Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the old style pensions should be capped.

618 replies

Blindering · 25/08/2021 16:17

ok, I am in Ireland so unaware of how UK pensions function but my neighbour who worked as a college lecturer but retired in 2008 in his 70s gets 600 euro a week in pension, equivalent to 513 stg.
This is on top of a 150k pay off he got when he left the job which I believe all civil servants here were getting.

But aibu to think a bachelor living in a house with the mortgage long paid off has no need for over 500stg a week? Like what would one need the money for at that stage in life?

OP posts:
RockingMyFiftiesNot · 27/08/2021 22:39

@MurielSpriggs

Pensioners above a certain income level do pay tax.

I know. Not enough!

And have paid tax all their working lives
echt · 27/08/2021 22:33

It's 20% at 12, 501 - 50,000, the same as those in work.

MurielSpriggs · 27/08/2021 22:29

Pensioners above a certain income level do pay tax.

I know. Not enough!

echt · 27/08/2021 22:24

[quote MurielSpriggs]@NoSquirrels,

Fair enough, I haven't followed all the twists and turns of the thread. I do have sympathy with both sides of this. I don't think it's right to alter pension payments at the last minute. But I do think that more financial burden should be shifted away from the young and onto the elderly. The better way to do that would be by taxation and other fiscal measures.[/quote]
Pensioners above a certain income level do pay tax.

StatisticallyChallenged · 27/08/2021 21:54

I think the state pension is a bit different TBH - it has always been a political football and subject to change (both small and large). You can get projections and so on but really there is no guarantee. You don't take a job and pay NI with someone saying "and when you retire you will get a pension equal to 1/60th of your final salary for every year you work" or whatever. It's simply you pay your NI whether you like it or not and in theory there will be a state pension but how much is very much subject to change.

I think the legal position would also be significantly different as the various public sector pension schemes formed part of an employment contract.

3478fhd883 · 27/08/2021 20:36

But the government absolutely does change state pensions retroactively and seeing as the state is also the employer of civil servants then potentially they could also change the pensions of civil servants retroactively.

governments can do all sorts of things retroactively - apply special taxes, reduce pension benefits etc etc etc

the biggest difference is political will - not whether or not it's possible or not

Sunak reconsidering the tripple lock is precisely changing pensions retroactively.

MurielSpriggs · 27/08/2021 20:35

@NoSquirrels,

Fair enough, I haven't followed all the twists and turns of the thread. I do have sympathy with both sides of this. I don't think it's right to alter pension payments at the last minute. But I do think that more financial burden should be shifted away from the young and onto the elderly. The better way to do that would be by taxation and other fiscal measures.

NoSquirrels · 27/08/2021 20:16

But @3478fhd883's post does kind of declaw your question.

Either @Blindering says yes, she would be happy with what you propose, in which case I'm not sure where your line of questioning goes then.

Or she says she wouldn't be happy at all, in which case you say: "Aha, hypocrite!". At which point she could use any number of reasons to distinguish the two situations, that given by @3478fhd883 being the most obvious.

The “savings account” is not the important principle in the question by ajandjj - it dues t matter if it’s a savings account or a pension (civil service or state or private). The “savings account” is just to illustrate in the simplest terms to this particular OP, who seems unwilling/unable to understand all the different nuances of pensions, that you can’t just change the rules retrospectively at retirement based on an arbitrary “you’ve got too much” measure.

ajandjjmum · 27/08/2021 19:45

But surely the fact that you are given whatever the rules say at the time - bearing in mind that at least historically salaries were lower than in the commercial world, but the balance was an excellent pension - means that the entitlement (like the savings) would be yours, and no-one has the right to take it away.

There is a reason that the OP has ignored the question.

MurielSpriggs · 27/08/2021 19:37

[quote ajandjjmum]**@3478fhd883 Thanks - but that isn't answering the question that I asked on Wednesday, and has been repeatedly asked since - although it remains unanswered.

Thanks for reminding the OP again @UserNameNameNameUser Grin

I'm boring myself now![/quote]
But @3478fhd883's post does kind of declaw your question.

Either @Blindering says yes, she would be happy with what you propose, in which case I'm not sure where your line of questioning goes then.

Or she says she wouldn't be happy at all, in which case you say: "Aha, hypocrite!". At which point she could use any number of reasons to distinguish the two situations, that given by @3478fhd883 being the most obvious.

ajandjjmum · 27/08/2021 17:34

@3478fhd883 Thanks - but that isn't answering the question that I asked on Wednesday, and has been repeatedly asked since - although it remains unanswered.

Thanks for reminding the OP again @UserNameNameNameUser Grin

I'm boring myself now!

Gem176 · 27/08/2021 16:33

Why would you want to fight for everyone to have less than for everyone to have more? Instead of capping old style pensions, why not fight for current pensions to be at the same level? It's not a race to the bottom.

And yes, yabu.

UserNameNameNameUser · 27/08/2021 16:28

OP it’s been a long thread, so you may not have realised, but you missed a question ….

OP - say you save into an interest-bearing account, how would you feel if someone came along when you were about to retire and said there was more money in there than you needed, so decided to take some to distribute to others. Would you be happy with that?

knittingaddict · 27/08/2021 15:15

@Blindering

''I don't know about Ireland, but I believe care home costs in the UK average £700 a week, more for nursing homes. So let's hope he's putting a bit by at the moment, to cover his costs should he need to go into a care home.''

I don't get why care comes into every single financial thread on mn considering the stats show less than 10 percent go into care if you check but people here go on like it's guaranteed.

And many never go into a care home because they use their funds to buy in care that allows them to stay at home. Any more weak arguments to send our way?
pointythings · 27/08/2021 14:53

DroopyClematis it's like pulling teeth but without the Tooth Fairy.

Honestly, OP. It's not a difficult question, is it? I'm starting to feel a bit like Jeremy Paxman interviewing Michael Howard here.

DroopyClematis · 27/08/2021 14:36

@pointythings

Hello there, Blinering,

Any update on that question you were asked yesterday? Here it is again, so you don't have to scroll:

OP - say you save into an interest-bearing account, how would you feel if someone came along when you were about to retire and said there was more money in there than you needed, so decided to take some to distribute to others. Would you be happy with that?

It's like pulling teeth, isn't it? 🙄
pointythings · 27/08/2021 14:17

Hello there, Blinering,

Any update on that question you were asked yesterday? Here it is again, so you don't have to scroll:

OP - say you save into an interest-bearing account, how would you feel if someone came along when you were about to retire and said there was more money in there than you needed, so decided to take some to distribute to others. Would you be happy with that?

Blindering · 27/08/2021 14:08

''I don't know about Ireland, but I believe care home costs in the UK average £700 a week, more for nursing homes. So let's hope he's putting a bit by at the moment, to cover his costs should he need to go into a care home.''

I don't get why care comes into every single financial thread on mn considering the stats show less than 10 percent go into care if you check but people here go on like it's guaranteed.

OP posts:
CounsellorTroi · 27/08/2021 14:06

@Blossomtoes

Public sector pensions are a huge cost to the taxpayers which restricts our public service budget now

What restricts our public service budget is Tory spending priorities.

This. Margaret Thatcher got the electorate used to taxation levels that were too low to sustain decent public services. No party can now be elected on a promise to increase taxation so we’re now stuck with crap public services.
ilovesooty · 27/08/2021 14:02

@Blossomtoes

Public sector pensions are a huge cost to the taxpayers which restricts our public service budget now

What restricts our public service budget is Tory spending priorities.

Well said.
lanthanum · 27/08/2021 13:33

@Blindering

Edit: just to note I say 'old style pensions' because I don't know if they have being changed since he retired for the next generations but in general I think it's madness that people in their golden years are getting whopper pensions every week. Seems wasteful.
I don't know about Ireland, but I believe care home costs in the UK average £700 a week, more for nursing homes. So let's hope he's putting a bit by at the moment, to cover his costs should he need to go into a care home.
pointythings · 27/08/2021 13:01

@Blossomtoes

Public sector pensions are a huge cost to the taxpayers which restricts our public service budget now

What restricts our public service budget is Tory spending priorities.

👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

This.

Blossomtoes · 27/08/2021 12:54

Public sector pensions are a huge cost to the taxpayers which restricts our public service budget now

What restricts our public service budget is Tory spending priorities.

ilovesooty · 27/08/2021 12:43

@UserNameNameNameUser

Just posting this for you again OP, just in case you missed it …

OP - say you save into an interest-bearing account, how would you feel if someone came along when you were about to retire and said there was more money in there than you needed, so decided to take some to distribute to others.

Would you be happy with that?

The OP is never going to answer that question.

I've rarely seen posts from an OP which are so consistently bitter, jealous stubborn and just plain dense.

3478fhd883 · 27/08/2021 12:08

@ajandjjmum in answer to your question that is often the case e.g. state pension is very much like that with the government tweaking how much people get even though technically people had paid in all their lives - they dont actually know what they will get out.

Unfunded public sector pensions were not private per se - you dont get what you put in, you got what the rules were at the time. Many people ended up getting much more than they put in, some less.

Civil service pensions are not your own private pension account. They have not always been funded like traditional pensions funds etc etc etc.

That is not to say that rules can be changed retroactively - it's just not as simple as saying you put the cash in and get it back.

Swipe left for the next trending thread