Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Afghanistan

346 replies

Refreshpage · 26/08/2021 19:45

More US troops killed today than over the last 4 years . Pulling put has cost more deaths of US troops than staying there.
Afghans now being slaughtered.
Massive fail from Biden following Trumps pull out.

Very, very 😔

OP posts:
MadameMinimes · 28/08/2021 12:31

I find it really distasteful that so meany people who are safe at home in the U.K. are happy to be so judgemental of someone who has found themselves caught up in the middle of the situation in Afghanistan. Whether you agree or disagree with the rescuing of animals, I just can’t see how those safe at home feel comfortable with the level of character assassination of Pen Farthing. The man was doing his best for those he was responsible for under threat of death or worse.

It shouldn’t really surprise me. I’m a history teacher and everyone always seems to think that they would have been a member of the resistance if they’d been in Europe in 1940. People have cognitive biases that make them think that they would make perfect, rational decisions in circumstances that they can’t even imagine finding themselves in. People also massively overestimate their own bravery. The reality is most people keep their head down and avoid conflict and prioritise their own safety and that of their immediate family. If the majority of people weren’t like that authoritarian regimes would be easily overthrown and would never last, as they are always massively outnumbered by those they terrorise.

Odisia · 28/08/2021 12:01

Stepup yes I realise that. I know it wasn't either or but it's still distressing to think about.

stepupandbecounted · 28/08/2021 12:00

The animal optics are not great, but you can't transport people in a hold.

Odisia · 28/08/2021 11:27

I just cannot get my head around desperate people and their children watching while animals are loaded onto a plane. The idea is heartbreaking.

ancientgran · 28/08/2021 11:19

@Livelovebehappy

I think it’s sad. Very sad. And very frightening for the people there. But there are so many countries world wide who breach human rights, and treat their people alien to our way of life in the west. There are children and women being exploited in other countries, other than Afghanistan. We just can’t step in and remove all these unfortunate people, because it’s just absolutely impractical to do so. We should negotiate having people in these countries who can help from within, and so keep communication open with the outside world. We can’t solve the problems of every single country, no matter how much we may want to.
That's precisely why there were priorities. As it stands the translators and guards who worked for the British haven't all got out, they and their families are in danger and they had a right to expect to be prioritised.

We could never have got millions out and millions are in danger but we failed to protect the people we owed protection to.

AlternativePerspective · 28/08/2021 11:18

If the taliban are not letting afgan nationals through the check points who is Pen supposed to rescue instead of the cats and dogs? nobody. If military time was taken up to rescue a load of animals which are being brought here to add to an already over-stretched rescue system then clearly people may have died because of that mission.

The man is loathsome, but obviously people are blinded by the sight of cats and dogs being brought out of the country so he’ll get a hero’s welcome.

Livelovebehappy · 28/08/2021 11:17

I think it’s sad. Very sad. And very frightening for the people there. But there are so many countries world wide who breach human rights, and treat their people alien to our way of life in the west. There are children and women being exploited in other countries, other than Afghanistan. We just can’t step in and remove all these unfortunate people, because it’s just absolutely impractical to do so. We should negotiate having people in these countries who can help from within, and so keep communication open with the outside world. We can’t solve the problems of every single country, no matter how much we may want to.

ancientgran · 28/08/2021 11:16

@Proudboomer

If the taliban are not letting afgan nationals though the check points then how do you expect the British army to be helping them?

If the taliban are not letting afgan nationals through the check points who is Pen supposed to rescue instead of the cats and dogs?

I couldn't care less who Pen rescues, I think he's caused a load of hassle for the military this last couple of weeks, he must have caused terrible distress to the animals who were in vans for hours in the heat and hearing gun fire and explosions, he swore he wasn't leaving without his staff and he has.

I feel for the people left behind who should have got out, I feel for families here who know their loved ones are in danger but see cats and dogs being prioritised.

It is sick.

Proudboomer · 28/08/2021 11:11

If the taliban are not letting afgan nationals though the check points then how do you expect the British army to be helping them?

If the taliban are not letting afgan nationals through the check points who is Pen supposed to rescue instead of the cats and dogs?

ancientgran · 28/08/2021 11:08

@chaosrabbitland

the uk goverment has said that the final flight is today for evacs , they could extend it a further day or so , they have admitted some will be left brhind , but have said something had prevented them coming ,rather than a failure in processing . if eligible afghans to come here were prevented from getting into the airport sadly theres not much anyone can do ,and its not the fault of pen farthing , or the cats and dogs that everybody seems to be convinced is somehow taking the place of refuges , or stopping them getting through , even pens staff were stopped and prevented from leaving the taliban have already made a statemnet a few days ago stating they did not intend to be allowing ordinary afghans to leave unless they had relevent paperwork , visas , biden has changed the rulings on visas , which affected pen when he first went to the airport . i do wish commenters on here could somehow comprehend the poor people who will die , be raped and tortured is not down to the cats and dogs who got to leave , its really not hard is it .
If military time was taken up helping get him and his cats and dogs through rather than helping get get people out then yes the cats and dogs getting to leave will have prevented some people leaving.
ancientgran · 28/08/2021 11:06

one of his vets is afghanistans first I'm not sure what that means? One of the vets working for him was the first vet in Afghanistan or one of the vets he's supposed to have trained was the first vet in Afghanistan?

chaosrabbitland · 28/08/2021 10:31

the uk goverment has said that the final flight is today for evacs , they could extend it a further day or so , they have admitted some will be left brhind , but have said something had prevented them coming ,rather than a failure in processing . if eligible afghans to come here were prevented from getting into the airport sadly theres not much anyone can do ,and its not the fault of pen farthing , or the cats and dogs that everybody seems to be convinced is somehow taking the place of refuges , or stopping them getting through , even pens staff were stopped and prevented from leaving
the taliban have already made a statemnet a few days ago stating they did not intend to be allowing ordinary afghans to leave unless they had relevent paperwork , visas , biden has changed the rulings on visas , which affected pen when he first went to the airport .
i do wish commenters on here could somehow comprehend the poor people who will die , be raped and tortured is not down to the cats and dogs who got to leave , its really not hard is it .

Proudboomer · 28/08/2021 10:27

Bland the taliban or even Biden for Pen not being able to bring the staff.
He had his whole convoy within the grounds of the airport but they were turned away as Biden had changed the rules and they were not allowed through.
Next day he tried again but the taliban wouldn’t let Afghanistan nationals though the road blocks and into the airport. His staff urged him to leave alone and with as many animals as he could take as they would be safer if he wasn’t with them.

Pen cannot be blamed for leaving as if he stayed with them he would be putting them at greater risk for having a westerner with them. He did everything possible to get them out as well but if the taliban wouldn’t allow them to the airport what was he to do?
And the first attempt were he got them to the airport as was turned away due to Bidens rule changes how is that his fault?

Ijustknowitstimetogo · 28/08/2021 10:24

He’s got the animals out. He tried to get his people out but they were not permitted through the airport. They were stopped the first time and this time. Which is tragic. He’s running an animal shelter not the airport or the country.

ancientgran · 28/08/2021 10:16

@GladAllOver

Animals are important, but people come first. Every time .
I read he had military assistance to get the animals through. The poor people who will die, be tortured, raped because no one could go and help them.
chaosrabbitland · 28/08/2021 10:12

@Guavaf1sh

If that’s true and he actually has brought the animals and left his staff then he’s the lowest of the low. Going by some of these comments though he’s as cruel and callous as half of mumsnet
if you read the news , he wasnt able to bring his staff , the taliban stopped them and would not allow his staff through , he had no choice to leave them and he was in tears about it , he wanted to bring them ALL. that was the point . the taliban are preventing people leaving , they dont want afghans leaving . insead of posting stupid comments like this maybe read the news first . and yes he is regarded as something of a hero , hes dedicated the last few years of his life to living in that country , helping stray animals and also helping afghans , one of his vets is afghanistans first , why dont you get off your butt and go live in india or pakistan , working with the poor and helping them , before you shoot your mouth of on here slating a man you have never even met , just following on the trite rubbish about oh he only cares about animals .
GladAllOver · 28/08/2021 10:10

Animals are important, but people come first. Every time
.

Guavaf1sh · 28/08/2021 09:57

If that’s true and he actually has brought the animals and left his staff then he’s the lowest of the low. Going by some of these comments though he’s as cruel and callous as half of mumsnet

Mookie81 · 28/08/2021 09:45

I have great respect for the military by the way and this is not a reflection on the institution.

Mookie81 · 28/08/2021 09:26

@AlternativePerspective

I was in Afghanistan in the 1970s so I do have an interest in that part of the world. My feeling is that the west should never have got involved in a country which is deeply traditional and tribal attempting to impose our forms of government. We are wise to get our people out asap. this. We should never have gone in there, or Iraq. The West is far too obsessed with deciding how other countries should be, just like us, and invariably when we go in it fails.

Iraq has never been as unstable than when we went in there. Whatever we thought of Saddam Hussein, the country was far more stable under him than the west.

The Afghans want the Taliban in force. Of course there are going to be those who want to get out, but the media will show us what they want us to see, the fact the Taliban moved back into power within days is very clear proof that they were never really out of power in the first place. We should never have gone in there.

As for Pen Farthing, he had clearance for him and his staff to leave the country on Friday, but they held off because of the animals. If any of those people are killed he is personally responsible, because they all stayed because of a load of bloody dogs and cats. He’s a disgrace, but he makes a nice media presence because he talks about cute animals, and everyone loves a cute animal. And now people are going to die because of him.

He has brought 200 cats and dogs back and left his staff. He's an absolute arsehole and I don't know why MN seem to love him so much; oh yes I do, he's a handsome ex-military white man.
Zotter · 27/08/2021 23:14

@Brighterblighter

Plan your comments don't make sense in the frame of Bidens own comments.

There will be more saigon, taliban won't be running wild everywhere..

In July, Biden presented a false impression of what to expect with the troop pullout Trump had negotiated. All the US Presidents and allies since 2001 weren’t truthful to the public that they were losing.
Zotter · 27/08/2021 23:03

@Brighterblighter

Under the circumstances all trroop have done incredible job. Some did no shifts working two days and nights straight in searing heat, human crisis..
Agree
Zotter · 27/08/2021 23:02

We had and could have have continued with a NATO force with a small complement of peacekeepers and forces to ensure a much smoother exit than the one we are currently witnessing now!

Not so sure about that. In July, Biden, had the choice of abiding by the deal first made by Trump for US and NATO allies to withdraw this summer - Biden extended US withdrawal by 4 months to Aug 31 -or confronting an anticipated expansion in Taliban attacks once Aug 31 passed if US went back on this. The Taliban had been growing in strength since the Trump Administration’s deal with Taliban in Doha in Feb 20.

This article says:

“According to the Washington Post, a series of negotiated surrenders began across Afghanistan in early 2020, shortly after Trump announced the US would be leaving: “The deals…were often described by Afghan officials as cease-fires, but Taliban leaders were in fact offering money in exchange for government forces to hand over their weapons, according to an Afghan officer and a U.S. official. Over the next year and a half, the meetings advanced to the district level and then rapidly on to provincial capitals, culminating in a breathtaking series of negotiated surrenders by government forces, according to interviews with more than a dozen Afghan officers, police, special operations troops and other soldiers.”

However, a better withdrawal at the end may have been possible especially US and U.K. expediting visa’s quicker for Afghans that had worked with them, France began theirs in May.

ancientgran · 27/08/2021 22:03

@Brighterblighter

Under the circumstances all trroop have done incredible job. Some did no shifts working two days and nights straight in searing heat, human crisis..
Yes and the border force staff who volunteered to go out there to get people processed. I fear alot will suffer with what they have seen. It is bad enough seeing it on TV, being face to face with desperate people must live with you.

I hope there will be help for them all going forward.

Brighterblighter · 27/08/2021 20:59

Under the circumstances all trroop have done incredible job. Some did no shifts working two days and nights straight in searing heat, human crisis..