Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Where do these evil people come from? Throughout history

106 replies

TerraNovaTwo · 26/08/2021 00:03

...

OP posts:
BrozTito · 28/08/2021 13:09

Well I asked her and she doesn't remember it but is now suggesting radiation. Rostov had around 30 serial killers in 20 years.

NiceGerbil · 27/08/2021 18:32

'Rostov's dearly bought expertise in solving serial killings is now sought after by the rest of the country. The city's killer department is the only one of its kind in Russia. Rostov has twice hosted international conferences on serial murders and social aggression, both organized by Bukhanovsky. Police forces from other regions turn to Bukhanovsky and his colleagues for help in tracking down suspected maniacs.'

I couldn't see anything about the home birth connection?

NiceGerbil · 27/08/2021 18:32

Having a read.

The person they're talking about at the beginning - chikatilo. Was born and grew up in Ukraine. Moved to Rostov on Don in his 20s according to wiki.

BrozTito · 27/08/2021 12:01

Heres an article from before the village home birth theory. Rostov is a huge cossack area which is how the practice developed. www.themoscowtimes.com/archive/a-killers-confidante-in-a-murderous-town

TerraNovaTwo · 27/08/2021 09:07

[quote LoveFall]DH and I watched a documentary series on The Dunedin Study from New Zealand. They have closely followed the study participants for years and learned a lot about nature/nurture.

If you haven't read about the study, here is a link:

dunedinstudy.otago.ac.nz/[/quote]
Seems a far bit of that is down to being born into poverty and inequality. Interesting to note that Dunedin itself is steeped in Scottish highlander (and Maori) heritage.

Nothing wrong with tribalism. Throughout the sands of time, animals 'staying in the pack' has ensured the survival of the species, especially in times of scarcity or threat. The Scots have been most successful with doing this exact thing. As others having pointed out, we are at the heart of it merely animals trying to survive.

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 27/08/2021 02:03

I can also find only one serial killer there.

NiceGerbil · 27/08/2021 02:01

I googled and nothing.

Do you remember what the custom was to make the births go wrong?

Got to admit given birthing with non medical people is hardly unusual around the world and though history and most people aren't serial killers, it seems odd that they would have a custom to fuck it up and that would be the result.

In all honesty it sounds like whose to blame for all this? Bound to be a woman probably mother. I'll have another Google with some other search terms.

I'll bet she didn't say what the outcome was for all the girls being born that way either!

BrozTito · 27/08/2021 01:55

A russian woman doing psychology at university told me about the rostov thing, still talk to her often though so il ask about accessable reading. I think the guardian also did an article about it years ago.

NiceGerbil · 27/08/2021 01:27

[quote Berkeys]@NiceGerbil yes, it’s funny because I know humans are animals too and I have a lot of time for animals. I prefer them probably. Maybe it doesn’t make sense that we have the option to be better but so many don’t take it or prefer to be selfish /ruthless instead. I was raised surrounded mainly by Buddhists so normal society seems hugely messed up and nasty.

I'm not sure art, technology etc makes up for all the suffering we inflict on other species and our own kind. The only times I feel ok about being human is when I see people doing compassionate things like rewilding, saving Afghan street dogs or floating stranded whales. Not enough.[/quote]
I think it makes perfect sense tbh. Sort of been wondering for a while and after a long thread about the animal charity in Afghanistan I think I get it.

Because most people are nice tbh. Well at least not horrible! Why ordinary people are capable of doing hideous things under certain circs. And why others look away/ go along with it.

And why so many people are more moved by an advert with an unhappy kitten than an unhappy baby.

This is just a theory! And even if it's reasonable it won't be everyone.

I think it's to do with being too close. Humans doing this to humans. All of the sickening things in the news every day. From local towns to other countries. And what can we do about it? Not much really. And it's us, our species doing this. And the scale esp now wall to wall news is impossible to take in.

How has this happened? Why are they doing this? Has it been made worse by countries that are our allies? It's complicated and horrific and it's everywhere and so people just.. push it away.

A gorgeous kitten or lovely dog well that's easy. They're innocent, it's nothing to do with them, helping is much more straightforward.

The fact that they too are animals and left to their own devices are pretty dangerous. Stray dogs forming packs are really scary and dangerous. Cats are serious highly successful predators.

But I mean I don't think that when I see a cat. I go all soppy.

It does bother me a bit tbh when people seem to genuinly see animals as more vulnerable and innocent than human babies. Cats and dogs are less vulnerable. They survive in all sorts of circs. Human baby can't look after itself at all. I like to think IRL that wouldn't be the action taken should the situation arise.

NiceGerbil · 27/08/2021 01:13

@BrozTito

Rostov on Don is very famous for producing serial killers. Studies suggested home births carried out badly in the local area as is custom causes brain damage so more killers
Do you have a link? Google gives me zero!

Home births or ones attended by people other than docs etc have been the vast majority through history etc. I have heard of one place where the custom is for the woman to go off by herself into the woods and give birth.

So yes fascinating link please!

hiplip · 27/08/2021 01:11

Anyone can be evil. Look at The Stanford Prison Experiment. Darkness lurks within all of us.

NiceGerbil · 27/08/2021 01:09

Ooh lead!

There is apparently a correlation between lead in petrol and 'delinquent' behaviour in young people in areas with more pollution.

Certainly young people seem way less reckless etc than when I was young!

Not sure where I read that.

NiceGerbil · 27/08/2021 01:07

I'm finding it all interesting as well.

No dictators carried out all the atrocities by themselves. They had large numbers of people supporting them. Helping with strategy. Carrying out the actual cruelty on the ground. Looking people in the eye while they did it.

I think it's just so much easier to imagine they were sort of inhuman almost.

Interesting that two posters have cited mothers as contributing to their appalling behaviour!

This putting it down to home births that were carried out badly which is the custom is interesting going to Google!

Marmaladeagain · 27/08/2021 01:03

Yes contentious. Went to Derbyshire mine and interesting to learn about the lead poisoning etc the article attached talks about romans having much higher than modern safe levels but says contentious.

Either way some grim stories. Being in pain can cause people to behave out of character so there must have been lots in a bad mood ?! No expert, but I like to have some Nurofen in my bag and not yet been driven to murder anyone.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-29568505

Berkeys · 27/08/2021 00:44

There’s a lot of othering going on here. Syphilis, brain damage, citing big names etc. But we’re all a little bit like that and some just more than others. How much responsibility are people taking for their own behaviours and ethics day to day?

Berkeys · 27/08/2021 00:41

@NiceGerbil yes, it’s funny because I know humans are animals too and I have a lot of time for animals. I prefer them probably. Maybe it doesn’t make sense that we have the option to be better but so many don’t take it or prefer to be selfish /ruthless instead. I was raised surrounded mainly by Buddhists so normal society seems hugely messed up and nasty.

I'm not sure art, technology etc makes up for all the suffering we inflict on other species and our own kind. The only times I feel ok about being human is when I see people doing compassionate things like rewilding, saving Afghan street dogs or floating stranded whales. Not enough.

BrozTito · 27/08/2021 00:38

Rostov on Don is very famous for producing serial killers. Studies suggested home births carried out badly in the local area as is custom causes brain damage so more killers

LoveFall · 27/08/2021 00:34

DH and I watched a documentary series on The Dunedin Study from New Zealand. They have closely followed the study participants for years and learned a lot about nature/nurture.

If you haven't read about the study, here is a link:

dunedinstudy.otago.ac.nz/

Ionlydomassiveones · 27/08/2021 00:29

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

BrozTito · 27/08/2021 00:28

The whole roman lead downfall thing was interesting but now also discredited. The behaviour from those lot comes from exageration of biased historians of the time like Suetonius mostly but also family dysfunction, being spoilt and the belief they're continuations of the olymian pantheon id imagine.

LoveFall · 27/08/2021 00:26

It seems to me that many people who have done truly evil things have an antisocial personality disorder. That, combined with trauma in their upbringing, and a tendency towards narcissism add up to someone who will stop at nothing to satisfy their impulses and gain influence and power.

Marmaladeagain · 27/08/2021 00:19

Yes interesting I often wonder if pain led to more violent behaviour in general in the past and bad decisions.

Bit of blood letting being offered etc not going to help.

Lead poisoning certainly led to a few poor decisions (understatement ) blogs.transparent.com/latin/the-madness-of-the-emperors-nero-i/

www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-02476-w

Interesting short read attached about syphilis and observations that it led to shame about sex with the mental disease - says that a third of patients in institutions could have had it looking back at records being discussed.

Never been to Luton, thanks for the heads up 👍

BrozTito · 27/08/2021 00:17

No evidence at all that Hitler had syphilis. He didnt use meth until the 40s either. He did however almost certainly really have only one ball and came from jewish ancestry-'Hiddler'. He was rejected by a jewish woman and didnt seem to develop anti semitism until post WW1. Also some plausable rumours he was a communist briefly before swinging far right.

BrozTito · 27/08/2021 00:09

Culloden isnt particularly evil? Unless we're going for the SNP wrerite version

BrozTito · 27/08/2021 00:05

Bony, Stalin and Hitler all had zeal of the convert, ie.stalin was georgian, hitler austrian, bony corsican/italian but supported nationalism of dominant other countries. Bony possibly & Hitler and Stalin certainly had typical supposed oedipal complexities with pissed abusive fathers and overbearing idolised mothers. All 3 supported ideologies in which the inside groups overides and excuses anything towards its greater purpose.

Swipe left for the next trending thread