Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the old style pensions should be capped.

618 replies

Blindering · 25/08/2021 16:17

ok, I am in Ireland so unaware of how UK pensions function but my neighbour who worked as a college lecturer but retired in 2008 in his 70s gets 600 euro a week in pension, equivalent to 513 stg.
This is on top of a 150k pay off he got when he left the job which I believe all civil servants here were getting.

But aibu to think a bachelor living in a house with the mortgage long paid off has no need for over 500stg a week? Like what would one need the money for at that stage in life?

OP posts:
titchy · 25/08/2021 18:13

You think private pensions are state benefits 😂

I know right! Grin

NoSquirrels · 25/08/2021 18:12

ok so I will wait until the next ''I / my adult son can't afford a house despite working full time with a phd thread'' or the ''pension age is too high'', ''landlords buying all the houses'' threads to start and I will link this thread on all those who say things should stay as they are.

Not being able to afford a house isn’t because pensioners are being paid according to the schemes they signed up for.

Landlords buying all the houses isn’t anything to do with pensions.

The pension age being ‘too high’ is nothing to do with currently retired pensioners - what do you propose, that we ‘un-retire’ some of them to make it fairer? Confused

titchy · 25/08/2021 18:12

@Blindering

'' He may not have mortgage, but he still has income tax, Council tax, utility bills, transport, any private healthcare, all DIY costs, probably cleaning costs....''

no council tax in Ireland, healthcare all free for him, he cleans himself so far since his retirement nearly 15 years ago. He lives in city centre like myself and rarely travels or ventures too far that he needs transport.

And when he goes into a care home he'll be paying for it himself. Unlike those selfish fuckers who made no pension provision and have their care costs paid for by the tax payer (which includes your neighbour).
SimonJT · 25/08/2021 18:10

@Blindering

''Benefits to pensioners are means tested.''

clearly not if he owns a property in Dublin worth millions amongst other assets and still received a 150k pay off at the end along with a golden plated 2500 euro a month. It's just madness.

You think private pensions are state benefits 😂

I love a good reach on MN

Buttons294749 · 25/08/2021 18:09

My Dad worked for the council back in the 90s. The pay was fairly low and my parents struggled financially sometimes. His pension is relatively high in comparison to that so I do think it makes more sense to pay a bit higher when younger and you have dependents. But I don't think people who were paid low salaries in anticipation of an ok pension should be made to suffer so they never feel comfortable!! (My dad's pension is still not 24k per year tho)

Also pensioners have often care needs that are not met by the NHS

KrisAkabusi · 25/08/2021 18:09

He paid into his pension. There was a contract between him and the college/government that he would receive a certain amount when he retired. Can you not see that you can't go changing contracts unilaterally? Whatever about the agreements in place with new entrants, it CANNOT be applied retrospectively.

Blindering · 25/08/2021 18:09

'' He may not have mortgage, but he still has income tax, Council tax, utility bills, transport, any private healthcare, all DIY costs, probably cleaning costs....''

no council tax in Ireland, healthcare all free for him, he cleans himself so far since his retirement nearly 15 years ago. He lives in city centre like myself and rarely travels or ventures too far that he needs transport.

OP posts:
1forAll74 · 25/08/2021 18:07

You might get old yourself, and you can have a fine old time with a load of money when you are an oldie, so you can look forward to this !

NoSquirrels · 25/08/2021 18:07

@Blindering

''The schemes the previous generation had set up are not sustainable for future generations. So they’ve been changed. Doesn’t mean we rob the previous generation of what they worked for all their lives. That they were given a more generous deal than us is just how it goes.''

And so alternatively we rob the younger generations so they can sit on over inflated pensions?

No. You are either not listening, or fundamentally misunderstanding.

No one is ‘robbing’ us. We haven’t reached retirement age yet - there’s nothing to rob, we still have choices. Continue to pay in at current terms - even if they’re not as favourable as previous iterations of the scheme- or opt out and amass savings for retirement another way.

Those already retired do not have options. To retrospectively change their terms, give them less or means-test their entitlement to the money they paid in over their working lives would be robbing them. As they do not have a choice to opt out or earn more or retire later. They made their decisions based on the scheme they were offered.

No one is robbing the younger generations to pay for the already-retired.

Blindering · 25/08/2021 18:06

''Never have I read an OP oozing with so much envy and jealousy. You need to mind your own business.''

ok so I will wait until the next ''I / my adult son can't afford a house despite working full time with a phd thread'' or the ''pension age is too high'', ''landlords buying all the houses'' threads to start and I will link this thread on all those who say things should stay as they are.

OP posts:
PlanDeRaccordement · 25/08/2021 18:06

YABU
Governments should not change pension rules resulting in a lower pension for anyone already retired or less than twenty years to retirement. This is because the people have no way to then work or save to make up the shortfall between what they were promised and what the government now thinks it can afford.

I agree to that the race to the bottom isn’t something to be encouraged. State pension in the U.K. should be going up, not down.

I also think that £500/week is a low total pension amount to cover all your costs. He may not have mortgage, but he still has income tax, Council tax, utility bills, transport, any private healthcare, all DIY costs, probably cleaning costs....as you age you need more and more help for just day to day things that we young people do ourselves without a second thought. But there comes a time where you are too old for DIY, gardening/landscaping, and deep cleaning.

StatisticallyChallenged · 25/08/2021 18:05

UK stats - albeit a few years old - suggest about 75% of over 65s own outright, about 5% have a mortgage - and the other 20% are renting.

Pensions have undoubtedly worsened for current workers compared to those who are now retired or who have benefits accrued under older schemes. The classic old DB schemes are basically unaffordable now without enormous contributions and the writing has been on the wall for that for a very long time. But you can't take away the pension which people were guaranteed and which they have already accrued - that's kind of the point of defined benefit schemes, the risks are with the scheme and the sponsor not the individual.

ShingleBeach · 25/08/2021 18:05

The later you draw your pension the bigger it is when you do.

He carried in laying and working into his 70s.

And how do you know that some of his pension isn’t a private pension that he paid into?

GF post.

HalzTangz · 25/08/2021 18:02

@NashvilleQueen

It's absolutely none of your business.
This
Crankley · 25/08/2021 18:02

Never have I read an OP oozing with so much envy and jealousy. You need to mind your own business.

Blindering · 25/08/2021 18:01

''The schemes the previous generation had set up are not sustainable for future generations. So they’ve been changed. Doesn’t mean we rob the previous generation of what they worked for all their lives. That they were given a more generous deal than us is just how it goes.''

And so alternatively we rob the younger generations so they can sit on over inflated pensions?

OP posts:
notacooldad · 25/08/2021 18:00

eh I struggle to think of anybody in their mid 70s still paying a mortgage
I know a few tbh.

notanothertakeaway · 25/08/2021 18:00

@Wooollffff

I’m in the UK civil service. During my interview I was told that the pay was lower than I was getting in the private sector but the pension was effectively deferred pay.

Of course successive Governments have pulled the rug from under us and it’s worth a lot less.

OP. It’s none of your business anyway.

I worked in private sector. We were led to understand we would have higher salaries, but lower pension. And then the salaries were frozen, or we were made redundant. I think it's become harder for private and public sector employees
Marcee · 25/08/2021 17:59

I understand the pain. I myself am paying into a scheme that if I'd been 10-20 years older I would have got a huge amount more.

I'm paying huge amounts from my salary into the pension scheme and every few years they change it so we get less out.

But I dont begrudge the older pensioners- it's all down to the mismanagement from the government.

By changing the terms for the retired, I'd lose all confidence and probably opt out- I mean what's stopping them from changing it further- but at least I know what I've paid in already is protected.

And I'm also looking into other investments because I don't think the pension scheme will pay out enough despite how much I'm putting in.

NoSquirrels · 25/08/2021 17:59

@Blindering

''I’ll be much poorer in retirement than my parents. But that’s not their fault.''

but I never pointed the finger at my neighbour or individuals who benefitted from their situation, I am pointing it at the govt who could make changes so things are more fair.

What changes?

We’re an aging population. The changes have been made precisely so that we don’t all run out of cash entirely in retirement.

The schemes the previous generation had set up are not sustainable for future generations. So they’ve been changed. Doesn’t mean we rob the previous generation of what they worked for all their lives. That they were given a more generous deal than us is just how it goes.

Willowtree999 · 25/08/2021 17:57

Why would it be about needing the money? Surely pensions are a product of what you pay in through contributions, either government (NI) or private and therefore it's yours, for whatever you want.

As for housing my DM has a mortgaged house, her parents paid off their mortgage early and I will be renting forever. This is a result of house prices / supply and demand for past generations.

I can't see why any of that is your neighbour's fault and why he shouldn't be able to enjoy his retirement with what he has earned.

knittingaddict · 25/08/2021 17:57

@Blindering

''Why would you say that he doesn't need the money ?''

I struggle to think what the average person in their 70s would do with over 500stg a week, Their kids will be adults, their mortgages will most likely be paid.

Care? Things to make their lives a bit easier? A few luxuries to make old age bearable? Heating when mobility decreases? Or are old people supposed to sit in their armchairs, wrapped in blankets, eating their meals on wheels and watching tv?

Another bloody ageist thread on mn. Why am I not surprised.

NoSquirrels · 25/08/2021 17:57

@Blindering

''But my pension entitlement has been cut. And will be cut again over my working life. No, I don't like it, but it would certainly seem fairer if all USS beneficiaries shared the pain. Why must the younger generation work to fund final salary pensions they will never receive themselves?''

but the same thing happened in Ireland, pensions and salaries were cut for teachers in 2010 on the agreement that existing union members keep their pay safe. But ofcourse when you raise this unfairness you get accused of being 'jealous' and how they worked hard for their money so the younger generation must take the hit.

A change to a scheme must occur at a fixed point.

If the change must happen, you think all those people who paid in before you were even employed should share what they paid?

No one would agree to that. Would you?

Blindering · 25/08/2021 17:56

''I’ll be much poorer in retirement than my parents. But that’s not their fault.''

but I never pointed the finger at my neighbour or individuals who benefitted from their situation, I am pointing it at the govt who could make changes so things are more fair.

OP posts:
titchy · 25/08/2021 17:55

@sst1234

The private sector can pay what it likes, it’s simply up to their shareholders to decide how remuneration works. Public sector pensions, however, are simply unsustainable if they are cushioned to this extent.
USS isn't a public sector scheme...