Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To enjoy being a bit skint

337 replies

Welcometotheterrorzone · 26/08/2021 08:39

I realise this might sound really privileged to some.
We are by no means struggling to pay our mortgage or buy food. We both have alright jobs, low paid but steady and enough to pay for a lovely house in a rough part of town. Like I said, we do alright but have to budget in order to have Christmas and holidays. We camp, we don't eat out, we share subscriptions with friends, we have one car, we buy second hand everything, we use freetogo apps etc to save. I am an obsessive yellow sticker shopper and do not pay full price for any meat, bread, milk or fruit as I hit different supermarkets at different times and have a huge freezer to store it all in. We eat veggie 70% of the time too.
Yesterday it was a one off treat day for DS as he's starting school. I had £24 for the day and no access to anymore money. We had such a lovely time, bakery lunch, went to a national trust place where just going in the grounds is a lot cheaper than tickets for the house so did that, treated them to an ice lolly and found a Poundland on the way home for a toy instead of getting (the same quality) toy in the gift shop. I was a bit worried at one point as we walked past this amazing sweet shop and I thought that they were going to ask for something I couldn't afford (only had £2 left by this point as we were on our way to the train station) but brilliantly they had a reduced section with these Harry Potter chocolate bars for 50p so still had a £1 at the end of it.
My aibu is that I don't want to lose this feeling of joy that we have found something that fits our budget and makes me feel like I'm treating them. I've had times where I felt really down that I can't just say 'choose whatever you like' but I think every parent sets limits so I'm not being unnecessary harsh. I'm trying to teach them to find pleasure in small things, and that finding the right toy in a charity shop is better than going to a big toy shop full of plastic where you can choose anything. I hope they don't resent me for it.
Luckily it's payday tomorrow!

OP posts:
wtfisgoingonhere21 · 26/08/2021 11:16

Working poor family here.

Earn too much to get help with anything but not enough to have any savings or emergency funds thanks to Covid ripping our finances apart for 18 months and still continuing now.

We will be trying to catch up for a good 12 months now and we've had some hairy moments with less than £24 for a week for fuel and food so it's utterly shit and no I don't enjoy being frugal at all.

It's a shit show when two full time workers struggle to financially keep a house and family.

In fact it's disgusting that so many people are currently in the same boat and worse.

I hate the counting of pennies every week and budgeting so tight to the wire I don't sleep towards the end of the month worrying in case it doesn't quite stretch.

It's a vicious circle for many people op so I think your post will run people up the wrong way.

Covid has caused such a massive divide in the country in terms of finances it's unreal.

Our local community kitchen and cupboard is about to close down and move to different premises and people are seriously worried how long this will take because that's how they feed their kids each week and they work Shock

It's a disgrace

WitchBaby · 26/08/2021 11:14

I’m gonna make them choose between an ice cream or a ride on the carousel, even though we can easily afford both, because I think they’ll enjoy it more and it’ll make them better people xx

This is a really good idea. We grew up with not very much and it was so exciting when we did get things, I can still remember the feeling now 🤗 . My DNephew has always had everything he wants/asks for and he doesn't even get excited at Christmas, it's very sad.

3ormorecharactersss · 26/08/2021 11:07

@namechangeno7 I’m glad you understood what I meant - I have asked MN to remove my comment as I realised the wording I used was really bad form and potentially upsetting and I didn’t mean it like that at all. Brain and mouth are often disengaged these days!

grapewine · 26/08/2021 11:07

And as much as some people would scoff at me for this, I have a massive bugbear with people who have their bills all covered and spare money to play with on nice days out buying up all the yellow sticker items. Families who really really struggle are desperate for lower priced goods, but there's you hoarding them in your massive freezer and skipping merrily through National trust properties on a lovely day out, with money left over for toys and sweets. Those other families can't even dream of it because they're unlikely to be able to visit multiple supermarkets and swipe up all their perishables for cut prices, so every penny goes on bills and food, with much juggling and corner cutting

I'll probably get flamed, but I couldn't agree more.

Somethingsnappy · 26/08/2021 11:05

@WitchBaby

I think she was talking about that happening in the past, wasn't she?

No, "twice this summer" OP said she had her electricity turned off allegedly.

Ah, OK.
WitchBaby · 26/08/2021 11:02

I think she was talking about that happening in the past, wasn't she?

No, "twice this summer" OP said she had her electricity turned off allegedly.

Somethingsnappy · 26/08/2021 11:01

[quote Welcometotheterrorzone]@Bluntness100 you're always so tiresome on threads. I'm not saying I never want to to change, I'm saying that i don't want to lose this feeling of appreciating the little things. Yes with that comes feelings of failure at times, but also joy, relief, exhilaration. Finding a dress for a friends wedding for £3 in Cancer Research and everyone asking where you got it. Not that complex is it.[/quote]
This makes sense, OP. I think you just didn't properly think through some of the wording in your first post and title.

Although you're getting a hard time on the here, I hope it will please you to know that this thread has got me thinking and actually inspired me in some ways. Smile

namechangeno7 · 26/08/2021 11:00

I actually do hope a paper picks this up, then OP will know from multiple comment threads just how skint they are not.

DGFB · 26/08/2021 10:59

I think the point you’re trying to make is that being frugal with young children can be a good thing…
Wait until they are teenagers though and want branded stuff to keep up with their mates. Plus cash for cinema and burgers

powershowerforanhour · 26/08/2021 10:56

I have a massive bugbear with people who have their bills all covered and spare money to play with on nice days out buying up all the yellow sticker items.

My mum always used to say this. I love the yellow sticker section but she insisted we leave the things unless there was loads of the item we wanted left, or it was just before closing and guaranteed to get chucked and go to waste anyway.

As far as the original OP is concerned- finding a pound in your coat lining or a canny charity shop purchase- always fun. Getting the green eyed monster over this- My friend on UC (but earns more than me) gets a huge hamper of food every two weeks which she doesn't have to pick up, it's delivered. She also gets free holiday club all summer, with a bag of food to take home for dinner - not fun.

Somethingsnappy · 26/08/2021 10:56

@WitchBaby

I don't get this thread. OP started off 'privileged' in the OP and just playing at being skint. But then a few drip feeds posts in says she had her electricity cut off for not paying her bills, well that's not privileged is it? 🤷🏼‍♀️
I think she was talking about that happening in the past, wasn't she?
icedcoffees · 26/08/2021 10:56

The OP had £24 for a day out.... Its not like she's wiping her ass with wads of bills.... Shes not saying she has £24 per day... She's saying this is what she had for her day out. I don't like referring to people as "skint" but yes, she is and there is no need to be rude about it is there. If your offended by her self claimed "skintness" then why are you on her post...

Having a nice house, a mortgage and all your childcare, food and bills covered each month is not being skint.

I'm not offended but I think OP's post is tasteless and misses the mark somewhat. There's nothing wrong with enjoying budgeting or getting your finances to stretch, but saying you "enjoy being a bit skint" when you're not even remotely skint is just a bit...off.

Skint is not being able to pay the rent. It's choosing between using the heating or feeding yourself. It's scraping pennies together from down the sofa to buy bread and milk. It's not having a nice home, a mortgage and "only" having £24 to spend on a day out Hmm

VyrnwyGirl · 26/08/2021 10:55

@icedcoffees

I am sorry you are getting flak on here. It's inevitable and not a nice side of MNet.

Personally I don't think it's very nice to post about "loving being skint" when you're clearly not skint.

This. ^

Dreadful thread. Hmm

And the 'Jesus lighten up' brigade can do one.

As has been said, being ACTUALLY SKINT is no picnic. It's dreadful. It ruins lives, and affects peoples mental health...

@Welcometotheterrorzone this thread is in very poor taste. Ask for it to be deleted FFS. Hmm

Rainallnight · 26/08/2021 10:55

Sharing subscriptions is stealing and pushes prices up for those of us who do pay full price.

yourestandingonmyneck · 26/08/2021 10:55

@Lonelylooloo

I fully understand what you mean OP I grew up on the breadline and it was very hard but we were happy and very careful. I remember going on free/ very cheap days out and dreaming about being able to buy food from the cafe, get a big ice cream or buy something more than a pencil (if I was very lucky) from the gift shop.

My sibling and I had so many ‘if we had lots of money’ fantasises and would play imaginary games together over what we would do. We took SOOOO much pleasure in little treats.

No I have plenty of money and it turns out the cafe food is usually shit, the ice cream has become normal and the gift shop is just overpriced tat. I miss the joy of fantasising. I have 2 small children of my own and my DH thinks I’m crackers because I fully intend to conceal that we can afford things from them.

I’m gonna make them choose between an ice cream or a ride on the carousel, even though we can easily afford both, because I think they’ll enjoy it more and it’ll make them better people xx

This is what I was trying to say. You've put it much more eloquently than me.
Somethingsnappy · 26/08/2021 10:54

@EmeraldShamrock

Now I can't get the tune out my head... Thanks for that @araiwa! I've listened to it twice. Grin
You're going to be humming it for weeks now... Be warned!
namechangeno7 · 26/08/2021 10:53

[quote 3ormorecharactersss]@namechangeno7 I don’t buy reduced bits because it’s like feeding time at the zoo usually, but I’ve never thought about it that way. Your post would definitely make me think twice in the future.[/quote]
I also find it a mad rush, but I know all too well that half of the people there are just desperate to save some money so that a bill can be paid or a school uniform can be bought and the other half are like OP, smug over saving a fiver that they didn't need, unless you believe all of OPs drip feeding and hole digging about having her electricity cut off twice after she stated she was fine for mortgage payments and bills....

Viviennemary · 26/08/2021 10:51

Being skint = not having enough money for your basic needs. That is not you. YABU.

GrandDuchessRomanov · 26/08/2021 10:49

Come back and tell us how fantastic it is when you are REALLY skint OP.

I won't hold my breath.

ChaToilLeam · 26/08/2021 10:48

You’re far from being skint. Very, very far.

Nothing wrong with being frugal and seeing how far you can make your money stretch. It’s a good skill to have. But I imagine anyone who is genuinely skint reading your post would not be terribly impressed.

3ormorecharactersss · 26/08/2021 10:47

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

GlinnerForPM · 26/08/2021 10:46

@Notcontent

I am assuming you don’t mean to offend anyone but really, your post is so out of touch….
Why do you think that.?
Lonelylooloo · 26/08/2021 10:45

I fully understand what you mean OP
I grew up on the breadline and it was very hard but we were happy and very careful. I remember going on free/ very cheap days out and dreaming about being able to buy food from the cafe, get a big ice cream or buy something more than a pencil (if I was very lucky) from the gift shop.

My sibling and I had so many ‘if we had lots of money’ fantasises and would play imaginary games together over what we would do. We took SOOOO much pleasure in little treats.

No I have plenty of money and it turns out the cafe food is usually shit, the ice cream has become normal and the gift shop is just overpriced tat. I miss the joy of fantasising. I have 2 small children of my own and my DH thinks I’m crackers because I fully intend to conceal that we can afford things from them.

I’m gonna make them choose between an ice cream or a ride on the carousel, even though we can easily afford both, because I think they’ll enjoy it more and it’ll make them better people xx

namechangeno7 · 26/08/2021 10:44

Visiting bakeries, National trust properties, sweet shops and even having a spare £24 for a day is not skint, OP. Far, far from it. You were just on a budget for the day. How many days of the month are you deciding between food or putting money on the electricity meter?

And as much as some people would scoff at me for this, I have a massive bugbear with people who have their bills all covered and spare money to play with on nice days out buying up all the yellow sticker items. Families who really really struggle are desperate for lower priced goods, but there's you hoarding them in your massive freezer and skipping merrily through National trust properties on a lovely day out, with money left over for toys and sweets. Those other families can't even dream of it because they're unlikely to be able to visit multiple supermarkets and swipe up all their perishables for cut prices, so every penny goes on bills and food, with much juggling and corner cutting.

yourestandingonmyneck · 26/08/2021 10:44

God, lighten up people. She is not "playing at being poor" Hmm She has acknowledged that she is lucky to have a home and food on the table, but equally she buys second hand and reduced food as they have to be very careful with money. She's not a millionaire pretending to be poor for the day.

OP, I get what you're saying.

I'm ok for money. Not loaded but ok. I could go into a gift shop and say "chose whatever you want" and I could pay for it. It would have an effect on my finances though and it isn't something I'd do because it would be a stupid waste of my money.

Basically, I don't have enough to say "choose what you want" and it not matter. And I do sometimes wonder what it would to be so wealthy that I could just do that all the time. And while that thought is initially attractive, I can see how very quickly you wouldn't really get any joy out of that.

So yes, I completely understand the joy at finding something you want that is reduced or just within your budget. I get what you are saying.