Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Split costs on different incomes

133 replies

Depolo · 26/08/2021 16:10

Household A: Income of £30000 per annum

Household B: Income of £128000 per annum (before tax/NI)

3 x children. 50/50 joint care between homes. No maintenance paid, but all joint costs split 50/50 ie uniform, school trips, dinner money. Children have two wardrobes provided at each household, costs are not shared for activities booked and organised at individual homes.

My question. Should joint costs be split 50/50 as per shared care agreement OR should costs be split on an income ratio.

OP posts:
KatharinaRosalie · 27/08/2021 09:14

I think 85 for a school bag is excessive - not if you have a 6 figure income.

I think the split like LBOCS2 suggest might make sense, so you buy x items they buy y, then each family can choose according to their budget.

LBOCS2 · 27/08/2021 09:05

We're in a similar position to OP except our side is the one with the higher income.

For uniform, we find it easiest to split what we're buying rather than the bill, so each family can pay what they can afford - means no nasty surprises like that one. In theory it's 50/50 but in practice we pick up things like trainers, coat, blazer, etc, which tend to be the most costly aspect of the shop. It doesn't help this year but might be worth suggesting it going forward?

I agree it should be 50/50 but if it means the other option is DSS going without then we're happy to contribute more.

Disneycharacter · 27/08/2021 09:02

I would send him the bill back as he has already paid for it and you not pay your 'share'. It's a piss take. I would go to local shops, supermarkets etc and cost up what you would pay for these items. List them for him and repay him half that amount with a text to say this is what a uniform costs and which you can afford. He can hardly sue you for the additional costs. I would be furious in your shoes. If you keep separate uniforms at each other's houses just keep the cheaper ones at your house, it would still be cheaper.

HarrietsChariot · 27/08/2021 08:52

You just need to be clear with them from the outset what your budget is. Agree that when they buy anything over a certain value that they expect you to pay half for, then they have to get your agreement first.

Generally 50/50 sounds fine here.

It feels like you were hoping they'd pay for the uniform in full, because it was their week when the uniform was being bought. You've been caught out and are pissed that you have to pay your share. If you'd said to them beforehand that you knew it was uniform-buying-week and you expected to pay up to X as your share, they'd have known where they stood.

Also you can't factor in dividends that are paid to your ex's wife, even if they are playing the system.

DuckDuckGooses · 27/08/2021 08:42

For three children, backpacks, full uniforms, trainers etc that sounds like a fairly normal total! Especially if the items are better quality, they will probably last longer than cheaper items and shouldn't need replacing as often, saving money in the long run.

It doesn't matter if his wife works / doesn't work for the company (I'm not sure how you can be 100% sure on this unless they run everything by you?) anything paid to her needs to be taken out of their household total earnings you're using to calculate this!

If you genuinely can't afford to pay the £300 odd, how much can you afford? Maybe offer that amount, then say you'll take care of a few more bits in the future until it's evened out? If you knew it was the school shop this week, you should have mentioned prior to the shopping your budget.

hibbledibble · 27/08/2021 07:36

It sounds like you need to have a conversation with ex about what you can afford (eg Asda uniform) and that if he wants more expensive than this, he can pay the extra cost himself.

Costs 50:50 if agreed regarding spending and custody is 50:50 is reasonable.

I assume you are claiming the child benefit, and possibly child tax credits/universal credit as well? As he wouldn't be eligible based on his income, but you are.

BarbaraofSeville · 27/08/2021 07:32

@Longestsummerever23444

Has it been an issues before OP? I think 85 for a school bag is excessive- 20/25 is fine! School uniform from John Lewis isn’t excessive though. I’d say you can do the uniform half as that’s needed but the bags are OTT and be honest that you just can’t afford it- and say it was lovely of him to treat the kids. Moving forward there needs to a budget
Of course school uniform from JL is excessive if your budget is Asda.

OP tell him that you can't pay and he should have discussed with you if he intended to buy the high end version of everything.

Tell him that you will buy the uniforms next year, and will alternate years like this from now on. Therefore you both get to control the budget as you see fit.

Longestsummerever23444 · 27/08/2021 06:49

There will be plenty of things moving forward that if the kids want to do he will need to fit the bill for, the expensive ski trips….. the New York trips in secondary etc. I think you just need to be honest about your disposal income and he must know how much you earn etc

Longestsummerever23444 · 27/08/2021 06:47

Has it been an issues before OP? I think 85 for a school bag is excessive- 20/25 is fine! School uniform from John Lewis isn’t excessive though.
I’d say you can do the uniform half as that’s needed but the bags are OTT and be honest that you just can’t afford it- and say it was lovely of him to treat the kids.
Moving forward there needs to a budget

phishy · 27/08/2021 06:40

@Depolo

So I am household A. Household B is ex and partner.

Ex and wife took the D.C to buy school uniform today. I was presented with half the costs afterwards. But (and this is the bit I think is unfair), if I had taken them shopping I wouldn’t have shopped as up market as they did. Bill for my half is over £320. It wasn’t discussed with me that the youngest would have a very expensive rucksack (£85), branded trainers for all 3 for PE and uniform from John Lewis. The bill was just text to me as “your half”. There is no way I can afford that and if I’d taken them shopping I’d have shopped cheaper. He’s chosen to shop where he has without considering if I could afford my half.

They should not have bought these things without checking with you if you’re expected to pay half.

Don’t pay half, tell them they either need to return what they bought, or you will make a contribution based on what you would have bought for DC.

timeisnotaline · 27/08/2021 06:35

@simonjt it’s not quite clear but seems probable that his partner was simply added to his business to save on tax, the op says the partner doesn’t actually work which is vastly different from someone who runs half of a paying business.

I would just say I can’t afford that so wouldn’t have bought those. Next year we will have to pre agree budget amounts, if you want to return half of it happy to buy at my budget, otherwise I will transfer £x.

SimonJT · 27/08/2021 06:30

@Youseethethingis

Yours and your family ex's income aren't that different. He'll have to pay nearly half of that £128 k in tax, then split between two of them 128k post tax is £78k. 30k post tax is £24k.
Remembet £128k includes his partners income.

If we assume they earn the same amount then OPs ex takes home £45k a year (this doesn’t include pension contributions).

SimonJT · 27/08/2021 06:27

@Depolo

£128000 is the amount he paid himself and partner in dividends and salary last year. It isn’t after tax.

Why is having a uniform week bonkers?! It’s the last full week before they go back to school, have done all the shopping this week since eldest was in reception. Lolz at bonkers

Why do you think his partners income shoulf be used to pay for the children?
messybun101 · 26/08/2021 22:50

DPs mum just demanded £95 for a school bag with pencil case for dsd6 starting school. This is after additional money was put on a gift card for half the uniform.
I think it's an absolutely ridiculous amount of money for a school bag and we had budgeted what we could for uniform already. She was told no.
however it did later transpire she only wanted cash and hadn't bought/planned to buy the bag at all

mswales · 26/08/2021 22:47

I think parents should split the cost of having a kid/s fairly but not base it on how many nights a week the kid sleeps at each place - I think the total cost for the kids existence 24/7 should be shouldered by both parents. I've never understood why childcare costs are only paid by the parent who has the child sleeping at their place during those childcare days. Both parents need the childcare in order to work, no matter where the child is sleeping.
That said, I think the split in costs should reflect different income levels. In basic human fairness, if you have an amicable relationship with your ex, why would you want their income to take a proportionally huger hit than yours for your shared child?

I say this as someone who shares custody and who is the higher earner. My ex pays for half of childcare but for all other costs I pay more because I see that as fair. We work out what a fair contribution is each month according to what my ex has earned (he's self employed).

JulesCobb · 26/08/2021 22:35

I knew it was going to be a Kanken. My dd has one for this year too.

Op, youre not wrong. He should have more sense than this.

mobear · 26/08/2021 22:25

I bought my son a Kanken backpack recently, at a discount (!), and I didn't even bother asking DP to contribute because I knew he'd object to it on principle. It was my choice so I paid for it. It's a shame your ex-DP doesn't feel the same way. It's an obvious indulgence.

mobear · 26/08/2021 22:23

I think in future you need to tell him what your budget limit is and then if he chooses to spend over it that's on him.

Excelthetube · 26/08/2021 22:21

He obviously doesn’t pay maintenance because it’s 50/50
That’s how it works.

I would just be totally honest and say you can’t afford it. You’ll get uniforms next year instead. One year on one year off.

Is he really that hard of thinking? Have you ever sat down and talked about it all.

Also how do you know what they took in dividends. I own a company. You can’t see what dividends I take

Lou98 · 26/08/2021 22:21

@Seesawmummadaw it says in the OP he has them 50/50 custody and pay all costs 50/50 - why would he pay child maintenance?

Seesawmummadaw · 26/08/2021 22:19

Why doesn’t he pay maintenance?

Youseethethingis · 26/08/2021 22:16

DSDs mum bought her that one last year as it's the brand to have just now. Lasted s few weeks as it was useless with those silly little straps.
Doubly annoying.

Planty13 · 26/08/2021 22:13

I vote 50/50. It’s by far the fairest.

helentomelon · 26/08/2021 22:11

@arethereanyleftatall

Ok. So, £45k vs possibly £30k. (Op didn't say if hers was gross or net). So, yes a disparity, but not as per the implication in the op.
It's not 45k, it's 90k. They only split it out for tax purposes.
Depolo · 26/08/2021 22:10

This is the bag. Which DD “wanted” so isn’t unreasonable apparently.

Split costs on different incomes
OP posts: