Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do I get one of THOSE children

303 replies

Elmoandbert · 26/08/2021 22:42

What is it that makes a child motivated, busy, sparky, confident...you know, those children that private schools seem to produce. Is it the school or the parenting? Both?

My son is 8 and is lovely most of the time but just comes across as being lazy, bored, unconfident, addicted to screens, like a teenager in many ways,the complete opposite of this. Sad

He takes part in a few extracurricular activities but just says how much he hates them. I am at my wits end and feeling like a failure.

OP posts:
mumda · 28/08/2021 17:57

He's addicted to screens: deal with that. Limit screen time. Offer other activities - are you taking him places and leaving him (organised activities/cub/scouts/after school stuff?) or going doing things together.

Find an activity he'll like. It might take some time.

ginexplorer · 28/08/2021 17:52

"It really isn't your parenting. It's personality. And luck.

I'm a very average parent - reasonably good at some bits of parenting and pretty crap at others. DH likewise (I'd say that he is even more average than me, but he might disagree.grin) However, DD makes us look like fucking amazing parents and as a result, I get loads of people asking me for advice.

I genuinely don't have any - it's just luck and she just is who she is. Very confident, very positive, very kind, very outgoing and full of enthusiasm for just about anything she does. The kind of kid who gets straight 9s while excelling in loads of extracurricular stuff and having loads of really nice friends. It sounds like I'm boasting, which genuinely isn't my intention. My point is that I have no right to boast because she just turned out like that, we can't take the credit for it. My friend who is an infinitely wiser and more patient parent than I could ever be has two children who are very different from each other but each very challenging. Again, just luck. And even though they are challenging they are also both wonderful in their own ways.

We get the children we are given. We do what we can through parenting them as well as we can and by encouraging them to engage with school, extracurricular activities etc, but ultimately, we don't get to control who they are. They each have their own unique nature, their own strengths and weaknesses, their own personalities and interests. They will be whoever they are meant to be.

She goes to a state comprehensive by the way."

For some weird reason the above made me want to cry as its just so true and spoken from the heart. I have seen a good friend with twins who go to private - one is highly academic and a total school swot - on for straights 9's and plays piano etc probably going to work for Nasa - aged 15 and doesn't like the idea alcohol or swearing etc The other twin who is just as bright has rebelled entirely and doesn't want to do A levels but have a more freestyle life. Very lazy and negative about a lot of things despite having so many privileges, a very affluent lifestyle and a loving mum and doting Dad.

So private school definitely not the total answer although they may be good for some in that expectations and standards are higher - but thats not always the case and i have friends whose children in hindsight would have suited a state comp more. I do think lazy is often a word used too liberally with boys and sometimes its a mask for not believing in themselves. Bringing other good, inspiring people/coaches/tutors in to their lives can help. I have found too much pressure doesn't work. Working on your relationship at the different stages and accepting them for where they are right now and not seeing current behaviour as necessarily the ultimate future prediction.

Middersweekly · 28/08/2021 17:37

It’s an interesting question. I have 4 x DC who are all different academically speaking, but teachers seem to love them. DD1 academically brilliant but extremely lazy. She had great motivation in a large state school but lost it in a small international fee paying school. DD2, quiet, dyslexic, sporty. Great sporting achievements. Academically average but keen to learn and tries hard. DD3 and DD4 are the two like you describe. Outgoing, lots of friends, academically bright, motivated etc. No difference in parenting style. I would say I’m somewhat strict but not overly so. I also let them learn and grow from their mistakes and help them to make better choices. That’s it really.

recall · 28/08/2021 17:26

It's pure luck....my oldest girl 14.... in top sets ....top grades ...totally sorted, I have never once had to ask her to do her homework.

Her brother 12 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️....total opposite. All over the place....requires micro managing.....total fucking nightmare !

fantastaballs · 28/08/2021 11:15

My daughter is the last of 4. She is just turned 13 and pretty amazing (though my other kids weren't shy or retiring). According to her class teacher, she is the natural go to for the whole form if they don't know the answer. She has a very strong sense of social justice and stands up for the under dog. She has a few sm channels for her hobby and regularly has 2-10k views she attends cadets and has a very strong desire to go into medicine with a view to surgery through the armed forces. Her friend shop groups are solid. She also breeds small species pedigree animals for showing and has a great grasp of genetics and handling a small business. All of our kids have been similar but she is really something.

How did we do it? We let them have kids cartoons but balanced every minute of cartoon time out with us all watching a documentary of some sort. If something interested then we would really encourage it . We always had the news on just before dinner and would talk about what was happening and actively court their opinions. If we saw something unfair, we would lead by example and call it out.

I decided I wanted to do a postgrad, so I talked to them and they agreed to help me. They came to my graduation. Then i did other courses for fun and my husband retrained They see that education doesn't end at 18/22 and should be life long as it brings happiness and good things.

AlexaShutUp · 28/08/2021 11:06

if I'd only had him I might have been smug

We only have one because of secondary infertility. DH and I sometimes joke that it was nature's way of not exposing how very average we are as parents! DD makes us look amazing...a second child would probably have given the game away!Grin

somewhereoverthe · 28/08/2021 11:04

I have two dss, the older one is fairly able academically and at high grade exam level in classical music (age 12). He had always been a gamer though age appropriate stuff and hates fortnite . He enjoys coding also. He read early and if I'd only had him I might have been smug that he hadn't had games before he was an independent reader. But ds2 has autism, dyspraxia abs dyslexia. We are helping him with a small fortune worth of support but he may never read a book independently due to his learning delays - this is nothing to do with whether he has had screens or not. However speech to text programmes, audiobooks and so on are integral for him. He gets a lot of vocabulary out of streaming cbbc etc and things like his train app and his Roald Dahl app. Without technology his life would be much less rich. I think unless they are playing age 16-18 games all day that the screen thing is more complex than just thinking that banning screens will make your child a genius.

BFrazzled · 28/08/2021 10:28

Most parents ferrying their children to activities do it to enrich their children’s world in the best way they can. Most parents don’t have money to spend their life between Japan and California like Skye Brown parents but still strive to do the best they can by paying hundred pounds a term for a dance class or a football team - same thing really, just different parental means.

Both are quite different from letting your child to play Minecraft for hours (while you are busy doing your own thing) in hope that he will become interested in coding, LOL.

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 28/08/2021 10:22

The real question is why do you want one? Why is your kid not good enough?

BFrazzled · 28/08/2021 10:18

@Nayday
It is also possible to became a chef while loving sausage rolls…

Nayday · 28/08/2021 10:05

@BFrazzled you can be as blunt as you like re screens being a waste of time - you're still incorrect Grin.

Incidentally, it's possible to be a gamer and read.

Nayday · 28/08/2021 10:03

@BFrazzled name calling is unnecessary thanks. I don't display naivety but am interested in the ways that successful people approach things. Am in no way suggesting it's a cookie cutter approach (unlike the hordes of parents desperately ferrying their kids to expensive activities that they have little interest in - in the vain hope that it will lead to some kind of 'success')

LakieLady · 28/08/2021 01:19

I went to state primary and was a precocious child. I would only make an effort with stuff I liked though, which was really only reading, drama and languages. I couldn't be arsed with anything sporty, or arty, or to do with science, but as those things weren't in the 11+, I passed.

And I was exactly the same when I went to an independent grammar school, but I became less and less precocious because there were so many girls there who were much cleverer than me. It didn't make me work any harder, just made me resentful because they all had ponies, went skiing and had expensive shoes.

BFrazzled · 28/08/2021 01:02

@Brighterblighter

I don't see screen time has any correlations at all to whether dc turn out bright or confident.
“Screens” for young kids is an unhealthy and pointless addiction that eats away on time that could be productively spent on other things, basically. This has as much to do with being attracted to “coding” or “engineering” as eating sausage rolls has to do with becoming a chef later in life. Sorry for being blunt.
BFrazzled · 28/08/2021 00:58

Re:Skye Brown - she had her own ramp in a backyard and a dad who regularly skateboarded. Her family is also very wealthy and obviously very much supported her hobby and her media presence. They are just being smart about it.
Don’t be naive :)

Nayday · 28/08/2021 00:44

Interestingly, Skye Brown - who demonstrates at an extreme level just how much can be achieved when someone has talent and support - talks about how 'fun' skateboarding and surfing are. She works her ass off because of her passion. Equally her parents are far from tiger pushy types - they've supported her every step of the way and her dad Stu is relaxed, - saying he had the attitude 'she could quit if it doesn't go well' as a hobby.
It's an interesting perspective.

Nayday · 28/08/2021 00:28

It's human nature for adults to be terrified of the next generation's culture. Screen time seems to be the TV of our current generation (how I laugh at recalling not being allowed to watch ITV, IL sure that directly propelled me to my current career 😂). As were 'racy' novels to 19th century sensibilities.

There are lots of benefits to screen time
such as gaming, including it's many routes to careers such as coding/engineering.

There's undoubtedly some nurture in these alleged wunderkind but nature plays a part top - parents often credit themselves too much. Who knows if they wouldn't have done better with a hands off approach (looking at Skye the self taught skateboarding Olympian here, she was the opposite of ferried around to a gazillion sports clubs - naturally talented, well supported and home schooled - yes).
Funny how I look around the world of work and it all seems a bit irrelevant. Thankfully noone is banging on about their extra curricular activities or achievements. It's helpful for children understand what motivates them - their strengths and weaknesses - that is where extra curricular activities can add value and development, they are not an end in their own right.

Brighterblighter · 28/08/2021 00:06

I don't see screen time has any correlations at all to whether dc turn out bright or confident.

BFrazzled · 27/08/2021 23:09

I have those stereotypical bright confident children. I invested a lot time and money into extracurriculars (but would never in a 1000 years dream of forcing them to do anything they didn’t like).
The biggest difference I see between myself and many other parents I know is that for me games and screen time in general is not children’s “right” or something to negotiate. They don’t get it as a reward or any fixed amount every week and oldest started playing computer games occasionally at age 8 and a half. But we only do it sporadically when on a long drive or when we have an occasional lie in on a weekend. And even then she would often choose to read a book.
In retrospect I would not introduce screen time alone (as opposed to movie with the whole family say) before the child is reading books fluently and for their own enjoyment.

MintyCedric · 27/08/2021 23:07

I think he has a lot of anxiety and that fuels it.

I do think this is a massive issue.

Dd became best mates with a lovely girl at nursery and they remained friends through primary although they went to different schools.

They have both just finished high school with similar grades, largely in the 8s and 9s.

Friend who suffers from anxiety is doing a training contract with a local hair dresser and hopes to married with babies by 25.

Dd is doing a levels, hopes to do a law degree or a business degree apprenticeship and isn't sure she wants kids at all...certainly not before 30.

I'll be honest, having known her friend since she was tiny it seems like a waste of talent (she wanted to be a writer or English teacher at one point) but you have to take into account personality as well as academic ability.

ChilliChoco · 27/08/2021 23:03

Can so relate to this post.

Polkadots2021 · 27/08/2021 23:01

@MooseBreath

My brother was one of those kids. Straight A student, popular, athletic, musical, charismatic, super confident... He could be anything he dreamt of. He wound up dropping out of University because the pressure of being "perfect" got to him. 6 years (and many dead-end jobs) later he's now back on his feet and is opening his own yoga studio - a passion he didn't find until his mid 20s.

As long as your son is happy and healthy, I wouldn't worry. He will find his way!

Your bro sounds super smart and smarter than many, resisting societal pressure to choose a top flight job and went instead for the more unusual yoga option as it'd make him happy. Cool dude!
sociallydistained · 27/08/2021 22:57

I’m a nanny to 6 children and the eldest has been like this since I started when he was aged 2. He didn’t even want to do the toddler activities that all the others have loved! It’s just his character. He’s a lovely lad, now a teenager but that lack of motivation and well, everything is a struggle attitude has just been him from day dot! I think he has a lot of anxiety and that fuels it. His sisters are so keen to do activities etc. He never even wanted to go to the park 🤦🏻‍♀️ It’s very interesting as clearly raised quite similarly and same opportunities.

KingofQueens · 27/08/2021 22:55

It's luck. I have one like this, and two absolutely not.

DisorganisedOrganiser · 27/08/2021 22:53

Thanks Fraulein, glad your DD is enjoying it now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread