Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Split costs on different incomes

133 replies

Depolo · 26/08/2021 16:10

Household A: Income of £30000 per annum

Household B: Income of £128000 per annum (before tax/NI)

3 x children. 50/50 joint care between homes. No maintenance paid, but all joint costs split 50/50 ie uniform, school trips, dinner money. Children have two wardrobes provided at each household, costs are not shared for activities booked and organised at individual homes.

My question. Should joint costs be split 50/50 as per shared care agreement OR should costs be split on an income ratio.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ItsNotMeAnymore · 27/08/2021 18:09

50/50 but you were daft not to have anticipated that this might be a problem. I'd suggest you split what items you buy rather than splitting the entire cost.

I wouldn't worry about him
Having more disposable cash than you. Your kid will
Know he has more money. It doesn't matter unless you are completely skint.

Chasingsquirrels · 27/08/2021 17:37

Grrr, auto correct!
Half mast

Chasingsquirrels · 27/08/2021 17:37

Lol, trousers half master up their legs!

LBOCS2 · 27/08/2021 17:31

Ah, ours haven't worn uniform since the start of the pandemic, so we definitely need it!

Chasingsquirrels · 27/08/2021 17:05

@LBOCS2

I haven't bought our uniform yet and I don't have to coordinate with anyone 🤷🏼‍♀️
Same here, but then I don't get new uniform just because its the start of a new school year, I get it when needed.
LBOCS2 · 27/08/2021 17:01

I haven't bought our uniform yet and I don't have to coordinate with anyone 🤷🏼‍♀️

Caroloke · 27/08/2021 16:59

@Bluntness100

It is late to be buying uniform which does beg the question thay with three kids and knowing they needed uniform why the op didn’t buy within her budget and then ask them for have instead of not getting involved at all and leaving it all to them.
OP said they do it on this week every year, I agree that means an agreement should have been made first to avoid this situation, but why should she have done it because he didn't engage his brain?
Bluntness100 · 27/08/2021 16:48

It is late to be buying uniform which does beg the question thay with three kids and knowing they needed uniform why the op didn’t buy within her budget and then ask them for have instead of not getting involved at all and leaving it all to them.

Jangle33 · 27/08/2021 16:29

It’s very late to be buying school uniform. Given such a disparity between incomes items like this should be agreed in advance though if they’re so wealthy I don’t blame them for shopping for better quality items. Better to buy once and so items last.!

Why don’t you just buy your kids things for when you take them to school Confused

sst1234 · 27/08/2021 15:55

@NannyAndJohn

Can't say until we know who is A and who is B.
Why does that matter?
nuro · 27/08/2021 14:51

I'm going to go completely against the grain on here and say I think the higher earner should contribute more than 50/50.
If I had extra disposable income I would want my dc to benefit from that.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 27/08/2021 11:24

I think this is a good idea from a PP

Did uniform week fall on your week last year and how much was it then? Could you not message back "Last year the entire cost for all 3 kids was £250 and we paid £125 each. I can't afford to buy them branded stuff. Have you got receipts? I'm happy to take back and buy the more affordable versions" and take it from there?

Buttons294749 · 27/08/2021 11:22

I think 50/50 is fair but should be agreed in advance. So school uniform was needed, you should have both discussed how much it should cost.

How about splitting it so he gets it this time, then when your kids next need shoes/bags/whatever you get it. That probs makes the most sense

Do you have a DH or is all the wage yours? You should just be focusing on your own earnings so half of 128, 30 etc. Fwiw I think that backpack is too expensive and is more Christmas present than back to school.

Fwiw I think with things like hobbies, if it's expensive I would be happy to pay more if I was the higher earner if it was me/the DC that decided to sign then up. So if I am into horses then I sign DC up to riding lessons but absorb the cost myself, if the ex wants the lessons they pay. If the DC requests it then I consider how much I want them to do it and offer a higher contribution if I think the sport is a good idea.

helentomelon · 27/08/2021 10:48

If I was on his income (which is his income whether he diverts half to his wife for tax purposes or not) then I'd want my kid to have the fancy bag and the JL quality trousers rather than Asda. But I wouldn't expect his lower earning parent to pay for it.

timeisnotaline · 27/08/2021 10:47

[quote DuckDuckGooses]@TractorAndHeadphones but that's just what is being assumed by the OP - who I'm guessing doesn't have full financial insight into how their finances work? Doesn't matter who's company it is if the money is going half to each of them, only count one half (the exHs half)? It's just a snappier 50/50 debate if OP includes the new wife's half too, makes it look more skewed in the OPs favour![/quote]
It’s not that dissimilar to a self employed man not declaring income to lower tax (& child payments). It’s not the same as it’s legal or borderline legal depending on how it’s done, but it’s just reshuffling his income to maximise the after taxes amount. He’s still really earning it all.

DuckDuckGooses · 27/08/2021 10:41

@TractorAndHeadphones but that's just what is being assumed by the OP - who I'm guessing doesn't have full financial insight into how their finances work? Doesn't matter who's company it is if the money is going half to each of them, only count one half (the exHs half)? It's just a snappier 50/50 debate if OP includes the new wife's half too, makes it look more skewed in the OPs favour!

Carboncheque · 27/08/2021 09:59

From a quick Google, Asda’s bestselling grey school trousers for a 9 year old boy were £7 for two pairs. M&S’s most popular were £13 for two pairs. John Lewis’ bestselling grey school trousers for a 9 year old boy are £22 for two pairs. He chose the most expensive option (when you don’t have to buy from a prescribed uniform shop.)

beingsunny · 27/08/2021 09:51

Sorry I didn't read the full thread, my ex would just pay for it, let me get it next time or you could just offer what you had budgeted?

beingsunny · 27/08/2021 09:46

The usual line is 50/50 as that's the legal stand.

However up until fairly recently my exh earned more than double my salary, we have an almost 50/50 child arrangement but he paid me $250 a week support which enabled me to stay living in our very very expensive area as well as pay for after school care and swimming etc.

This arrangement suited him as he's rubbish with money and was happy to pay as long as it was a fixed weekly amount.

He viewed it as me being able to stay local (2 streets away) was of the greatest benefit to our son.

It really depends on the relationship between you, my exh and I are still close and consider one another family and I know if I were in his position I would do what I could to help him.

Carboncheque · 27/08/2021 09:42

The ‘should costs be split 50:50 if one family earns much more?’ is why 75% are saying YABU.

If it had been ‘should I have to pay half of the costs when ex has spent way over what I can afford/is necessary?’ would have a different result.

selflove · 27/08/2021 09:39

Did uniform week fall on your week last year and how much was it then? Could you not message back "Last year the entire cost for all 3 kids was £250 and we paid £125 each. I can't afford to buy them branded stuff. Have you got receipts? I'm happy to take back and buy the more affordable versions" and take it from there?

BarbaraofSeville · 27/08/2021 09:38

@Carboncheque

I think if you’d posted about your ex spending a huge amount (for your budget) on school stuff for your DCs, without any consultation, and then presenting you with a bill for half of it you’d have a different response.

Half of the cost of trainers needed for school PE - fine
Half of the cost of X branded trainers for school PE - not fine
Half the cost of a school bag - fine
Half the cost of an £85 school bag - not fine

There’s a huge difference in your budgets so it’s very unreasonable for him to splash out and then expect you to match his generosity.

That's what did happen, didn't it?
TractorAndHeadphones · 27/08/2021 09:34

@DuckDuckGooses

For three children, backpacks, full uniforms, trainers etc that sounds like a fairly normal total! Especially if the items are better quality, they will probably last longer than cheaper items and shouldn't need replacing as often, saving money in the long run.

It doesn't matter if his wife works / doesn't work for the company (I'm not sure how you can be 100% sure on this unless they run everything by you?) anything paid to her needs to be taken out of their household total earnings you're using to calculate this!

If you genuinely can't afford to pay the £300 odd, how much can you afford? Maybe offer that amount, then say you'll take care of a few more bits in the future until it's evened out? If you knew it was the school shop this week, you should have mentioned prior to the shopping your budget.

The household earnings is an interesting point. If only one person is the earner and their spouse a SAHM shouldn’t their entire salary be counted? It’s earned by one person . However much they decide to give SAHM is an expense of the main earner. Not money earned by a partner.

In the same way if one person runs the business all of the money is his. It doesn’t matter whose name is where for whatever tax dodging reason. If she doesn’t work for the business any money he choses to pay her is again his expense and not income earned by her.

Carboncheque · 27/08/2021 09:33

I think if you’d posted about your ex spending a huge amount (for your budget) on school stuff for your DCs, without any consultation, and then presenting you with a bill for half of it you’d have a different response.

Half of the cost of trainers needed for school PE - fine
Half of the cost of X branded trainers for school PE - not fine
Half the cost of a school bag - fine
Half the cost of an £85 school bag - not fine

There’s a huge difference in your budgets so it’s very unreasonable for him to splash out and then expect you to match his generosity.

HeckyPeck · 27/08/2021 09:23

Tell him that you will buy the uniforms next year, and will alternate years like this from now on. Therefore you both get to control the budget as you see fit

This seems like a fair way to do it.