Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say there is such a thing as a sugar addiction?

60 replies

Crimblecrumble1990 · 26/08/2021 22:23

I am braving AIBU for the first time...

For nearly 20 years I have what I would call a sugar addiction. In particular, chocolate. It's normally the first thing I think about when I wake up to the last thing at night. I will go out of my way to get it, hide it, eat it. Suggest entire meals out when I don't even want to see people just because they have a good dessert menu.

I am beyond miserable. It is wrecking my life and my health. I have always gotten away with being a bit chubby but I've now tipped into fat, high blood pressure etc. I've detested the way I look since I was pre teen. The one thing that could have changed it easily would be me stopping eating chocolate, why on earth haven't I done it??

It's a running joke in my friends and family that I eat so much of it - endless themed bday presents and I want to cry with shame every time I receive one. I've tried hypnotism and CBT as well as trying to not eat the stuff. I literally don't know what's wrong with me. I eat when I'm happy, sad, stressed, whenever. I adore the taste of it.

This sounds like a joke writing it all down but sadly this has been my life for nearly 2 decades. I made my son very poorly by consuming so much sugar while I was pregnant with him yet the utter horror of that has still not stopped me. I live with a smoker who loves me but cannot compare my 'addiction' with a 'proper' addiction like cigarettes, drugs, alcohol etc.

I guess I am wondering if I am alone??? Is there anyone else who feels the same way? Or if there are people who think this is not an addiction then please I would like to hear your thoughts also.

YABU - no such thing as sugar addiction
YANBU - yes there is such a thing as sugar addiction

Sorry for the long read.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Llamasally · 28/08/2021 23:12

This sounds extreme but I could see how I could get there too, the urge is overwhelming sometimes. Do you do any sports or hobbies? Not wanting to sound patronising, just thinking if the chocolate prevented you from doing something you love it might be a motivator, like smokers giving up to conceive

Twilight7777 · 28/08/2021 23:05

It’s absolutely an addiction, one I’ve suffered with since my teens. I’m now verging on developing diabetes and it still hasn’t stopped me eating chocolate like it’s going out of fashion. I wish I could change but I’ve tried everything I can

Looubylou · 27/08/2021 20:44

You have to go cold turkey - when I cut out all sweet things, I feel rubbish and crave them, but after 3 or 4 days, I stop thinking about it. I'm fine as long as I eat none - but only one thing and I'm on a slippery slope. I'm the same with Pepsi Max - I assume due to the caffeine. Sugar addiction definately exists

Angrycat2768 · 27/08/2021 20:14

Listen to 'A thorough examination'podcast by Drs Chris and Xand Van Tulleken. Quite emotional in parts. also Why we eat too much. The food industry spends millions trying to tap into our dopamine receptors, trying to get us to eat more and more cheap, sugary junk. I think sugar is a psychological adiction, and needs to be treated as such, so cold turkey until you break the habit. Dont tell people that you think you are addicted to sugar. Why do they need to know? Do they buy you bars of chocolate? Its nobodys business what you are eating or not. Sometimes if you tell people you are not going to eat something, they somehow see it as a personal affront or challenge and try to get you to fall off the wagon. Also, try cutting your carbs down to under 100g a day.

Thatnameistaken · 27/08/2021 19:50

I did the Fast800 diet over the summer, no sugar or carbs for 12 weeks. During the first 2 weeks I had headaches, weakness in my limbs, shakeyness, it was a proper addiction withdrawal.
Lost 3 stone and totally in control of what I eat now so it was worth it, but yes, sugar addiction is very real.

RealBecca · 27/08/2021 19:26

Sugar addiction is real but my opinion is that its more a craving at a set time, like after a meal or of an evening and can be broken quite easily if you caj get through the first week.

Im not trying to be mean or play doctor but the amount of time you are thinking about it sounds more of a disorder and i think you should speak to a doctor x

SmileyClare · 27/08/2021 19:19

Insulin resistance doesn't make you physically crave sugar. It's definitely a very harmful physical symptom of a sugar addiction.

If we're nit picking, then a physical addiction is one which causes unpleasant physical effects if the "drug or substance" is stopped suddenly.

I'm not minimising psychological addictions. Cocaine isn't physically addictive and is still highly addictive. A psychological addiction is incredibly hard to beat.

HereticFanjo · 27/08/2021 19:17

Great thread OP you are not alone.

longtimemarried · 27/08/2021 19:14

Crimble - I was so shocked at my increasing weight I stopped eating sugar literally overnight., and bought sugar free chewing gum instead. It worked for me.

Invasionofthegutsnatchers · 27/08/2021 19:09

I do think it's physically addictive though especially if you have insulin resistance.

Invasionofthegutsnatchers · 27/08/2021 19:08

Yes I'm quoting Superhans Grin

SmileyClare · 27/08/2021 19:00

Well that's silly, I wouldn't say it's more addictive than crack; it's not physically addictive and you won't go through a withdrawal with paranoia, hallucinations, shaking, sweating and extreme changes in mood. You wouldn't prostitute yourself to fund your chocolate habit.

If you're quoting Super Hans then Grin love that show but it's not really a reliable source for facts on addiction.

Invasionofthegutsnatchers · 27/08/2021 18:52

Sugar is more addictive than crack.

Crack is moreish.

SmileyClare · 27/08/2021 18:49

I think what you're asking is "Is sugar addiction a medically recognised addiction?" because you feel you need help and support?

If so, then yes it comes under the umbrella of an eating disorder. There is help through the NHS. Look at NHS overeaters support or BEAT. There are also meetings you can attend and online support groups. You just need to take the first step in seeking help.

EmeraldShamrock · 27/08/2021 18:43

I remember Davina McCall when she gave up sugar, she created sugar free range of yummy treats to help her overcome her sugar craving.
You might find some of her recipes on line.

SmileyClare · 27/08/2021 18:37

The combination of fat and sugar (e.g. chocolate) and the pleasure receptors it fires in your brain are what you're addicted to.

The slightly good news is that it's not a physical addiction, more psychological, so you won't experience awful withdrawal symptoms if you stop. That's not to say it will be easy.

I would suggest that instead of seeking support from friends who haven't been particularly understanding or sympathetic, you look at joining an overeating support group such as overeaters anonymous. You can explore the emotional issues behind your binges.

Good luck Smile

Bluntness100 · 27/08/2021 18:26

@Crimblecrumble1990

I guess I was just briefly outlining in my post my experience to see if other people were in the same boat and whether or not there was a consensus that it is a 'proper' addiction (or not as you imply *@Bluntness100* ) thanks all
Did you get the wrong poster? I specifically and clearly stated it was a thing. Confused
scarpa · 27/08/2021 15:42

It can definitely be an addiction. And like any addiction, there are environmental and mental factors that make 'just make a proper effort to stop' a rather incomplete bit of advice.

Yes, you should absolutely try and put things into place to help yourself stop - like an alcoholic should probably avoid pubs (esp in early sobriety) or a gambler should get registered with GamStop, you should identify your triggers (after a meal - can you replace chocolate with fruit or even just 'less chocolate' initially? Can you buy one of those Killa Vanilla sticks?), set yourself a goal (no sweet stuff before Monday) and extend it as you go, train yourself to respond to the craving with a particular action (if you reach for the Galaxy, make yourself wait 10 minutes and repeat why you don't want to do that any more to yourself out loud, go and do 30 starjumps, go and drink a pint of water, whatever is a breaking of your original course of action and makes you step back from the craving > eating process).

But addictions have a mental component and it's also something you should seek help for. Without that, you're fighting an ingrained mental 'default' that's been there a long time and it'll be harder (not impossible - god knows I've seen heroin addicts kick it with nothing other than grim determination! - but harder).

And you need to change your life. Genuinely. You need to fulfil yourself and provide yourself with healthy scenarios that don't threaten your recovery. Sounds dramatic for 'a bit of chocolate', but you wouldn't expect a crack addict who got clean but stayed living with 3 crack addict friends, only friends with users, and didn't have a job or anything different in their lives, to find it easy to stay clean. So stop the shame spiral that helps you convince yourself you're a lost cause and adds to the mental burden (no 'jokey' presents off friends and family - be firm!). You need to stop buying it - get your partner to do the shopping if needs be. You need to wake up in the morning divert your thoughts immediately, every day until it becomes habit - make a peppermint tea and do some wanky journalling, do some yoga, go and feed the dog, whatever. Remind yourself you are in charge of what you do - the addiction 'wants' you to feel as though you're not to satisfy the craving.
What Bluntness is not very tactfully saying, I think, is that you have to reach the point where you are actively fighting back against the addiction instead of assuming you have no power.

It won't be easy, but you do have agency and choice and you need to position the addiction as something you're working against, not under the power of (as well as getting external help).

Crimblecrumble1990 · 27/08/2021 12:45

I guess I was just briefly outlining in my post my experience to see if other people were in the same boat and whether or not there was a consensus that it is a 'proper' addiction (or not as you imply @Bluntness100 ) thanks all

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 27/08/2021 11:54

Whereas if I said to someone - I'm drinking too much every day, it's affecting my life. Those same people would say 'that sounds tough Crumble, I think it's time you got some help'

Generally becayse people don’t need help, they go cold Turkey ans break addiction, no it’s not easy but it’s not like being an alcoholic or a heroin addict.

Have you even tried to stop? Like properly? There’s an element of lack of personal responsibility in your post. Like it’s not your fault, you’re addicted sort of thing,

Many of us have been there, but if you don’t make a proper effort to stop then no one can help you. It’s you who has to do it.

Neron · 27/08/2021 08:03

YANBU. I am one (and working on it)

WeKnowFrogsGoShaLaLaLaLa · 27/08/2021 08:00

I agree with watching the films suggested above. Also start looking at where all the hidden sugars are in the processed foods you eat - you will be surprised at how much it features.

For example, the Tesco Finest ready meal Shepherds Pie - has four different types of sugar in it - in a meal that has to intention of tasting sweet at all.

If you also read Why We Eat Too Much - it talks a lot about just how processed our foods are, including the addition of sugar, you will also feel more aware.

For me it's been this education that's finally helped me lower my intake. I visited Cadbury World and was appalled at the amount of travelling and processing that went into one bar - it actually put me off - such is the switch in my thinking.

This makes me sound virtuous, I'm not, but I'm trying and that's a start.

EmeraldShamrock · 27/08/2021 07:50

I'm afraid I do absolutely adore the taste as well as the 'high'
So do smokers, alcoholics, heroin addicts, from opening up the wrapper and putting it in their body.

TravelDreamLife · 27/08/2021 07:47

My husband was raised to worship sugar. At his peak, he was hiding it, and eating massive amounts. People would give him huge chocolate gifts for birthdays and Christmas and treat it like a joke, even though I'd begged them not to. It really was like giving alcohol to an alcoholic. It was that bad.

To quit, he read books & watched docos ('Sweet Poison', 'I Quit Sugar', 'That Sugar Film'). He learnt about the addiction & strategies to quit.

It's tough. Years on and he still struggles. He doesn't get support, especially from his parents who are horrified he's quit sugar & try to undermine it constantly (I've had to stop unsupervised DC contact for same reason). Everywhere we go people are shoving it in his face and keep asking 'are you sure?' It was much more difficult than when I quit smoking as you feel fantastic after you quit that one as it's pretty gross, really!!

I don't want to make it sound horrible, but it IS worth it. His health is much better and he lost weight. That's how he keeps on top of it. I w

EmeraldShamrock · 27/08/2021 07:40

Of course it is a very real addiction, it is tough, too much of anything that is doing more damage than good will lead to addiction.
It is an all or none situation like every addiction - Many people have given up sugar altogether so there is hope.
I use 2 spoonfuls x 10 cups of tea daily. 🤮