Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask if you think ben wallace has done a bad job?

730 replies

Needapoodle · 27/08/2021 08:41

Loads of people on social media calling for Ben's (defence secretary) resignation over pen farthing and his operation ark.

I think ben and his department have suddenly been thrust into a highly volatile and constantly changing dangerous situation in which he has to make decisions for the good of the most amount of people possible. I also think that the insistence on evacuating hundreds of animals will undoubtedly have taken resources away from getting people out of Afghanistan and prevented human lives from being saved. I don't think that calling for ben's resignation over some animals not being able to be evacuated is reasonable at all. Or have i missed something?

OP posts:
IAmSuperman · 28/08/2021 14:21

KeflavikAirport

You clearly do not know much about Nowzad. Pen has dogs and cats not just linked to UK troops but also US. Until the CDC ban he was making trips to the US to reunite animals and soldiers. They also have animals belonging to embassy staff who have left over the years and are always working to get the necessary paperwork to reunite people with their animals. And yes, they have some street dogs and cats ....and some donkeys.

Have a read on their website, YouTube etc if you’re actually interested.

I’ve followed this charity for many years and they have done so much good for Afghan people and animals. They go into schools to educate children on animal welfare and partner with various institutions to help train new vets. They’re passionate about educating young women.

Flyingantday · 28/08/2021 14:12

@Saucery

They won’t be going to the sort of ‘rescue’ that kills healthy animals Smile

I’ve seen the “we have so many pets in rescue put to sleep” rubbish pop up on these threads before. And it is rubbish. Bad rescues not worth the name may do that. Decent rescues won’t.
Does anyone seriously think those animals will just be dumped in a cardboard box outside the nearest RSPCA shelter when the plane lands Grin

animal rescues may not routinely put them to sleep… but they do routinely say they are too full to accept any more (even if they are full of long termers that never get rehomed) so the putting to sleep happens by proxy, in council kennels or in the community by people who can’t keep them and can’t arrange a private rehoming.

A lot of it depends on the criteria set by the rescues, U.K. ones are notoriously strict on who can adopt, hence why the imported strays charities do so well over here (Romanian dogs for example).

I’m sure there will be a high publicity scramble to adopt these dogs and cats.

The exotic disease risk to U.K. animals and humans from these dogs coming in is a whole other issue.

notimagain · 28/08/2021 14:10

US seem to have endorsed the Taliban decision to deny entry to Afghan passport holders.

Yep, bit of a screw up that, The US should have sat down with the Taliban at a meeting and raised serious objections.

Strangely enough this has drifted into a Pen 3 thread…..

I’m glad he got out, but he’s just one of what’s now reckoned to be 100,000 people who have got out of Afghanistan in the last fortnight..

Hopefully in a few days people will step back, stop concentrating on one individual, actually look at the big picture here and consider than Pen was one of roughly 99,999 people who got out.

To try and drag this back towards the thread title: Given the UK were responsible for evacuating maybe 15000 plus people, no, Ben Wallace has objectively not done a bad job.

EsmaCannonball · 28/08/2021 13:52

The Taliban are notorious for their cruelty towards dogs. They have also physically punished people for having pet dogs (not unique in extremist countries). I wonder if being a vet or running an animal shelter would be seen as worthy of reprisals in itself. I'm worried about the staff of this and other animal charities. Pen's staff would not have been a priority for evacuation. He got them the paperwork to leave, he got them to the airport, but the US seem to have endorsed the Taliban decision to deny entry to Afghan passport holders. The Americans also gave the Taliban lists of their Afghan staff and their biometric data. The incompetence is unbelievable. I think the British have also stupidly handed lists of Afghans to the Taliban.

Saucery · 28/08/2021 13:51

They won’t be going to the sort of ‘rescue’ that kills healthy animals Smile

I’ve seen the “we have so many pets in rescue put to sleep” rubbish pop up on these threads before. And it is rubbish. Bad rescues not worth the name may do that. Decent rescues won’t.
Does anyone seriously think those animals will just be dumped in a cardboard box outside the nearest RSPCA shelter when the plane lands Grin

KeflavikAirport · 28/08/2021 13:45

He should have just euthanised the animals two weeks ago if he was that worried about the Taliban getting hold of them.

I'm also curious as to how cats are service animals.

I'm also curious as to how many of the dogs were street dog rescues rather than military support animals given the UK withdrew combat troops in 2014 and what will become of them in the UK where unwanted dogs are routinely put to sleep.

HollyGrail · 28/08/2021 13:35

Ok, thanks, I'm better informed now.

Doodlebug71 · 28/08/2021 13:15

@HollyGrail. He's going, because he's a former marine and a target. Here. Read this. metro.co.uk/2021/08/28/nowzad-pen-farthing-forced-to-leave-afghan-staff-behind-as-he-escapes-with-animals-15167441/

He wanted to get his staff out, because that was his best shot (coudln't get everyone out, but getting *some out would have been something...). So he tried to get them out, and the smear campaign against him has really taken off.

PicsInRed · 28/08/2021 13:05

@HollyGrail

Why is Pen farthing going - I'm sure I read he is going to return. There were dogs homes in China when I was there, they self funded and got on with it, nothing to do with the Gov. Are the Taliban going to start shooting all stray dogs - if so why isn't it a known event already, Taliban kill animals would be regularly in the headlines - they should all have just stayed. Who the heck would have cared.
As these are ex service pets, should ISIS (or the nastier of the Taleban) have got hold of them it would be worse than shooting and on the part of ISIS probably televised. Aside from the humane considerations, strategically, it would have been highly damaging to morale.
HollyGrail · 28/08/2021 13:04

In that case there will soon be no dogs in that part of Afghanistan - I expect it's religious reasons. I wouldn't think that is particularly a bad thing. There must be other countries with no dogs.
Why are there dogs at all if for religious reasons they aren't wanted. Possibly embassy staff abandoning them when they return home. That was the case for larger dogs in China.
Whole thing is ridiculous imv.

IAmSuperman · 28/08/2021 12:54

Are the Taliban going to start shooting all stray dogs - if so why isn't it a known event already,*

I’ve read and seen pics on twitter that say the Taliban are abusing and killing dogs in the last week. Shooting would have been much better than what I have read and seen.

HollyGrail · 28/08/2021 12:50

Why is Pen farthing going - I'm sure I read he is going to return. There were dogs homes in China when I was there, they self funded and got on with it, nothing to do with the Gov. Are the Taliban going to start shooting all stray dogs - if so why isn't it a known event already, Taliban kill animals would be regularly in the headlines - they should all have just stayed. Who the heck would have cared.

IAmSuperman · 28/08/2021 12:49

I hope he does, to keep up the pressure and awareness of his vulnerable colleagues still trapped there.

Of course he will, as will Dyer, Peter Egan, Ben Abraham, Iain McGill who have all been doing lots of interviews for Pen, his staff and animals.

IAmSuperman · 28/08/2021 12:46

Kabul Small animal rescue said last night that Pen and his animals had already flown out. They said that at about midnight.

SueSaid · 28/08/2021 12:44

Such heart breaking stories coming out of people leaving with one small bag each. These are the lucky ones.

"No words can describe my feelings & nothing would heal this trauma & pain. I never imagined I’d leave my country like this with a small hand bag. Deeply n sorrow, fearful & heartbroken. All what I hv worked for & all the dreams I had are vanished & left behind"📍#Kabul Airport t.co/PNBVUE0u83

So even if his supporters are adamant he has done the right thing surely at some point they must recognise if people are leaving with the clothes on their backs and a small bag then someone else taking 200 animals is grossly unfair and inappropriate. It just seems such a gross display of white privilege.

notimagain · 28/08/2021 12:39

I hope he does, to keep up the pressure and awareness of his vulnerable colleagues still trapped there.

He might want to be a bit careful about how that’s done, but I’m sure he’s well aware of that.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 28/08/2021 12:39

good point @Saucery

Saucery · 28/08/2021 12:35

@MrsLargeEmbodied

i hope he doesnt flood the tv/radio now
I hope he does, to keep up the pressure and awareness of his vulnerable colleagues still trapped there.
MrsLargeEmbodied · 28/08/2021 12:33

where will his animals go once they are here?
such a huge operation

notimagain · 28/08/2021 12:32

@DogFoodPie

I think he is still waiting in the airport somewhere. They said he was taken to a warehouse with the animals.
The very much rumours doing the rounds are:

1.He’s still stuck in Kabul, mobile phone network out of service due to the continuing threat of ISIS bomb attacks.

  1. He is en-route to Tashkent,
  1. He is en-route to Tajikistan ..

FWIW it looks like the 727 freighter that was flying between Kabul and Kulyab, Tajikistan yesterday will shortly land in Kulyab again having done another shuttle to Kabul again this morning.

IAmSuperman · 28/08/2021 12:29

i hope he doesnt flood the tv/radio now

Of course he will, he’ll want to let people know about his staff and the people of Afghanistan.

There’s a thing called an off button if you need it.

BritishSummertime · 28/08/2021 12:28

@Odisia

How did Pen Farthing get out? Was it on the private plane he chartered or was it on a military aircraft? Has that been confirmed?
Daily Fail are reporting a private jet
IAmSuperman · 28/08/2021 12:28

where will he live?

How would anyone know that? You want the address?
He has family and friends here.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 28/08/2021 12:27

i hope he doesnt flood the tv/radio now

IAmSuperman · 28/08/2021 12:26

Twitter is a cesspit

There will be people who behave badly everywhere. I have got to know/know if some good people via twitter and other social media from people involved in human rights, animal welfare through to fans of certain music. So it’s not all bad.