Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Afghanistan

346 replies

Refreshpage · 26/08/2021 19:45

More US troops killed today than over the last 4 years . Pulling put has cost more deaths of US troops than staying there.
Afghans now being slaughtered.
Massive fail from Biden following Trumps pull out.

Very, very 😔

OP posts:
snowballer · 29/08/2021 12:39

I was also thinking of the military people who have commented, sorry can't remember their names.

Charlie Herbert has been commenting a lot (retired Maj Gen, well respected)

He had this to say this morning, and I could not agree more. People need to get some perspective, cut through the pet noise and hold the actual people to account responsible for the overall mess, and that's not one man and his dog(s).

https://twitter.com/charlie533080/status/1431875309633253382?s=21

OrchestraOfWankery · 29/08/2021 12:38

Haven't read the whole thread but my understanding is Pen Farthing and his animals left on a private chartered plane - with the animals in the cargo hold. People cannot travel in the hold.

Guavaf1sh · 29/08/2021 12:30

Depends what constitutes British feeling. If it’s the likes of chaosrabbitland then yes I stand by what I say. Animals over people. Horrible. If it’s the more sensible posters here such as ancientgran then I am wrong.

So SOME people here are whacky and disguising

Rhannion · 29/08/2021 12:26

@WanderingFruitWonderer

Re the animals PF saved - I read somewhere (can't remember where) that they're all already spoken for.

On a separate note. I wonder how/if Joe Biden, Donald Trump, Boris Johnson et al are sleeping at night these days?
My emotions have changed. The last few days, I've felt desperate. Desperately sad. I still do. I was looking on in horror. But now Britain's role in the air evacuation is over, I obviously still feel just as sad, but that's also evolved into anger. I've just been hearing about all the unopened emails from desperate people with a legitimate right to evacuation. Totally ignored by ministers. I'm brimming over with righteous anger, on behalf of innocent Afghan people who worked with the allies, who are now in hiding, and living in terror.
Details of Afghan staff carelessly left behind to fall into the Taliban's hands etc etc. Yes, I'm overjoyed for those who got out, and think the forces personnel made an amazing humanitarian effort, and nothing but praise for them. But the number of people left behind, who are at huge risk, and who had a right to leave, is far higher I fear, than we've being led to believe. That's primarily on government ministries and politicians. Shame on them AngrySad

I hope the inadequacy of the politicians involved in this, in all the countries, is lead bare when the full version is told, however there is that saying that a lie goes around the world before the truth has go its shoes on...
Rhannion · 29/08/2021 12:22

@Guavaf1sh

That comment was related to chaosrabbitland’s stupid comment that she would throw a human under a bus to save a rabbit. Which delegitimised everything else she says as it proves her perspective is way off. Some seriously alarming whacky comments on this thread demonstrating that perhaps British priorities in general are totally off kilter with basic decency
That’s a nasty comment you’ve made , , British people generally have good sense of injustice and fairness. It’s not wacky to care
thereisonlyoneofme · 29/08/2021 12:19

Twinkie1 How right you are. Armchair pundits have no idea of the logistics of moving troops, equipment etc, safely. We had to leave first because the US were leaving and they were running the airport.

HarrietPierce · 29/08/2021 12:15

A good man, who desperately tried to get his workforce out, but was let down by Government agencies, both UK and US will have his name smeared and scapegoated as a distraction for Government failures.

ancientgran · 29/08/2021 12:07

[quote Doodlebug71]**@ancientgran* Well the people in charge, military and govt, are saying the military having to deal with him has diverted them from helping others.*

The people in charge would be Wallace. The Home Office is Priti Patel. Neither are shining examples of decency or humanity. Patel is trying to make it illegal to claim asylum in the UK, despite government rules that one has to be on British soil to claim asylum.

All their platititudes about building a system for those who need to claim asylum from Afghanistan are just that: empty platitudes. They're running a massive smear campaign against one man, because he *tried to save people.

It's stunning that so many people believe everything the UK govt says, despite their history of lying through their teeth.

I'm wondering if any of those believing all the nasty stories about Farthing have any direct experience of dealing with this UK government and their departments? Anyone who's tried to apply for PIP or any other form of welfare support will know how this govt works.[/quote]
I wasn't thinking of Patel, I try not to, but Wallace has been honest about what is going on. He said we wouldn't get everyone out way before anyone else would admit it. He said there was a priority list and Farthing was on it and would be called when it was his turn but that didn't seem good enough for him or his supporters.

I was also thinking of the military people who have commented, sorry can't remember their names.

I've had dealing with govt departments, I've been my husband's carer for 30 years.

Apart from anything else it is surely commonsense that if soldiers are supporting him with his animals and then loading them onto planes they can't be doing other things. I can't see how there can be any argument about that.

I will be interested to find out the truth about him and his staff having clearance to leave and him refusing to go without the animals, then he left his staff behind and left with the animals. That isn't a good look if it's true but I will wait for the full story, I don't jump to conclusions.

I'd also like to hear how much support he needed, how many soldiers were involved and for how long.

Guavaf1sh · 29/08/2021 12:04

That comment was related to chaosrabbitland’s stupid comment that she would throw a human under a bus to save a rabbit. Which delegitimised everything else she says as it proves her perspective is way off. Some seriously alarming whacky comments on this thread demonstrating that perhaps British priorities in general are totally off kilter with basic decency

WanderingFruitWonderer · 29/08/2021 12:03

Re the animals PF saved - I read somewhere (can't remember where) that they're all already spoken for.

On a separate note. I wonder how/if Joe Biden, Donald Trump, Boris Johnson et al are sleeping at night these days?
My emotions have changed. The last few days, I've felt desperate. Desperately sad. I still do. I was looking on in horror. But now Britain's role in the air evacuation is over, I obviously still feel just as sad, but that's also evolved into anger. I've just been hearing about all the unopened emails from desperate people with a legitimate right to evacuation. Totally ignored by ministers. I'm brimming over with righteous anger, on behalf of innocent Afghan people who worked with the allies, who are now in hiding, and living in terror.
Details of Afghan staff carelessly left behind to fall into the Taliban's hands etc etc. Yes, I'm overjoyed for those who got out, and think the forces personnel made an amazing humanitarian effort, and nothing but praise for them. But the number of people left behind, who are at huge risk, and who had a right to leave, is far higher I fear, than we've being led to believe. That's primarily on government ministries and politicians. Shame on them AngrySad

DGRossetti · 29/08/2021 12:03

@HarrietPierce

"And presumably there's equipment that has to be either loaded or destroyed to prevent the Taliban getting their hands on it"

The Taliban have got their hands on it.

The US has admitted they are leaving $85 billion of equipment behind (and the UK is leaving a lot of could-have-been-spent-on-hospitals kit behind too). Mainly Black Hawks, Humvees and 625,000 assault rifles and the like.

Presumably time to buy shares in Northrop etc ?

Twinkie01 · 29/08/2021 12:00

I'd imagine the last few days were a bloody logistical nightmare. Those poor soldiers being tasked with getting civilians out whilst worrying if they were going to be blown up by a suicide bomber. Imagine if your child were serving over there you'd just be happy that they got out safely.

I think it's all well and good giving your two penny's worth about what should be done and when whilst knowing nothing about the complications of the situation and international law but it's very much like all of those who were bleating on about how the scientists were wrong at the start of Covid and what they would do whilst knowing nothing about the legalities and scientific basis for decisions that were made.

We're all sitting safe and sound without the huge burden of people's lives being on our shoulders and it's crazy and naive to suggest we'd do better in that situation.

ancientgran · 29/08/2021 11:59

Someone did say they'd throw someone under a bus to save their rabbit, or was that on a thread that was deleted. I saw the post and the poster confirming they would.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 29/08/2021 11:42

@HarrietPierce

"Oh, btw, I missed the bit about people being thrown under a bus to save a rabbit."

Yes because it's nonsense.

Indeed
Doodlebug71 · 29/08/2021 11:36

@Rhannion

Read Pen’s book One Dog at a Time about the animal rescue he started, it might just help people see exactly what he and the workers are doing and why .
I did, some time ago. All sold out everywhere, and sellers charging very high prices now.
notimagain · 29/08/2021 11:33

I'm wondering if any of those believing all the nasty stories about Farthing have any direct experience of dealing with this UK government and their departments?

Personally almost as much direct experience as PF of “dealing” with MOD and despite that I have severe doubts about many aspects of his story.

HarrietPierce · 29/08/2021 11:32

"And presumably there's equipment that has to be either loaded or destroyed to prevent the Taliban getting their hands on it"

The Taliban have got their hands on it.

Doodlebug71 · 29/08/2021 11:30

@TeloMere

Why don’t they carry on evacuating up to the deadline if there are so many more people to save?

I'm sure they would if they could but the US and UK can't just keep evacuating and then drop everything and leave on 31Aug, it has to be done in stages especially as the terrorist threat increases as departure time gets closer.
The Taliban will be in there rifling through everything once the deadline's reached so there's a lot to be sorted. And presumably there's equipment that has to be either loaded or destroyed to prevent the Taliban getting their hands on it

The UK pulled all their troops out yesterday, didn't they? No stages. Just withdrew the lot.
Rhannion · 29/08/2021 11:21

Read Pen’s book One Dog at a Time about the animal rescue he started, it might just help people see exactly what he and the workers are doing and why .

HarrietPierce · 29/08/2021 11:18

"Oh, btw, I missed the bit about people being thrown under a bus to save a rabbit."

Yes because it's nonsense.

DGRossetti · 29/08/2021 11:18

The deadline is the 31st August. So when Johnson said they'd continue until the very last minute, that was another lie

The deadline for the US was 31st. They are running the show and that is an end to that. For people not paying attention, the UK is impotent without US backing. And for all the grumbles about Ben Wallace, he's been honest about that. And the US is now only supporting the US.

But - to coin a phrase - this is what the UK has repeatedly voted for.

If only there had been some sort of similar military crisis in the past where it was clear the UK was nothing without the US, we might have done things differently. But, of course, who learned about Suez - ever ?

Rhannion · 29/08/2021 11:17

@GladAllOver

Where are his dogs and cats going to go? We have enough homeless animals in rescues in the UK as it is.

With the WHO warning of food running out in Afghanistan and an imminent humanitarian disaster, we should not be removing cats and dogs. They are always needed for food when people are starving.

Sorry if this offends pet lovers, but that is the situation in this cruel world.

You must be a troll, that’s a vile comment, you are disgusting.
Doodlebug71 · 29/08/2021 11:16

@ancientgran Well the people in charge, military and govt, are saying the military having to deal with him has diverted them from helping others.

The people in charge would be Wallace. The Home Office is Priti Patel. Neither are shining examples of decency or humanity. Patel is trying to make it illegal to claim asylum in the UK, despite government rules that one has to be on British soil to claim asylum.

All their platititudes about building a system for those who need to claim asylum from Afghanistan are just that: empty platitudes. They're running a massive smear campaign against one man, because he *tried to save people.

It's stunning that so many people believe everything the UK govt says, despite their history of lying through their teeth.

I'm wondering if any of those believing all the nasty stories about Farthing have any direct experience of dealing with this UK government and their departments? Anyone who's tried to apply for PIP or any other form of welfare support will know how this govt works.

WanderingFruitWonderer · 29/08/2021 11:13

Yes, I was confused about why they left early. I wasn't sure if it was due to logistics, or due to the terror threat or something else? Or maybe they knew nobody else with right to travel could get to the airport? I don't know. It must have been so horrendous for the armed forces personnel there to see those faces, and have to tell them that was that. No more hope of getting on a flight. Awful for them, and even more awful for the Afghan people there.

Oh, btw, I missed the bit about people being thrown under a bus to save a rabbit. Obviously, for the record, I disagree with that! The throwing someone under a bus part (I'm all for saving rabbits) I'm not sure anyone would really think that. Even if they say it.

It's perfectly possible to be passionate about both human and animal rights. I am. I'm a vegan, and can't bear for animals to suffer. But, I'm also an Amnesty International supporter, and care about people too. It's never either/or for me. It's all part of the same thing of caring for the world generally.
I do know some vegans who are misanthropes and don't care about people. But, to be honest, not many. I find generally that people who are kind to animals are nice kind people overall. That's my experience. I find it hard to trust people who don't like animals. It's so alien to me.

But, of course people can think whatever they want, no matter how terrible.As long as it doesn't turn into equally terrible action!

Doodlebug71 · 29/08/2021 11:02

@anonymousobserver

I thought the deadline for getting out was August 31st?

Why don’t they carry on evacuating up to the deadline if there are so many more people to save?

I don’t understand what the problem is with this guy saving a few innocent animals actually. It wasn’t up to him to decide who was allowed to get on a flight and nor did he stop anyone more worthy from being saved. There was time to save more - still is.

The deadline is the 31st August. So when Johnson said they'd continue until the very last minute, that was another lie.

The UK govt has found a scapegoat in Farthing. He runs a humanitarian service animal rescue, and knew he couldn't rescue every person he knew. So tried to get his staff and their families out.

He knew the Taleban wouldn't accept "Johnson says my staff can come", so waited until he had documentary evidence of that. Directly Farthing had those documents (which he had to beg for, earlier this week), Wallace invited Farthing to take him self, his staff and his animals to the airport for processing.

Farthing did as requested, then was refused entry to the airport for several hours. Wallace is in charge of the MOD, and the forces at the airport. He knew Farthign was out there, with his staff and their families, and didn't allow him in until 2 hours after Biden changed the rules for Afghans, so that Farthing's staff couldn't go after all. Farthing and his team didn't knw that until after they presented their documents.

Farthing and his team were turned away, and were caught up in the violence that followed those attacks. Had an Ak47 shoved in their faces twice, so decided to get back to their compound, because that was the safest option at that point.

Within hours, Wallace was all over TV again, saying "this is the last day for civvy evacuations, and anyone not already in the airport is not going". Wallace knew exactly what he was doing.

Someone really has behaved despicably in all this, and it's not Farthing. It's the people who've left thousands of people stranded in Afghanistan, despite having months and months to sort out an evacuation. The smear campaign against Farthing is despicable, and doesn't surprise me one bit.

Patel does this to Human Rights lawyers who are doing their jobs, and she does it to EU ctizens who have been forced to apply to stay in the homes they've paid for, with families they've raised in the UK.

The Tories have spent over a decade blaming everyone else for their despicable actions, from running the NHS into the ground, to fucking over disabled and vulnerable people, and even refusing to feed hungry kids.

Now, they've decided to smear Farthing, to distract from their own failings. I'm not falling for it, because I see the UK government for the vindictive bullies they are, and I watched whilst they set Farthing up, and then started their smear campaign. I know exactly what they did, because I watched them do it.

They got him to the airport, and started tweeting that they'd decided to *not allow "pets over people". They set him up, and left him out there. Then, they started their smear campaign.

I wonder if the American rescue will receive a similar fate? As far as I can tell, they're still stuck in that airport. Charlotte is in there, and her staff were outside (not allowed in).

Swipe left for the next trending thread