Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why we have now got rid of isolation for household members?

219 replies

AlexaShutUp · 25/08/2021 22:29

Sorry if there is already a thread on this, but isn't it a bit crazy to be sending children into school when their parents and/or siblings have tested positive for covid?Confused

I totally get that the pinging was getting too much and I am OK with a lot of rules being relaxed as we have to get back to some kind of normality at some stage, but surely it isn't unreasonable for members of the same household to carry on isolating. Isn't it going to spread like wildfire as soon as schools open up?

It just seems crazy...

OP posts:
Flowers2020bloom · 26/08/2021 04:50

My dcs are due back to school in 4 hours - youngest has woken up with a temp and there is no way I'm going to send my eldest in today. We have PCR tests booked for 8am and hopefully they will be negative but for me, it's not worth the risk of infecting a whole class on their first day back. Will be interested to see what school say when I phone as in theory the eldest should go in but they have spent the last six weeks together practically all day every day so if the youngest has got it then the eldest has at least been exposed. DH will still need to go to work as he's on the exempt list due to occupation but I wouldn't be over the moon if I was one of his colleagues!

UsedUpUsername · 26/08/2021 04:47

But masks aren’t to do with fear. They’re as sensible, if not more sensible than sanitising. If you’re happy to sanitise why not wear a mask and have distancing in place in certain a settings? Sanitiser doesn’t prevent airborne transmission

Neither do masks, at least the kind most ppl wear

a8mint · 26/08/2021 04:36

Her consultant rang me this week to inform me that if she has them we need to go directly to the hospital where they are based (15 miles away) rather than the nearest A&E (2 miles away) because they won't have capacity for her at A&E.

You realise many people dont live within 15miles of any a&e?

PurpleOkapi · 26/08/2021 04:34

@Babamamananarama

Wading in here with my CEV perspective (just undergone 6 months of very gruelling chemo for lymphoma and just out of a month in hospital for a stem cell transplant, which destroyed my immune system with extremely strong chemo and made me grow a new one from scratch like a newborn). I have probably no immunity despite being double jabbed; if I caught covid in my very weakened condition it could easily carry me off. I'm a mother of two age 5 and 7, and in a couple of weeks I have to send my kids back to school knowing all safeguards are gone. I can shield (at the expense of my income and my MH, for how long?) but I can't avoid the possibility of my kids catching it at school and bringing it home to me and landing me in hospital or worse.

How do I 'learn to live with it' please, if no one is willing to make any concessions for the the fact that we still have very high rates of an endemic airborne virus which exhibits nearly 100% transmission rate between household contacts?

Not sure where you live, but in many places, online instruction is an option for children. Homeschooling is also an option in the UK. You have the ability to control who your children spend time with. If you choose to allow them near others whose covid status you can't determine, you're choosing to accept a certain level of risk by doing that. I wouldn't do it if I were you, but the choice is yours.
Sunnyfreezesushi · 26/08/2021 04:05

A recent ONS survey showed that over 90
per cent of adults have antibodies to Covid here. So it isn’t a novel virus anymore in our population. It may be better for it to circulate “mildly” continuously as a natural booster in the population. I don’t know how many children have antibodies already/some immunity but it is probably much higher than one would assume.
I think all CEV adults and children should be tested regularly (if they want) to check what immunity they may or may not have and be protected by eg employment laws if they need to shield.

Trinacham · 26/08/2021 03:09

YANBU

I've tested positive, DH negative on PCRs, when we both had positive LFTs. I don't think he puts the swab far enough. I'm worried about him returning to work. I think the isolation should continue for household members. Even if they weren't positive at the time, they are likely to catch it!

WaterIsBest · 26/08/2021 02:26

Again,
So many selfish people on here!

Hellotoallmyfans · 26/08/2021 02:14

You honestly don't understand the reasons why we need to get rid of isolation for people who aren't sick? Okaaaaay then.....

(Though I suspect this OP is posting with faux naivety as they are a regular poster on the covid boards..)

HappyDays40 · 26/08/2021 02:03

Ill LFT each day.

HappyDays40 · 26/08/2021 02:03

We are just waiting on PCR tests. My husband did a LFT last night which was positive mine was negative and I have symptoms but have done a PCR as I work with CEV children.
Got annual leave starting Monday to take our child on a family holiday poor child has been in holiday club all summer a needs a holiday before starting back at school. If im negative and my husband is positive my son and I will go to our self contained accommodation and he can join us later.

CirqueDeMorgue · 26/08/2021 00:26

@Babamamananarama sorry you've had such a shit time but if you have no immunity, are you not worried about other viruses that your DC could bring home?

Babamamananarama · 26/08/2021 00:19

Wading in here with my CEV perspective (just undergone 6 months of very gruelling chemo for lymphoma and just out of a month in hospital for a stem cell transplant, which destroyed my immune system with extremely strong chemo and made me grow a new one from scratch like a newborn). I have probably no immunity despite being double jabbed; if I caught covid in my very weakened condition it could easily carry me off. I'm a mother of two age 5 and 7, and in a couple of weeks I have to send my kids back to school knowing all safeguards are gone. I can shield (at the expense of my income and my MH, for how long?) but I can't avoid the possibility of my kids catching it at school and bringing it home to me and landing me in hospital or worse.

How do I 'learn to live with it' please, if no one is willing to make any concessions for the the fact that we still have very high rates of an endemic airborne virus which exhibits nearly 100% transmission rate between household contacts?

Woolver23 · 26/08/2021 00:17

It makes no sense whatsoever that an unvaccinated 17 year old does not have to isolate after contact, but a single vaccinated and recent Covid patient (like DD19) would still have to isolate after contact until they've been able to get her second jab.
The rules have got so piecemeal and tangled as they've evolved that they make no sense anymore, to anyone with half a brain.

JesusIsAnyNameFree · 25/08/2021 23:50

@AlexaShutUp

What does it mean when people say learn to live with it? For me, that means things mostly getting back to normal but still taking sensible precautions like isolating household members. For some people, learning to live with it seems to mean pretending that the virus no longer exists?
Yeah, that's exactly what it means to people, unfortunately.

This pandemic has really changed the way I view other people.

AlexaShutUp · 25/08/2021 23:48

[quote Sweettea1]@Alexashutup Sorry I read it wrong I thought you was saying child was at home with covid not a family member at home. Yes I agree I think if households should still isolate if 1 member has it.[/quote]
So we agree. 👍

OP posts:
AlexaShutUp · 25/08/2021 23:46

[quote Lou98]@Sweettea1 as she explained, it's not the child that has covid. Someone in the child's household has covid but the child is allowed to go to school under these rules and is in her DDs class[/quote]
Yes, that's what I'm trying to say, thank you.

Fwiw, I'm not criticising the child's family as they are just following the new rules. I just don't agree with the rules.

OP posts:
Clocktopus · 25/08/2021 23:46

Or so that if/when they need to reintroduce restrictions over the winter they can blame it on people being reckless now - Boris fucking Johnson wibbling on TV that "we told you all to be cautious..."

Sweettea1 · 25/08/2021 23:46

@Alexashutup Sorry I read it wrong I thought you was saying child was at home with covid not a family member at home. Yes I agree I think if households should still isolate if 1 member has it.

Watermelon40 · 25/08/2021 23:45

I think they want it to spread now while most people have some coverage from the vaccine to gain some extra protection for this winter.

BluebellsGreenbells · 25/08/2021 23:43

COVID at home means the child has family members who’ve tested positive and isolating but the child attends schools having been exposed to the virus ans being a close contact and sitting next to OPs daughter.

Lou98 · 25/08/2021 23:43

@Sweettea1 as she explained, it's not the child that has covid. Someone in the child's household has covid but the child is allowed to go to school under these rules and is in her DDs class

AlexaShutUp · 25/08/2021 23:43

@Sweettea1

I do agree if a household member has covid then household should isolate I think there is more chance catching it then. I don't think bill from the back of the classroom should isolate because sue from the front tested positive tho.
That's not what I'm saying though. I'm saying that Bill from the back of the classroom should isolate when there is a positive case in his household in order to reduce the risk of Sue and his other classmates getting the virus and all having to isolate further down the line.
OP posts:
Sweettea1 · 25/08/2021 23:41

@Lou98 The child with covid still has to isolate so won't be at school untill isolation period ends. The rest off the class can still go to school.

BluebellsGreenbells · 25/08/2021 23:41

The biggest issue is people don’t understand what isolation actually means. Some are letting kids play together and sending the other child to school. (I know that’s difficult to separate one, but that surely should be a “rule”)

The other issue is if kids get COVID then the parents need to be at home to look after them, meaning school teachers won’t eagle to wrk anyway.

What the government are trying to do, is make employers responsible for works, so the must pay for isolation (or not) they should pay for LFT if they want them, they must accommodate parents who’s children are ill etc

DH work place insist WFH is there’s COVID at home, they also insist on LFT twice weekly, they also have banned those returning fro abroad retuning to the office without negative LFT/PCR test etc

Others will follow.

AlexaShutUp · 25/08/2021 23:40

Not happy with what? The child being at home sick away from others or that your child can still go to school

Not happy with my dd very likely being sat in close contact in a poorly ventilated room with someone who lives in a household where someone has covid and is therefore at a high risk of transmitting the virus. It seems an unnecessary risk to me.

If dh or I got covid and dd had to isolate to protect other people, I would be perfectly happy with that. If the virus rips through schools, it's likely that lots of the kids will end up having to take time off in any case. I would rather that a kid isolates when household members test positive than wait for them all to get sick.

OP posts: