Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU re landlord’s notice dispute..

59 replies

PardonBeeOne · 26/08/2021 20:06

Sorry its long but its an effort to give a clear picture…

I have been a tenant for over 10 yrs. Finally managed to buy.
Over the years LL has come if called out for something or another but would go for months without coming because they did not need to.
We looked after the property to the best of our ability, had a window cleaner, regular gardening, all bills and rent paid on time. Never missed a payment or asked for rent relief. Recently had driveway washed.
Before Covid 19, we had a regular cleaner. So the place was generally well looked after.

When we moved in, there was new wallpaper in the bathroom. Come winter, it turned out it was a mouldy spot that started to grow back. We removed wall paper and painted it with ant mould paint.. it became easier to maintain during winter months.

There was some wear and tear, having had to bring up 2 kids during that time. But LL was aware of them.
LL had always wanted to do the kitchen so problems in the kitchen were met with, ‘we plan to extend the kitchen anyway’

The boiler was replaced but the pipes were left exposed and we were left to live with that for a few years. We never complained.

Fast forward two months ago, we completed and exchanged. The day after we collected the keys, we gave a month’s notice to LL. up to this point, I thought we had a civil business relationship.
Few days after notice was sent, we got what I thought was a hostile email from LL complaining that we blindsided them. Notice was not sufficient… contract says one month’s notice. LL listed how they have been lenient over the years, not increasing rent but we return that by not being grateful. They demanded a spot check of the property within ASAP which we couldn’t do due to work commitments, but offered a day we could do.
LL said wants property the way it was when it was handed over to us… well not possible as its been lived in so general wear and tear is expected. Having said that, I expected them to be pleased because of the effort we have made over the years Smile

Now LL is saying umpteen years ago when we moved in, we moved in 12 days early (I cant even remember). So they are saying our notice should be 12 days less and they set a date. No complaints, we are working towards leaving.

My AIBU is: Are we within our right to call LL on this because as its never been an issue before.
LL is blaming us for property not being maintained outside… I say outside is LL’s responsibility to paint and decorate, Is this U?

LL said they will get a quote for carpet cleaning and fixing things they knew about and send us the bill? I think LL does not want to give us our deposit… AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Yesitsbess · 28/08/2021 10:07

Good stuff, it became mandatory for existing tenancies in April 2021 (I double checked) and it's a five grand fine for a first offence, there is no ignorance defence on this one same as gas safety.

I imagine 5k is probably a bit more than they were going to spend on carpets...Smile

PardonBeeOne · 28/08/2021 00:11

Thank you very much, very helpful suggestions and certainly things I was not aware of.

Yesitsbess…The electrical certificate is def added onto my list of things to raise as I was not aware of it!

MadinMarch… I will go through the DPS website properly over the weekend and get a better understanding of it and how to go about implementing the process.

OP posts:
MadinMarch · 27/08/2021 22:28

I agree the ll can't control the amount you get back.
I've used the DPS many times (although not very recently).
I think you've slightly misunderstood how it works. My understanding of how it works is that when the tenancy ends the ll contacts the DPS to inform them that the tenancy has ended and whether they want to return the whole of the deposit to the tenant, and if not what they want to claim for with an estimate of costs. The DPS will then contact you with these details, and you merely need to state you don't agree with the ll and state your reasons why, with any evidence you can provide.
The DPS may ask for further info from you and from the LL, and then they will make their decision about how much of the deposit should be returned.
I've not got much experience of the dispute side of things really, as mainly I return tenants deposits in full, but when I have used it, it seemed slightly biased in the tenant's favour imho.
I don't think you have much to worry about and should get your deposit back.
I second what another poster has said about the electrical installation condition report (eicr) which had to be obtained in rental properties by 1 April 2021. If you had gas in the property, was an annual landlords safety certifcate done anuually.
There are very serious fines if these weren't done and your landlord should be very worried that they will be reported.

longerevenings · 27/08/2021 21:37

The landlord can't control how much you get ( until recently I was a landlord).
The landlord can object to you getting your full deposit returned and then it would go to arbitration.
The arbitration team would decide how much was returned to you, not the landlord.

Yesitsbess · 27/08/2021 21:35

You should get a query list, and I repeat my earlier point, if your LL hasn't provided you with an electrical safety certificate before July of this year they are on very thin ice legally should you choose to raise that.

PardonBeeOne · 27/08/2021 21:29

MadinMarch

Its with DPS based in Bristol.
On their website, it says I have to tell them how the deposit will be split between LL and us Shock
Then says, LL or letting agent will review my request and respond, lol

LL has hinted that we are not getting any (even though its for things that are their responsibility) so how are we to know what the split is? LL actually wants more!

OP posts:
Clydesider · 27/08/2021 16:29

First thing to remember - a landlord is not entitled to have a house returned to him or her in the exact same condition it was let in. They certainly can not expect you to do exterior maintenance! That's all on the LL. It sounds as if you've really looked after the place and have actually done them a favour.

I wouldn't engage with the LL. Let the deposit scheme sort it.

MadinMarch · 27/08/2021 16:16

I don't know which deposit scheme you're in or how your one works, but are you sure you don't need to contact the scheme yourself to activate the return of your deposit, and then your landlord has 10 days to return it or make a claim against it?
From what you've told us here, you should certainly get all your deposit back.

PardonBeeOne · 27/08/2021 15:24

MadinMarch

Definitely, now that I know LL should not have pushed us out having pocketed the full month’s rent, I will mention it.
I looked at the conditions of the deposit scheme and it says it has to be paid within 10 days of moving out. If the 10th day comes and goes, I am writing to the deposit scheme.

OP posts:
MadinMarch · 27/08/2021 13:36

I'd let it be known to the deposit scheme that they told you to leave 12 days early but you paid rent for the whole month. Perhaps suggest that this more than covers the cost of cleaning the carpets?
Are you sure they paid the deposit into a deposit scheme? They should have done it within the first month of the tenancy and the scheme would have notified you that it had been lodged.
If your landlord didn't do this, they can be very heavily fined. At least it would give you a very strong bargaining chip if they refuse to give you your whole deposit back.

PardonBeeOne · 27/08/2021 09:55

KatieB55

I would have either hired the rug doctor or got it professionally cleaned but we were asked to leave before our pay day, so could not fit it in with all the costs that come with moving, all I could do was vacuum.

OP posts:
PardonBeeOne · 27/08/2021 09:50

Yesitsbess

Nope… no electrical safety check done and we have no copy either.

OP posts:
Gilmorehill · 27/08/2021 08:34

@user1477249785

Ps we are not all 'utter bastards'. I try my very best to be responsive but to leave my tenants in peace.
I agree. I’m also a LL but treat my tenants as I’d want to be treated. Ive had a couple of bastard landlords myself.
CovidDoesNotExistDuh · 27/08/2021 08:27

Your landlord has spat his dummy out. His easy money is gone and now the house needs work before it can be let out, during the work he spends more money and doesn't have the rent. It's totally normal as a landlord for this period and it can be expensive, but it's to be expected.

KihoBebiluPute · 27/08/2021 07:50

You will get your deposit back - no deposit protection scheme is going to side with a landlord over the wear and tear expected over 10 years.

You don't have to worry about the notice period either. Leave on the contractually stated date and pay rent up to that date. He can't make you leave 12 days early - the only way he could make you leave is with an eviction order and that takes months.

Just ignore his ranting abd continue to behave reasonably. You don't need him to be happy.

KatieB55 · 27/08/2021 07:43

Who puts wallpaper in a bathroom?!!
Hire a rug doctor and give the carpets a clean and take photos.
Maybe get professional clean of oven.
Leave garden tidy.
Then dispute with deposit scheme and don't discuss with landlord any further.

Beachmummy23 · 27/08/2021 07:13

We had this twice when we moved out. First time was friends deposit was unprotected. Got deposit back but sadly friendship didn't survive. We had spent a fortune on thar house.

Second time the agents produced a report saying property was fine. Then landlord complained wanted whole deposit and they changed the report. It was only luck that someone who worked for the agency felt it was so unfair that they sent a copy of the original report secretly.

We produced this to the dispute section of the Tenancy Deposit scheme. Honestly they were absolutely useless it took the best part of a year but we eventually got our deposit back. Definitely dispute it.

CleanQueen123 · 27/08/2021 07:03

Definitely go through the deposit protection scheme. I had to dispute my deposit through them for my last rental property and found them to be very helpful and fair.

It's a fair point about the carpets. They're at least 10 years old. Carpets don't last forever.

In my last place they'd put very soft and poorly fitted lino in the kitchen. When I moved the fridge out it caught on the bit that had lifted and unfortunately ripped.

The landlord wanted to charge me for a whole new floor but the deposit protection scheme agreed with me that the flooring was unsuitable for a high traffic area with heavy white goods and as it was so poorly fitted it was bound to be damaged.

They wanted my entire deposit but I got all bar about £100 back and that was only because they charged a check out fee Hmm and the protection scheme said it was in the tenancy agreement and wasn't unduly expensive so they couldn't see why I shouldn't pay it.

ItsNotMeAnymore · 27/08/2021 01:50

Good luck.

simitra · 27/08/2021 01:31

After 10 years the LL would be expected to have replaced the carpet and all the appliances as they do not have an unlimted life. As long as you have not damaged fittings beyond "normal" wear you are in the clear. He is being a CF.

Meraas · 26/08/2021 23:49

Yanbu, don’t pay a penny. LL is a CF twat.

Yesitsbess · 26/08/2021 23:12

I'm a landlord and this is not OK. Did your LL have your electrical safety certificate in place by July and do you have a copy?

Mummyoflittledragon · 26/08/2021 23:04

As the rental agreement states x to y date, he could be in for a heap of trouble for making you leave if you wanted to get nasty. I don’t understand why you were allowed to live there rent free for 12 days. The agent was very negligent. It’s so odd. The move in date is always the date the tenancy runs from, surely? Ergo the agreement should have been reissued.

PardonBeeOne · 26/08/2021 23:03

Thanks to everyone for their help and assurance! Cleaning is my fav job, so I know the place was well looked after. Only two rooms had carpets and they were vacuumed regularly.
After all our property was out, I went over every room vacuuming, took the rubbish to the recycling centre/ charity shops and felt proud but…. The response was shocking!

I will contact the deposit scheme people and start the process.

Thanks everyone, this has been extremely helpful! Smile

OP posts:
PardonBeeOne · 26/08/2021 22:56

MadinMarch

Sadly, we paid

I agree with PP, it was just sour grapes of losing the income than anything else. It was as if we had to apologise for buying our own property Smile

OP posts: