Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

2nd Thread: friend wants to move in for a 'few months'

970 replies

islandhoppin · 25/08/2021 23:11

As continued from my previous thread.

OP posts:
FartleBarfle · 26/08/2021 08:23

@FOJN I'm glad you said this as that was my exact thinking when I read the post saying she needed to explain more. No. Respect people's boundaries, don't expect an explanation!

Tirediam · 26/08/2021 08:23

OP I had a “friend” like this, she was my best friend for many years and it took her being shitty to me over the course of a few weeks for the veil to fall and for me to finally see her for who she was. Your friend has done you a favour, although it won’t seem like it now. I’ve heard my former friend has lost many friends due to her entitled behaviour and I imagine yours will too.
Your friends boyfriend sounds like a delight as well doesnt he … 🤨

Howshouldibehave · 26/08/2021 08:20

She sounds really hard work. How long have you known her and has she really been a good friend?

Sally872 · 26/08/2021 08:20

Hopefully friend will realise she is unreasonable. If she doesn't you have done nothing wrong, don't feel bad about it.

steppemum · 26/08/2021 08:19

Just read both threads.
This is not normal behaviour from her.
It is unreasonable to exepct to move in with a friend like this, especially with a dog and partner, and at the same time to say - I can't afford to pay you!

Most people would not even ask.
The only way we would do this is if someone is in crisis, like leaving an abusive relationship. Then of course you would be there for your friend. But this is nothing like that.

Don't be tempted to give in. She is being manipulative because she has not got what she wants. That is her problem, not yours.

Beautiful3 · 26/08/2021 08:18

She's trying to manipulate you, by guilt tripping you. I'm glad you didn't give in! Stand firm. Just ignore all messages until she stops talking about it. To be honest it's different if she asked to move in temporarily, but she's not. She's asking to move in with a boyfriend and a dog! That's alot to ask of someone.

Window1 · 26/08/2021 08:17

Has this behaviour come out of the blue from your friend or have you seen traits like this before? Does her family and partner now to her every demand? Is she a bit of a spoilt brat?

VetInAVat · 26/08/2021 08:16

Sounds like you're well rid. Stay strong

Mrgrinch · 26/08/2021 08:12

Just remember if the friendship is ruined, that's on her not you.

BeckyWithTheGoodHair5629456 · 26/08/2021 08:12

I hope you don't hear another peep out of her. I am afraid you probably will though she doesn't seem to want to take no for an answer. Well done for staying strong!

Angliski · 26/08/2021 08:11

@daisychain01

Let her spit her dummy out all she likes, just because you've said no to what now seems increasingly like a demand not a light hearted request.

She sounds unhinged to quote a favourite MN word. It isn't your responsibility to fix whatever her issue is. You're a friend, not her therapist or housing support officer. She's burdening you excessively and inappropriately.

This.

Not sure what part of ‘no’ she doesn’t understand but you cannot have the cf anywhere near you.

kittycluck · 26/08/2021 08:08

If she was a true friend she would respect your wishes. I'd feel mortified. And shame on her family for pushing her into asking to stay at yours. Why can't she stay with them?
You have definately made the right decision. Stick with it!

cameocat · 26/08/2021 08:04

I know she is your best friend but I don't think her behaviour is thoughtful or caring towards you at all. Is she always this selfish?

Daisylg · 26/08/2021 08:02

Wow!! Completely agree with you and everyone else! I wouldn’t be replying or if I did it would be a simple

‘ do not emotionally black mail me. This is not your moment of need, you do not NEED to move out, live in your home while
You sell it like 99% of people do? You both have family, it is not my job to house you all free of charge. My answer will not be changing, the way you are acting is disgraceful.’

Honestly the brass neck of some people, I cannot imagine being told no and arguing why they should change their mind Blush

Hope today is a better day for you Flowers

toobusytothink · 26/08/2021 08:02

Please don’t feel you have to justify your decision op. I can’t believe she left a voice message after all your replies. As if that would make you change your mind. Ignore ignore ignore. If she comes round don’t let her in - she will have a sob story ready. Afraid the friendship is ruined anyway so nothing to lose

messybun101 · 26/08/2021 07:57

She's utterly horrible. It's so sad when friends show colours you'd never expect

MaggieFS · 26/08/2021 07:55

Hopefully you can empty your head a bit today. Go for a walk or something if you can and come to terms with the fact this is NOT your problem and you don't have to do anything further. Decision is made. The ball is in her court if she wants to behave like a friend again or not.
Hope you have a peaceful day.

FOJN · 26/08/2021 07:53

You haven’t really responded to her arguments though which is potentially why she doesn’t understand.

The OP is not obliged to explain why she does not want housemates, it's not a negotiation. The CF could easily argue that the OP is concerned about things which wouldn't bother her, for her to understand would require her to view the OP's concerns as valid, she does not.
Boundaries belong to us, they are not obstacles to be negotiated out of the way by CF determined to get their own way. If CF doesn't understand the word no that's her problem, not the OP's.

Keep going OP, you're doing really well. I'm sorry your "friend" is behaving this way. If the friendship can be salvaged after this then at least your friend will know your boundaries are not up for discussion. I wouldn't personally mourn the loss of a friend who had so little respect for me.

islandhoppin · 26/08/2021 07:53

Morning everyone, thanks for your kind messages!
Must admit it took a while to drop off last night, like a PP said, I just had so much swimming around my head.
I hope she's got the message now.. I've not had any further communication from her so far!

OP posts:
WillyWallyWonker · 26/08/2021 07:45

Glad you stayed strong OP it's very difficult when someone tries to emotionally blackmail you

LAgeDeRaisin · 26/08/2021 07:45

her dog has pissed on all of the carpets. There are 4 months of dishes in the kitchen similar to the opening scene of 'Withnail and I'. Someone has done a turd in the bath and no one will admit to it so no one has cleaned it up. There are fag ends floating in off milk and none of the lightbulbs work. There's a huge dead rat that they've called Piggy and it has been mounted on a post in the hallway like William Golding's shit first draft. There are 2 used condoms on the front path and one of them has been blown up and fashioned into a sort of talisman mascot for the house with a face drawn on the front and hair taken from the matt clogging up the broken shower

She wants to take all of these items and habits to your house so that they don't impact her sale

I would like to amend my previous reasoning above to include:
A new place for 6 months will cost £800/month in rent
£120/month in wifi, gas, electric, water, council tax
£15/month in parking
£250/month in eating your food
£10,000 in the increase in sale value from removal of Piggy, the nut job and the turd
£5000 for her half paying for a lifetime of therapy for her old house mate

All in all, 6 months of this move will earn her £22,110

She has likely already spent this money on magic beans, or at the races, in anticipation of your acceptance. Now, in her mind, you owe her £22,110 and an apology.

Pipsquiggle · 26/08/2021 07:42

Well done OP. So glad you said no and her behaviour since has proved you were right to do.

What I find really weird:
*She won't to tell you in any detail why she needs a place to stay, particularly as her current house isn't on the market.
*She is not even remotely specific on timings.
*She wanted to stay with you rent free - complete cheeky fuckery.
*Her expectation that you will just say 'yes' to this ridiculous plan is staggering - she is insane

As others have said, if she keeps emotionally blackmailing you, maybe get DP to step in. Do not waste any more emotional energy or time on this

LookItsMeAgain · 26/08/2021 07:41

@islandhoppin - I hope you were able to get some sleep last night. I can only imagine the amount of ideas that would have been swimming around in your brain as you try to unwind and relax when you have this cheeky fucker (I'm not going to abbreviate as she really deserves the full words here) putting so much pressure on you.

I still stand by my suggestion to have a script ready if she decides to ring/show up.
If she is so brazen (and at this point, nothing she would do would shock me) to show up in tears at your front door, do not let her in. Get your DP to deal with her.
Have the script ready though. The answer is still no. It will always be no. And if the friendship ends, it is entirely of her doing.

In my opinion (for whatever that is worth) you are 1000% doing the right thing.

notanothertakeaway · 26/08/2021 07:40

@MadameMonk

Much as we might all speculate on this thread about what’s being left out of your friend’s story, I’d strongly advise you (and your DP) not to look into that or ask further questions. Anything other than a firm repeat of the basic boundary you’ve now set can (and no doubt will) be taken as a new opportunity to harangue you or escalate the sob story.

Boundaries are walls. You set them up, alert anyone who needs to know that it’s there, then walk away from your side of the wall back to your life. Don’t hang around your wall, getting worn down hearing the toddler wailing happening on the other side.

And any flying monkeys who pop over the wall to slyly scope the gossip or pressure you? They get the same short shrift. I use the sentence ‘Actually I’ve decided that topic is closed, I won’t be discussing it any more.’ Said in a calm, casual tone. Then change the subject or end the conversation.

I’d also be quickly planning some urgent house repairs/renovations to strengthen my resolve. Not cos I had to, just to give my boundary extra ‘bricks’. If you stop thinking of your home as having ‘spare rooms’, maybe others will too. They aren’t spare, they are exactly as occupied and useful as you want and need them to be. Rename them, redecorate them. You could probably use a meditation area with your current issues? Paint one red and hang a sex swing in it? That’ll send a couple of different messages to anyone hoping to stay. Grin

I love the analogy of a wall
Boombadoom · 26/08/2021 07:33

You haven’t really responded to her arguments though which is potentially why she doesn’t understand.

‘Dogs are not allowed upstairs in this house so that wouldn’t work I’m afraid’
‘We cannot afford to feed you and house you for free’
‘We want / need our own space and having you and it appears you DP here is not conducive to that’
‘I am not a selfish person inherently but I know that it will impact me negatively, I am a good friend and I hope you understand that I need to think of myself right now’.

She is trying to take advantage of you and is a complete CF. Get rid.