Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the old style pensions should be capped.

618 replies

Blindering · 25/08/2021 16:17

ok, I am in Ireland so unaware of how UK pensions function but my neighbour who worked as a college lecturer but retired in 2008 in his 70s gets 600 euro a week in pension, equivalent to 513 stg.
This is on top of a 150k pay off he got when he left the job which I believe all civil servants here were getting.

But aibu to think a bachelor living in a house with the mortgage long paid off has no need for over 500stg a week? Like what would one need the money for at that stage in life?

OP posts:
pointythings · 25/08/2021 20:15

£25k a year isn't a modest public sector pension, it's a high one. The average public sector pension pays out nothing like that - mine will pay out about £14k a year after 35 years of full time NHS work. I won't get a full state pension because I was in the contracting out scheme, so I expect to have to work part time well past retirement age. I'm actually fine with that, I'm not the sitting around doing nothing type, but people should really stop pushing the 'gold plated public sector pension' crap when the situation is that averages are distorted massively by a small number of very, very high payouts.

saraclara · 25/08/2021 20:15

If your neighbour gets 600 euro a week, it's not from a state pension. Presumably that's the total he gets from the govt and any private or employers' pensions he might have. It sounds as though he's been very sensible and paid in extra for a long time.

UserNameNameNameUser · 25/08/2021 20:14

@Blindering

''Here you go OP. This might help you get a bit of perspective.''

and yet everybody I knew in London over 45, many on basic jobs that required no education had houses.

There is clearly no point reasoning with you 😂

Dunning-Kruger effect

HotChoc10 · 25/08/2021 20:12

I hate this race to the bottom nonsense. I'm in my twenties and would much rather we fight for better pensions for the younger generations than worse ones for those who are retired now.

If we accept and endorse (further) decline it's hardly going to pay dividends when it's our turn.

saraclara · 25/08/2021 20:11

I don't know about where you are, but veryone in England pays for their govt pension in National Insurance deductions from their pay every month.

Some of us also pay into either private pensions or our employers' pension schemes. According to you, if we've paid the extra to get a company pension, we should forfeit the government pension that we've paid into for 40 years? Seriously?

IridescentPurple · 25/08/2021 20:10

paid into from an over inflated old style salary from tax*
🙂 You have no idea what you're talking about.

ufucoffee · 25/08/2021 20:09

@blindering I have a 1 bed flat. I got it cheap as it needed a lot of repair work and still does.

When you've fixed it up you could downsize to a studio. Just like old people don't need a lot of money you don't really need a separate bedroom do you?

wewereliars · 25/08/2021 20:04

Yes OP everyone should give their money to you.

Blindering · 25/08/2021 20:04

''Here you go OP. This might help you get a bit of perspective.''

and yet everybody I knew in London over 45, many on basic jobs that required no education had houses.

OP posts:
IgiveupallthenamesIwantedareg0 · 25/08/2021 20:03

OP: no one is taking you seriously, you are just being goading and looking for a fight. You are of the mentality "what I say is right and you are all wrong"!
Carry on..... you'll soon find yourself alone because no one will be bothered listening to your bizarre opinions - neither here on MN or in real life.

Blindering · 25/08/2021 20:03

''Being paid crappy wages working in crappy conditions to keep us safe, educate our kids and care for our sick. ''

the latter in Ireland were never paid ''crappy wages'' until 2010 when the existing ones threw their younger counterparts under the bus and agreed with the unions to sacrifice their own pay so that those who started after that got the ''crappy wages''.

OP posts:
UserNameNameNameUser · 25/08/2021 20:01

Here you go OP. This might help you get a bit of perspective.

For example I’ve picked 1970 in South East (it’s only U.K. I’m afraid).

Yes the average house price was 67% less (adjusted for inflation), but the average wage was also 41% less, and the cost of groceries was 27% more. Compound that with extraordinarily high interest rates and it’s not a pretty picture.

So yesthe average house price was 4 times the average salary, compared to now it being 7 times average salary, but other costs of living were more. And taking just the cost of the house is disingenuous. A monthly mortgage payment on that average house at 15% interest is £2,500 compared to just £753 at today’s lower interest rates.

www.hillarys.co.uk/back-in-my-day/

Blindering · 25/08/2021 20:00

''Most people I know in their 30s have afforded to buy. ''

the ones I know got help from bank of mum and dad.

OP posts:
WaltzForDebbie · 25/08/2021 20:00

I kind out agree with you op. There is definitely a 2 tier system for pensions where people in the public sector will get much better pensions than those in the private sector. It's our kids who will end up paying out of their taxes.

There are plenty of people in the private sector on low incomes as well. Factory workers, delivery drivers, shop workers etc etc. Only a few are on these mega salaries people seem to think all the private sector are on. Hmm

A modest public sector pension of £25,000 costs the taxpayer around £500,000 and that's without any lump sum. It's just not sustainable.

To really equal things up everyone should save for their own pensions but that's never going to happen with the union's etc.

wewereliars · 25/08/2021 19:59

We are living in a system of capitalism, fairness is not an issue one way or another.

No body has made central decision to increase house prices.

Maybe your elderly neighbour is very bright, earned a decent salary and now has a decent pension. Sod all to do with you.

May be set up your own capitalist utopia OP.

titchy · 25/08/2021 19:59

@Blindering

''Most pensions arent paid by the government''

retired teachers, police and nurses in Ireland have over inflated pensions higher than many wages in the uk.

Bloody teachers, police officers and nurses eh? Being paid crappy wages working in crappy conditions to keep us safe, educate our kids and care for our sick. Can't believe the cheeky bastards actually want a pension as well! They'll be asking for some respect next!
VestaTilley · 25/08/2021 19:58

YABVU. If it’s a private pension it’s absolutely none of your business.

If it’s a state pension issue write to your MP.

As to what he’ll spend it on- it’s his money to do with as he likes. He’ll probably spend it on care needs in his old age. My late DGM’s care home cost £4K a month.

StatisticallyChallenged · 25/08/2021 19:57

@wewereliars

House prices are high because not enough houses are being built, its simple economics.

Supply is less than demand so prices are high.

Absolutely nothing to do with pensions, private or state.

I'd argue there is a link with pensions tbh - but not in the way OP suggests! Pensions declining and lower returns on some investments, plus high house price inflation has contributed to more people becoming BTL landlords instead of investing in pensions - which in turn pushes up property prices more.

But making pensions insecure and subject to arbitrary capping would make this worse, not better.

StoneofDestiny · 25/08/2021 19:57

then how come massive amounts of the younger generations can't afford their own house?

How come masses amounts of the younger generation own cars, take foreign holidays, own multiple electric appliances in their home, eat out regularly, have wardrobes stuffed with clothes, visit hairdressers and beauticians regularly, have expensive weddings etc etc.

These things were not enjoyed by the older generation. If they did own a house, it's likely all that they owned. Houses might have been cheaper, but wages were lower.

My first house took everything I owned - nothing left for a car, holidays or even heating the house. The TV was rented and a trip to the Laundrette was a weekly chore. It took years to kit it out. My parents never owned their home. So don't think everybody had it easy just because they are older.

The man's income is none of your business. It's come as part of a contract he signed up to and as a result of his payments into a pension scheme, it's. It up to you to pick his pockets because you feel aggrieved.

Blindering · 25/08/2021 19:56

''Most pensions arent paid by the government''

retired teachers, police and nurses in Ireland have over inflated pensions higher than many wages in the uk.

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 25/08/2021 19:55

This was a good question from ajandjj

OP - say you save into an interest-bearing account, how would you feel if someone came along when you were about to retire and said there was more money in there than you needed, so decided to take some to distribute to others.

Would you be happy with that?

titchy · 25/08/2021 19:55

@Thisnamewasnttaken123

''It is tricky. My University pension is steadily getting worse and worse, I have to keep paying a greater percentage of my salary to get my pension later and receive a worse pension. This is in part because of having to continue to pay the pensions of earlier generations who were able to retire earlier with a final salary pension who are in general, unsurprisingly in such favourable circumstances, living very long lives.

The final salary pension was removed during my working life and the defined benefits calculater get worse and worse while the age to receive it goes up. I do not understand why my pension entitlement can keep changing but the pensions of those that retired earlier are set in tablets of stone and cannot be even slighty reduced to help the scheme deficit and support the next generations.

Not helped that I have a vile retired family member who gloats about his fat final salary pension from USS and how I am working to pay for it - when I will never receive anything like it.

It is a great intergenerational unfairness so I don't think the OP is being unreasonable in raising it.''

I agree, I also don't think the OP is being unreasonable.

Except quite of lot of what you've quoted isn't true...
Blindering · 25/08/2021 19:55

''If you already have a house OP why don't you downsize to a flat and donate the money to some poor young person for a deposit. It's the least you can do when you feel the system is so unfair.''

I have a 1 bed flat. I got it cheap as it needed a lot of repair work and still does.

OP posts:
Blindering · 25/08/2021 19:53

''Changing the rules AFTER people retire, when they don’t have the chance to increase their savings or contributions any more causes hardship and is unfair.''

and increasing house prices so much that many of the younger generation isn't fair either and no younger generation can't cut their cloth as they don't have the same chance to save and pay into pensions and get similar returns. If pensioner got 300stg a week it is more than enough and the money was used to help the younger generation.

OP posts:
ufucoffee · 25/08/2021 19:52

If you already have a house OP why don't you downsize to a flat and donate the money to some poor young person for a deposit. It's the least you can do when you feel the system is so unfair.