Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why we have now got rid of isolation for household members?

219 replies

AlexaShutUp · 25/08/2021 22:29

Sorry if there is already a thread on this, but isn't it a bit crazy to be sending children into school when their parents and/or siblings have tested positive for covid?Confused

I totally get that the pinging was getting too much and I am OK with a lot of rules being relaxed as we have to get back to some kind of normality at some stage, but surely it isn't unreasonable for members of the same household to carry on isolating. Isn't it going to spread like wildfire as soon as schools open up?

It just seems crazy...

OP posts:
GreenWillow · 26/08/2021 07:43

@Awalkintime

Bizawit So you mean parents should send their kids into school with it because that is what most of them do with colds/flu/sickness?
Yes.
GreenWillow · 26/08/2021 07:42

@motherrunner

I’m a teacher and come start of term there will be no ‘Covid secure’ measures in place, just the ‘back to school’ LFT (if parents consent).

On the flip side will parents be happy knowing I will be teaching their child (and hundreds other) with positive contacts at home? (I have 2 primary DS and a teacher DH) I could be a ‘super spreader’!

The director of PHE for my area has requested people still wears masks in enclosed spaces. Socially distance and take regular tests, as a 1000 people tested positive last week in my area. All the things I can not do in school.

Yes, of course they’ll be happy.

DC are very unlikely to become seriously ill if infected, and vulnerable people should be taking measures to protect themselves.

Awalkintime · 26/08/2021 07:42

Bizawit
So you mean parents should send their kids into school with it because that is what most of them do with colds/flu/sickness?

Bizawit · 26/08/2021 07:37

@AlexaShutUp

What does it mean when people say learn to live with it? For me, that means things mostly getting back to normal but still taking sensible precautions like isolating household members. For some people, learning to live with it seems to mean pretending that the virus no longer exists?
I think for most people, learning to live with it means treating it like any other infectious virus. Are children kept home/ isolated when one of their household members has a cold/ the flu?
Imnothereforthedrama · 26/08/2021 07:36

Why is it crazy though ? We’ve got used to that Covid is so dangerous every day we see threads on people that are double vaccinated reasonably well are worried because they have tested positive because that’s what the media have terrified them. We’ve been in this pandemic for more than 18 months I’m more surprised that some have managed to avoid it . If the majority are vaccinated and all adults have been offered it why would we need to keep isolating at this stage?

Heathofhares · 26/08/2021 07:30

Its madness household not having to isolate. There seems to be this idea from the government that the infectd person will isolate within their household. Keeping to their own room and bathroom and having meals delivered.

But in reality this is hardly ever happening. In our case the first person infected was a small child. No parent is going to be able to isolate from a small child - especially if they are ill. Once recovered and stuck home for 10 days do we say that the child cannot play with parents or siblings? Then of course the small matter that most homes don’t just have spare rooms and spare bathrooms to make up a covid isolation suite...

But then the rest of the family have gone down with it in the the classic 5 day intervals...

As it happened DH is WFH and the rest of us are on summer holidays so we did just isolate as a family. But from next week I would have been expected to be back in work ( as a teacher) despite a covid positive pre schooler at home!

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 26/08/2021 07:24

DD was back at school yesterday in year 3, cases in our postcode are 532.2/100,000 which is way above average.

I will be interested to see what happens to case rates and hospitalisations over the next couple of weeks.

We haven't had the Covid risk assessment/plan for school yet but based on what we've seen from yesterday they are keeping some aspects of the bubble principle and ditching others.

So they are still eating lunch in classrooms not the hall, but they can play outside with the other classes at break and lunch, they have re-instated class trips and swimming lessons which were all cancelled last school year. Not sure what is happening with assemblies.

Parents are not required to wear masks when doing drop off or pick up but teachers are still wearing masks if they want to when moving around the school.

No one seems to be being encouraged to do lateral flow tests, last school year parents were being asked to do them (not on the kids) to see if there was Covid in the household.

Scotland is showing a big rise in cases since the kids went back there, Leicester/Leicestershire went back this week so keep an eye out on cases here to see what the rest of the country is likely to see by end of September.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 26/08/2021 07:24

@SuperCaliFragalistic

What's crazy is the country remaining in a state of semi lockdown when the majority are fully vaccinated. If you're ill - stay home. If you're not ill - go to work/school/uni etc.
Except that 30 per cent of infected people are asymptomatic... They may pass it to me/anyone acv.....
Jemand · 26/08/2021 07:23

*Do you stay off work if someone in your house has a sickness bug (but you are otherwise well?) Or if your child has chicken pox does everyone stay home?""

Most people have either had CP or been vaccinated against it, and for most people that gives lifelong immunity. Neither vaccination nor having had Covid give that.

It's really odd that we are viewing 140 deaths a day as good news. If there were a one train crash causing that many deaths there would be endless inquiries, we'd probably close down the railways if there were one a day.

Bryonyshcmyony · 26/08/2021 07:23

Making whole families isolate meant that less people tested.

Bryonyshcmyony · 26/08/2021 07:22

@Lifeispassingby

I don’t understand these rules either. I cannot believe that I could go to work (in a job with no social distancing and I mix with a lot of colleagues and public), go to the gym, cinema, out for dinner etc etc whilst my family are at home with covid!! Then the next day test positive myself having spread it everywhere I’ve been for the last 2 days before!! Gradually going to spread through my workplace and lead to potential staff issues and staff off over longer term than 10days isolation. I understand we are learning to live with this virus etc etc but this is particularly contagious one and can kill people ( I know other virus can do that too). Even those vaccinated are ending up in hospital with it. I think some people have more fear now than ever
I don't have fear, but I also wouldn't do all those things you have listed either if my dcs tested positive. I'd try and stay out of people's way as much as possible, but I wouldn't hide at home for 10 days if I tested negative.
AlexaShutUp · 26/08/2021 07:21

@Hellotoallmyfans

You honestly don't understand the reasons why we need to get rid of isolation for people who aren't sick? Okaaaaay then.....

(Though I suspect this OP is posting with faux naivety as they are a regular poster on the covid boards..)

No faux naivety at all. Yes, I post on the covid boards sometimes, but I genuinely don't understand why we can't retain the self isolation for household contacts. It makes no sense to me.
OP posts:
Bryonyshcmyony · 26/08/2021 07:20

@newnortherner111

Why? I think it is because Mr Johnson is beholden to those backbenchers in his party who want no restrictions, and is unwilling to discuss proposals with opposition parties and find common ground. As there are some companies who want people back in the office (usually because the CEO or MD wants to be there primarily I expect), then the fewer children not in school, the better.
I think lots of the population want fewer restrictions and children back in school, unless we genuinely need to lockdown again due to a new variant.
Lifeispassingby · 26/08/2021 07:19

I don’t understand these rules either. I cannot believe that I could go to work (in a job with no social distancing and I mix with a lot of colleagues and public), go to the gym, cinema, out for dinner etc etc whilst my family are at home with covid!! Then the next day test positive myself having spread it everywhere I’ve been for the last 2 days before!! Gradually going to spread through my workplace and lead to potential staff issues and staff off over longer term than 10days isolation. I understand we are learning to live with this virus etc etc but this is particularly contagious one and can kill people ( I know other virus can do that too). Even those vaccinated are ending up in hospital with it. I think some people have more fear now than ever

Watermelon40 · 26/08/2021 07:19

I think it’s mad too.

But in our hospital we still have to isolate if a household member is positive.

And if we are a contact of someone who is positive (non household) we need a negative pcr and daily lfts before going in.

ZoBo123 · 26/08/2021 07:18

[quote sorrysaywhatnow]@SuperCaliFragalistic I get that, and you're right absolutely...but people don't die from sickness bugs. I just really worry about all the unvaccinated/immunosuppressed people that are at risk still.[/quote]
Lots of vulnerable, particularly elderly people die of norovirus every year. It closes hospitals very regularly. But we don't all stay home if someone in the family is sick and the rest are fine

newnortherner111 · 26/08/2021 07:17

Why? I think it is because Mr Johnson is beholden to those backbenchers in his party who want no restrictions, and is unwilling to discuss proposals with opposition parties and find common ground. As there are some companies who want people back in the office (usually because the CEO or MD wants to be there primarily I expect), then the fewer children not in school, the better.

Morph2lcfc · 26/08/2021 07:12

“I certainly wouldn't go into the office if others in my household had norovirus or similar... that would be incredibly selfish.”

It would never have occurred to me before reading this and before COVID to stay off work if I wasn’t ill but others in the household were, except if I had to look after a child of course which is holiday or unpaid leave. Did people genuinely used to stay off before, was it a done thing? Is it claimed as sick leave if you aren’t sick or holiday/unpaid leave?

Ghekotastic · 26/08/2021 07:08

YANBU and I'm glad household contacts here in Scotland still have to isolate until a negative pcr. I would not be happy having colleagues with positive partners /kids coming into work where we work in extremely close contact.
It's all very well saying you're vaccinated, get on with it, but lots of us have vulnerable family members and its looking increasingly likely that the vaccines do not work very well at all for the most vulnerable /immunocompromised.

motherrunner · 26/08/2021 07:07

I’m a teacher and come start of term there will be no ‘Covid secure’ measures in place, just the ‘back to school’ LFT (if parents consent).

On the flip side will parents be happy knowing I will be teaching their child (and hundreds other) with positive contacts at home? (I have 2 primary DS and a teacher DH) I could be a ‘super spreader’!

The director of PHE for my area has requested people still wears masks in enclosed spaces. Socially distance and take regular tests, as a 1000 people tested positive last week in my area. All the things I can not do in school.

DiscoDown21 · 26/08/2021 07:01

I think it’s madness. But I work in a hospital and we still have to isolate for household contacts.

Bryonyshcmyony · 26/08/2021 06:59

I think less people would bother getting vaccinated if they see that you still have to isolate despite being double jabbed.

I have a friend on Facebook who is CEV. She posts daily begging people not to gather in large groups, to still wear masks when out and about, not to go abroad, "just because you can doesn't mean you should" its a pita and I've unfollowed her.

spaceghetto · 26/08/2021 06:55

My friend and her family have tested positive, all double jabbed. We were in close proximity with them but we don't have to self isolate? We will be, i'd hate to carry on as normal and spread it around.

GreenWillow · 26/08/2021 06:48

@AlexaShutUp

I’d rather live with some precautions so others can live with a little less fear.

Totally agree.

This isn’t how our society works though - We have to cater to the needs of the (non-vulnerable) majority.

It’s pretty entitled to expect the majority of people to accept limitations on their freedom to accommodate you, when you are in the minority.

I’d totally support vulnerable individuals in any efforts they may wish to take to shield themselves/their families, but not if it means restricting the civil liberties of the majority.

Gingerlovesbiscuits · 26/08/2021 06:07

OP I absolutely agree that it’s madness and likely to cause much more disruption as sill spread like wildfire, especially in schools. Living with it should not mean abanding all sensible precautions designed to protect human life.

For every other health risk we take appropriate steps to reduce the risk. Why not Covid? We wear seatbelts in cars, helmets on bikes, condoms to prevent HIV, vaccines to prevent other diseases, nets to prevent malaria etc. Yet Covid has become so politicised (with some very well funded disinformation campaigns) that we have ended up in this very dangerous position.

Isolation for household contacts should definitely still be in place as should masks in busy indoor areas (including schools). As a family we are still masking indoors and the kids will still be wearing them in school. Since Delta we have also upgraded our masks to N95/FPP2 masks. We still live our lives to the full we just take precautions.