Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to make money from a charity shop purchase?

479 replies

Partnerprobs · 27/08/2021 11:29

Recently went to a charity shop and found a couple of items for sale that I liked and were in very good condition. A handbag and a book. Both were in a locked cabinet. I bought them for £25 in total and have sold them on eBay for £75 and £34 pounds, so I’ve made about £84 (less eBay fees which I haven’t seen yet)

My best friend was really shocked and said it’s like stealing and I should donate the money to the charity - this has surprised and unnerved me as I thought it was fine (as they were in the cabinet so had been picked as higher end items, and also they were more expensive than normal items)

I thought it was a lucky break and was looking forward to treating myself.

Aibu?

OP posts:
ManifestDestinee · 28/08/2021 03:24

@MissM2912

A very close friend of mine died of cancer last year- she specifically told me she wanted her clothes to go to Cancer Research to fund research. It was something that was really important to her in her final days. I know she would be upset that someone would profit in this way. As I said- not legally wrong but ethically so.
No, she would not, and if she did, she'd be as misguided as you.

She wanted to donate her clothes to cancer research who would sell them in their shop and give the money for research. They did that, and her wish was fulfilled in its entirety. What happened to the clothes after her wishes were fulfilled is immaterial. They could have been thrown away, or given away, or cut into rags, or sold on for a profit. It makes not one single difference to your friends request.

And if I was your friend I'd be disgusted at you using my death to try and win an argument on the internet.

Oldsu · 28/08/2021 03:10

slashlover The bag could has sat there for a month priced at £50, or the shop could have used that space to sell 6 bags at £20 each

Exactly that my DH runs 2 charity shops both shops are in the top 10 of 120 shops nationwide he is very very good at what he does, he could put a bag out for £50 and it wont sell for a week, meanwhile out the back he has boxes of bags that he has no room to display, put it out for £30 it will sell in a day and he can replace it and then sell the replacement and so on, I have seen it myself when I volunteer

NamechangeApril21 · 28/08/2021 03:03

@DukeOfEarlGrey then why don't you do that bit and donate the money you make.

DukeOfEarlGrey · 28/08/2021 01:15

@listsandbudgets

As long as you don't make a business of it.

I went to a charity shop earlier in the week and was blocked from the rails by a couple who were grabbing stuff off in any size.. they were only interested in the labels they actually discussed it.. White Stuff yes, Tu no, Jaegear yes, primark, primark, primark no, Hobbs yes etc. etc.
Several things in my size I'd have liked at least a look at swooped on and they made it so people couldn't get past.

Shop manager said they were obviously ebaying them and came in 4 to 5 times but there was nothing she could do as long as they paid.

There’s nothing wrong with what OP did but for some reason this example makes me a bit sad. I give my best stuff to a local charity shop in the hope that they can make decent money from it - I could sell on eBay myself but think of it as a charity donation. The cynicism in this just makes me a bit sad. My local charity shop is staffed by very elderly volunteers and I think it’s unlikely they would know the potential value of some of these things or have the capacity to research them.
MorriseysGladioli · 28/08/2021 01:08

It's not a big deal.
I sometimes buy things, use them for a while, then sell them on for more than they cost.
Nobody has to buy them; they do because they're happy with the item and price.

JaceLancs · 28/08/2021 01:01

I buy from charity shops, auctions, car boot sales etc for things I want for myself or family members
I also buy things to sell for a profit
Sometimes the things I buy from aforementioned are unwanted or I get bored with so sell on
I’m also the CEO of a charity that doesn’t have charity shops or online selling but I donate my time n money to them in other ways
Maybe if I didnt wheelman deal I couldn’t fo thus

slashlover · 28/08/2021 01:01

I guess in a lot of shops if something was priced at its 'correct' value a lot of people would say 'this is way too expensive for a charity shop'.

We've had several things we've priced accordingly then had to drop when they didn't sell especially ornaments, glassware, electronics etc.

Bumbl · 28/08/2021 00:55

Yes I should have made it clearer - when I said volunteers 'can't correctly value' stuff I didn't mean because they don't know how to etc. I appreciate that most will know their stock and customers well.

I guess in a lot of shops if something was priced at its 'correct' value a lot of people would say 'this is way too expensive for a charity shop'.

ItsNotMeAnymore · 28/08/2021 00:51

I think it's ok but I wouldn't do it myself. I guess if I was really skint I might do it though.

slashlover · 28/08/2021 00:46

@Bumbl

I think it's unethical tbh, but a lot of things in life are. I also think there's a problem with charity shops employing volunteers who can't correctly value/price things up in the shop - so things like this happen and people buy the stock cheaply and sell them for more.
Depends what you mean by "correctly value", we might know that something is worth £50 but we also know our customers and that we might only actually get £30 for it in our area.

I'll give you an example - sometimes we get cots donated, lovely wooden ones which probably cost well over £150 new. We can't even get £40 for them, most of the time we'll get £20 max. Now, a lay person may come in and see a cot priced at £20 and think we haven't priced it correctly and don't know what we're doing when we actually know our customers exactly.

Bumbl · 28/08/2021 00:41

Yes I agree with you - I'm not saying they are intentionally making a mistake or just putting any price they fancy on.

But I guess it's the charity's decision to use volunteers rather than paying staff, and again it's part of the 'is this ethical?' conversation around charity shops.

Would it be better to pay wages and then get slightly more money per item? Or is it not worth their while.

WanderleyWagon · 28/08/2021 00:40

This is absolutely fine to do. I think that much of the clientele of charity shops is shopping there for precisely this purpose, and I agree with the PP who called it a win-win-win. It's part of the business model of the charity. Not morally dubious at all.

XenoBitch · 28/08/2021 00:37

@Bumbl

I think it's unethical tbh, but a lot of things in life are. I also think there's a problem with charity shops employing volunteers who can't correctly value/price things up in the shop - so things like this happen and people buy the stock cheaply and sell them for more.
I don't think volunteers have the time or inclination to be looking up the potential resell price of every item that gets donated. A lot of people volunteering in charity shops might not be able to hold down paid work. Or they are retired and want to fill their day.
Seafog · 28/08/2021 00:36

Not only is is not wrong, as the charity store is still getting it's cut first, loads of us do this as a side hustle.
I love exploring second hand shops, and getting great deals. I also like reselling at a better price. I have an eye for quality, and timeless pieces. Why not sell them on to someone who will treasure them?

Bumbl · 28/08/2021 00:31

I think it's unethical tbh, but a lot of things in life are. I also think there's a problem with charity shops employing volunteers who can't correctly value/price things up in the shop - so things like this happen and people buy the stock cheaply and sell them for more.

slashlover · 28/08/2021 00:31

@MissM2912

Anyone that I know who gives stuff to charity shops is doing it with the intention of it being used to the benefit of either the charity or someone in need- otherwise you would just dump it!! I don’t know anyone who donates stuff with the intention of it being sold on for profit. There is a difference between buying from a charity like for example St Vincent de Paul and a second hand shop.
I work in a charity shop and A LOT of people donate instead of just dumping their stuff. I'd say at least 30% of our donations are absolute rubbish.

Would you rather the resellers didn't buy anything and it just sat on a shelf for months or was sold to someone else for less money?

XenoBitch · 28/08/2021 00:28

[quote Debetswell]@MissM2912 you don't know much about large charities and the way they're run if you think they're all ethical.
I find most large charities and their shameless begging abhorrent.
My df is 90.
He's inundated with charity begging letters.
My dsis works in charity shops. She actually gave a customer £5 of her own money after a pressure cooker they'd bought didn't work and the shop refused to refund the customers money.
The customer was distraught because they couldn't afford to lose the money but the charity shop manager was intransigent.
Self employed businesses with families to keep have to compete on the high street with charities that don't pay the same taxes or staff wages.
Imo other than Christmas cards they shouldn't be allowed to sell new items.[/quote]
There was an elderly lady in my hometown who took her own life after being inundated with begging letters and phonecalls from charities :(

Debetswell · 28/08/2021 00:26

@MissM2912 you don't know much about large charities and the way they're run if you think they're all ethical.
I find most large charities and their shameless begging abhorrent.
My df is 90.
He's inundated with charity begging letters.
My dsis works in charity shops. She actually gave a customer £5 of her own money after a pressure cooker they'd bought didn't work and the shop refused to refund the customers money.
The customer was distraught because they couldn't afford to lose the money but the charity shop manager was intransigent.
Self employed businesses with families to keep have to compete on the high street with charities that don't pay the same taxes or staff wages.
Imo other than Christmas cards they shouldn't be allowed to sell new items.

EatAllDay · 28/08/2021 00:12

I say Fair play to you

MissM2912 · 28/08/2021 00:09

The items were most likely donated by someone hoping they would raise as much money as possible for charity/ possibly one that was especially important to them. Maybe Macmillan nurses looked after a family member, maybe action for children provided counselling for a bereaved child, maybe PDSA provided emergency surgery they otherwise couldn’t have afforded for a beloved pet. You don’t know- and really if you can make further money you should give it to the charity if you can.

Hadjab · 28/08/2021 00:09

This. In spades!

XenoBitch · 28/08/2021 00:08

@MissM2912

A very close friend of mine died of cancer last year- she specifically told me she wanted her clothes to go to Cancer Research to fund research. It was something that was really important to her in her final days. I know she would be upset that someone would profit in this way. As I said- not legally wrong but ethically so.
If your friend's clothing was sold by the charity shop, then how does it matter what happens once the money has changed hands? The person who bought the clothing could be wearing them, selling them on, giving them away, burning them, cutting them up to reuse as something else... anything. Maybe someone buying from a charity shop and reselling at a profit is in dire straits themselves and needs the money.

My mum's dear friend left a vintage leather jacket when he died that she sold for good money on eBay, which she donated to the hospice he spent time in. If she had given it to a charity shop, it would have made that same hospice about £5, if it sold.

All being said, I am sorry you lost your friend.

XenoBitch · 28/08/2021 00:02

@MissM2912

Anyone that I know who gives stuff to charity shops is doing it with the intention of it being used to the benefit of either the charity or someone in need- otherwise you would just dump it!! I don’t know anyone who donates stuff with the intention of it being sold on for profit. There is a difference between buying from a charity like for example St Vincent de Paul and a second hand shop.
OP bought the items and paid for them. The charity did benefit from that.
MissM2912 · 28/08/2021 00:02

A very close friend of mine died of cancer last year- she specifically told me she wanted her clothes to go to Cancer Research to fund research. It was something that was really important to her in her final days. I know she would be upset that someone would profit in this way. As I said- not legally wrong but ethically so.

MissM2912 · 27/08/2021 23:59

Anyone that I know who gives stuff to charity shops is doing it with the intention of it being used to the benefit of either the charity or someone in need- otherwise you would just dump it!! I don’t know anyone who donates stuff with the intention of it being sold on for profit. There is a difference between buying from a charity like for example St Vincent de Paul and a second hand shop.