Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the old style pensions should be capped.

618 replies

Blindering · 25/08/2021 16:17

ok, I am in Ireland so unaware of how UK pensions function but my neighbour who worked as a college lecturer but retired in 2008 in his 70s gets 600 euro a week in pension, equivalent to 513 stg.
This is on top of a 150k pay off he got when he left the job which I believe all civil servants here were getting.

But aibu to think a bachelor living in a house with the mortgage long paid off has no need for over 500stg a week? Like what would one need the money for at that stage in life?

OP posts:
Od130990 · 26/08/2021 09:30

YABU
He's paid in & deserves his payout.

Bulldoglady89 · 26/08/2021 09:21

My pension invests my contributions into global index shares and the payout is profit from years of long term investment. Why would someone invest for 40 Years and not enjoy the dividends?

SmashingBlouson · 26/08/2021 09:19

[quote Fancymice]@saraclara I am 30, and am enrolled in the nest pension scheme. The fact that it is mandatory that it is offered to all employers makes me firmly beleive that when it is my time to retire there will no longer be a state pension.

OP, I don't understand the pure venom of some of these responses. I think it is misdirected to think current pensioners should receive less, but I understand the frustration with the clear intergenerational inequality in this country that a lot of people refuse to believe exists.

To be honest, I am jealous of people in the boomer generation. All I want is to own my own home to have some feeling of security, but sadly it's a pipe dream on my current earnings. Neither of my parents were proffessionals, but they bought a house. Me and my partner rarely go on holiday, eat out about twice a year and run a small cheap old car and are a million miles away from being able to buy, so it isn't a life of hedonistic luxury preventing us.[/quote]
Thanks for explaining your situation. It's similar for me and I'm in my 30's - I buy second hand stuff as much as I can, don't go on holidays abroad, buy expensive phones (just like the good old days), but when this is explained on these forums you just get told we buy too many luxury lifestyle items and eat too many avocados by ignorant people. The statistics speak for themselves and tell the story well, people's opinions don't. Instagram and Facebook are not real life, just a snap shot of it.

Our rent/housing is ridiculously high compared to salaries that have stagnated. We are in the top 3 for most expensive childcare in the world. Not amount of not buying avocados or lipstick will make a dent in that. I think many young people have just given up as having a secure home as it is unattainable. Eating well and taking care of yourself a bit might mean you are less likely to have years of poor health in old age and be reliant on the state, so young people are focusing on that as a means of protecting themselves in old age.

StatisticallyChallenged · 26/08/2021 09:15

I hate the generational arguments too. People who are entitled to a good old style final salary scheme are fortunate compared to most who follow them but they haven't done anything wrong and don't deserve the anger.

knittingaddict · 26/08/2021 09:08

[quote Fancymice]@knittingaddict I know there are some people these days that fritter money and consequently can't buy a house, but there are others, like me & my partner, who live frugally and still can't afford a house. Most of our furniture is second hand, all appliances we've had to buy are the cheapest we can get, we never go abroad and have had one holiday in the past three years, we don't drink at all apart from Xmas, we don't smoke, we eat cheap food (everything from scratch, lentils featuring heavily) and yet home ownership is not possible. We also both have a second part time job. The sheer amount we pay in rent takes a huge chunk of money, and makes it very hard to save. In contrast, my dad at my age has a mortgage on his own for a small flat in the south east and then met my mum and they were able to move in a few years into a 3 bed semi in the south West. My dad worked in a factory and my mum was a nurse, in a comparable job skill levels to me and dp now. They had to live frugally because of interest rates, but at least they had the opportunity to be property owners despite being working class. Now in their 60s they have paid off the mortgage. I feel like for my generation, even if we do everything right on paper and go to university and work hard it's still not enough to accomplish having a decent standard of living owning your own home. I know it's anecdotal, but personally, I feel like gen x and millenials have been dealt a bad hand.

I'm not saying I agree with the OPs novel ideas for wealth redistribution, but it gets very tiresome sometimes the trope that we're just not trying hard enough.[/quote]
I appreciate all that. My daughter has just bought her first home with her partner. It would have taken her longer if we hadn't been in a position to gift them some money.

What I was demonstrating was that we had to work for our step onto the property ladder too. It wasn't handed it to us on a plate, which is what people like the op always seem to think happened. We've lived through the 15% plus interests rates and negative equity and many didn't keep the houses they had worked so hard for.

I just hate threads like this which pitch one generation against another. We had no help from our parents to buy our own homes, but we have helped our children to do so. We aren't evil people and yet these threads keep coming.

Kithic · 26/08/2021 08:48

You have no idea how private pensions work. They are not paid by the government. The government pay 137 a week (I think). Private pensions are paid by the company/employees and they pay into a fund.

Yes, there are tax breaks for paying in.
Yes there used to be final salary pensions - however these have mostly be phased out due to cost. Defined benefit

Now we are more likely to have it based on how big your pot is (what you have paid in) defined contribution.

I worked in pensions previously, but am a little rusty.

Kithic · 26/08/2021 08:43

@Blindering

''If you already have a house OP why don't you downsize to a flat and donate the money to some poor young person for a deposit. It's the least you can do when you feel the system is so unfair.''

I have a 1 bed flat. I got it cheap as it needed a lot of repair work and still does.

Yesterday 16:57 Blindering

''I'd rather the government spent the money on pensions than a shite water rafting facility in the middle of Dublin.''

I meant it as in help the younger generation get on the property ladder. BTW I have a house.

House or flat??

nellly · 26/08/2021 08:40

@Blindering

''OP. It’s none of your business anyway.''

it is everybody's business how the govt spend tax money.

Surely most of what you're talking about isn't tax money though it's his private pension he payed into FROM HIS WAGES
Kithic · 26/08/2021 08:38

@Blindering

''The stage of life when you've worked for 40 years and now are free to do what you want? I can think of loads to do with it. |''

and the entire generation below them can't afford housing because the govt is paying whopper pensions to older generation.

The government aren't paying these amounts in pensions. Higher pensions are due to the job/company the person did.
SilverGlitterBaubles · 26/08/2021 08:38

Bergrudgery at its finest. Wanting others to get less doesn't necessarily mean that others like you will get more.

lotsofdogshere · 26/08/2021 08:33

I worked from age 17 - 62. I always paid so called full stamp. Older women in my first job advised me not to fall for the married women’s stamp con.
I had 2 years off in 1972 when my first baby was born. Mat leave didn’t exist, I wfh typing to make ends meet. Various jobs in retail/offices that fit round school /parents help. Then 40 years in public service. I paid extra into the pension scheme, from what was a very low starting salary.

I get a decent pension from work. It must be awful to try and manage on our state pension. I wouldn’t be able to do anything other than just about manage. My two dogs - couldn’t afford them. Couldn’t help my adult children -
These attempts to divide generations seem often based on false distorted views. Yes my generation were more likely to be able to save a deposit, house prices are ludicrous. Social housing supply devastated by right to buy and councils not allowed to use thst cash to build more. No one. I know supported that

Whycangirlsbesonasty · 26/08/2021 08:28

Can I also add that having invested into a civil service pension scheme and a state scheme, the amount you as an employee pay in vs the amount you get out, the civil service scheme is about 3 x s more generous. So yes you do pay into a civil service scheme, but the amount you pay in is fairly pitiful compared to the amount you would have to pay in to get the same benefit in a defined contribution scheme.

NotMyCat · 26/08/2021 07:55

@Blindering

''Not everyone that age will have a paid off mortgage.''

eh I struggle to think of anybody in their mid 70s still paying a mortgage.

My parents are 71 and renting... no paid off mortgage
PearlyBird · 26/08/2021 07:27

@Blindering

''So they took action for New Entrants. They took appropriate action imo.''

no appropriate action would have being cuts for all.

That is daft.

Do you not grasp that a contribution ihas been taken from their salary for their pension, every week/fortnight for 40 years (sometimes) or more? They can only use 40 years' service but the contributions have been taken for more than 40 years if they worked more than 40 years. It"s agreed, signed in contracts et cetera..

There is nothing to stop you paying in to a pension fund of your own though op.

I keep meaning to do this. Not sure if civil servants on the single scheme can get AVCs but I suppose, why wouldnt they take your business.

NoSquirrels · 26/08/2021 06:43

@Blindering

''So they took action for New Entrants. They took appropriate action imo.''

no appropriate action would have being cuts for all.

One more time for luck:

say you save into an interest-bearing account, how would you feel if someone came along when you were about to retire and said there was more money in there than you needed, so decided to take some to distribute to others.

Would you be happy with that?

MrsClatterbuck · 26/08/2021 02:44

@titchy
And when he goes into a care home he'll be paying for it himself. Unlike those selfish fuckers who made no pension provision and have their care costs paid for by the tax payer (which includes your neighbour

THIS

JustLyra · 26/08/2021 02:18

@Blindering

''So they took action for New Entrants. They took appropriate action imo.''

no appropriate action would have being cuts for all.

So, if it was decided that your salary was to be cut and that included an amount cut from the last few years as well you’d be happy with that?

Because that’s what you’re suggesting - part of the remuneration package that was agreed and worked for be retrospectively cut…

saltinesandcoffeecups · 26/08/2021 02:03

@Blindering

''So they took action for New Entrants. They took appropriate action imo.''

no appropriate action would have being cuts for all.

So I’m going to presume you are still working. If someone comes along and changes the rules, you have what 20, 30, 40 years to adjust. What happens if you have 0 years to plan for those cuts?

Might I suggest you take your earning power, time, and energy and focus them on learning about investments, saving, and the power of compound interest. In the meantime, get your nose out of your neighbor’s finances and focus on yourself. You have a lot to learn about personal finance and empathy.

Blindering · 26/08/2021 00:58

''So they took action for New Entrants. They took appropriate action imo.''

no appropriate action would have being cuts for all.

OP posts:
PearlyBird · 25/08/2021 23:55

I don't believe her parents were civil servants. No adult child of two old school servants thinks that their parents lump sums harmed them.

Also, her gripe is decades out of date! When troika (?) came in to Ireland after the crash, they did identity fhat civil servants' pensions were a big expense so they changed it going forward but they people who entered in to the pre 95 system, if they retire with forty years' they get half their final salary and a lump sum of 1.5 times their salary. That's what they''ve been paying in to all along.

It has been made less generous for new entrants MORE THAN ONCE since 1995.

So they took action for New Entrants. They took appropriate action imo. But they can't renege on the pensions owed to the pre 95 ers.

wewereliars · 25/08/2021 23:49

Firsttwelve people whoare on public sector salaries do pay in to them. A substantial deducton from salary every month.

echt · 25/08/2021 23:48

At some point the OP will say they were talking about Irish pensions all along.........

ithinkilikeit · 25/08/2021 23:46

I am also waiting with bated breath for my answer about whether generational wealth of the White British will be shared with ethnic minorities. OP is very selective with their answers aren’t they Grin. Seems like they avoid anything that debunks their ridiculous logic.

PearlyBird · 25/08/2021 23:44

What's your beef here? Civil servants' pensions specifically? Or just ......... other people have more.

Believe me, I get it. I'm a member of the single scheme. My civil service pension will top up the state pension by about four grand. Whoop.

But the pre-95 ers paid contributions in to the ''pot'' and no deductions were taken for a state pension. so this is the product they PAID FOR.

They changed the system quite a while before the crash. 1995 civil service pensions got less generous and then in 2004 they made it so that 60 was an actuarially reduced pension.

Not sure what your point is tbh but if you'd paid for a financial product you'd want to see that ''crystalised''' wouldn't you?

echt · 25/08/2021 23:42

@Firstwelive

State pension - no sorry, elderly people no matter who, should receive basic living income

Defined benefit/final salary govt pension - yes absolutely they should completely scrap them, stop paying retirees out of current taxpayers revenue, and turn all these schemes into contributory ones I.e. get what you pay into it. And the govt should then contribute more for teachers, firemen, nurses, etc. See above for state pension provision.

People did pay into the pensions they receive.