Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or was the Doctor correct?

170 replies

Quantokz · 26/08/2021 14:00

I visited my GP this morning, I’m not someone who visits them regularly and I’ve been putting off this visit for a while.

He asked me what the visit was for. I started to say that I ‘thought’ I may have IBS, ‘woah’ he said, ‘that’s for me to decide, not you’.

Okay, so I started describing my symptoms. ‘You’ve been reading too much google you have’ he said ‘just use the word tummy, no need to say abdomen’ big sigh, roll eyes.

It put me on the back foot and I felt awkward to further explain my symptoms in case he pulled me up on my terminology again.

I do think I may have some issues with bile acid malabsorption but didn’t like to say in case he pulled me up on it. I just said I had yellow / orange stool. ‘POO’ he said.

I came away feeling like he thinks I’m some kind of hypochondriac who obsessively checks google for everything. Yes I have had a read to try and see what’s up with me but AIBU? Or was he rude?

Not that it’s relevant but I have a science degree and am very familiar with the right terminology for things, I could have been a nurse or doctor as far as he knew!!

I came away really annoyed. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AnneElliott · 27/08/2021 17:26

He was definitely rude! And as for all the others on here - words fail really.

I also use proper terms as I spent time working for a GP and then had a job in forensics. Why any adult would use 'tummy' is beyond me.

Complain- Drs are often arrogant and need telling off IMHO.

LimitIsUp · 27/08/2021 14:17

He was very rude

HavelockVetinari · 27/08/2021 13:58

@MissTrip82

Goodness I wouldn’t have stayed for forty minutes. Feedback to the practice and someone will speak to him. I’d request an appointment with someone else also.

You’ll now be flooded with stories about the time I told the dr what was wrong with me and I WAS RIGHT. The vastly larger number of people who were completely wrong - including those who demand a cannula in a certain spot and then confidently point to a tendon - will stay quiet.

The solicitor who finds drs attitudes change when it somehow ‘gets dropped’ into conversation that she’s a solicitor made me laugh. In my experience it’s the very first thing solicitors say…..no need for it to be dropped in. I’m never sure if they’re trying to say ‘I also have a degree’ or if it’s meant to imply they’re about to sue me. It’s certainly never once been relevant to the conversation.

I was thinking this! Grin

In my experience solicitors often get annoyed that medics/barristers get all the glory whilst they get labelled ambulance-chasers and similar. Gives some of them a chip (although I have met several who are wonderful people, NASALT!).

WanderleyWagon · 27/08/2021 10:53

What are the odds he would have talked to a man that way?

NotMyCat · 27/08/2021 09:26

@EpidermolysisBullosa he genuinely is brilliant. When I have bloods done he will throw in my thyroid ones or anything else, he couriered me antibiotics when I had a UTI and couldn't see a GP, he arranged everything when I was missed off the shielding list from food to medication deliveries

WeRTheOnesWeHaveBeenWaitingFor · 27/08/2021 09:20

I had this exact thing with one of DS’s doctors. I had to try really hard to not use the correct terms (Biology formed part of my degree).

Peace43 · 27/08/2021 09:19

I am autistic and one of the things that makes me tweak is not using the correct terminology. He'd have had to watch my head slowly revolve if he'd made me call it a tummy and poo. The pain is clearly in my abdomen and I am describing my stool.

I have refused to see one of the GPs at my local practice for similar offences. I am an intelligent woman with a STEM degree and a very senior job in medicines licensing and I don't need to be patronised.

Start off next time by telling him not to be a cunt (that is definitely the correct terminology in this instance) as you are quite capable of using words with more than 3 letters in the correct context.

This makes me rather angry on your behalf.... I'll come and tell him!

EpidermolysisBullosa · 27/08/2021 09:14

@NotMyCat - your consultant sounds fab!

I have Ehlers Danlos Syndrome, as diagnosed by Professor Grahame's team at UCLH who specialise in EDS. I was diagnosed 8 years ago.

I have had so many instances like yours where a doctor, usually an A&E doctor or a GP, occasionally a Rheumatologist, has said to me when I say I have been diagnosed with EDS 'that's very rare, you almost certainly don't have that, what made you think you did?'. Some have even said I was mistaken and definitely don't have EDS.

What made me think I did was when the EDS consultant said to me 'you have Ehlers Danlos Syndrome', followed up by a letter which read 'Diagnosis: Ehlers Danlos Syndrome'. They then ask 'and who was this "consulant" and then shut up when I say it was Professor Grahame's team.

It really annoys me! I also have EpidermolysisBullosa Simplex which is very rare but no-one queries that diagnosis as it's diagnosed with a DNA test. Although I did have a physiotherapist once who told me off for going swimming and said it wasn't fair on the other pool users to have 'someone like you' in the pool and wouldn't listen to me when I tried to explain that I don't swim with open blisters. I didn't swim for months afterwards as he knocked my confidence. Twat. The EB clinic were furious as swimming is recommended for the condition as other forms of exercise triggers blistering. I also had a job convincing my dentist that no my gums won't stop bleeding if I 'persevere' with flossing as people with my condition are advised not to floss. Also, that I can't use normal mouth wash either as I get blisters in my mouth. He did get it eventually and the hygienist is wonderful - she went away and did loads of research after we first met so she could give me better care.

I never complained about the physiotherapist as he upset me so much and made me worry for months that I had been doing something awful going swimming and I had a long wait to see the EB clinic for reassurance. I regret not complaining so I hope OP complains. No HCP should make people feel uncomfortable or criticise them for using the correct names for body parts.

MissTrip82 · 27/08/2021 03:36

Goodness I wouldn’t have stayed for forty minutes. Feedback to the practice and someone will speak to him. I’d request an appointment with someone else also.

You’ll now be flooded with stories about the time I told the dr what was wrong with me and I WAS RIGHT. The vastly larger number of people who were completely wrong - including those who demand a cannula in a certain spot and then confidently point to a tendon - will stay quiet.

The solicitor who finds drs attitudes change when it somehow ‘gets dropped’ into conversation that she’s a solicitor made me laugh. In my experience it’s the very first thing solicitors say…..no need for it to be dropped in. I’m never sure if they’re trying to say ‘I also have a degree’ or if it’s meant to imply they’re about to sue me. It’s certainly never once been relevant to the conversation.

Graphista · 27/08/2021 01:53

Patronising and condescending twat!

I'd be straight onto practice manager.

He could have assessed you whatever way you chose to communicate your concerns.

I've had similar - even worse since I got a mh diagnosis. Apparently this renders me incapable of understanding words of more than one syllable and things must be repeated to me slowly and loudly as if I'm both stupid and deaf! I am neither! I hold 2 degrees inc nursing and my mh issue is ocd not anything that affects my cognitive abilities!

he kept me there for 40 minutes

I wouldn't call that thorough I'd say he made the appointment last longer than it needed to by constantly interrupting and correcting you!

I agree a GOOD hcp knows how to work with a patient who is engaged with and knowledgeable about their body and may know what's wrong with it

I'd bet good money he wouldn't have spoken to a man like that! Sexist dick!

In your shoes I'd also be requesting a different gp for the following appointment and instructing the practice that you never want to see that one again.

New - so HE is insecure and is dealing with that by belittling patients? Fuck that! Get him told!

Yaya26 · 27/08/2021 01:38

What a prat! How dare you take an interest in to your own health. As for telling you to use infant vocabulary 😡Be ready for him next time. 🥊

RookieRoo · 27/08/2021 01:34

Definitely complain. No science or medical background but if a doctor was telling me to say "tummy" and "poo" I'd walk straight out to reception and ask for someone more professional. I would be saying stomach/abdomen (depending on issue) and stool. Just because I feel more comfortable with those words.

DinosaurDuvet · 27/08/2021 01:25

YANBU that’s horrible

I mention to go that I was tired all the time and she asked what time I went to bed at 😵‍💫 turns out I was severely aenmic

LaBellina · 27/08/2021 01:22

He sounds like a patronizing dick.
His job is to help his patients, not show off his superiority complex. This attitude might actually put off people from seeking medical help. Definitely complain, if it’s not for you then it’s for those who might start to avoid the GP because of his POO 💩 attitude.

Dixiechickonhols · 27/08/2021 01:19

I’d feedback. He sounds like a trainee who has listened to the don’t use jargon class but missed the judge your audience class. A bit of mentoring now could do him world of good.
On a positive note he did examine you/tests not fob you off.

ITakeCharge · 27/08/2021 01:14

Sorry you had a frustrating consultation. I hope your follow up appointment goes better.

I am not defending poor communication however I do work in healthcare & I do find a lot of non medical people or vaguely medical -but-not-familiar-with-my-specialty-people use medical terminology imprecisely or incorrectly especially if they have googled and already decided what is wrong. They may come out with a whole lot of medical jargon that on further exploration turns out to be frankly incorrect and could lead me down the wrong path if I accept it at face value. I often ask people to use everyday language to describe what is going on and then we can both understand what has been said - it can then be reframed in medical terminology as necessary. It is possible he was trying this approach but being a bit clumsy about it maybe. Clearly I would anticipate a health care professional is using terminology properly and wouldn't ask them to use other terms. I am embarrassed if I have used very basic oversimplified language to people who know what they are talking about whether due to being in the medical profession or having a science background, or being a patient with more years of experience and education on their condition than I have.

user1745 · 27/08/2021 00:59

@Busybee5000

Many times when I’ve been to visit the GP, in recent years, they’ve asked me what I think is wrong! I always thought it strange but this is the total opposite. I think this is absolutely awful, you should definitely bring this up with the practice.
I think often they ask that question to find out if there is something that is particularly worrying you. E.g if you go in with a lump, they ask you what you think it is, and you answer "I'm worried it might be cancer", then they know they need to particularly reassure you of why it isn't cancer. Otherwise people might be too afraid to ask so they just continue to worry.
Busybee5000 · 26/08/2021 23:58

Many times when I’ve been to visit the GP, in recent years, they’ve asked me what I think is wrong! I always thought it strange but this is the total opposite. I think this is absolutely awful, you should definitely bring this up with the practice.

nancydrewsupersleuth · 26/08/2021 23:58

Just wanted to say adults using the word tummy gives me the ick

ThinWomansBrain · 26/08/2021 23:44

he'd prefer you to use words like "poo" and "tummy" - just tell him that you're not a fucking toddler, and you'd prefer a consultation with an adult.

Saw my GP a couple of weeks ago (or stand in for my GP who is away) - she is fine, but tried to get me to make appointments with a particular nurse i'd had a few phone appointments with in lockdown.
I haven't made a formal complaint, but said that the woman was rude and patronising, and I had better things to do with my time.
I got the feeling she'd had similar replies from others.

Angrymum22 · 26/08/2021 23:41

I’m a dentist so when I picked up my DS from school and he told me that his sore foot had got worse I had a look and realised he had cellulitis. It was too late to see our own GP so I contacted out of hours and I could almost hear the triage nurse roll her eyes when I explained my 10 yr old son had cellulitis with striae extending from his toes towards his ankle.
When the lovely GP called us in he asked DS to remove his shoe and sock and while he did this started to ask me “what makes you think ……oh yes he does have cellulitis “.
He gave him flucloxacillin which is probably the most disgusting tasting medication this side of hell. After trying capsules, when Ds point blank refused to take fluid form,however we tried to make it palatable, I took him back to our own GP who suggested that I hadn’t tried hard enough and should try mixing it with Nutella. I asked him whether he had actually tried tasting it himself, I had and was not surprised DS was refusing it, I explained that although his suggestion was helpful DS didn’t like Nutella and finally my profession had fought for years to make medicines sugar free so it rather defeated the point adding it to high sugar based products. He rapidly wrote out a prescription for a topical antibiotic which did the trick.

fourandnomore · 26/08/2021 23:33

This has happened to me twice. Different doctors. Both times I have actually been honest with them after the event when I’d calmed down. The first one on the phone - she was extremely apologetic and I explained how she had made me feel and that lots of people would not have gone back after that experience so she should perhaps be more aware of how she speaks to patients. The second I think was so shocked someone called him out on his behaviour he was pretty silent but I think it did sink in. When you go back to see him let him know that after your last appointment how you felt on reflection and have an honest conversation about his bedside manner, it’s so disrespectful of him. If it doesn’t get you the outcome of understanding and an apology I would submit a written complaint but we are all human and his manner may just have been off that day so I would give it a chance first. I’m sorry about your symptoms too.

MuckyPlucky · 26/08/2021 23:26

I get this all the time. From GP, physios, osteopaths etc. I’m an HCP with particular training in functional anatomy, and yet have still been told there’d be “no point” in copying me into my MRI spine scan results because they’re “full of jargon” that I wouldn’t understand.

When I explained that I was more than capable of understanding due to my training and, you know, the fact that it was ME who had been asserting all along that I had the particular condition they found on the scan, they changed their attitude pronto.

I feel your pain OP. So, so, so bloody high-handed. I’m never like this with my patients. I assume they’re the expert on THEM, and I’m just their to help with any questions they may have and to facilitate the kind of support they feel they’d like.

EBearhug · 26/08/2021 23:20

oh i see you’re a vet…. I don’t suppose you have much to do with reproduction though do you….?

They don't know much about livestock farming, at least!

NotMyCat · 26/08/2021 23:14

@AmazinglyGraceless

Some GP's are just patronising twats with a God complex.

I once went with tonsillitis and saw a locum. I have it at least once a year and have since I was born. I'm not a hypochondriac and I've learnt to recognise when it's tipping over from viral to bacterial by the pus, my temperature and the time I've been ill. I need antibiotics roughly 1 in 4 times, when I can manage it myself I don't bother the GP.

This once I made the mistake of beginning with 'I've had tonsillitis for about ten days which I think might need antibiotics now...'

If I did. She cut me off, held up her hands and said 'RIGHT well most cases are just viral...' and then explained to me in detail the difference between viral and bacterial, including sketching a bloody diagram - and that 'although you might not know this, antibiotics don't have ANY effect on viral illnesses!' with big patronising smile.

I think it was only my dead pan face that shut her up eventually, then I then had chance to advise that I fully understood the differenced but that a virus had developed into my tonsils being covered in white pus and a temperature of 40.

I think some older GP's especially really hate the fact that nowadays if you're reasonably intelligent, the Internet gives the average person access to a lot of information that you previously wouldn't have had.

Oh tonsillitis.. I have NEVER had viral tonsillitis in my life I got "so what makes you think it's bacterial?" < opens mouth > "I'll just get you a prescription" as they recoil from my throat