers or school scheduling stuff at antisocial hours and assuming everyone has someone at home to pick up the slack etc.

I once got told off by a (female) boss for mentioning my children in the office. I was taken aside and told that it was fine to sometimes leave early etc as long as I didn't communicate that it was child-related. I'm pretty sure a bloke who left work early to pick up his kids would be lauded as a perfect dad and got a medal for being so "supportive".

OP posts:
Freddiefox · 27/08/2021 14:53

@znaika

They also hate it when your child does well.
Have to agree with you there as well. There’s almost an expectation that your child with be naughty a year away and stupid.
Freddiefox · 27/08/2021 14:51

@znaika

I never saw the original thread and would interested to see it. There is definitely a stigma against single mothers normally always from other women who sneer at you in social situations or refuse to invite you to things, or pity and patronise you and then get huffy when they suspect you might have more money than them. It is not all women by any means but I have a good group of single mother friends and we have all experienced it.
This. I often find some women use you to make themselves feel better. Particularly if they have a shitty relationships or are insecure. People like to assume you have no money, are poor or uneducated. They often like to use the term broken home, Which is very offensive.

Some people also like to other you and your. children, often with faux concern to dress the situation as something else.

I’ve been very lucky with garages and workmen.

thepeopleversuswork · 27/08/2021 14:49

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

One thing I have seen is a lot of situations etc where there's an expectation that there is a supportive second parent around to help, e.g
  • don't bring younger siblings along to class assembly etc (what else are you supposed to do with them)
  • parents meeting in the evening when children are in bed & theres no second parent to stay home while one attends

I can imagine all such situations being a real nightmare when you are juggling a family & work with no second pair of hands around

Exactly. That's a really good example.

There's loads of latent, low-level stuff like this at school. Stops just short of being actual discrimination but its part of a mindset that assumes everyone is part of a couple and doesn't take into account that anything outside work/childcare hours just isn't possible for single parents.

The whole PTA thing (which I'm a supporter of) relies on you being in a couple. All the evening stuff etc.

It's taken as read that that there's another parent on hand.

OP posts:
thepeopleversuswork · 27/08/2021 14:47

@gardeninggirl68

You just sound like you don't like men.....and you are generalising and being dismissive yourself!

using the term 'mansplaining'

I work with men in the building/trades/decorating industry and done ever see this kind of thing at all. I'm female, they happily come to me for help and advice the same as women do actually

Grin

So you have to be a man-hater to use the term "mansplaining"?

Grin
OP posts:
NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 27/08/2021 14:43

One thing I have seen is a lot of situations etc where there's an expectation that there is a supportive second parent around to help, e.g

  • don't bring younger siblings along to class assembly etc (what else are you supposed to do with them)
  • parents meeting in the evening when children are in bed & theres no second parent to stay home while one attends

I can imagine all such situations being a real nightmare when you are juggling a family & work with no second pair of hands around

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 27/08/2021 14:40

Hmm not sure. My DH is always the one to get preyed on by dodgy workmen/mechanics! They basically sniff out whether you have the knowledge to challenge them on prices/time spent etc.

They also have no way of knowing you are single? I'm married but don't wear a ring, I've dealt with plenty of tradespeople when DH out at work.

DelphiniumBlue · 27/08/2021 14:34

My Mum was a single parent for most of my childhood. She kept a fireman's helmet very visibly in the hall - you could do something similar, like a big pair of boots.
I've got a DH and adult sons, and I keep them out of the way when expecting workmen/deliveries, otherwise they get roped in finishing jobs off and humping equipment around.

znaika · 27/08/2021 14:33

They also hate it when your child does well.

znaika · 27/08/2021 14:32

I never saw the original thread and would interested to see it. There is definitely a stigma against single mothers normally always from other women who sneer at you in social situations or refuse to invite you to things, or pity and patronise you and then get huffy when they suspect you might have more money than them. It is not all women by any means but I have a good group of single mother friends and we have all experienced it.

gardeninggirl68 · 27/08/2021 14:31

You just sound like you don't like men.....and you are generalising and being dismissive yourself!

using the term 'mansplaining'

I work with men in the building/trades/decorating industry and done ever see this kind of thing at all. I'm female, they happily come to me for help and advice the same as women do actually

beinglikedisoverrated · 27/08/2021 14:27

Once went to a garage to buy a used car. Had the money in the bank ready to buy. Bloke said if I came back with my husband, I could test drive a car! Spent my 6k at a garage who let me test drive a car! Without my husband!

UserStillatLarge · 27/08/2021 14:25

@CorrBlimeyGG

Men get taken advantage of by dodgy workmen too.

In this respect, the problem is dodgy workmen, not men in general.

Yes I agree - my DH has accepted some absolutely ridiculous quotes from workmen because he won't say "hang on, that sounds a lot".