Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Split costs on different incomes

133 replies

Depolo · 26/08/2021 16:10

Household A: Income of £30000 per annum

Household B: Income of £128000 per annum (before tax/NI)

3 x children. 50/50 joint care between homes. No maintenance paid, but all joint costs split 50/50 ie uniform, school trips, dinner money. Children have two wardrobes provided at each household, costs are not shared for activities booked and organised at individual homes.

My question. Should joint costs be split 50/50 as per shared care agreement OR should costs be split on an income ratio.

OP posts:
arethereanyleftatall · 26/08/2021 22:08

Ok.
So, £45k vs possibly £30k. (Op didn't say if hers was gross or net). So, yes a disparity, but not as per the implication in the op.

Lou98 · 26/08/2021 22:08

I think that's expensive for uniform, however, you said you knew he was doing it this week. Why wouldn't you both agree on a budget before hand? I think you're both at fault to be honest.

Either way though, if you can't afford it there's not much you can do, you'll need to work out how much you can afford and speak to ex about it, if he can't accept that you'll need to return some of their stuff and get it cheaper elsewhere

Depolo · 26/08/2021 22:07

£128000 is the amount he paid himself and partner in dividends and salary last year. It isn’t after tax.

Why is having a uniform week bonkers?! It’s the last full week before they go back to school, have done all the shopping this week since eldest was in reception. Lolz at bonkers

OP posts:
CorianderBee · 26/08/2021 21:56

Just tell him you can't afford that and would never have gone to JL or spent that much on a bag. Discuss. If he demands half tell him it'll have to be returned and you'll do the shop more cheaply.

Youseethethingis · 26/08/2021 21:52

Indeed, you are correct.
90k take home in the DFs household then, £45k personally, against £24k for OPs
Of course he should be for the bloody £85 bag himself Hmm

TweedePrik · 26/08/2021 21:49

I'd message and say that surely he understands that's not in your budget, and mention the sum you can provide that you think is fair. He can return things, or suck it up.

helentomelon · 26/08/2021 21:47

@Youseethethingis

Yours and your family ex's income aren't that different. He'll have to pay nearly half of that £128 k in tax, then split between two of them 128k post tax is £78k. 30k post tax is £24k.
OP also said that his wage is split and paid half each to him and his wife (although she doesn't work) so tax will actually be less than that and the take home higher
RainbowMum11 · 26/08/2021 21:46

Having read your updates, their DF really should have more consideration for your ability to afford the 50%, rather than forcing it on you as a done deal.
He perhaps doesn't understand your situation fully though.
If you are on good terms (which I presume you are for 50/50 care) then can you have a discussion about budgets etc - if he wants to spend more then he can, but you can't.

sleepylittlebunnies · 26/08/2021 21:43

How have you divided it up in previous years? It also isn’t just about disparity of incomes but also attitudes to spending. We have a reasonable household income but there’s no way I’d spend £85 on a school bag. I’m happy to buy the £10 supermarket trainers for primary school PE trainers as PE kit is left in school and only comes home at school holidays for washing. I don’t mind spending more on secondary school PE trainers as they only go into school on PE day so can be worn at home. I also hand down whatever uniform I can and have bought done second hand items and buy things when they’re on offer eg. M&S 20% off uniform and £15 off Treads shoes, other items in sales.

It might be an idea going forward to add up all the uniform that you would buy and tell ex that you’re happy to pay half that amount towards what he’s buying if he wants the kids to have more expensive items. If he’s happy for them to be kitted out on your budget then it’s probably best that you shop for them.

Youseethethingis · 26/08/2021 21:43

Yours and your family ex's income aren't that different. He'll have to pay nearly half of that £128 k in tax, then split between two of them
128k post tax is £78k.
30k post tax is £24k.

TractorAndHeadphones · 26/08/2021 21:42

@rockaround

You should text him and say you can't afford this and he will have to return it all. Cost up the uniform at Asda or wherever you want to get it from and tell him that's what you are prepared to pay. Chances are he will just let them keep it if not do an online order.

Having a 'uniform week' is bonkers though. Just do it yourself next year.

So she has to do things because the ex doesn’t have any common sense?
TractorAndHeadphones · 26/08/2021 21:41

Why is everyone being so harsh on OP?
He’s the one who’ll be out of pocket so it’s his responsibility to agree on the budget.

Bluntness100 · 26/08/2021 21:41

@arethereanyleftatall

Yours and your family ex's income aren't that different. He'll have to pay nearly half of that £128 k in tax, then split between two of them.
I think you need to do the maths again,😃
rockaround · 26/08/2021 21:38

You should text him and say you can't afford this and he will have to return it all. Cost up the uniform at Asda or wherever you want to get it from and tell him that's what you are prepared to pay. Chances are he will just let them keep it if not do an online order.

Having a 'uniform week' is bonkers though. Just do it yourself next year.

arethereanyleftatall · 26/08/2021 21:30

Yours and your family ex's income aren't that different. He'll have to pay nearly half of that £128 k in tax, then split between two of them.

helentomelon · 26/08/2021 21:28

Nothing wrong with buying an £85 rucksack for your kid if your household income is in the six figures. But you can't make a decision like that then demand half the money for it. There should have been a budget agreed then if your ex wanted to get more extravagant things he could cover that cost himself.

I dont know what you can do about it now though if no conversation was had about a budget beforehand

SimonJT · 26/08/2021 21:23

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss

I think for three children needing uniform, bags and trainers thats not a huge amount per child. If it’s always done this week you should have offered to do it yourself if you wanted to control costs and brands. Even if worked long full days all week it could have been done online.
Its just over £200 per child, when I think how much kitting out my 6 year old costs I think £200ish each is pretty reasonable, especially if school bags were included.
Caroloke · 26/08/2021 21:21

Gosh some very odd views on this thread. I guess going forward it's worth agreeing on a rough amount for school uniform etc, and then if he chooses to go over that amount because he can afford it then fair enough- hindsight is a wonderful thing. Say you can't afford to but will pay a fair amount, surely he has some awareness that saying oh yeah that'll be nearly £400 isn't something easily absorbed, especially if he's spent that much on a backpack uneccessarily.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 26/08/2021 21:19

I think for three children needing uniform, bags and trainers thats not a huge amount per child. If it’s always done this week you should have offered to do it yourself if you wanted to control costs and brands. Even if worked long full days all week it could have been done online.

NailsNeedDoing · 26/08/2021 21:14

While you should be paying 50/50, it’s not fair if he’s going to choose to spend £85 on a bag. I wouldn’t expect him to get the cheapest of everything, but not should he be making the most expensive choices for everything either.

It’s something that you knew was coming though, so you should have spoken to each other about it before the shop happened as you have a budget. You’ll know for next year that you need to do the shop, or talk to him about it first.

SimonJT · 26/08/2021 21:14

Well it should be mum and dads incomes, not household income, you can’t be including the income of new partners.

Generally 50/50 with agreements on larger things like school trips.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 26/08/2021 21:14

It really doesn't matter who's week it was presumably you both have some idea of how much income you both have. If costs are split 50/50 then you should be able to say I can afford to pay x amount. If you spend more than that it's out of your pocket. Equally he should have said how much can you afford

Depolo · 26/08/2021 21:12

Behaved like the OP Hmm

We have a week we buy uniform. It’s this week. Kids are at his. Therefore he bought the uniform

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 26/08/2021 21:10

i think if he's the one that will be out of pocket, it is ultimately his responsibility

And if they both behaved like the op and didn’t buy the uniform who is responsible? Neither should be a passenger here.

HeckyPeck · 26/08/2021 21:09

@Bluntness100

I definitely wouldn't do this OP.He should have asked you before spending so much. His own fault if he doesn't get half back.

Sure, but doesn’t she have any responsibility? She knew they needed uniform. She could have popped down Asda or where ever, got it, and then billed him half, she didn’t, she let him deal with it.

Neither have managed this well but it’s not all on him to not just ask her how much but do the shopping too. She has equal responsibility.

I think if he's the one that will be out of pocket, it is ultimately his responsibility.