Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To enjoy being a bit skint

337 replies

Welcometotheterrorzone · 26/08/2021 08:39

I realise this might sound really privileged to some.
We are by no means struggling to pay our mortgage or buy food. We both have alright jobs, low paid but steady and enough to pay for a lovely house in a rough part of town. Like I said, we do alright but have to budget in order to have Christmas and holidays. We camp, we don't eat out, we share subscriptions with friends, we have one car, we buy second hand everything, we use freetogo apps etc to save. I am an obsessive yellow sticker shopper and do not pay full price for any meat, bread, milk or fruit as I hit different supermarkets at different times and have a huge freezer to store it all in. We eat veggie 70% of the time too.
Yesterday it was a one off treat day for DS as he's starting school. I had £24 for the day and no access to anymore money. We had such a lovely time, bakery lunch, went to a national trust place where just going in the grounds is a lot cheaper than tickets for the house so did that, treated them to an ice lolly and found a Poundland on the way home for a toy instead of getting (the same quality) toy in the gift shop. I was a bit worried at one point as we walked past this amazing sweet shop and I thought that they were going to ask for something I couldn't afford (only had £2 left by this point as we were on our way to the train station) but brilliantly they had a reduced section with these Harry Potter chocolate bars for 50p so still had a £1 at the end of it.
My aibu is that I don't want to lose this feeling of joy that we have found something that fits our budget and makes me feel like I'm treating them. I've had times where I felt really down that I can't just say 'choose whatever you like' but I think every parent sets limits so I'm not being unnecessary harsh. I'm trying to teach them to find pleasure in small things, and that finding the right toy in a charity shop is better than going to a big toy shop full of plastic where you can choose anything. I hope they don't resent me for it.
Luckily it's payday tomorrow!

OP posts:
IWantT0BreakFree · 26/08/2021 13:18

This thread is so nasty. It's just dozens of people who are statistically extremely likely to be significantly better off than the OP (someone posted a helpful link upthread to compare household income nationally) pretending to be outraged on behalf of the very poorest people in society so they can give someone a good kicking. MN demographics being what they are, some of these people attacking the OP for calling herself skint when she's managed to scrape together £24 over the summer to treat her kid to ONE day out in the school holidays will be earning 6 figures (and more) themselves. Now thats offensive.

Is it OK to call yourself skint if you survive on benefits and rely on a foodbank? Or actually is that really offensive because some people are literally living on the streets or in homeless hostels with only the clothes on their back? It's all relative and it's not a race to the bottom.

Someone who has twice in recent months been unable to pay their electric bill (a basic necessity) and who has managed to scrape together £24 over the course of the summer for one day out is skint. That indicates a significantly lower than average household income.

FuckingFabulous · 26/08/2021 13:15

@DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult

It is patronising, op has previously said they have spent £1700 on a holiday cottage, and booked a museum at £20 per person and kids who only give a shit about gift shops, yet has also had the electric cut off twice this summer and lost freezers full of food? Confused

Shes come on to tell us how great it is to be a bit skint, when she absolutely has no concept of it at all, apart from in her own mind.

Share tips on how to have a cheap day out, even share that you've had a lovely day out, but don't come on stating that being a bit skint is great when you're clearly not skint at all.

I seriously doubt the electricity story, OP just needed to redirect the stream of indignation
Takenoprisoner · 26/08/2021 13:13

Can't believe the vitriol on this thread.

Takenoprisoner · 26/08/2021 13:12

@Blankscreen

I think the op chose an unfortunately worded title.

If she had said 'to enjoy budgeting' it would have been met with a different response

It is a odd choice of title but I understand the point she was making. She was pleased with herself for having a nice day out for £24.

Obviously some people on here will blow £24 every day on just ice creams others have £24 for the whole holiday.

That doesn't take away from the substance of the OP.

Some people love to get offended.

100% this.
5128gap · 26/08/2021 13:03

[quote Welcometotheterrorzone]@icedcoffees I've been really skint. I've been the person crying on the phone to HMRC when they stopped my tax credits for six months. Ive had to explain to my boss that I would have to resign as no tax credits means I can't afford childcare so therefore won't be able to work. I've still got debt from that time. Things are a lot better now that I'm not paying childcare for two kids. What my post was saying was that I don't want to lose this, I don't want to ever think that finding a quid isn't really exciting. I don't want to become. This choice (being able to spend money) is sometimes daunting (as there were days when I couldn't ever spend money) and I find it hard to not go crazy and buy my kids everything. [/quote]
The problem is, the downside to being excited over finding a quid is being in the horrors when you need one and can't find it. So, while I get your point about not losing sight of gratitude, and empathise with the feeling of satisfaction you get from being savvy and making the most of limited money, I wouldn't describe it as an enjoyment of being skint. Being truly skint can be terrifying and stressful as you know yourself, so I'd pick comfortable every time.

GinPin2 · 26/08/2021 13:01

@beastlyslumber

Good god the people on here going on about how 'insensitive' and 'privileged' the OP is when half the posts on here are about how your husband earns £100k but won't pay for shopping, or how the nanny/cleaner/butler has BU, or how your neighbour is a CF for parking over your driveway so you can't get your second car in.

Sadly, some people are just always looking for a sign of what they consider weakness so they can stick the boot in. OP, you sound lovely. Don't apologise for your situation, and don't let the idiots ruin your day.

Agree 100%
beastlyslumber · 26/08/2021 12:58

The OP can still be considered insensitive even though other people are more insensitive, though.

She's clearly not insensitive at all. It's the fact that she's sensitive and self-aware and a bit apologetic in her OP that made people think she was weak and would be an easy target for a kicking.

And FWIW I don't think people posting about their butler problems are being insensitive either. People are allowed to talk about their lives. If those posts make you roll your eyes, you can just move on.

GinPin2 · 26/08/2021 12:58

@EatYourVegetables

People are being really harsh to the OP. I know not everyone has £24 for the day out and some people don’t have £24 for the week, but this is a forum where last week everyone agreed that spending £8K on a second hand watch is a good investment, that Birkin bags are the only really good bags, that you should never date a man who doesn’t drive, and that a child needs a new bag, pencil case and a water bottle every year.

Enjoy your days out on a budget, OP.

Absolutely agree!
Bluntness100 · 26/08/2021 12:56

Agree this is a poor phrasing issue, saying she enjoys being skint and is crying about her tax credits and getting the leccy switched off but going to spend 24 quid on a day out is poorly worded, if she said I enjoy seeing the value in money and budgeting it would be very different.

Arsebucket · 26/08/2021 12:56

I think the point you’re trying to make is that being frugal with young children can be a good thing…
Wait until they are teenagers though and want branded stuff to keep up with their mates. Plus cash for cinema and burgers

My 19 year old isn’t like this. And nor are his close
friends that I know.

Not all teens are materialistic or oblivious to the value of money.

icedcoffees · 26/08/2021 12:54

Good god the people on here going on about how 'insensitive' and 'privileged' the OP is when half the posts on here are about how your husband earns £100k but won't pay for shopping, or how the nanny/cleaner/butler has BU, or how your neighbour is a CF for parking over your driveway so you can't get your second car in.

The OP can still be considered insensitive even though other people are more insensitive, though.

thebeatingofthedrums · 26/08/2021 12:53

MN is always about a race to the bottom.

You can't ever be skint, because someone is always more skint than you.

FWIW, I get it, @Welcometotheterrorzone. I remember penny pinching when I was younger and poor, and whilst it's nice not having to worry about money these days, I do remember the joy of finding a nice yellow sticked product, or being able to stack discount codes to swing presents for family for cheap.

It's not really about wanting to stay 'skint' forever - and by 'skint', you can use whatever definition you like - it's about never wanting to let go of the joy in life.

I feel pretty miserable right now. If I had no money, it would be worse, but having money doesn't necessarily equate with joy.

You do you, let the vipers do them. Stay happy.

beastlyslumber · 26/08/2021 12:53

Good god the people on here going on about how 'insensitive' and 'privileged' the OP is when half the posts on here are about how your husband earns £100k but won't pay for shopping, or how the nanny/cleaner/butler has BU, or how your neighbour is a CF for parking over your driveway so you can't get your second car in.

Sadly, some people are just always looking for a sign of what they consider weakness so they can stick the boot in. OP, you sound lovely. Don't apologise for your situation, and don't let the idiots ruin your day.

BittaOrange · 26/08/2021 12:53

@Notcontent

I am assuming you don’t mean to offend anyone but really, your post is so out of touch….
What nonsense I would say the OP has got it exactly right.
theleafandnotthetree · 26/08/2021 12:50

@DGFB

I think the point you’re trying to make is that being frugal with young children can be a good thing… Wait until they are teenagers though and want branded stuff to keep up with their mates. Plus cash for cinema and burgers
Not every teenager is like this, mine couldn't care less about branded stuff and never have. You see this written as if it's a given - scaring the life out of people who can't afford it - but it really isn't. And I do think the messages of frugality, values etc in earlier childhood do filter through
OhWhyNot · 26/08/2021 12:50

Everyone agreeing £8k is a good investment for a watch ?

I doubt everyone for many of us (though I recognise that MN is overwhelming mc) that isn’t something we would even think of as being a good investment as we simply wouldn’t have that sort of money to invest in a watch or buy a Birkin bag

The op comes across as crass and has posted on AIBU should we just all be agreeing how great and what fun it is to be skint for a day

VeryLongBeeeeep · 26/08/2021 12:48

this is a forum where last week everyone agreed that spending £8K on a second hand watch is a good investment

A proportion of people on that particular thread may have agreed, but that's very far from 'everyone' on the site, and I doubt the OP of it said "I'm pretty skint but I'm thinking about spending £8k on a watch".

nettie434 · 26/08/2021 12:38

Eatyourvegetables Well said!

RubyFowler · 26/08/2021 12:36

@theleafandnotthetree

OP I think I know what you are getting at. I went from pretty comfortably off to barely scraping by when I left my marriage 4 years ago and while I was getting re-established career wise. There were awful bits - having a fiver left to put in the electricity meter, having to say no to so many things - I do also remember having moments/days of feeling really satisfied and proud for the quality of what we were doing versus the cost. We had a LOT of picnics, lots of day trips to free places like beaches and woods, afternoon tea parties where we ate the same thing we would have been doing anyway but doing so out of a china tea pot and crockery. But I was very aware that this would first of all be relatively temporary - I now earn a decent enough salary and I don't have to worry unduly about bills etc - but more importantly, it was built on a bedrock of pre-existing privelege. I had an education, a car from previously, a wardrobe of clothes, hundreds of books, family members who could lend me money, networks and contacts, a pre existing mobile phone contracr, some nice things to keep us going and I knew that my children were getting to do really nice and more costly things with their Dad. I never kidded myself that this phase of my life gave me anymore than a glimpse into what it is really like to live day after day, year after year in poverty with no improvement in sight. Your post is a little all over the place and it's a bit hard to place where on a spectrum you actually lie so I think you have got some people's backs up
I'm in the same situation now as you were then, and I totally recognise what you're saying. It is nothing more than a glimpse.
Honeymare · 26/08/2021 12:29

*I never want to lose the thrill of making a splurge

Honeymare · 26/08/2021 12:28

I know exactly what you're saying OP but you got your wording wrong. I never want to enjoy the thrill of being able to make a splurge and get the thrill of it.

I'm not skint but my financial situation has varied over the years. I once had a horrific couple of years with illness, couldn't work, had bills piling up etc. I got out of it, lined up a well paid contract. The day before I started I happened upon a designer jacket way out of my usual budget and tried it on for a laugh. I fell madly in love, i felt beautiful in it which was not a feeling I'd had about myself since before I was ill. I checked the shop regular while doing the contract and on payday rushed out to buy the jacket.

As my financial situation improved drastically over the following years I always keep my spending in check because it's not the spending money it's the relative feeling that makes it exciting and I want to hang onto that.

In a nutshell, we should apply to ourselves the same caution parents take not to spoil children.

Tal45 · 26/08/2021 12:27

I think you phrased it badly OP, it wasn't that you enjoyed being skint - you said yourself you were a bit worried that you couldn't afford anything in the expensive sweet shop for instance - more that you were pleased that you could could enjoy a day out on a strict budget with no complaints from the kids.

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 26/08/2021 12:26

@grapewine

And as much as some people would scoff at me for this, I have a massive bugbear with people who have their bills all covered and spare money to play with on nice days out buying up all the yellow sticker items. Families who really really struggle are desperate for lower priced goods, but there's you hoarding them in your massive freezer and skipping merrily through National trust properties on a lovely day out, with money left over for toys and sweets. Those other families can't even dream of it because they're unlikely to be able to visit multiple supermarkets and swipe up all their perishables for cut prices, so every penny goes on bills and food, with much juggling and corner cutting

I'll probably get flamed, but I couldn't agree more.

Agree with this as well
EatYourVegetables · 26/08/2021 12:20

People are being really harsh to the OP. I know not everyone has £24 for the day out and some people don’t have £24 for the week, but this is a forum where last week everyone agreed that spending £8K on a second hand watch is a good investment, that Birkin bags are the only really good bags, that you should never date a man who doesn’t drive, and that a child needs a new bag, pencil case and a water bottle every year.

Enjoy your days out on a budget, OP.

MuddlingMackem · 26/08/2021 12:18

@allLonelylooloo Thu 26-Aug-21 10:45:46
I have 2 small children of my own and my DH thinks I’m crackers because I fully intend to conceal that we can afford things from them.

I’m gonna make them choose between an ice cream or a ride on the carousel, even though we can easily afford both, because I think they’ll enjoy it more and it’ll make them better people xx

No need to do this. Since you have the money just give them pocket money and let them choose what they want within their own budget. Our kids have spent their childhood's learning the value of money and learning to gauge just how much they really want something when they have to buy it with their own money and learning to save for things which are more expensive. Double benefit. Grin

My now 14 year old even commented recently how much of a benefit it is to have this experience in budgeting compared to her friends who just get handed money for things by their parents.

For an example, I like taking my kids out for coffee and cake occasionally but I have a limited budget for this. Last time DD wanted a more expensive drink than I'd budgeted for, so she covered the difference from her spending money as it was something she really did want. :)