Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To enjoy being a bit skint

337 replies

Welcometotheterrorzone · 26/08/2021 08:39

I realise this might sound really privileged to some.
We are by no means struggling to pay our mortgage or buy food. We both have alright jobs, low paid but steady and enough to pay for a lovely house in a rough part of town. Like I said, we do alright but have to budget in order to have Christmas and holidays. We camp, we don't eat out, we share subscriptions with friends, we have one car, we buy second hand everything, we use freetogo apps etc to save. I am an obsessive yellow sticker shopper and do not pay full price for any meat, bread, milk or fruit as I hit different supermarkets at different times and have a huge freezer to store it all in. We eat veggie 70% of the time too.
Yesterday it was a one off treat day for DS as he's starting school. I had £24 for the day and no access to anymore money. We had such a lovely time, bakery lunch, went to a national trust place where just going in the grounds is a lot cheaper than tickets for the house so did that, treated them to an ice lolly and found a Poundland on the way home for a toy instead of getting (the same quality) toy in the gift shop. I was a bit worried at one point as we walked past this amazing sweet shop and I thought that they were going to ask for something I couldn't afford (only had £2 left by this point as we were on our way to the train station) but brilliantly they had a reduced section with these Harry Potter chocolate bars for 50p so still had a £1 at the end of it.
My aibu is that I don't want to lose this feeling of joy that we have found something that fits our budget and makes me feel like I'm treating them. I've had times where I felt really down that I can't just say 'choose whatever you like' but I think every parent sets limits so I'm not being unnecessary harsh. I'm trying to teach them to find pleasure in small things, and that finding the right toy in a charity shop is better than going to a big toy shop full of plastic where you can choose anything. I hope they don't resent me for it.
Luckily it's payday tomorrow!

OP posts:
NotTheGreatGatsy · 27/08/2021 00:56

@Opal93

You don’t sound skint but what i would call you is FRUGAL. You sound sensible and have a good attitude to spending money. I do enjoy this when I get into the mindset as it gives me a sense of control but then I have a blowout(posted before about spending addiction-getting better.) I think it’s a good way to be and a great example for your DC to make the most of what you do have. While you don’t sound like your struggling, £24 pounds could easily have cost way more if you had of paid to go in the house, ate and a more expensive restaurant and let the kids have “anything they wanted” in the sweet shop. Easily £124! Probably more.
Right. But everyone having a massive go at the OP over what is at a basic level semantics is a bit much.

I've lived in damp, freezing houses and often run out of electricity and food before, if that is relevant. It should not be, though.

sessell · 27/08/2021 00:56

Stoic quote: Contentment comes not so much from great wealth as from few wants. EPICTETUS. I agree with you OP. I have a ridiculously low income, enjoy simple pleasures and want for nothing. It makes me richer than high earners who feel they still don't have enough.

Lachimolala · 27/08/2021 00:54

I think you mean frugal, which in itself isn’t a bad thing. It’s very smart actually.

I can honestly say I hate being skint, I’ve got 27p to last me until September 6th. No idea how I’m going to buy food for the kids next week, it’s like this every month and I’m throughly sick of it. It’s no fun being truly skint OP. It’s quite terrifying actually.

NotTheGreatGatsy · 27/08/2021 00:54

icedcoffees
Good god the people on here going on about how 'insensitive' and 'privileged' the OP is when half the posts on here are about how your husband earns £100k but won't pay for shopping, or how the nanny/cleaner/butler has BU, or how your neighbour is a CF for parking over your driveway so you can't get your second car in.

The OP can still be considered insensitive even though other people are more insensitive, though
^

^
Threads about "shall I sack my cleaner?" or "is my high-earning husband financially abusive?" aren't generally met with this level of vitriol against somebody just because their understanding of tjhe word "skint" is different, as it is relative in all circumstances, periods of history and countries. I think the way the OP has been spoken to is very unfair, personally. A lot of the vitriol comes across as bitterness: which I understand as I was desperately broke for many years. But this isn't the place to take it out. Contacting MPs would be a better use of time.

UrbanRambler · 27/08/2021 00:50

Yes, FRUGAL is the word... maybe the title should read "AIBU to be pleased that we had a nice day out, while being frugal?"

Opal93 · 27/08/2021 00:41

You don’t sound skint but what i would call you is FRUGAL. You sound sensible and have a good attitude to spending money. I do enjoy this when I get into the mindset as it gives me a sense of control but then I have a blowout(posted before about spending addiction-getting better.) I think it’s a good way to be and a great example for your DC to make the most of what you do have. While you don’t sound like your struggling, £24 pounds could easily have cost way more if you had of paid to go in the house, ate and a more expensive restaurant and let the kids have “anything they wanted” in the sweet shop. Easily £124! Probably more.

NoNotMeNoSiree · 27/08/2021 00:41

I haven't read all the replies.
Yes, I get where you're coming from it's lovely to be able to spend hardly anything on a budget, isn't it?
So many little cheap and cheerful treats, whether it be a pound football from Poundland, and a picnic at the park.
If you don't have the money for days out, you can adapt and find cheap alternatives to keep them occupied and fed etc.
It becomes seriously tiring, boring, drudging, and monotonous when it's literally your day to day life though!!
Sometimes you'd love something a bit different, like the cinema, or bowling, but just can't.
You remind me of the Pulp song Common People lol.
"Playing" at being poor.
"When you're laying in bed at night, watching roaches climb the wall, you could call your Dad and stop it all...."

Your OP has the same privileged vibe.
So YABU

UrbanRambler · 27/08/2021 00:39

I think the title of this thread is misleading. It sounds like rather than enjoying being "a bit skint", you enjoy the challenge of having an enjoyable day out on a modest budget, and you're pleased that you succeeded in your misson. Mind you, I'm unsure how to word that succinctly for a thread title.

So, YABU for your thread title, but YANBU to feel pleased that you made the most of your low budget day out. People have been a bit harsh on you, IMO, but there are lots of people struggling financially who can barely make ends meet, so some people are bound to be sensitive.

Kanaloa · 27/08/2021 00:16

Also, doing things like hitting supermarkets at different times is often not possible for those who are skint - when I was really skint I would have had to walk two/three miles with a two year old and a buggy to check all the different supermarkets. I had to scrimp my money carefully to go once a week and buy only cheap items that I could afford. And certainly no camping! No way could we have afforded tents and the price of travel to a nice camping spot. We just stayed at home and went to the park/the beach. Often I couldn’t even afford to buy them an ice cream or a bar of chocolate so would pack sandwiches and make up bottles of squash for lunch so they had a picnic.

Kanaloa · 27/08/2021 00:11

Well you aren’t really enjoying being skint because you’re not skint. Skint wouldn’t be affording a lovely house and days out. Skint is counting out change and trying to make the price of bread and milk, or checking the electricity key and hoping £1.10 lasts till next Friday. It’s not that enjoyable.

You’re enjoying budgeting/frugal living, which is very satisfying. I sorted out all my kids wardrobes last month and was pleased with how their clothes have very little wear and can be shared/passed in. I feel I’ve made a little saving as nice things I saved from the older kids now fit the younger ones and I won’t have to buy them again, including boots and winter coats. It’s not the same as being skint though.

XenoBitch · 27/08/2021 00:08

Sounds like you enjoy being frugal. You can be frugal, and still splash the cash if/when you want. If you are proper skint.. there is no option. And that way of living is not fun or enjoyable.

Upsidedownworld21 · 27/08/2021 00:07

I don't understand/get the point of your post...

ohhhhdear · 27/08/2021 00:02

@icedcoffees

Good god the people on here going on about how 'insensitive' and 'privileged' the OP is when half the posts on here are about how your husband earns £100k but won't pay for shopping, or how the nanny/cleaner/butler has BU, or how your neighbour is a CF for parking over your driveway so you can't get your second car in.

The OP can still be considered insensitive even though other people are more insensitive, though.

Also, I don't know why that person is assuming that these are the same two groups of people?

thepeopleversuswork · 26/08/2021 23:57

The OP had a nice day on a modest budget. She has posted about how she had a special day with £24 including lunch for an adult and 2 children. The post was fine, and a good reminder that we don't need to spend a fortune to have a special treat day out.

Yeah that bit was fine.

But posting about enjoying being "skint" when you have what by some people's standards is a generous budget is crashingly insensitive.

And the paeans to the "feeling of joy" about playing at being poor are cringeworthy.

I'm sorry OP as this clearly came from a good place and you sound like a decent person at heart but you don't know what skint means and it comes across as a bit Marie Antoinette.

NotTheGreatGatsy · 26/08/2021 23:51

@Welcometotheterrorzone

I think I am skint. I don't ever have any money at the end of the week. If I had to pay for something today, I wouldn't be able to, my partner wouldn't either, we don't have savings we can access apart from the kids ones which are locked until 18. I think that's skint in many peoples books, not budgeting knowing you've got £800 in the bank. Having to budget so you can have a £25 day out at the end of the summer holidays is hardly flush. We chose this place rather than the wood or park as there was something as there was something of interest in this place for my son and it was his special day.
Ignore this competitive poverty, OP. I get what you mean. In years gone by I had no money for food, gas, electric, rent - it was always a struggle. This thread has all got a bit Four Yorkshiremen.

m.youtube.com/watch?v=ue7wM0QC5LE

Wakeywakey86 · 26/08/2021 20:46

You've got such a hard time for this post!
I get the wording is a little off but I genuinely don't feel you set out to be offensive.
I think it's definitely subjective. I would personally say you were skint. Having no money at all in savings and only £24 for a one off treat in the school holidays with the kids is hardly lavish. I get not everyone can afford to even do that but bloody hell... you've saved up a bit of cash and stretched it as far as it can go for a nice day out and the stick you getting is unreal.
My sister is totally skint too, in debt, but she does try to budget and rejig the outgoings so the kids can have a day at the seaside in the summer... it's a balancing act so her kids don't feel like they miss out 🤷🏼‍♀️

MissTrip82 · 26/08/2021 20:38

Really don’t love the posts dripping with envy over someone who is regularly given free food to feed her children. That’s not something to envy.

Thai turned out to be a very nasty benefit bashing thread really, didn’t it? Those ‘lovely friends’ you like so much but can’t help getting little digs in about.

I preferred it when it just seemed a bit tasteless and lacking in insight.

Oblomov21 · 26/08/2021 20:09

Why is op getting a hard time?
The poster who said she only had £24 for the 6 weeks of the summer holidays? Hmm

AnAnonymousCheerleader · 26/08/2021 20:05

Exactly! I would hate to have to bring my kids up thinking this was a life to aspire to. It isn't! Relying on charity shops and poundstretcher is not something to be proud of

It's nothing to be ashamed of either.

Honeymare · 26/08/2021 19:51

@thebeatingofthedrums explained it so much better than me. It's holding onto the joy of life!

Somethingsnappy · 26/08/2021 19:46

[quote JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil]‘@SisterJude. Wow. You win the award for nastiest comment on the thread.’

Sisterjude was nowhere near as nasty as some others on this thread going out of their way to make a woman who clearly isn’t rolling in it feel bad for having the ‘luxury’ of having 24 whole pounds at the end of the month.

The competitive poverty is what’s nasty. If people want to get into a competition over who’s poorest I’m sure the woman I saw in Tangiers a few years ago who was holding a stray cat, looked skinny as fuck, had all kids of sores on her face, was begging for food from shops and was chased away by a shop owner with a squirty bottle of water is probably worse off than any of the people on this thread.[/quote]
I wasn't particularly referring to nastiness to the OP as such. It was the breezy 'relying on charity shops and poundstretchers is not something to be proud of', that got to me....

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 26/08/2021 19:42

‘The winner to be decided by a panel of nice ladies with darling husbands doing something in the City’

Their husbands also have to have a mysterious ‘hobby’ which is probably just cycling.

AmazinglyGraceless · 26/08/2021 19:40

I know what you mean op and I agree with pp's that you enjoy being frugal.

I'm the same. Having been skint in the past (properly, not having enough to pay the basic bills skint) I also now enjoy being frugal at times.

It gives me a feeling of, I don't know...satisfaction and security, I guess...to get to the end of the month and realise we've not spent as much money as we could have afforded to.

MurielSpriggs · 26/08/2021 19:40

A new Mumsnet jostle for virtue - skintier than thou.

The winner to be decided by a panel of nice ladies with darling husbands doing something in the City Grin

IWantT0BreakFree · 26/08/2021 19:31

I don't think you have any notion of what it is to experience crushing penury.

She didn't say she did. She said she was skint, which to a lot of people just means that money is pretty tight. I would say that having to save £24 over the course of the summer to spend on a single day out with your child in the school holidays is having pretty tight finances.

If you don’t feel like you are losing all your hair from stress then you are absolutely not skint. hmm

Says who? Is that the official definition?

People are beating OP around the head with their own definitions of a word that is just slang. It has no real definition. It only means that someone has limited money, not the extent to which their money is limited. Being a bit skint to most people does not mean "crushing penury" or abject poverty FFS.