Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the old style pensions should be capped.

618 replies

Blindering · 25/08/2021 16:17

ok, I am in Ireland so unaware of how UK pensions function but my neighbour who worked as a college lecturer but retired in 2008 in his 70s gets 600 euro a week in pension, equivalent to 513 stg.
This is on top of a 150k pay off he got when he left the job which I believe all civil servants here were getting.

But aibu to think a bachelor living in a house with the mortgage long paid off has no need for over 500stg a week? Like what would one need the money for at that stage in life?

OP posts:
sst1234 · 25/08/2021 17:55

@Marcee

If think printing money is the solution to all problems, that’s a scary lack of knowledge.

NoSquirrels · 25/08/2021 17:55

@Blindering

''Seriously loads have mortgages in their 70s. How naive,''

I can't think of 1 person.

It doesn’t matter, though. A mortgage or housing payment is just one cost. You still have to fund all the other costs of living - and if you own a property you need to pay to maintain it too. Having paid off the mortgage is not a golden ticket to great wealth and riches in retirement. It just makes it a bit easier.
titchy · 25/08/2021 17:54

But my pension entitlement has been cut. And will be cut again over my working life. No, I don't like it, but it would certainly seem fairer if all USS beneficiaries shared the pain. Why must the younger generation work to fund final salary pensions they will never receive themselves?

Not quite. Your entitlement at the point you made the contribution hasn't changed. The scheme has changed from a fixed point onwards. Contributions made prior to that fixed point a couple of years ago will contribute the expected calculated amount.

AICM · 25/08/2021 17:54

It's not a case of whether he needs this money at all.

It's simply the case that he is entitled to this money because he paid into the system all his life.

The pension is not, and never should be, a means tested benefit.

Blindering · 25/08/2021 17:52

''But my pension entitlement has been cut. And will be cut again over my working life. No, I don't like it, but it would certainly seem fairer if all USS beneficiaries shared the pain. Why must the younger generation work to fund final salary pensions they will never receive themselves?''

but the same thing happened in Ireland, pensions and salaries were cut for teachers in 2010 on the agreement that existing union members keep their pay safe. But ofcourse when you raise this unfairness you get accused of being 'jealous' and how they worked hard for their money so the younger generation must take the hit.

OP posts:
sst1234 · 25/08/2021 17:52

The private sector can pay what it likes, it’s simply up to their shareholders to decide how remuneration works. Public sector pensions, however, are simply unsustainable if they are cushioned to this extent.

NoSquirrels · 25/08/2021 17:52

I do not understand why my pension entitlement can keep changing but the pensions of those that retired earlier are set in tablets of stone and cannot be even slighty reduced to help the scheme deficit and support the next generations.

Because they’re already retired and you aren’t. You have the option to earn more and save more and they don’t.

It might feel like a generational inequality, perhaps it is. But the generation now retired will have had its own inequalities to contend with. As PP has pointed out, pensioners pay income tax & VAT and all the other taxes working people do. They are still contributing to the economy in this way, just as much as other tax payers. And their incomes are fixed, and for many eroded by inflation. Their costs increase in as many ways as they decrease as they age.

It’s bloody stupid to think ‘means-testing’ someone’s personal occupational pension would solve anything. Where would the incentive be to save, own property, anything?

Give your head a wobble, OP.

I’ll be much poorer in retirement than my parents. But that’s not their fault.

loopylindi · 25/08/2021 17:50

With this kind of attitude you'd fit in really well in Russia @Blindering. Oh no, I forgot. That's not REALLY a communist state any more is it? You've got a very perverted view of the role of pensions and how they are accrued over a working life. i worked in the public sector all my life. I earned below wages paid to private sector workers, but I didn't mind because, as I was told, I'd get a better pension (delayed gratification).So now, here I am enjoying a comfortable retirement - and it's none of your business how I'm spending it.

HeadNorth · 25/08/2021 17:49

@AuntieJoyce

The final salary pension was removed during my working life and the defined benefits calculater get worse and worse while the age to receive it goes up. I do not understand why my pension entitlement can keep changing but the pensions of those that retired earlier are set in tablets of stone and cannot be even slighty reduced to help the scheme deficit and support the next generations

You have a fundamental misunderstanding of pensions

Pensions already earned cannot be reduced without agreement . How would you like it if your pension entitlement was suddenly cut?

Your future pension has become more expensive and less generous because current market conditions (government bond returns) mean it is more expensive to provide. Pensions already earned by other people and you in the past do not come into this calculation and are funded in addition

But my pension entitlement has been cut. And will be cut again over my working life. No, I don't like it, but it would certainly seem fairer if all USS beneficiaries shared the pain. Why must the younger generation work to fund final salary pensions they will never receive themselves?
MyDcAreMarvel · 25/08/2021 17:44

@RedElephants the state pension is £179.60 . Between the two of you ,you have forty years left to save into a pension.

Marcee · 25/08/2021 17:43

@Blindering

''It should be averaged up so everyone gets the same as him.''

and where do you propose the money for this comes from?

In the UK i think you'll find the government has magically found billions that they've managed to funnel through to their mates.

The money is there. They just want you believe they havent got it.

Marcee · 25/08/2021 17:40

The ideal would be- the money people put into a pension scheme is invested and put into a pot so then they can claim it back when they retire.

Instead it is used for whatever the government needs and expects the current tax payers to fund the pension.

Unfortunately you cant expect people who have paid into their pension for years to forgo what they have been promised just because the government mismanaged it.

I'm not sure you would enjoy paying into a pension and then being given a mediocre payout, which will then end up being means-tested despite how much you've paid in.

And then further cut down because the current taxpayers expect to get even less when they eventually retire.

Blindering · 25/08/2021 17:39

''Seriously loads have mortgages in their 70s. How naive,''

I can't think of 1 person.

OP posts:
GloriaSilver · 25/08/2021 17:38

@IridescentPurple

eh I struggle to think of anybody in their mid 70s still paying a mortgage

My mortgage will be paid back when I'm 77. You can actually get a small mortgage at 70.

Seriously loads have mortgages in their 70s. How naive,
Blindering · 25/08/2021 17:38

''I’ll be getting 3k+ a month pension and have lots of plans for spending it. YABU.''

and yet you''ll moan that your grandkids can't buy a house or get x,y and z.

OP posts:
FrownedUpon · 25/08/2021 17:37

I’ll be getting 3k+ a month pension and have lots of plans for spending it. YABU.

AuntieJoyce · 25/08/2021 17:35

The final salary pension was removed during my working life and the defined benefits calculater get worse and worse while the age to receive it goes up. I do not understand why my pension entitlement can keep changing but the pensions of those that retired earlier are set in tablets of stone and cannot be even slighty reduced to help the scheme deficit and support the next generations

You have a fundamental misunderstanding of pensions

Pensions already earned cannot be reduced without agreement . How would you like it if your pension entitlement was suddenly cut?

Your future pension has become more expensive and less generous because current market conditions (government bond returns) mean it is more expensive to provide. Pensions already earned by other people and you in the past do not come into this calculation and are funded in addition

Blindering · 25/08/2021 17:33

''It should be averaged up so everyone gets the same as him.''

and where do you propose the money for this comes from?

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 25/08/2021 17:33

This isn't a pensioner bashing thread

I think you’ll find it is.

Marcee · 25/08/2021 17:32

Yabu.

Rather than bringing everyone down for the sake of equity.

It should be averaged up so everyone gets the same as him.

Blindering · 25/08/2021 17:32

''It is tricky. My University pension is steadily getting worse and worse, I have to keep paying a greater percentage of my salary to get my pension later and receive a worse pension. This is in part because of having to continue to pay the pensions of earlier generations who were able to retire earlier with a final salary pension who are in general, unsurprisingly in such favourable circumstances, living very long lives.

The final salary pension was removed during my working life and the defined benefits calculater get worse and worse while the age to receive it goes up. I do not understand why my pension entitlement can keep changing but the pensions of those that retired earlier are set in tablets of stone and cannot be even slighty reduced to help the scheme deficit and support the next generations.

Not helped that I have a vile retired family member who gloats about his fat final salary pension from USS and how I am working to pay for it - when I will never receive anything like it.

It is a great intergenerational unfairness so I don't think the OP is being unreasonable in raising it.''

Just for all the people who are accusing me of ''not getting it'', this poster has explained very well my point and what many of you don't seem to get. This isn't a pensioner bashing thread, it is about over inflated pensions and inequality.

OP posts:
MarieIVanArkleStinks · 25/08/2021 17:30

He has PAID for that pension. It hasn't been given to him as a favour.

A decent pension used to be part of the compensation college and university lecturers received given that in their professional capacity they are about the poorest paid in Europe. They also earn significantly below par in comparison with the US, where they receive all manner of pension and health insurance benefits on top.

Teachers and lecturers have paid into this pot. Incidentally, there have been various raids on the different pension schemes over the years, including the TPS and USS schemes, where final salary pensions have now become average, to quote one example. This is breaking faith with the deal many staff took out when they started.

Needless to say, there has been no salary increase which even begins to take account of this: conditions are so poor that ahead of COVID there were UCU strikes all over the country.

YABV,VU.

Blindering · 25/08/2021 17:29

''I'll repeat - young people have the option of paying into their pension scheme. Plenty choose not to, but plenty of older people choose not to either.''

and if you read the other poster's post that supported my point she already said it is not worth paying in as the returns are much less than in the past.

''That's not a reason to resent those that did the sensible thing and planned for their retirement.''

they could plan more easily as their wages were higher and their mortgages were a fraction of today, that and money they paid in got much better returns. It's not black and white as you say. It's a case of inequality that I am pointing out.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 25/08/2021 17:27

@Blindering

''Benefits to pensioners are means tested.''

clearly not if he owns a property in Dublin worth millions amongst other assets and still received a 150k pay off at the end along with a golden plated 2500 euro a month. It's just madness.

So you don’t understand what benefits means either. You’re not doing g yourself any favours here.
midgemagneto · 25/08/2021 17:27

Save more , vote for socially minded political parties , we get the country the majority (?!?) vote for

And most people don't want to save and don't want to pay taxes for thier future benefit

Being jealous of others isn't a good look

And you have decades to go . None of them thought they would be wealthy , they certainly were not at your age