Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to give the deposit for this particular house?

113 replies

MissMarpleTheMurderer · 27/08/2021 12:30

Aibu to get involved and stop my sister (Anna) from buying her son (my nephew-Brian) the house next door?

Anna is a very strong character, single parent for many years but now has a lovely partner, but she wears the trousers in everything (and did so when we were growing up, very driven, confident and wants what she wants)

Brian (going into year 9, so 13 nearly 14) is the polar opposite, lovely quiet kid but prone to anxiety, worries more than normal but certainly not crippling, attends school doing well. Has a select group of friends that Anna approves of but isn't allowed to socialise freely, isn't allowed down the park or beach etc only allowed around approved households or when she is with him. Our parents have mentioned that Brian needs more freedom but Anna disagrees.

Now the issue, I've agreed (a long time ago, but more than happy to do so) to put a deposit down on a house, which will be rented out until Brian is old enough to live there. The money is from a house sale elsewhere in the country and I now have the funds.

I have found a great house in the same area but Anna has been talking to the neighbours and has found out they are planning on selling and wants to buy this house. I feel this will become an extension of Anna's house and that Brian won't actually ever be able to move out. Anna says that his anxiety means that he won't be able to live apart from her, but I feel she smothers him.

AIBU to get involved, and I should let Anna buy the house next door or

AINBU and it is reasonable to not release the funds so that Brian can have a place nearby but not next door

OP posts:
HighNetGirth · 27/08/2021 16:55

Money is freedom, a house is a tie. Give Brian money, not a house.

R0SEMARY · 27/08/2021 16:48

@Alternista

Why on earth is anyone buying a house for a 13 year old to live as an adult?

Let him grow up and make his own decisions. Give him the money at that point if you want to.

This. Or invest in a buy to let and save any profit for his education. Let him decide where he wants to live as an adult.

You will need tax and legal advice of course

Fizzbangwallop · 27/08/2021 15:19

It sounds as though the best thing you could do is buy Brian a house that is located at least an hour away, rather than next door to his mother Smile

FAQs · 27/08/2021 15:18

Brian you have your mother and aunt making decisions for you which should be yours, run Brian, run!

Jemand · 27/08/2021 15:12

Your money, your choice.

beigebrownblue · 27/08/2021 15:10

I wouldn't worrry.

Brian will rebel soon enough quite effectively on his own.

That is what teenagers do.

The mother in question will get the shock of her life when he is 14/15/16

I don't envy her actually, the process of growing up is an adjustment for parents and mothers too, and if she doesn't make friends with that process she will be in for no end of trouble (and stress).

DustyMaiden · 27/08/2021 15:01

Are you trying to avoid tax? You are forcing him to own a house he knows nothing about.

A minor can’t enter into a letting agreement.

listsandbudgets · 27/08/2021 14:56

@LegoCaltrops

Poor little bugger. No wonder he has anxiety. Put the money in trust for him, wait until he grows up, then release it so he can buy a house wherever he feels comfortable, if he wants.
This is exactly what I was going to say. No doubt, Brian will be very grateful to be given help up the housing ladder when he is older but he needs some choice. Supposing he gets a job abroad or at the other end of the country - certainly he can sell the house next door but it seems likely from what you've said that he'll come under emotional pressure not to.

Also there are always risks that come with being a landlord and having to pay mortgages - we don't know what will happen to interest rates for example or whether a tenant will not pay the rent and the will have to be a costly eviction during which time the mortgage might be defaulted on.

Invest it in trust in a diverse portfolio until he's finished university / hits 21 and is ready to decide where he wants to live.

SoftSheen · 27/08/2021 14:55

I agree with PP. Use the money to set up a trust fund DN can access when he's 21. Don't use your sister as one of the trustees. Or, buy an investment property in a different area of the country...

LockdownLisa · 27/08/2021 14:53

I was thinking of money, the posters that say I could also be restricting his future choices have been really helpful. I want to widen not shrink his world

This is what I love about MN - it's so easy to get fixated on something (in this case, you KNOW buying a house for him is the best option, it's just the location that's the issue) but after chatting with disinterested strangers, it makes you think seriously about the drawbacks of this course of action.

I too think a trust of some type is the best course of action. I can imagine him thinking 'I'll just move into this house for a couple of years while I decide what I want to do with my life' and 10 years later, he's still there, under his mother's thumb. Whereas with a decent lump/income, he could travel, move to another city etc...

You sound like a lovely aunt who has her nephew's best interests at heart; he's lucky to have somebody like you in his life.

peboh · 27/08/2021 14:49

He's far too young to be buying a house for. What if when he turns 18 moves away for uni, and never comes home? You're putting far too much onto a child's head.
Put the money in a trust. He can then choose to buy a property of his own wherever he wants when he's old enough to make the decision himself.

Teamfemale · 27/08/2021 14:45

Brian is going to be the new Norman Bates.

Inertia · 27/08/2021 14:41

Don’t saddle the poor lad with all this hassle- it’s an absolute poisoned chalice.

Better to get proper legal advice about putting the money in trust until he is an adult (say 21+), so that your sister isn’t involved at all.

ThisOldSaddo · 27/08/2021 14:36

@Kiduknot

Poor Brian.

I agree it wouldn’t be kind to buy him the house next door.

Minors can't own houses, and there are property and tax implications for trusts.

Look into this a little further.

Also, it sounds weird.

HomesForHedgehogs · 27/08/2021 14:35

@Coconutscrub

YA BOTH BU

I think you should wait until Brian is a fully fledged adult and let him rule his own life.

This. It’s an utterly bizarre thing to do.
trevorandsimon · 27/08/2021 14:34

What if Brian dies young? His estate will be left to his parents so you will have given your sister a house. It all sounds really stupid, tbh. Just invest the money however you want until the time comes where Brian has moved out and is planning where to live on a permanent basis. (When he first moved out he might just plan to study in a town and not live there long term). Then, if you still have a job and the money and your own home(as none of these are guaranteed in the future) you can offer to put money towards or buy him a place then. Why your sister and you are planning to do it now is odd and bad financial planning.

leavesthataregreen · 27/08/2021 14:33

YANBU. Say you don't feel it is in an adult's best interest to live that close to a parent and you will wait until he is 18 so you can consult him on where he might like to live. Or, if he goes to uni, wait until he's 21 and knows where we wants to find work. Pointless to do anything else.

JuneOsborne · 27/08/2021 14:32

I know someone in a very similar position to this. The son is now in his mid 30s, hates the house, doesn't feel that he can sell it, and worse, feels as though the people that bought the house trapped him in a life he didn't want. He wanted to move to London (as far away as you can get really from where the house is) and do something completely different with his life.

He blames the people that bought the house.

Now you and I know he could have sold it and done whatever the hell he pleased, but he didn't feel like that. And he knows it makes him sound like a whingy martyr but that's the situation.

Do not buy a house for Brian. Buy a house if you want to and when he's/you're ready, sell it and give him the money. Or put the money in trust now. But, do not buy house that will be his.

MumW · 27/08/2021 14:32

Invest the money in a buy to let property of your choosing which is in the best location to return you a reasonable rent and rate of return when the property is finally sold.
When your DN is ready to buy his first property, you can sell your buy to let to free up the funds for DN's deposit on a property of his choice, in an area that is relevant to his life at that point.

unfortunateevents · 27/08/2021 14:31

It will be Brian's to do with as he pleases, he can sell, he can rent it out - well that obviously isn't true it is? Poor kid can't even go to the park so he's hardly like to be allowed by his overbearing mother to make such a huge financial decision is he? Honestly, you both sound as if you are overwhelming him in different ways, surely his future happiness and wellbeing should be more important to you than squeezing some extra percentages out of his inheritance?!

Mummyoflittledragon · 27/08/2021 14:26

I am a landlord. Management companies don’t do and decide everything. Surprisingly, I have heard shares do better than houses in the long run.

In your position, I would invest the money and give your dn access to the money in stages. He may blow it up the wall at 18 if you don’t.

As for his parenting and anxiety, poor Brian. This was also my first reaction btw before reading the responses. He needs freedom. My dd is his age and she walks about, goes to the park, takes the bus to the city with a group of friends etc.

Giving your dn a house, albeit seemingly wonderful, comes with so many caveats and is also a bit controlling.

A rental can be a major headache especially if tenants don’t pay and have to be taken to court. Or tenants, who trash the place. What if there were a fire? Who organises and chooses new kitchens, bathrooms, insurance valuers and so forth?

I’m yet to come across a management agency, which would effectively manage a property so completely. Then even if you did, they’re not going to do it for 10/15%, you’d have to employ another company to project manage repair work, then lawyers, who would manage any legal work.

This all will seriously damage any profit and I personally would have a long think about where’re the rental income with all of the ensuing headaches will be worth the while.

randomlyLostInWales · 27/08/2021 14:26

I second cheeseismydownfall - you need proper legal and investment advice.

I can see many downsides to being given a property at 18 - especially if there's a mortgage or tennants and TBH at that age I'd have heavily looked to my parents to guide me though whatever legal/money implications there were so you could well be increasing your sisters control and reducing your DS future options.

Plumtree391 · 27/08/2021 14:25

You're not unreasonable but it won't hurt for your sister to buy a house as an investment; when Brian is an adult he can make his own mind up about whether or not he lives there. Whatever happens, it won't be a wasted investment.

Winter2020 · 27/08/2021 14:21

Hi OP,
It sounds like your nephew is very important to you. Is your will up to date so that it reflects how you want to leave your estate (for example if you die before making this gift)?

Zilla1 · 27/08/2021 14:18

FWIW I think you know all the dimensions, OP. YANBU to consider the issues that might arise if the default house location is his DM's neighbour as it would require an active decision to move away which will be more difficult to make if his DM doesn't want to encourage his development and she can use emotional blackmail to stretch the apron strings as far as next door.

Your choices are whether to make the investment in trust which would help with financial planning or not, whether that investment is then made in property which could be managed by an agent on a day to day basis even if the ultimate beneficiary if your DN and finally if a property is bought then where.

You sound really kind and arguably the choice of the neighbour's house might have adverse consequences to him when presumably your intention was entirely positive.

You might need to go against your DSis' wishes somewhat to act in your DN's longer-term interests if, as you appear to suspect, his anxiety is situational rather than baked in permanently. Your argument to your forceful DSis might have to be you made a choice that will maximise your DN's financial return to give him the maximum financial security if his anxiety will constrain his life and your judgement was that it would be best to invest either a house in a suitable price bracket in a different location 'where the market looks better' or an investment in stocks and shares if the housing market looks too 'toppy'.

You could probably try and reasure her or deflact anger by saying when he is looking to move out, he will ultimately have the option to sell up and buy a house near his DM if that is best for him or retain the investment if his anxiety means he'll always need to stay at home. Presumably he will hopefully run like the wind as soon as he can.

Good luck.