Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Flattering or inappropriate from mechanic at garage?

362 replies

georgeaibu · 26/08/2021 13:08

I'm a mid twenties woman who took the car to the garage for a new tyre (alone). I have not been to this garage before but it comes highly recommended from the local mums Facebook page.

I pull up and the manager/owner (according to their Facebook page), who must have been between 60-70, says 'hello princess, how can I help?'. We then discuss the needs of the car and he asks if I am going to wait- I say yes as it will only be about 20 minutes- and he says 'that's our pleasure to have you wait, you look absolutely lovely'.

I wait inside uneventfully. When he calls me up to pay he explains about the car throughly and normally, but then as I go to leave he says (I assume clocking my wedding ring) 'your young man is a very lucky man, you're really pretty'.

On each occasion I didn't know what to say so mumbled something about 'thanks' and felt progressively more uncomfortable, especially after the last comment. He's 100% older than my dad.

AIBU to have felt uncomfortable? Should I have just felt flattered?

(He wasn't saying things in a 'leery' way, I never felt unsafe, and there were other mechanics in the area albeit they wouldn't have heard what he said).

OP posts:
5128gap · 28/08/2021 12:08

Pumperthepumper, have you never made an overture to a man or woman you considered attractive? Or had one made to you by someone? If you have, how did you gauge whether your interest in the person was reciprocated or indicate to them their attentions were welcome or not? I'd have a wild stab in the dark that the signals you used were similar to those Blossom goes by, as they're fairly universal. If you're at a complete loss still, there are lots of materials out there on unspoken cues.

Pumperthepumper · 28/08/2021 11:59

@Blossomtoes

And she’s reading these replies, and still won’t say

Because I’m nor answerable to you. And you’re still bullying. Do you never learn?

Still no answer then? Maybe not quite so proud of your behaviour as you claim to be.
Blossomtoes · 28/08/2021 11:57

And she’s reading these replies, and still won’t say

Because I’m nor answerable to you. And you’re still bullying. Do you never learn?

Pumperthepumper · 28/08/2021 11:50

@5128gap

By disproportionate censure I meant that Blossomtoes was accused of abuse for flirting with young men. Its disproportionate to apply the term abuse to the behaviour she is describing. You are now I think, suggesting there is no difference in her behaviour and that of a situation where the man is making the comments; and that the young men she flirts with may feel preyed upon? Even if you choose to ignore that Blossomtoes has not said she would continue if they were uncomfortable, do you think the young men concerned are likely to be frightened by her? Do you think they may fear leaving work in case she is waiting for them? That she could overpower and assault them? Do you think they have grown up in a society where female attacks on males are commonplace and therefore perceive attention from women as a potential threat to their safety? I would venture to suggest that typically, they have not, and that this changes the dynamic immeasurably.
I don’t think any of those things. I think @Blossomtoes is inappropriate towards younger men for her own entertainment, because that’s what she said. And that she won’t say how she knows when it’s not reciprocated, because that would prove my point.

And she’s reading these replies, and still won’t say.

Blossomtoes · 28/08/2021 11:47

Think your point - and mine - have just been illustrated perfectly @5128gap.

5128gap · 28/08/2021 11:46

By disproportionate censure I meant that Blossomtoes was accused of abuse for flirting with young men. Its disproportionate to apply the term abuse to the behaviour she is describing. You are now I think, suggesting there is no difference in her behaviour and that of a situation where the man is making the comments; and that the young men she flirts with may feel preyed upon? Even if you choose to ignore that Blossomtoes has not said she would continue if they were uncomfortable, do you think the young men concerned are likely to be frightened by her? Do you think they may fear leaving work in case she is waiting for them? That she could overpower and assault them? Do you think they have grown up in a society where female attacks on males are commonplace and therefore perceive attention from women as a potential threat to their safety? I would venture to suggest that typically, they have not, and that this changes the dynamic immeasurably.

Pumperthepumper · 28/08/2021 11:19

@Blossomtoes

you've actually made that up to make her seem worse

Thank you @5128gap. I’m that woman and I pointed that out some pages ago at the point where I challenged the bullying on this thread.

This was your quote:

I don’t make inappropriate comments to young men - or perhaps I do by current puritanical standards? I’ve always been an incorrigible flirt and I’ve definitely got worse with age. I enjoy it and it’s often reciprocated because I’m way too old to present any kind of threat.

‘Perhaps I do’ and ‘I enjoy it’ ‘often reciprocated’.

Pumperthepumper · 28/08/2021 11:16

@5128gap

Yes I did assume that. However, taking that assumption out of the equation, my point still stands. People, male or female, criticising this man see no hypocrisy in doing so in light of their own behaviour to women on this thread. The poster who flirts with men said she knew her flirting was not unwelcome because she read the signals, which to me indicates a significant difference already, as how many men who make comments to women do you think even bother to look for signals? Do you think the man in the garage did for example? She also didn't say her entertainment was more important, so unless I've missed something, you've actually made that up to make her seem worse. And that's my point. In a thread about yet another example of a man being inappropriate to a woman, disproportionate censure is levelled at a woman (abuse? Really?) who flirts with a man.
‘Disproportionate censure’ - in what way does this relate to that poster?

That poster displays predatory behaviour to young men. The man in the garage displays predatory behaviour to young women. That poster introduced that experience to this thread, I suppose to highlight how harmless she found it? But it’s not harmless if the other person doesn’t find it harmless.

And @Blossomtoes wouldn’t say how she knows if it’s not reciprocated, only that it sometimes isn’t. So what happens then Blossom? Fancy telling us now what the signs are for this non-reciprocal ‘banter’?

Blossomtoes · 28/08/2021 11:07

you've actually made that up to make her seem worse

Thank you @5128gap. I’m that woman and I pointed that out some pages ago at the point where I challenged the bullying on this thread.

5128gap · 28/08/2021 10:29

Yes I did assume that. However, taking that assumption out of the equation, my point still stands. People, male or female, criticising this man see no hypocrisy in doing so in light of their own behaviour to women on this thread.
The poster who flirts with men said she knew her flirting was not unwelcome because she read the signals, which to me indicates a significant difference already, as how many men who make comments to women do you think even bother to look for signals? Do you think the man in the garage did for example? She also didn't say her entertainment was more important, so unless I've missed something, you've actually made that up to make her seem worse. And that's my point. In a thread about yet another example of a man being inappropriate to a woman, disproportionate censure is levelled at a woman (abuse? Really?) who flirts with a man.

Pumperthepumper · 28/08/2021 10:12

@5128gap

What is depressing is how quickly a thread about male inappropriate behaviour turns into an excuse for some women to turn on others. The most self righteous critics of this man see no hypocrisy in spewing their insults and ageism onto other women who might navigate these issues differently. Not to mention the hyperbolic abuse accusations levelled at the woman who flirts with younger men she states welcome it (though of course being older she is obviously deluded!?). I can only assume the people who believe this is no different to the reverse have somehow allowed thousands of years of power imbalance between men and women to pass them by.
You’re assuming we’re all women then?

The poster who flirts with younger men refused to say how she knew it wasn’t welcome ie she didn’t consider how it might make a younger man feel because to her, her entertainment is more important. That’s not a man/woman issue, that’s basic human decency.

5128gap · 28/08/2021 09:42

What is depressing is how quickly a thread about male inappropriate behaviour turns into an excuse for some women to turn on others. The most self righteous critics of this man see no hypocrisy in spewing their insults and ageism onto other women who might navigate these issues differently. Not to mention the hyperbolic abuse accusations levelled at the woman who flirts with younger men she states welcome it (though of course being older she is obviously deluded!?). I can only assume the people who believe this is no different to the reverse have somehow allowed thousands of years of power imbalance between men and women to pass them by.

Sankhomumof3 · 28/08/2021 08:38

This!!!

Kisskiss · 28/08/2021 08:35

Hmmm I mean, given his age/he didn’t then ask for your number/call you.. I think it’s ok? Have had this sort of thing happen to me, both alone , or with my partner ( they tell my partner they are lucky etc) but I assume it’s just someone older trying to be nice…

NoNotYou · 28/08/2021 08:21

If you went back, you would be condoning his inappropriate behaviour. Vote with your feet and don't go back.

Darlingx · 28/08/2021 03:40

My mother upon arriving in the UK was confused when men would call her Darling and Love the whole time because of the language she thought they were being sincere.
My local Postoffice guy said ‘ oh someone attractive at last’ so now I have the pressure of being attractive to send parcels. Depending on how I am feeling I go to the next town to the post office that is less friendly Hmm with bigger queues which is annoying.
The thing is I am at the age where I am invisible on the street which was beginning to be a disappointment and a relief. For women its a tightrope navigating being seen and is it for the right reasons.
When I worked up North running my own business they always addressed the man who was working for me like he was in charge Confused this was about 10 yrs ago and I hope things have progressed.

Mummadeze · 28/08/2021 02:33

In this day and age it does sound misjudged but you said yourself you didn’t feel it was leery or said in a creepy way. I think I would have put it down to him trying to be complimentary and just smiled politely and said thank you. The line someone has to cross to test my personal boundaries is a step further than this.

Kanaloa · 28/08/2021 02:08

Well if that poster feels it was an abusive comment she is welcome to report, and it will be removed. Personally I found her comment a lot more worrying.

Earlydancing · 28/08/2021 01:55

@alexdgr8
have noticed that older women seem more accepting of this sort of thing

Personally for me it's not that I'm more accepting than a woman in her 20s, I'm just more confident in being able to say what I think rather than asking social media: What should I think about this? What should I do about this?
If that guy had said those things to me, I would have decided if I was ok about it or not. And if I wasn't, I'd tell him. Nicely but firmly. But I'd ask him not to do it. I wouldn't start moaning about it to everyone or going online. But honestly, I have a lot going on in my life, and him calling me princess and saying I was pretty would not be something I'd expend a lot of my energy on. It's so far down my list of worries, it might merit an eyeroll at best. I do acknowledge it might be different for younger women who are often scared to speak up.

Haywirecity · 28/08/2021 01:43

But @Kanaloa you're writing things not saying them. If you're shocked, you have time to consider what you're writing. When you start swearing at another poster, that's abusive. Particularly when you're trying to make them change their mind.
I mean this whole thread is pretty pointless now anyway, as everyone has dug in with entrenched opinions and no ones going to move so keeping on winding each other up seems a waste ot time. But obviously it's up to posters what they decide to do. I just don't think it needs to be a race to the bottom of who can insult who the most.

Mamanyt · 28/08/2021 01:34

Do keep in mind that, given his age (as best you can guess it), he grew up in a time when women expected to receive compliments if they looked nice. I doubt he meant much beyond that, and you, yourself, said that there was no leering or ogling going on. He is a product of his time. Don't expect him to be too up on current usage, and, if he does good work, go back. When he compliments you, simply say "Thank you," and immediately turn the conversation back to business. No need to get into a froth over an old man trying to be nice.

alexdgr8 · 28/08/2021 01:30

@BigRedFrog

You misunderstood. I said I, as in me, I enjoy a bit of banter.
but OP doesn't regard it as banter, there's no two-way. i agree with that. also, not being rude, but would it be correct to say that you are an earlier vintage than the OP. i have noticed that older women seem more accepting of this sort of thing; maybe they've had to be, as it was so dominant previously.
Kanaloa · 28/08/2021 01:26

I wasn’t abusing anyone. I said her standards were rock fucking bottom because they are. I didn’t say she was stupid or say ‘you must be ugly if you’re waiting for randos to harass you publicly.’

I said her standards were low, and I expressed shock because I can’t believe any woman would love for men to wolf whistle at them. It’s disgusting. And you do realise these same men will wolf whistle at any woman or indeed girl who is walking alone, to intimidate and harass them. No woman should be tolerating it, it gives a message that it’s acceptable behaviour in a public space, which it is not.

Haywirecity · 28/08/2021 01:23

@Kanaloa
Do you really not see anything very wrong with somebody who says they’d love someone to wolf whistle at them?

It doesn't matter what I think, what matters is that women are allowed to have opinions about things that might differ from yours. And if you abuse or insult them because you don't agree with them, then I don't see how you can criticise men who abuse women because you're both doing the same thing.

LimeRedBanana · 28/08/2021 00:59

And even if it is ‘admiration’, so what?

Like I’m interested in what some knuckle-dragging loser thinks of me…?

Why would I be? I can, and have, done a damn sight better.

This is why I cringe for people who think it’s a compliment - it comes across as so desperate and needy. I freely admit - I judge, and judge hardly.