Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Flattering or inappropriate from mechanic at garage?

362 replies

georgeaibu · 26/08/2021 13:08

I'm a mid twenties woman who took the car to the garage for a new tyre (alone). I have not been to this garage before but it comes highly recommended from the local mums Facebook page.

I pull up and the manager/owner (according to their Facebook page), who must have been between 60-70, says 'hello princess, how can I help?'. We then discuss the needs of the car and he asks if I am going to wait- I say yes as it will only be about 20 minutes- and he says 'that's our pleasure to have you wait, you look absolutely lovely'.

I wait inside uneventfully. When he calls me up to pay he explains about the car throughly and normally, but then as I go to leave he says (I assume clocking my wedding ring) 'your young man is a very lucky man, you're really pretty'.

On each occasion I didn't know what to say so mumbled something about 'thanks' and felt progressively more uncomfortable, especially after the last comment. He's 100% older than my dad.

AIBU to have felt uncomfortable? Should I have just felt flattered?

(He wasn't saying things in a 'leery' way, I never felt unsafe, and there were other mechanics in the area albeit they wouldn't have heard what he said).

OP posts:
Endoftether2000 · 29/08/2021 10:19

Pumper the pumper funny you should say that but my father has been told on many occasions by men, how good looking he is and many have said his wife is lucky to have him especially as he can turn his hand to anything.

Endoftether2000 · 29/08/2021 10:14

So it kinda makes sense...

Endoftether2000 · 29/08/2021 10:14

Shade 17 Read the bit about him not wanting to go back under the car... He didn't want to go back on the floor to do the pads

GladAllOver · 29/08/2021 09:48

Don't go to Cornwall then, you might be called "my lover".

Shade17 · 29/08/2021 09:48

I can remember going to get new brake pads from a named Garage and they advised that I needed new discs also. I knew I didn't as my Dad had changed them for me but did not want to go under the car again to do the pads

That makes no sense as you always fit new pads with new discs.

Kanaloa · 29/08/2021 09:31

Why do people keep ruminating on how their lovely dad/uncle/grandpa calls women love/dear, while ignoring that this man made repeated comments in her physical appearances that she did not respond to?

People are happy to jump in with ‘oh so shall I tell my grandpa he can never ever ever smile at a woman again??!!!’

Well, no, but most adult men can tell that after one ‘compliment’ has been ignored, more aren’t wanted.

Pumperthepumper · 29/08/2021 08:54

@Endoftether2000

My Sister In Law took a call yesterday from a Sales Person (Man). He was asking to speak to a Mrs ***. She replied Sorry Love you have the wrong number. He replied I am not your love and hung up. Around where I live we have a lot of terms of endearments, so I guess I better stop using them. Personally I would not have been offened by the comments but can see some people would. If the Garage is good I would use it again as finding good, reliable Garages is a must. I can remember going to get new brake pads from a named Garage and they advised that I needed new discs also. I knew I didn't as my Dad had changed them for me but did not want to go under the car again to do the pads😂😅🤣. If people make me that uncomfortable who I have to deal with Men and Women alike I send my husband. OP out of interest if the person was the same age as you (either gender) would you of been as uncomfortable? My father (totally lovely man) calls everyone Love and engages with anyone he interacts with should I tell him to stop?
I guess a better question would be - would your dad like a string of comments from another man about how attractive he was and how his wife was a lucky man? Or would that make him uncomfortable?
youvegottenminuteslynn · 29/08/2021 07:51

@Endoftether2000

My Sister In Law took a call yesterday from a Sales Person (Man). He was asking to speak to a Mrs ***. She replied Sorry Love you have the wrong number. He replied I am not your love and hung up. Around where I live we have a lot of terms of endearments, so I guess I better stop using them. Personally I would not have been offened by the comments but can see some people would. If the Garage is good I would use it again as finding good, reliable Garages is a must. I can remember going to get new brake pads from a named Garage and they advised that I needed new discs also. I knew I didn't as my Dad had changed them for me but did not want to go under the car again to do the pads😂😅🤣. If people make me that uncomfortable who I have to deal with Men and Women alike I send my husband. OP out of interest if the person was the same age as you (either gender) would you of been as uncomfortable? My father (totally lovely man) calls everyone Love and engages with anyone he interacts with should I tell him to stop?
That's very different though, he didn't use a term like 'love'. He repeatedly made comments about her appearance specifically, despite her not reciprocating the same behaviour or appearing pleased / flattered.

Totally different sitting being objectified with uninvited comments about your appearance vs someone saying 'love'.

Endoftether2000 · 29/08/2021 07:04

My Sister In Law took a call yesterday from a Sales Person (Man). He was asking to speak to a Mrs ***. She replied Sorry Love you have the wrong number. He replied I am not your love and hung up. Around where I live we have a lot of terms of endearments, so I guess I better stop using them. Personally I would not have been offened by the comments but can see some people would. If the Garage is good I would use it again as finding good, reliable Garages is a must. I can remember going to get new brake pads from a named Garage and they advised that I needed new discs also. I knew I didn't as my Dad had changed them for me but did not want to go under the car again to do the pads😂😅🤣. If people make me that uncomfortable who I have to deal with Men and Women alike I send my husband. OP out of interest if the person was the same age as you (either gender) would you of been as uncomfortable? My father (totally lovely man) calls everyone Love and engages with anyone he interacts with should I tell him to stop?

Hugoslavia · 28/08/2021 22:17

I don't understand why you need to seek others opinions. It's about how it made you feel and whether you felt it appropriate that counts. And obviously you are then free to take your business elsewhere, which I would guess that you would do.

ClubTropicanaVIP · 28/08/2021 18:48

Can understand your discomfort as I would’ve been the same at your age but I don’t think he (at his age) realised it would make you feel that way. He’s of the age where men were ‘allowed’ to ‘flatter’ women and make those sorts of comments.

However a good few years ago I was filling up with petrol and sensed 2 blokes (hairy arsed builder types) in a van staring at me...I kept looking behind me, convinced they were looking at someone else. I went in to pay and they were still staring so I stared to feel v uncomfortable. When I came back out the driver opened his door and said “I’m so sorry we are staring at you so much but you are absolutely bloody beautiful” and drove off. I went bright red and said something like “oh right”......the rest of the day though I drove around feeling like frikkin Beyoncé 😂 😂

Pumperthepumper · 28/08/2021 18:32

@Foramen

On the basis of your last paragraph, you should be flattered. Remember, if he is as old as you say then he was brought up and spent his teens and twenties in times when it was quite normal to compliment a pretty girl who then didn't go running off complaining. It's like getting a wolf-whistle. I've always thought them very flattering. Too old for them now!
So? Even if it were true he was brought up in an era that you could say anything at all to women - he’s now lived another 40+ years past that. Do you still behave the same as you did in your 20s? I’m guessing not.
Lostmarbles2021 · 28/08/2021 18:26

In respect to anyone suggesting that you ‘should’ be flattered. I find that objectionable - women have been trying to move away from being judged purely on their looks.

Lostmarbles2021 · 28/08/2021 18:24

Haven’t read full thread and I’m sure others have said this but could you write a google and/or trust pilot review. You can share that it was good service etc but that as a woman the comments on your appearance made you uncomfortable. That way other women will be pre-warned and the manager gets some feedback. He’s a different generation but still needs to learn.

Foramen · 28/08/2021 18:17

On the basis of your last paragraph, you should be flattered. Remember, if he is as old as you say then he was brought up and spent his teens and twenties in times when it was quite normal to compliment a pretty girl who then didn't go running off complaining. It's like getting a wolf-whistle. I've always thought them very flattering. Too old for them now!

cfb35 · 28/08/2021 16:43

Sorry if this has already been said, but I haven’t managed to read the entire thread, just the first few pages.
Context is everything, I consider myself as feminist, and have in the past been removed from a shop by security because I objected to the bloke behind the counter calling me “love”. It wasn’t the word itself that was objectionable, but the tone and context in which it was used, as a put down to make out I didn’t know what I was talking about (didn’t help because query I had was about football studs….niche..and yes, I am quite knowledgeable about them 🤣) I stood my ground and called bloke out on it.
I live in a part of the country, NW, where colloquial familiar terms are used. Princess, Queen, etc and I can only ever get annoyed with blokes using them when the context or implication is not well meaning. Similarly, Duck and Love from DH’s hometown.
Comments about appearance though are completely overstepping and the should be called out…not saying you need to be as bolshy as me and require security. It does sound like you were caught a little off guard, but you could maybe next time be prepared, and tell him that you’re not happy about the comments.
Sorry for the long post.

Pumperthepumper · 28/08/2021 15:09

@Blossomtoes

When you display predatory behaviour because you enjoy it

Please stop making this up. I have answered your tedious questions. RTFT. .

See your quote above Blossom.
Blossomtoes · 28/08/2021 15:08

When you display predatory behaviour because you enjoy it

Please stop making this up. I have answered your tedious questions. RTFT. .

Journeyofthedragons · 28/08/2021 15:07

Surely it's a privilege for an older woman to be able to harass young men with impunity @Blossomtoes?

Pumperthepumper · 28/08/2021 15:06

@Blossomtoes

And she’s reading these replies, and still won’t say

Because I’m nor answerable to you. And you’re still bullying. Do you never learn?

Here you go @Blossomtoes
Pumperthepumper · 28/08/2021 15:05

@Blossomtoes

but definitely used their privilege to make someone else feel uncomfortable

What fucking privilege? Are you seriously suggesting that we’ve all imagined the patriarchy in which women have fought for their rights? In what scenario is the woman the privileged one?

And I have answered your questions ad nauseum. The question in my mind is how on earth have I managed to be so uncharacteristically patient with you.

When you display predatory behaviour because you enjoy it.

You said about an hour ago you hadn’t answers my question, I’ll quote it so you can see it again:

Blossomtoes · 28/08/2021 14:58

but definitely used their privilege to make someone else feel uncomfortable

What fucking privilege? Are you seriously suggesting that we’ve all imagined the patriarchy in which women have fought for their rights? In what scenario is the woman the privileged one?

And I have answered your questions ad nauseum. The question in my mind is how on earth have I managed to be so uncharacteristically patient with you.

PipeDownPete · 28/08/2021 14:42

Not at all @Pumperthepumper

Pumperthepumper · 28/08/2021 14:40

On a thread about male impropriety to women, why is the need to protect men the priority?

It’s not.

Pumperthepumper · 28/08/2021 14:39

@PipeDownPete

She has answered it, but you're in such a froth of self righteous indignation that you keep missing it.
Still desperate for that reaction?

Hey @Blossomtoes good news! Pete’s on your side!