Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Afghanistan

346 replies

Refreshpage · 26/08/2021 19:45

More US troops killed today than over the last 4 years . Pulling put has cost more deaths of US troops than staying there.
Afghans now being slaughtered.
Massive fail from Biden following Trumps pull out.

Very, very 😔

OP posts:
TeloMere · 29/08/2021 10:57

...posters whinging on here about the cats and dogs leaving , but not railing about the fact our goverment had a deadline of 31st and just decided to finish early whilst admitting they know more people eligiable to come here are now stranded...

If you'd been following the news you'd have heard why the brits have to leave earlier than the Americans.

chaosrabbitland · 29/08/2021 10:42

@anonymousobserver

I thought the deadline for getting out was August 31st?

Why don’t they carry on evacuating up to the deadline if there are so many more people to save?

I don’t understand what the problem is with this guy saving a few innocent animals actually. It wasn’t up to him to decide who was allowed to get on a flight and nor did he stop anyone more worthy from being saved. There was time to save more - still is.

this , posters whinging on here about the cats and dogs leaving , but not railing about the fact our goverment had a deadline of 31st and just decided to finish early whilst admitting they know more people eligiable to come here are now stranded
ancientgran · 29/08/2021 10:41

@Ijustknowitstimetogo

He might think whatever damage has been done to other people is worth it because he got the animals out, others disagree.

What damage has he done to other people? The Americans control the airport and they decide who is allowed on to the planes. He took the people there and they were refused.

Well the people in charge, military and govt, are saying the military having to deal with him has diverted them from helping others.
ancientgran · 29/08/2021 10:40

@anonymousobserver

I thought the deadline for getting out was August 31st?

Why don’t they carry on evacuating up to the deadline if there are so many more people to save?

I don’t understand what the problem is with this guy saving a few innocent animals actually. It wasn’t up to him to decide who was allowed to get on a flight and nor did he stop anyone more worthy from being saved. There was time to save more - still is.

The threat of terrorists attacks is growing so the safety of the officials and military has to be considered. It also takes time to get all those people out so the refugee rescues have to stop once they have to start prioritising getting the military/officials out.

I think the British had to get out before the Americans as they have the bigger force so if they left the British would be very exposed. Not 100% sure but I think that is what was being explained.

TeloMere · 29/08/2021 10:40

Why don’t they carry on evacuating up to the deadline if there are so many more people to save?

I'm sure they would if they could but the US and UK can't just keep evacuating and then drop everything and leave on 31Aug, it has to be done in stages especially as the terrorist threat increases as departure time gets closer.
The Taliban will be in there rifling through everything once the deadline's reached so there's a lot to be sorted. And presumably there's equipment that has to be either loaded or destroyed to prevent the Taliban getting their hands on it

Ijustknowitstimetogo · 29/08/2021 10:37

He might think whatever damage has been done to other people is worth it because he got the animals out, others disagree.

What damage has he done to other people? The Americans control the airport and they decide who is allowed on to the planes. He took the people there and they were refused.

ancientgran · 29/08/2021 10:36

I know someone who is willing to take one of his dogs. She has several rescues and expensive pedigrees. All are interesting stories, she wouldn't dream of just going to the local sanctuary and choosing a dog. I can't quite figure it out.

knittingaddict · 29/08/2021 10:36

@GladAllOver

Where are his dogs and cats going to go? We have enough homeless animals in rescues in the UK as it is.

With the WHO warning of food running out in Afghanistan and an imminent humanitarian disaster, we should not be removing cats and dogs. They are always needed for food when people are starving.

Sorry if this offends pet lovers, but that is the situation in this cruel world.

I'm pretty sure that Pen Farthing hasn't rounded up every available stray cat and dog in Afghanistan. There should be plenty left for them to eat if they so wish.
sadperson16 · 29/08/2021 10:34

I hope the world unites over this, before then

If it was Sweden, the world would be a whole lot more interested.

knittingaddict · 29/08/2021 10:33

@TroysMammy

Where are his dogs and cats going to go? We have enough homeless animals in rescues in the UK as it is.
I'm willing to bet that they get snapped up by people who have followed this story on the news. Whether that's at the expense of other home grown animals, I have no idea.
HarrietPierce · 29/08/2021 10:30

"Where are his dogs and cats going to go? "

Many of the dogs will be reunited with ex servicemen, which was part of the charity's purpose.

chaosrabbitland · 29/08/2021 10:28

[quote Mookie81]@chaosrabbitland not interested in the opinion on 'normal comprehension' from someone who would push a human under a bus to save a bunny.[/quote]
thats fine , but maybe try to have a bit of normal common sense about why he wasnt going to be able to offer his private plane to the goverment to use . but i expect you wont , still too pissy about the fact he got his animals out .

anonymousobserver · 29/08/2021 10:28

I thought the deadline for getting out was August 31st?

Why don’t they carry on evacuating up to the deadline if there are so many more people to save?

I don’t understand what the problem is with this guy saving a few innocent animals actually. It wasn’t up to him to decide who was allowed to get on a flight and nor did he stop anyone more worthy from being saved. There was time to save more - still is.

GladAllOver · 29/08/2021 10:27

Where are his dogs and cats going to go? We have enough homeless animals in rescues in the UK as it is.

With the WHO warning of food running out in Afghanistan and an imminent humanitarian disaster, we should not be removing cats and dogs. They are always needed for food when people are starving.

Sorry if this offends pet lovers, but that is the situation in this cruel world.

Mookie81 · 29/08/2021 10:18

@chaosrabbitland not interested in the opinion on 'normal comprehension' from someone who would push a human under a bus to save a bunny.

DGRossetti · 29/08/2021 10:15

Yes, and the IMF have flagged that the country will run out of cash in September also.

I dunno, they could always put a couple of Black Hawks or a fleet of HumVees on eBay. I've always fancied a rocket launcher myself.

TroysMammy · 29/08/2021 09:45

Where are his dogs and cats going to go? We have enough homeless animals in rescues in the UK as it is.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 29/08/2021 09:23

Yes, of course the real tragedy is the people who have been left behind. I don't think anyone would disagree with that. Not many anyway. It's heartbreakingly awful Sad

WanderingFruitWonderer · 29/08/2021 09:14

@chaosrabbitland and @HarrietPierce I agree totally with you both 👏👏

WanderingFruitWonderer · 29/08/2021 09:11

@heldinadream

I just heard on the BBC World Service that according to the UN World Food Programme Afghanistan is in all likelihood going to run out of food by September.

I'm so shocked that there is this on top of everything else so I wanted to post informing people.
Not expecting anyone to have any solutions to anything; just thought the more people know about this aspect too the more it's possible the world community might find a constructive way forward.

@heldinadream thank you. How desperately desperately sad and awful Sad I hope the world unites over this, before then. Before it's too late. In spite of all the horror we've seen. I still do believe there's more goodwill in the world for others than bad. Especially among ordinary people
chaosrabbitland · 29/08/2021 09:03

@HarrietPierce

chaosrabbitland

It doesn't matter how many times you explain Pen Farthing's good intentions, to those who believe the smears against him, they will still come out with vitriolic rubbish like " You could see from the beginning what a thrill he was getting from the attention."
The man was desperate to get his work force out. He looked completely broken in that last interview after he returned back to his base, because Biden had changed the rules on paperwork, and his Afghan workers were not allowed through.

indeed , some of the comments are just to stupid for normal comprehension , like the one about why pens staff werent going to be bumped to the top of the taliban hit list !! when many of his staff were female vets and rescuers , ,he didnt have an all male workforce , but your right im afraid ,all we are going to hear about are what a selfish prick he is and the poor women and babies that could have gone instead of the manky cats and dogs , even if they couldnt have gone instead because they werent able to get through , or travel in hold ,but that just passes them by .
ancientgran · 29/08/2021 09:00

There is an old saying, "The road to hell is paved with good intentions."

I think it is possible to accept that Farthing had good intentions but the result didn't balance out as good. He might think whatever damage has been done to other people is worth it because he got the animals out, others disagree.

PicsInRed · 29/08/2021 08:56

@heldinadream

I just heard on the BBC World Service that according to the UN World Food Programme Afghanistan is in all likelihood going to run out of food by September.

I'm so shocked that there is this on top of everything else so I wanted to post informing people.
Not expecting anyone to have any solutions to anything; just thought the more people know about this aspect too the more it's possible the world community might find a constructive way forward.

Yes, and the IMF have flagged that the country will run out of cash in September also.

Between that and ISIS K, we're going to see floods of refugees, plus famine, plus unrest and this will be why Russia abruptly withdrew (after intially appearing triumphant and speaking of staying).

I think one key issue is that the faster the country becomes ungovernable, the more foothold that ISIS K can gain simply by providing employment in their army to starving men - and promises of food for their families. This would explain why the west is now offering cooperation with the Taliban.

HarrietPierce · 29/08/2021 08:54

chaosrabbitland

It doesn't matter how many times you explain Pen Farthing's good intentions, to those who believe the smears against him, they will still come out with vitriolic rubbish like " You could see from the beginning what a thrill he was getting from the attention."
The man was desperate to get his work force out. He looked completely broken in that last interview after he returned back to his base, because Biden had changed the rules on paperwork, and his Afghan workers were not allowed through.

notimagain · 29/08/2021 08:48

Wake up this AM and I see yet another thread has gone off track again to facilitate grumbling about one man.

This despite the fact that 15000 ish people have been evacuated by HM Forces no no casualties to them, under the auspices of a UK government that it seems some think have no empathy….

The real tragedy here is that more of those who had legit connections with Uk Gov/UK Forces couldn’t be extracted.

Swipe left for the next trending thread