Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU re landlord’s notice dispute..

59 replies

PardonBeeOne · 26/08/2021 20:06

Sorry its long but its an effort to give a clear picture…

I have been a tenant for over 10 yrs. Finally managed to buy.
Over the years LL has come if called out for something or another but would go for months without coming because they did not need to.
We looked after the property to the best of our ability, had a window cleaner, regular gardening, all bills and rent paid on time. Never missed a payment or asked for rent relief. Recently had driveway washed.
Before Covid 19, we had a regular cleaner. So the place was generally well looked after.

When we moved in, there was new wallpaper in the bathroom. Come winter, it turned out it was a mouldy spot that started to grow back. We removed wall paper and painted it with ant mould paint.. it became easier to maintain during winter months.

There was some wear and tear, having had to bring up 2 kids during that time. But LL was aware of them.
LL had always wanted to do the kitchen so problems in the kitchen were met with, ‘we plan to extend the kitchen anyway’

The boiler was replaced but the pipes were left exposed and we were left to live with that for a few years. We never complained.

Fast forward two months ago, we completed and exchanged. The day after we collected the keys, we gave a month’s notice to LL. up to this point, I thought we had a civil business relationship.
Few days after notice was sent, we got what I thought was a hostile email from LL complaining that we blindsided them. Notice was not sufficient… contract says one month’s notice. LL listed how they have been lenient over the years, not increasing rent but we return that by not being grateful. They demanded a spot check of the property within ASAP which we couldn’t do due to work commitments, but offered a day we could do.
LL said wants property the way it was when it was handed over to us… well not possible as its been lived in so general wear and tear is expected. Having said that, I expected them to be pleased because of the effort we have made over the years Smile

Now LL is saying umpteen years ago when we moved in, we moved in 12 days early (I cant even remember). So they are saying our notice should be 12 days less and they set a date. No complaints, we are working towards leaving.

My AIBU is: Are we within our right to call LL on this because as its never been an issue before.
LL is blaming us for property not being maintained outside… I say outside is LL’s responsibility to paint and decorate, Is this U?

LL said they will get a quote for carpet cleaning and fixing things they knew about and send us the bill? I think LL does not want to give us our deposit… AIBU?

OP posts:
longerevenings · 26/08/2021 22:46

There won't be confrontation, the deposit arbitration process is done by a third party,
It won't be between you and the landlord.

PardonBeeOne · 26/08/2021 22:43

Mummyoflittledragon

LL has happily accepted our monthly rentals which covered 30/31 days. they never asked us to pay more for the first month because we moved in early. This was the first I heard of it.
I will double check the tenancy agreement.

But we did not argue, we adjusted our plans and moved out.

OP posts:
SeasonFinale · 26/08/2021 22:42

He can't reduce the notice period either.

Themeparklover · 26/08/2021 22:34

Take full photo and communications evidence make sure it is as clean and presentable as you possibly can and go to CA they will be able to direct and advise you on next steps on how to get your deposit back and warn your LL they are acting unreasonably and unprofessionally. Also stick to your notice date and go through your contract with a fine tooth comb to highlight any issue he hasn't addressed or adhered to to throw back at him just in case

AngelDelightUk · 26/08/2021 22:29

A tip from when I was in rental, look up average life of carpets. I was in the same place for about 10 years and the agent tried to claim I’d wrecked the living room carpet. So I set up a dispute saying the carpets weren’t new when I moved in, so they were at least ten years old and the average life was xxx years (5-7 if I remember correctly)

They had to give all the deposit back!

MadinMarch · 26/08/2021 22:24

I'm a landlord.
Your landlord is bonkers!
I don't understand why you agreed to move out 12 days early though?
You would be legally allowed a month to move out from whatever day of the month is stated on your tenancy agreement.
I hope you didn't pay rent for the whole of the month?

PardonBeeOne · 26/08/2021 22:19

BycullahRoad

We maintained the inside very well!

In fact, on the 1st property check, LL’s OH said property was good and has always told friends that they were happy with us hence no regular visits.
On the final day, OH would speak in a different language to LL, then LL would respond in English how disappointed they were about state of the property, using words like shambles Shock

The 12 days would have applied to initial contract. After that it was a gentleman’s handshake, with no written contracts.

I would need to check the name of the deposit scheme.
We were desperately trying to avoid confrontation, but we have heard nothing about our deposit since.

OP posts:
PardonBeeOne · 26/08/2021 22:09

BrilliantBetty

LL said they will get quotations for carpet cleaning and send us the bill Shock

Had LL let us stay past our pay day, Knowing me, I would have had the carpets in the bedrooms cleaned. But our 30 days notice was reduced when they brought up the issue about moving in 12 days early!
Having just bought a house, the money tree had not grown back Smile

OP posts:
BananaMilkshakeWithCream · 26/08/2021 21:16

The TDS are great. When we gave notice after buying our house they tried to keep 80% of the deposit! Alleged Misdemeanours included; spraying coke on the ceiling 🤔 and leaving the place untidy (only evidence was one crisp packet behind a wardrobe that was there when we arrived) He also tried to claim for the carpets which were years old, tatty and frayed even when we moved in and we were there for 1.5 years after that. Took a while but we got back the monies.

What was funny was the landlord actually lost his claim on a technicality. This was because the photos he’d taken of the property were dated three weeks before we moved in. TDS said that the damage could have occurred before we moved in and the landlord had no proof to the contrary 😂

TrainspottingWelsh · 26/08/2021 21:16

LL is a dick, and either clueless or bluffing.
I had tenants for 12 months that tried to claim their damage was fair wear and tear. We're talking cracked wall tiles, holes in walls, new carpet completely ruined, doors wrecked, stains, mould and filth everywhere. And I had to prove and document everything to keep the deposit, I couldn't just say 'well after 12 months the house shouldn't look like a shit tip'. So there is absolutely no way that he'll be allowed to make deductions for normal wear and tear, especially after 10yrs.

Mummyoflittledragon · 26/08/2021 21:07

@Dippydinosaurus

Don't even go to your LL with this. Login to your deposit and request 100% of it back once you've moved out. The LL will then respond via the same website. If there's a dispute this will be managed by a third party. You can upload your inventory and pictures from when you moved in and the one when you move out. They will decide. From personal experience don't worry and use the dispute service that's what it's for. Unless there's holes in the walls, things are damaged etc , it's unlikely you'll have a problem if it's fair wear and tear. Also landlords can't charge for carpet cleaning, curtain cleaning, painting anymore since the newlawl came in a year or two ago. When we renewed our tenancy, the charges that were in there for these disappeared. Obviously out of courtesy I would pay for a professional clean and get the carpets cleaned. But don't commit to anything just put the claim in
This isn’t strictly true. If a carpet is more dirty than expected and the carpet was clean on entry, a ll can expect it to be cleaned to an appropriate standard. Not necessarily professionally. But a professional clean may be required to get the carpet clean enough. Ditto an exceptionally dirty wall.

The situation is far fairer on tenants, who have unscrupulous landlords such as these whilst still protecting fair landlords. However, they still cannot expect the carpet cleaned after over a decade. It will have fully depreciated and would probably fall to pieces!

cookingisoverrated · 26/08/2021 20:59

Oh, and take pictures of absolutely everything, date stamped, at the end.

cookingisoverrated · 26/08/2021 20:58

@Narutocrazyfox

You are not being unreasonable. Landlords are utter bastards. I say this after living in 17 rented properties and having to fight tooth and nail for my deposit back each time. We were model tenants, paid on time, kept each property clean and tidy. Paid for professional exit cleans every time we moved. Stick to your guns, your LL is being ridiculous. Good luck!
This.

And tell him you will be more than happy to dispute any attempted reductions for wear and tear over 10 years. Triple damages for withholding them unlawfully, isn't it? - said lightly

Stand firm. He is being unreasonable. You can give 1 month's notice pursuant to the terms of your contract, regardless of what he says in either direction. Or HE's breaking the terms. Again, said lightly, but firmly.

Dippydinosaurus · 26/08/2021 20:48

Don't even go to your LL with this. Login to your deposit and request 100% of it back once you've moved out. The LL will then respond via the same website. If there's a dispute this will be managed by a third party. You can upload your inventory and pictures from when you moved in and the one when you move out. They will decide. From personal experience don't worry and use the dispute service that's what it's for. Unless there's holes in the walls, things are damaged etc , it's unlikely you'll have a problem if it's fair wear and tear. Also landlords can't charge for carpet cleaning, curtain cleaning, painting anymore since the newlawl came in a year or two ago. When we renewed our tenancy, the charges that were in there for these disappeared. Obviously out of courtesy I would pay for a professional clean and get the carpets cleaned. But don't commit to anything just put the claim in

Tempusfudgeit · 26/08/2021 20:47

If your deposit is held in a scheme, you don't ask the landlord directly - just apply to the scheme for the return of your full deposit. LL has to prove why they should keep any of your money, and after 10 years, as long as you haven't knocked through any walls, you'll get it all back. Congratulations on your house purchase!

Mummyoflittledragon · 26/08/2021 20:46

I’m a landlord. Your ll is bonkers. When tenants leave after a long period, I plan for extensive work and wouldn’t charge unless there is serious damage.

Carpets will be considered to have depreciated to pretty much zero unless they can prove they are expected to last longer due to being exceptionally good quality, such as Axminster. But even then….

I agree with others about not engaging. This should go straight to the tenancy deposit scheme. Any damage will most likely come under fwat and you’ll most likely get 100% back. They are cheeky fuckers.

And as for the exit date, are you saying they want you to leave 12 days earlier and pay for those 12 extra days when you’re not actually there? Was there anything in writing in place? This request is extremely odd and I don’t actually understand.

citycitycity · 26/08/2021 20:41

I’m in a similar position after 5 years tenancy and I will be going down the wear and tear route if they try and hold my deposit.

Dazedandconfused10 · 26/08/2021 20:38

If there is no check in report to compare a check out report to he can't keep any of the deposit. The deposit protection will win in your favour mostly likely due to length of tenancy anyway

PardonBeeOne · 26/08/2021 20:37

Gilmorehill

We only had agents when we moved in to allow proper vetting and all, after that, LL let whatever arrangement he had with them, lapse.

OP posts:
Spanglybangles · 26/08/2021 20:32

Do not engage with this. You say your deposit is protected in the scheme, so simply raise a dispute if LL tries to retain the deposit.

We had a similar experience from our LL when we told them we had bought a house. Came up with all sorts of things in order to try and retain the full deposit.

We raised a dispute and got everything back. We put forward a very good argument as there had been sooo many issues with the house (broken door that wasn’t fixed for 6 weeks meaning the house couldn’t be secured, possibly being the worst), but it wasn't actually necessary in the end as the LL failed to produce the tenancy agreement as requested by the scheme….how stupid can you get!!

Deposit scheme overwhelmingly sides with tenants in these situations I believe. Good luck.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 26/08/2021 20:31

They can't charge you for carpet cleaning of a 10+ year old carpet Grin
Wait for the bill then get the deposit protection scheme to arbitrate. I doubt he'll see a penny.

Phineyj · 26/08/2021 20:26

I'm a landlady of a property and this sounds very unreasonable. I'd suggest arbitration to them yourself if they carry on being ridiculous.

BycullahRoad · 26/08/2021 20:25

It's landlords like this that make tenants not want to pay their final months' rent. Not that I am giving you ideas.

In relation to the 12 days, it's the start date on the most recent signed tenancy agreement that counts. And if that agreement has expired, then you only have to give 31 days notice.

In relation to the condition of the property, landlord is responsible for the exterior, you are responsible for the inside subject to fair wear and tear given the duration of the tenancy.

Who is the deposit protected with?

BrilliantBetty · 26/08/2021 20:22

YANBU.

Wear and tear is to be expected. As LL they will need to cover deep clean of carpets or new carpets that's not your responsibility.