Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Split costs on different incomes

133 replies

Depolo · 26/08/2021 16:10

Household A: Income of £30000 per annum

Household B: Income of £128000 per annum (before tax/NI)

3 x children. 50/50 joint care between homes. No maintenance paid, but all joint costs split 50/50 ie uniform, school trips, dinner money. Children have two wardrobes provided at each household, costs are not shared for activities booked and organised at individual homes.

My question. Should joint costs be split 50/50 as per shared care agreement OR should costs be split on an income ratio.

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 26/08/2021 21:09

So why didn’t you text him and say right shopping is to be done, I can do it or you, budget is x? You are not a passenger.

Depolo · 26/08/2021 21:08

“Left him to it” - he’s their father...with 50/50 care. That’s a weird choice of words.

It’s his week with them. The same week the school shop is always done. It fell on his week so he took responsibility, he wasn’t doing me a favour!

Yes I’ve been at work this week - so didn’t have time to “nip to ASDA”

OP posts:
HeckyPeck · 26/08/2021 21:07

@sweeneytoddsrazor

It'll be his own fault for not agreeing a budget.

But not hers for not agreeing a budget?

We don't even know that he had told OP he was taking them uniform shopping. Maybe OP was planning it for next week.

Even if he did, he's the one who'll be out of pocket so his responsibility to prevent that.

womaninatightspot · 26/08/2021 21:05

Say you can't afford; ask him to return and buy somewhere else or you can pay for the next lot instead.

Depolo · 26/08/2021 21:04

@PollyPepper

I hope you're not including your exes wifes income in this.
His wife doesn’t work. They have a joint company, wages and dividends paid to each of them.
OP posts:
Youseethethingis · 26/08/2021 21:03

So as I said. Budget has to fit the lower earning household if the wealthiest household wants to stick rigidly to 50/50.

Bluntness100 · 26/08/2021 21:02

@sweeneytoddsrazor

It'll be his own fault for not agreeing a budget.

But not hers for not agreeing a budget?

Exactly.
Bluntness100 · 26/08/2021 21:01

I definitely wouldn't do this OP.He should have asked you before spending so much. His own fault if he doesn't get half back.

Sure, but doesn’t she have any responsibility? She knew they needed uniform. She could have popped down Asda or where ever, got it, and then billed him half, she didn’t, she let him deal with it.

Neither have managed this well but it’s not all on him to not just ask her how much but do the shopping too. She has equal responsibility.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 26/08/2021 21:01

It'll be his own fault for not agreeing a budget.

But not hers for not agreeing a budget?

G5000 · 26/08/2021 21:01

I see how the ex is thinking, I would not want my children to wear cheap stuff if I can afford nicer things, just because their dad doesn't earn as much. You need to have a discussion that your budget only stretches so far; it's of course very nice if he wants to buy them fancier things, but then you can't pau 50-50.

BananaMilkshakeWithCream · 26/08/2021 20:59

Communication is what is needed here. We have a rule with DH’s ex regarding things like this which are over and above maintenance. If she discusses things with us beforehand then we’ll make a contribution because sometimes we need time to save. If she just buys something/books something and expects us to contribute then it’s a hard no. This was after she paid the deposit on a £1500 school trip, just assuming that we’d pay half. She then left it until about a month before the balance was due to inform us that £750 was due! In the end it was a moot point as it was cancelled due to
Covid but we’ve said she can’t do it again as we can’t guarantee to be able to come up with the cash. Maybe you should do something like that?

HeckyPeck · 26/08/2021 20:59

@Wilmaa

Is 128000 not including his partners wage?

I would have said before hand can you get trousers from x or x and so on tbh.
You left him free rain to shop wherever

I don't think OP has mentioned there being a court order for 50:50 costs in which case he will have to accept whatever OP offers towards it.

It'll be his own fault for not agreeing a budget.

Wilmaa · 26/08/2021 20:56

Is 128000 not including his partners wage?

I would have said before hand can you get trousers from x or x and so on tbh.
You left him free rain to shop wherever

HeckyPeck · 26/08/2021 20:55

@MissM2912

I would just tell him you can’t afford that and ask to pay over three months.
I definitely wouldn't do this OP.

He should have asked you before spending so much.

His own fault if he doesn't get half back.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 26/08/2021 20:55

Even knowing which household you are its not possible to say. Your ex could be earning 30k and his wife the rest, you could be a sahm and your household income come entirely from your partner.

MissM2912 · 26/08/2021 20:53

I would just tell him you can’t afford that and ask to pay over three months.

Bluntness100 · 26/08/2021 20:52

i would work out what I would have spent without the brands etc and send that over

Nah, she could have said they need uniform I’ll deal with it and let you know your half. Leaving them to deal with it, setting no boundaries then complaining after? No not so much.

Bluntness100 · 26/08/2021 20:50

But that’s different op. You should agree parameters in advance. Set a budget. The fact you’ve not is your issue. You knew they needed uniform. You could have taken them shopping and presented him with half, you didn’t you left it to them.

HeckyPeck · 26/08/2021 20:48

@Depolo

So I am household A. Household B is ex and partner.

Ex and wife took the D.C to buy school uniform today. I was presented with half the costs afterwards. But (and this is the bit I think is unfair), if I had taken them shopping I wouldn’t have shopped as up market as they did. Bill for my half is over £320. It wasn’t discussed with me that the youngest would have a very expensive rucksack (£85), branded trainers for all 3 for PE and uniform from John Lewis. The bill was just text to me as “your half”. There is no way I can afford that and if I’d taken them shopping I’d have shopped cheaper. He’s chosen to shop where he has without considering if I could afford my half.

I would work out what I would have spent without the brands etc and send that over.

Or if I was feeling petty I wouldn't send anything at all. Unless I had to because of a court order.

PollyPepper · 26/08/2021 20:46

I hope you're not including your exes wifes income in this.

Depolo · 26/08/2021 20:43

So I am household A. Household B is ex and partner.

Ex and wife took the D.C to buy school uniform today. I was presented with half the costs afterwards. But (and this is the bit I think is unfair), if I had taken them shopping I wouldn’t have shopped as up market as they did. Bill for my half is over £320. It wasn’t discussed with me that the youngest would have a very expensive rucksack (£85), branded trainers for all 3 for PE and uniform from John Lewis. The bill was just text to me as “your half”. There is no way I can afford that and if I’d taken them shopping I’d have shopped cheaper. He’s chosen to shop where he has without considering if I could afford my half.

OP posts:
PegasusReturns · 26/08/2021 20:40

The higher earning parent shouldn’t allow their DC to go without.

If that means person B has to pay more, because person A cant or won’t pay then they should.

autummvibes · 26/08/2021 20:29

As it's also 50/50 care then 50/50 cost is fair. No maintenance is expected when sharing care as you're both paying your bit the time you have them. And I think it's fair with costs overall.

OhSmellyCatSmellyCat · 26/08/2021 18:45

[quote Youseethethingis]@OhSmellyCatSmellyCat
Bias makes the difference.[/quote]
Indeed , it does

NailsNeedDoing · 26/08/2021 18:39

It’s fair for joint costs to be 50/50.

The parent whose income is less still has the same obligation to pay for half of their children’s costs regardless of what the other parent earns.