Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Split costs on different incomes

133 replies

Depolo · 26/08/2021 16:10

Household A: Income of £30000 per annum

Household B: Income of £128000 per annum (before tax/NI)

3 x children. 50/50 joint care between homes. No maintenance paid, but all joint costs split 50/50 ie uniform, school trips, dinner money. Children have two wardrobes provided at each household, costs are not shared for activities booked and organised at individual homes.

My question. Should joint costs be split 50/50 as per shared care agreement OR should costs be split on an income ratio.

OP posts:
Youseethethingis · 26/08/2021 18:36

Say I earn roughy 1 quarter of my husband's wage. We pay the bills 50/50. This means either I struggle to keep up and end up in debt or we have a lifestyle that I can afford on my wage, rather than what we as a couple can afford.
Now transfer the same scenario to your kids. Should they lead a lesser lifestyle half their life based on your principles or their lower earning parent go into debt to keep up the lifestyle you want them to enjoy because you are a higher earner? Or should you pay for more?
Those are the options.

Bluntness100 · 26/08/2021 18:35

Curious to know the genders of each income family here and who the op is,

However It’s nice to see for once no gender bias and a fairly unanimous response.

Once upon a time if a woman said we are split should he pay more for the kids than me, the answer would be yes, but if a man said should the mother pay more than me he’d be told to fuck off and step up, he had rhem so he should pay.

It’s nice to see no bias on this one. That people strongly expect both parents to step up equally for their own kids now.

Merryoldgoat · 26/08/2021 18:23

When the relationship is over I’d say 50/50 would be the norm.

FortniteBoysMum · 26/08/2021 18:16

Personally 50/50 the kids belong equally to each parent. Why should household a benefit from house hold bs work. That would discourage house a bettering their careers as house hold b is allowing them extra spare cash.

DuckDuckGooses · 26/08/2021 18:08

50/50

It's a shared child so surely shared costs at 50/50 makes sense? Then the individual activities with each family can be paid for by that family? That's what happened when I was a child between my parents anyway!

Youseethethingis · 26/08/2021 18:06

@OhSmellyCatSmellyCat
Bias makes the difference.

lanbro · 26/08/2021 18:05

If I was the higher earner I would pay more, because I want the best for my kids and I don't seethe as a financial transaction. In fact, I do have a higher disposable income than xh due to the fact I claim all the child benefits but we have them 50/50, so I'm happy to spend more. Generally though, whoever has them when they need something buys it

OhSmellyCatSmellyCat · 26/08/2021 18:01

@NannyAndJohn

Can't say until we know who is A and who is B.
Why not? What difference does it make?
SevenOldLadies · 26/08/2021 17:58

@NannyAndJohn

Can't say until we know who is A and who is B.
Why does that make a difference Confused
NannyAndJohn · 26/08/2021 17:45

Can't say until we know who is A and who is B.

FrownedUpon · 26/08/2021 17:40

50/50

LuaDipa · 26/08/2021 17:38

50/50 is fair, but if I was the higher earning parent in this situation I certainly wouldn’t see dc going without.

Youseethethingis · 26/08/2021 17:26

should costs be split on an income ratio?
That's the question, straight from OP.
Not "whether the lower earning family have to lay for their own kids" Hmm

Bluntness100 · 26/08/2021 17:13

@minipie

50/50

But if there’s a relevant reason why household A has a much lower income - eg if A gave up their career to look after the dc when small, and this enabled B to reach their current much higher income - then I would be making an argument for spousal maintenance in addition to the child cost arrangements. No idea how likely this would be to succeed these days though

That’s done at the time of a divorce ans spousal maintenance is very rare these days, the op isn’t asking about spousal maintenance she’s (of he) is asking if the lower earning family have to pay for their own kids.
mstroutpout · 26/08/2021 16:44

You need to look at each parent's income not household as what partners earn is irrelevant.

After that I'd say 50/50 unless the wealthier parent wants the child to join clubs/activities that the less wealthy parent couldn't afford. And I'd hope they would want to.

pinganail · 26/08/2021 16:42

Answers to this question usually depend on which one the OP is. If she's the higher earner then the answer is usually that the ex needs to step up, work more hours etc. If she's the lower earner then the ex is usually expected to be more generous than 50/50.

Lindjam · 26/08/2021 16:41

50/50

Any differentials that had a bearing should have been disclosed and discussed before the Consent Order/Financial Agreement was drawn up.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 26/08/2021 16:41

50/50, they have two parents who should pay equally not based on their salary, both have a responsibility to provide.

minipie · 26/08/2021 16:38

50/50

But if there’s a relevant reason why household A has a much lower income - eg if A gave up their career to look after the dc when small, and this enabled B to reach their current much higher income - then I would be making an argument for spousal maintenance in addition to the child cost arrangements. No idea how likely this would be to succeed these days though

Shamoo · 26/08/2021 16:37

On the face of it 50/50, but that could mean that sometimes the child couldn’t do something presumably. Eg a school trip that the more wealthy family could afford but the less wealthy could not. Then I think it’s the wealthy family to decide if they are happy to pay more than 50% or all - but it’s their choice.

Bluntness100 · 26/08/2021 16:30

Who are you in this op?

I’d worry the lowe earning family was thinking they shouldn’t have to pay for their own kids and that the other parent should do it as they habe more money. That’s quite unpleasant. When couples are no longer together and split is fifty fifty they both have an equal responsibility, financially, emotionally the lot snd can’t just duck their responsibilities.

Youseethethingis · 26/08/2021 16:27

Personally, with such a huge disparity, if I was the higher earner id probably be paying a higher proportion of the costs.
Said it before and I'll say it again - children get one life, not bits of lives that can be allocated as suits their parents.
Really depends on loads of factors though so j cannot argue with the official legal position on it. Too messy to legislate for everything.

SevenOldLadies · 26/08/2021 16:27

50/50, although if there was something essential needed that the lower income parent wasn’t able to pay for I’d expect the other parent to pay rather than see the children go without.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 26/08/2021 16:26

50/50 for standard things. If the higher income household wants them to go on the £2k ski trip to USA or something like that though, they have to be sensitive that the lower income household might not have half. Or if they want Private School as another example

Bluntness100 · 26/08/2021 16:26

It’s fifty fifty, of course once a couple have split one can’t continue to want the other to support based on how much they earn in comparison. They are equal parents and should pay for their children equally.