Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to give the deposit for this particular house?

113 replies

MissMarpleTheMurderer · 27/08/2021 12:30

Aibu to get involved and stop my sister (Anna) from buying her son (my nephew-Brian) the house next door?

Anna is a very strong character, single parent for many years but now has a lovely partner, but she wears the trousers in everything (and did so when we were growing up, very driven, confident and wants what she wants)

Brian (going into year 9, so 13 nearly 14) is the polar opposite, lovely quiet kid but prone to anxiety, worries more than normal but certainly not crippling, attends school doing well. Has a select group of friends that Anna approves of but isn't allowed to socialise freely, isn't allowed down the park or beach etc only allowed around approved households or when she is with him. Our parents have mentioned that Brian needs more freedom but Anna disagrees.

Now the issue, I've agreed (a long time ago, but more than happy to do so) to put a deposit down on a house, which will be rented out until Brian is old enough to live there. The money is from a house sale elsewhere in the country and I now have the funds.

I have found a great house in the same area but Anna has been talking to the neighbours and has found out they are planning on selling and wants to buy this house. I feel this will become an extension of Anna's house and that Brian won't actually ever be able to move out. Anna says that his anxiety means that he won't be able to live apart from her, but I feel she smothers him.

AIBU to get involved, and I should let Anna buy the house next door or

AINBU and it is reasonable to not release the funds so that Brian can have a place nearby but not next door

OP posts:
n11e · 27/08/2021 13:17

put the money aside and give it to him when he's older. The house is clearly going to cause lots of family drama.

MissMarpleTheMurderer · 27/08/2021 13:16

@Hankunamatata

Dont tie the child to a house. If he is a mellow fellow then he wont branch out and make his own decisions if they are made for him.
This is really helpful thank you. I have been thinking of the best financial return but you are right, even if I buy the house in our town it will be too easy to just end up there, to not think about where he actually wants to live.
OP posts:
GrolliffetheDragon · 27/08/2021 13:15

This is a terrible idea, both for Brian when he's an adult, and for any tenants in the meantime, because from what you've said it sounds like she could be a nightmare to anyone renting the house as well.

EarringsandLipstick · 27/08/2021 13:15

Regards the intricacies of the financial set up, it will be Brian's, I'm confident that all that is covered (including all eventualities)

How though? I'm just curious. Can a 13 yo own a house? He certainly can't make any decisions about tenants, carry out repairs, and deal with the finances. So that would have to be you or your DSis.

You've a lot more worries than just your sister & the house location.

I find this unbelievable tbh, and you didn't answer how you were proposing to do this & make it Brian's.

knittingaddict · 27/08/2021 13:14

It sounds like a mess. I would put the deposit money into a fund for when he is an actual adult and let him decide where to live.

Hankunamatata · 27/08/2021 13:13

Dont tie the child to a house. If he is a mellow fellow then he wont branch out and make his own decisions if they are made for him.

knittingaddict · 27/08/2021 13:13

@Mosaic123

If the house is solely in Brian's name he will be able to sell it when he is an adult so maybe no need to worry.
A house cannot be owned by a 13 year old.
MissMarpleTheMurderer · 27/08/2021 13:12

@Margo34

Buy a house yourself with your money (the next door one, if you want) and rent it out, any proceeds ploughed back in to maintain the property or put in savings for Brian later on - don't know if you can do this in Trust for Brian, worth checking.

When Brian is old enough and ready to own a property, sell the house and gift to Brian to reinvest in a property of his choosing.

His mother has nothing to do with it as its not for her benefit now or later, it's for Brian.

Had I known how my sister would parent her son I would have never made the offer. I would have still provided for Brian but without her knowledge, the problem is she had known this was the plan from when Brian was small. She is very forceful, I think refusing to put it into a house and put it in trust is probably the way forward, although will need to look into how to make sure it is his.
OP posts:
Driftingblue · 27/08/2021 13:12

A big part of this is who will pay the mortgage and manage the rental. If it’s Anna, then she will control the house anyway. Plus it would be easier if it’s next door.

Kiduknot · 27/08/2021 13:12

Whose name will the mortgage be in?

Kiduknot · 27/08/2021 13:11

Can a child uphold property? I didn’t think so 🤔

Proudboomer · 27/08/2021 13:11

A 13 year old cannot own property in the uk. If a house is bought now for him it will have to beheld in trust until he is 18.
Once he is 18 it will be up to him if he wants to keep or sell the house.

I can’t see anything wrong with the plan as long as a proper trust is set up.

Kiduknot · 27/08/2021 13:09

How will it be his? How will it be set up and organised?

plodalong12 · 27/08/2021 13:09

He can sell it to fund the move, I know my op said live in because I was thinking more short term but he may never want to live in it and that is fine. As to why, I've been very fortunate and I can give him an enviable start in adult hood.

I understand that, and it’s very generous, but that is a massive hold to hang over someone. There are countless house threads on here every day from grown adults with entire families, never mind a teenager with no real life experience at all. If you have the means to be generous, why not just wait and hold the money for when he decides what to do with it? (I realise it’s Anna driving this but she’s not here so I’m directing the questions at you lol).

MissMarpleTheMurderer · 27/08/2021 13:08

@EarringsandLipstick

Apart from the notion of buying a house for a 13yo being utter madness (yes I know his to do with in the future etc), how will this work in practice?

So, you're providing the deposit. Who is taking out the mortgage?

That obviously influences on how it becomes 'Brian's' house.

If it's you, you presumably plan that the rent will cover the mortgage. But what about any unforeseen issues like a gap in tenants, and then there's the upkeep ... and if your own circumstances change, and having a mortgage against your name proves problematic.

The whole thing is massively bonkers. It's kind of you to want to care for Brian, set up a trust instead.

I fully accept you thinking it is bonkers, and many have said put in trust and I am seriously considering this as it will solve the present problem but financially it will not be as profitable.

Regards the intricacies of the financial set up, it will be Brian's, I'm confident that all that is covered (including all eventualities) It's my sister and the house location that is the issue.

OP posts:
Margo34 · 27/08/2021 13:06

Buy a house yourself with your money (the next door one, if you want) and rent it out, any proceeds ploughed back in to maintain the property or put in savings for Brian later on - don't know if you can do this in Trust for Brian, worth checking.

When Brian is old enough and ready to own a property, sell the house and gift to Brian to reinvest in a property of his choosing.

His mother has nothing to do with it as its not for her benefit now or later, it's for Brian.

girlmom21 · 27/08/2021 13:06

You're as bad as Anna. If you want to give him the money, put it in a trust fund until he's 18/21.

MissMarpleTheMurderer · 27/08/2021 13:04

@plodalong12

Why are you even contemplating buying a house for a 13 year old?? ConfusedConfused Talk about stifling. How do you know he won’t want to live halfway across the other side of the world to get away from the smothering ?
He can sell it to fund the move, I know my op said live in because I was thinking more short term but he may never want to live in it and that is fine. As to why, I've been very fortunate and I can give him an enviable start in adult hood. I will have no control on what he does with the house, he could gift it to Cats protection if he wants. I'm just concerned my sisters influence will be hard to shake.
OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 27/08/2021 13:02

Apart from the notion of buying a house for a 13yo being utter madness (yes I know his to do with in the future etc), how will this work in practice?

So, you're providing the deposit. Who is taking out the mortgage?

That obviously influences on how it becomes 'Brian's' house.

If it's you, you presumably plan that the rent will cover the mortgage. But what about any unforeseen issues like a gap in tenants, and then there's the upkeep ... and if your own circumstances change, and having a mortgage against your name proves problematic.

The whole thing is massively bonkers. It's kind of you to want to care for Brian, set up a trust instead.

Kiduknot · 27/08/2021 13:01

You say it will be his but surely a child can’t hold property?
Will his mother be able to prevent a sale? Who will get rental income etc whilst he’s still a child?

plodalong12 · 27/08/2021 13:01

Why are you even contemplating buying a house for a 13 year old?? ConfusedConfused Talk about stifling. How do you know he won’t want to live halfway across the other side of the world to get away from the smothering ?

TractorAndHeadphones · 27/08/2021 12:57

You’re right so say no. Also maybe don’t let him touch the trust money until hes old enough to be mature and have flown the coop properly

MissMarpleTheMurderer · 27/08/2021 12:54

But maybe trust is the way forward, at least it will give him options, and dilute the coming argument with my sister.

OP posts:
FirewomanSam · 27/08/2021 12:53

Gosh, 13 is very young to be bought a house that you’re supposed to live in when you’re an adult. How do you know he won’t move away for university or for a job? Even if he’s anxious and a worrier at that age you have no idea what he’ll be like as an adult. Plenty of shy kids find their confidence when they’re a bit older.

Either way, please don’t buy him a house next door to his mum. She sounds extremely controlling, even if it is coming from a place of love, and this would only make things ten times worse.

MissMarpleTheMurderer · 27/08/2021 12:53

@Alternista

Why on earth is anyone buying a house for a 13 year old to live as an adult?

Let him grow up and make his own decisions. Give him the money at that point if you want to.

It will be Brian's to do with as he pleases, he can sell, he can rent it out -it will be his, the reason I want to put it into property is because the return is better and safer than many other options. Financial planning means I don't want to hold on to the money.

To those that say he can just sell it, I'm just worried that if it becomes an extension of his home he will never get that freedom.

Brian doesn't know that it will be his so not involved in decision on which house. If you asked him now he would say what his mum wanted.

OP posts: