Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset that MIL lives on same street and hardly sees DC

208 replies

3plantpots · 26/08/2021 21:23

I’m really starting to struggle to hold my tongue on this with my DH and others and pretend it’s all fine when it’s not really.

My DC’s GPs live 5 minutes walking distance from us if that, yet have never once offered to take them out, have a sleepover, have them for an evening so we can go out etc. They see them once every 1 -2 weeks, best we get is sometimes for tea. MIL is retired. I ask if she can look after them odd times if I want to go to an appointment, I’d say this is agreed to about one in five times, other times too busy or got something else to do. I give lots of notice. Then the rare times she does take them it’s literally for the precise amount of time needed, no more, no ‘don’t rush back’ or ‘I’ll keep them until bed time’. Now I know my MIL is entitled to do what she wants with her time and I obviously can’t make anyone do anything, but am I BU to be a bit upset by this?

I find it worst when people pass comment on what lovely children they are, polite etc, and that MIL must love having them so close/seeing them all the time etc. I have to sort of smile and gloss over it then feel very embarrassed and hurt that actually I have to pay a babysitter for any childcare we have and they see very little of them. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GrolliffetheDragon · 01/03/2022 10:04

@smorgasbords

I do find the modern obsession with grandparents quite strange - I think it’s nice to have nice grandparents but I don’t think kids gain much from being really, really close to them. I think mostly parents benefit from it in terms of childcare, and then when I read threads on here most seem to complain when they feel grandparents are getting too close or overly involved with their grandchildren - they can’t win in a lot of cases.
I think it's nice to have a close relationship with grandparents. Perhaps because, for various reasons, I only had a close relationship with one of my grandparents.
JudgeJ · 28/02/2022 13:32

@HalfCakeHalfBiscuit

YABU - why should MIL take on your childcare responsibilities?
If MIL was round every day then the moan would be that she was there too often! MIL may read these pages about awful interfering MILs, it seems to come down to 'can't do right for doing wrong'. I am often shopping close to my daughter's home but I would never dream of just dropping in, if I text to see if she wants anything getting she'll often ask me over for a coffee. My SIL once said, half joking, Don't plan to be away til we know when we'll need baby sitters, and he got a right flea in his ear from his wife!
smorgasbords · 28/02/2022 13:17

I do find the modern obsession with grandparents quite strange - I think it’s nice to have nice grandparents but I don’t think kids gain much from being really, really close to them. I think mostly parents benefit from it in terms of childcare, and then when I read threads on here most seem to complain when they feel grandparents are getting too close or overly involved with their grandchildren - they can’t win in a lot of cases.

Cheryl22x · 28/02/2022 11:53

How do I make a new thread ?

BreastedBoobilyToTheStairs · 28/02/2022 11:07

@Cheryl22x

My mil won’t come and visit her grandchild at my house or her sons she thinks my child should just be at her house, she never texts or rings to ask about her grandchild and when we’ve confronted her about all this she says yous know I want to see her, I won’t allow my daughter to be alone with anyone just yet so her dad has to take her over. But she never makes any effort to be in her life so why should we arrange to take her over to hers ? Am I being unreasonable? She gets in contact with her son ( my daughters dads) and never mentions my daughter not even to ask how she is. When I send her photos of my daughter she will reply back saying beautiful etc but is never interested when I tell her about her milestones etc. can I have some advice please
You'd be better off starting your own thread - this one is old and you'll likely get a lot of people replying to the Op from August rather than giving advice for your specific situation because not everyone will read the full thread before posting.
averythinline · 28/02/2022 10:52

Don't gloss over it ... you can't expect her to do anything...but equally you don't need to pretend she does..

If anyone says mil blah blah...just say oh you wouldn't believe hardly see her she's so busy....

Relationships require effort in the main....if she doesn't want to thsts fine but equally you need to stop expecting or engaging and pull back to where you are comfortable not resentful..
Make other arrangements for support....most do....

My dc no useful grandparents so no help ,but no thwarted expectations either...

Brefugee · 28/02/2022 10:48

Tell your mum to stop stirring it. Your MIL sees them plenty, she isn't childcare for you, she is a retired woman taking a well earned rest.

honeylulu · 28/02/2022 10:38

I feel for you OP. We had a dud pair of grandparents on both sides. Like a PP said, it's that they don't care that really hurts (as opposed to no childcare though that would also have been nice).

Both my husband and I had childhoods where we saw and stayed with our grandparents regularly so we were a bit shocked when our own parents were so remote and uninterested.

We kind of had some warning from PIL as they had a grandchild before we had our first and they did very little babysitting for her. They did seem very proud though and paid for her various activities etc. By the time we had out first 9 years later the novelty had totally worn off. Occasionally when they had extended family visiting we'd be told to bring our son over and parade him. But other than that pretty much zero interest. They lived 5 mins away.

My own parents seemed thrilled with the idea of a grandchild (their first). They did show a lot of interest in the first few months. Would come and visit and encourage us to have a break and go out. However my sister (golden child) had her first a year later and since then it's almost been like mine barely existed. They regularly visited my nephews, had them to stay in the school holidays but there was always an excuse if I asked if they could help. Latterly it was "we don't feel comfortable having him on our own as we don't really know him". Erm, yes! I gave up making so much effort maintaining contact and they didn't even notice.

We now have another child who has only seen them a handful of times in her life. During a lockdown conversation she was surprised to hear that Granny and Grandpa are actually my mum and dad!

It's such a shame. We can afford childcare including evening babysitters so it's not that. But it's hurtful that their grandparents care so little about having a relationship with them especially when they do with their other, preferred grandchildren.

GrolliffetheDragon · 28/02/2022 10:27

@amylou8

I am planning to be this grandparent. I want to have a relationship with my grandkids, to see them on a regular basis, help out on the occasional emergency, but taking on regular childcare responsibilities, being at the kids beck and call...no thanks. I had my first at 21, now I'm in my mid 40s and all 3 are adults. This is MY time.
Which is fair enough if you're clear and upfront about it.

MIL told me before I was even pregnant that she would not provide childcare, then she provided it for all the rest of her grandchildren. We asked once if she could watch DS for a very short amount of time, it was less than an hour, she agreed then called us to come and get him half way through the time.

I've tried to encourage a relationship, and DS adores her, but she just seems less interested in him than her other grandchildren. And I don't understand why.

Cheryl22x · 28/02/2022 10:02

My mil seems like she doesn’t want to see my daughter at all tho. No texts or anything not bothered so why should I put any effort in

Brainwave89 · 28/02/2022 09:08

It is quite difficult sometimes to get your head around the fact that different families have different approaches. Seeing grandkids once every week or two weeks was quite normal in my DHs family, and this worked quite well for us- no one interfered we were always able to set our own agendas etc. It is nice to have support, but some retirees will have very busy lives planned- it does vary, and these may not be planned around grandkids. I think you have to look positively on the support you do get.

Cheryl22x · 28/02/2022 08:06

My mil won’t come and visit her grandchild at my house or her sons she thinks my child should just be at her house, she never texts or rings to ask about her grandchild and when we’ve confronted her about all this she says yous know I want to see her, I won’t allow my daughter to be alone with anyone just yet so her dad has to take her over. But she never makes any effort to be in her life so why should we arrange to take her over to hers ? Am I being unreasonable? She gets in contact with her son ( my daughters dads) and never mentions my daughter not even to ask how she is. When I send her photos of my daughter she will reply back saying beautiful etc but is never interested when I tell her about her milestones etc. can I have some advice please

Dreamstate · 28/08/2021 20:32

But ao what if you mum does all that. Its not a competition. Just becuasd they are closer they aren't obligated to see you or the children more.

You say your fil has a job, your mil most likely then still does most of the house stuff, then having her own hobbies and meeting her own friends. It's easy to see why there is not lots of free time. She has a life and she is entitled to live it how she sees fit.

You say the time they have is quality time so whats the problem...oh yeh she just won't give you free childcare. That's all and thats is where your problem really is. Just admit it because we can all see it.

Worst thing is you said earlier that your not going to pretend anymore...meaning what your going to talk negatively about them. Why would you even do that...do yo think if they knew that would make them want to help you more Hmm

3plantpots · 28/08/2021 19:25

@HeartvsBrain

OP, on the occassions when Grandma does babysit her DGC is she allowed to just get on with it, or does the favour she is doing you come with all sorts of rules and regulations regarding her DGC? Also OP, when your DC returns home, do you ring up Grandma and thank her for having said DC, or do you first cross-question your DC about everything they have done, and everything they have eaten and drunk, and then ring up, or more likely, get DH to ring her up to tell her that she didn't follow every rule to the letter, and that she didn't make her DGC have enough exercise by taking them out for a long walk, but she did wrongly let her DGC have a cake when everyone else was having one, and that grandma mustn't let baby/then later toddler, have a rest when they were very tired because the DGC would then not want to sleep the solid 12 hours at night that mum insists on? When your DC was older did you tell your DC that if they watched any TV at grandma's they would have to go to bed without being allowed to watch the TV you normally let them watch as you don't want to entertain them yourself (and in this little scenario OP you are a SAHM)? Oh and OP, do you give your DC one tiny baby size yogurt for breakfast and nothing else because you are sure that grandma will overfeed them when DC is at hers, which of course means that grandma has to give them more because she is not willing to be in charge of a starving child, so then obviously when DGC goes home, grandma gets the expected phonecall telling her off again for overfeeding DGC. If grandma tries to stick up for herself is she then told that she can never babysit DGC again because she can't be trusted to follow all of the rules? Of course, OP do you then back down and ask grandma to babysit again after 2 weeks at the most, because you can't cope with not having at least one day off from being a mummy? The grandma asking all these questions is still available everytime she is asked by her DDiL to have DGC, because grandma cares about DiL's mental state, and loves her DGC very much, buy this grandma is terribly stressed everytime she has DGC, because she knows that at the after DGC goes home that she is going to get another ohone bollocking either from D DDiL herself, or more likely from DS who has been told to do so by his DW. If you are even a 10th like the DDiL in this scenario it would not be surprising if another grandma declines the kind offer some of the time. I am not saying that you are anything like that OP, I am just putting it forward as a possible reason a GP might be too afraid to babysit her wonderful GC too often.
Nope, none of the above. They do what they like and I am always very grateful including small thank you gifts, cards, flowers…
OP posts:
3plantpots · 28/08/2021 19:13

@dontstealmymagnolias

OP I think you should direct some of your anger/disappointment towards your own mother. If she is so hands on and 'a martyr' why is she not offering to come and stay with you every so often for a few days to provide the plentiful free childcare that she got? How often does she take the dgc for weekends to bond with them and give you a break? I'm very surprised she hasn't offered to move to provide the care that she is seemingly so discusted about that your ILs aren't providing.
@dontstealmymagnolias no offer to move but do come and stay lots, for extended periods, offer (and actually do) take them out, have them overnight, encourage us to go out as a couple and they take care of them. Certainly much more time spent and offers of help from 3+ hours away vs 3 minutes!
OP posts:
ancientgran · 28/08/2021 19:12

@3plantpots

Thanks for all the responses, good food for thought.

To all saying ‘you decided to have kids’ - yes you’re absolutely right - but the model I had seen with my own family and pretty much everyone I know I envisioned being the norm - which is heavy involvement of GPS and doting adoration of GCs. I perhaps had too high expectations based on this but you only know what you know.

Their relationship is good and I have no worries there, the time spent is quality time.

I think PPs are right also, my DM is probably stirring it up and I hadn’t really given this and my feelings about it much thought (probably out of jealousy on her side as suggested). She has never directly slagged off MIL but has made it very clear that she disapproves of the situation, thinks she should be helping a lot more and often drops in how she would be round to ours all the time if she lived so close etc etc. Which she probably would to the point of being annoying and I’d probably be on here moaning about that Grin. She’s really the polar opposite TBH and is a bit of a martyr with putting herself out for GCs.

I'm not sure high expectations is appropriate, it sort of implies your expectations are superior and his family are inferior. Your expectations were wrong, they don't have to do what you expect.
Heliachi · 28/08/2021 13:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

serialname · 28/08/2021 12:16

Don't expect anything from them, then you won't be disappointed. They won't change.

HeartvsBrain · 28/08/2021 11:43

OP, on the occassions when Grandma does babysit her DGC is she allowed to just get on with it, or does the favour she is doing you come with all sorts of rules and regulations regarding her DGC? Also OP, when your DC returns home, do you ring up Grandma and thank her for having said DC, or do you first cross-question your DC about everything they have done, and everything they have eaten and drunk, and then ring up, or more likely, get DH to ring her up to tell her that she didn't follow every rule to the letter, and that she didn't make her DGC have enough exercise by taking them out for a long walk, but she did wrongly let her DGC have a cake when everyone else was having one, and that grandma mustn't let baby/then later toddler, have a rest when they were very tired because the DGC would then not want to sleep the solid 12 hours at night that mum insists on? When your DC was older did you tell your DC that if they watched any TV at grandma's they would have to go to bed without being allowed to watch the TV you normally let them watch as you don't want to entertain them yourself (and in this little scenario OP you are a SAHM)? Oh and OP, do you give your DC one tiny baby size yogurt for breakfast and nothing else because you are sure that grandma will overfeed them when DC is at hers, which of course means that grandma has to give them more because she is not willing to be in charge of a starving child, so then obviously when DGC goes home, grandma gets the expected phonecall telling her off again for overfeeding DGC. If grandma tries to stick up for herself is she then told that she can never babysit DGC again because she can't be trusted to follow all of the rules? Of course, OP do you then back down and ask grandma to babysit again after 2 weeks at the most, because you can't cope with not having at least one day off from being a mummy?
The grandma asking all these questions is still available everytime she is asked by her DDiL to have DGC, because grandma cares about DiL's mental state, and loves her DGC very much, buy this grandma is terribly stressed everytime she has DGC, because she knows that at the after DGC goes home that she is going to get another ohone bollocking either from D DDiL herself, or more likely from DS who has been told to do so by his DW. If you are even a 10th like the DDiL in this scenario it would not be surprising if another grandma declines the kind offer some of the time.
I am not saying that you are anything like that OP, I am just putting it forward as a possible reason a GP might be too afraid to babysit her wonderful GC too often.

phishy · 28/08/2021 09:15

Maybe the younger two are still in diapers while the eldest is capable of conversing/ interacting at a more interesting or lower maintenance level. Grandma is not required to have an identical relationship with each child.

As pp said: ‘her mum seems to be creating more work and stress for her. Misty has to now fit in a visit for DS1 to her mum at 11 and pick him up at the fixed time of 1pm, whilst juggling the other two young DC and doing whatever else she needs to do.’

Porcupineintherough · 28/08/2021 08:49

All these mothers in law who dare to have a life of their own rather than devoting it to support their daughters in law (men dont be see to playing a big role in this story). Shocking.

Heliachi · 28/08/2021 08:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

amylou8 · 28/08/2021 08:33

I am planning to be this grandparent. I want to have a relationship with my grandkids, to see them on a regular basis, help out on the occasional emergency, but taking on regular childcare responsibilities, being at the kids beck and call...no thanks. I had my first at 21, now I'm in my mid 40s and all 3 are adults. This is MY time.

Meraas · 28/08/2021 08:26

@Heliachi but also not fair to put pressure on Misty for these 2 hour visits for one DGC.

Heliachi · 28/08/2021 08:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.