Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to give the deposit for this particular house?

113 replies

MissMarpleTheMurderer · 27/08/2021 12:30

Aibu to get involved and stop my sister (Anna) from buying her son (my nephew-Brian) the house next door?

Anna is a very strong character, single parent for many years but now has a lovely partner, but she wears the trousers in everything (and did so when we were growing up, very driven, confident and wants what she wants)

Brian (going into year 9, so 13 nearly 14) is the polar opposite, lovely quiet kid but prone to anxiety, worries more than normal but certainly not crippling, attends school doing well. Has a select group of friends that Anna approves of but isn't allowed to socialise freely, isn't allowed down the park or beach etc only allowed around approved households or when she is with him. Our parents have mentioned that Brian needs more freedom but Anna disagrees.

Now the issue, I've agreed (a long time ago, but more than happy to do so) to put a deposit down on a house, which will be rented out until Brian is old enough to live there. The money is from a house sale elsewhere in the country and I now have the funds.

I have found a great house in the same area but Anna has been talking to the neighbours and has found out they are planning on selling and wants to buy this house. I feel this will become an extension of Anna's house and that Brian won't actually ever be able to move out. Anna says that his anxiety means that he won't be able to live apart from her, but I feel she smothers him.

AIBU to get involved, and I should let Anna buy the house next door or

AINBU and it is reasonable to not release the funds so that Brian can have a place nearby but not next door

OP posts:
Inthemuckheap · 27/08/2021 14:18

Well if you are buying and paying for the house, your sister can shove her opinion.

If Brian wants to live near her when he's an adult, he can sell whatever you buy and move in with Mummy Dearest.

cheeseismydownfall · 27/08/2021 14:12

You need to seek proper legal and financial advice on how best to achieve your objectives with regard to your nephew.

Investing in housing may seem attractive due to the huge historic gains in the market, but it is fraught with complexity and has very poor liquidity.

You may well get a much better (and much lower maintenance) return through a well-invested fund. You need advice here.

Regarding putting money in trust - a good lawyer will be able to discuss full range of options available to you, including a discretionary trust that will provide some protection against the money being squandered by an inexperienced young adult making bad decisions.

Seriously, get proper advice.

raspberrymuffin · 27/08/2021 14:11

As others have said a 13 year old legally cannot own property in the UK - it will have to be kept in trust for him until he's 18 so you'd need to be extremely careful about who the trustees are (ie not your sister if she's that overbearing) and prepare them for drama.

If you have the cash then consider hanging on to it for now in case he wants to go away to uni and she decides to exert control by refusing to complete the forms for student funding or making it conditional on him staying local. This is a thing controlling parents sometimes do even when their child would be entitled to full funding, and you'd be doing something really outstandingly good by making it so he doesn't need to worry about that. I appreciate he could sell a house to achieve this goal, but that's a big legal faff for an anxious 18 year old with his mother breathing down his neck, not to mention a hostile neighbour putting off buyers.

BittaOrange · 27/08/2021 14:07

@Alternista

Why on earth is anyone buying a house for a 13 year old to live as an adult?

Let him grow up and make his own decisions. Give him the money at that point if you want to.

As an investment surely?
HugeBowlofChips · 27/08/2021 14:06

You don't have an option but to put it in trust. Legally Brian can't own property until he is 18, so the only option is a trust.

This all sounds highly messy.

Step away.

reesewithoutaspoon · 27/08/2021 14:04

Trust fund or buy the house in your name rent and sell when Brian is old enough to make his own decisions.
As generous as your offer is, if he is the anxious or worrying type he might feel obliged to live in it and beholden for the generous start. You would be clipping his wings before he got a chance to find out whether he liked flying or not.

Ozberry · 27/08/2021 13:55

I think if you buy a house you’ll need to put it in your own name at this stage. Property can be a good return. Obviously that will incur higher stamp duty as a second home, and be listed as an asset of yours in terms of tax etc. Is that part of the reason you are looking to do it this way?

If it’s more about securing Brian’s future a trust fund might be a better option. Or even drip feeding into a help to buy ISA or similar over the next 5 - 10 years till he’s old enough to make that decision.

I definitely wouldn’t buy him a house next door to his mum. That feels quite stifling, as you say.

Driftingblue · 27/08/2021 13:47

I don’t think buying a house as an investment is a bad idea at all, if all the legalities can be worked out. I’m just skeptical of that part. We so often see threads on here where people have agreements about houses that rely on personal trust and.l not on the written paperwork and they inevitably get burned by the situation.

Lorw · 27/08/2021 13:45

Put the deposit in a trust for him so he can choose somewhere to live when he is older, choosing is part of the fun buying your first home 😁

MauveMagnolia · 27/08/2021 13:44

A child can’t get a mortgage. Who is paying the rest apart from your deposit?

MissMarpleTheMurderer · 27/08/2021 13:43

@Wagglerock

Poor Brian. This sounds like a nightmare situation. I think some money in trust would be a good idea but a significant life changing sum? Nah, I'm not sure that's wise. There's so many what ifs - what if he's a drug addict or a boy racer and buys himself a huge high performance car. Similarly buying a house for him sounds awful - being suddenly responsibly for a house when you're 18 and finding your way in the world doesn't sound fun. It's ok saying, well you can just sell it but selling a house isn't exactly a quick or easy or cheap process.
I think this is a lot of the reason why I hadn't considered a trust fund, properties can be completly controlled by a management company so not necessarily a headache (although obviously not cheap)

Thanks for all that have taken time to reply, it's been helpful to have other thoughts as I need to be sure and firm when dealing with my sister.

I'vegotasong not at all, your input helps, I certainly do not want my sister as a trustee.

OP posts:
TheWoleb · 27/08/2021 13:40

@Blossomtoes

But he wont own it outright. The OP only has the money for the deposit and is going to rent it out to cover the mortgage (at least, that what it sounds like). He'll be getting added to a mortgage on a house he didnt choose, with tenants. That's a headache being handed to him.

FrippEnos · 27/08/2021 13:36

I am reminded of the sitcom sorry!

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 27/08/2021 13:36

That reads like I'm giving you orders! Blush I am just offering a suggestion.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 27/08/2021 13:35

Giving him a house is just giving him a whole load of hassle.

Go with the trust fund suggested. Under no circumstances make his mother a trustee. It's a good idea to have a professional trustee as well as, for example, you. My son's other trustee is a solicitor and it makes things very straightforward.

Blossomtoes · 27/08/2021 13:32

If he decides that he doesn't want to live in it and sells it to buy somewhere else then he loses out on a first time buyer mortgage

If he already owns a house outright I imagine that will be the least of his worries!

Buy a house of your choice in your name @MissMarpleTheMurderer. Rent it out, invest the rental income in Brian’s name and give him the money and the house when he’s old enough to make sensible decisions.

Wagglerock · 27/08/2021 13:31

Poor Brian. This sounds like a nightmare situation. I think some money in trust would be a good idea but a significant life changing sum? Nah, I'm not sure that's wise. There's so many what ifs - what if he's a drug addict or a boy racer and buys himself a huge high performance car. Similarly buying a house for him sounds awful - being suddenly responsibly for a house when you're 18 and finding your way in the world doesn't sound fun. It's ok saying, well you can just sell it but selling a house isn't exactly a quick or easy or cheap process.

Missreginafalange · 27/08/2021 13:28

Live not leave*

Missreginafalange · 27/08/2021 13:28

Could you buy a house of your choosing and then sell it and give him the proceeds when he is of an age, that way you are getting the best return for your money and Brian doesn't feel obligated to leave next door to mummy for the rest of his life and can do what he wishes with this lone tarry gift...

TheWoleb · 27/08/2021 13:27

If you buy this and put it into his name when he turns 18, then he becomes legally responsible for the tenants and all the stuff they would require from a landlord.

If he decides that he doesn't want to live in it and sells it to buy somewhere else then he loses out on a first time buyer mortgage.

Just put the money into a trust. And dont talk to your sister about it. It isnt her money and it will never be her money. Put it aside for him.

MissMarpleTheMurderer · 27/08/2021 13:24

@EarringsandLipstick

Regards the intricacies of the financial set up, it will be Brian's, I'm confident that all that is covered (including all eventualities)

How though? I'm just curious. Can a 13 yo own a house? He certainly can't make any decisions about tenants, carry out repairs, and deal with the finances. So that would have to be you or your DSis.

You've a lot more worries than just your sister & the house location.

I find this unbelievable tbh, and you didn't answer how you were proposing to do this & make it Brian's.

Report me, I'm not a troll MN can confirm. Whilst I understand posters interest in the financial side, I am not compelled to answer nor do I have any wish to divulge because I do not require help with the financial side of this issue. I wanted to check I wasn't being unreasonable to refuse to buy the house next door, and it has been interesting that people think iabu buying a house in the first place. I was thinking of money, the posters that say I could also be restricting his future choices have been really helpful. I want to widen not shrink his world.
OP posts:
MargosKaftan · 27/08/2021 13:23

Dont do this.

Buy a house in your own name as a BTL in different area /different part of town. You are under no obligation to tell Anna or Brian about this.

Tell your sister sorry, your finances haven't worked out the way you hoped, but hopefully when Brian is at a stage to buy his own first home, you'll be in a better position to help him with deposit, just not now.

Mentally earmark that house /flat as Brians. When he's ready to leave home (18 or later if he goes to uni), tell him you have a BTL you are happy to sell to him for whats left on the mortgage, or you are going to sell and give him the equity to buy his own place.

Or keep it for your own investment and release enough equity to give him a nice deposit.

yoyo1234 · 27/08/2021 13:20

Be very careful with capital gains tax implications if it is rented out. I think trust fund and invest the money. He gets it at an age you think is appropriate. This (I think) would probably yield better returns if invested well than in a property that is rented. It may be hard to get a good mortgage rate if property in child's name.

Motherofcats007 · 27/08/2021 13:20

I get what you’re trying to do here, to secure a good financial future for Brian. I’m just worried with your sisters personality it is going to make the tenants life a living hell. Buy a buy to let in another high growth area, rent it out, and then when Brian is ready to move out and buy his own property, he can sell it and move wherever he wants to

LeafOfTruth · 27/08/2021 13:19

Whilst having someone buy you a house might sound a dream it's Brian I genuinely feel sorry for because, to be brutally honest, it sounds like you both are trying to control his life and using a house to do so.

His mum by keeping him close and you by deciding that is not going to be good for him.

I agree with buying a rental investment without any ties to Brian. Then deciding when he is an adult whether or not it's right to sell that house to give him some money towards his own place.