Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say this to parents of only children

622 replies

LBirch02 · 25/08/2021 08:51

There are loads of only child threads here and especially parents feeling guilty about having and only child.

Well if anyone’s in this position I just wanted to say:

Children don’t need siblings and only children aren’t necessarily any different from children with brothers and sisters

I hope this helps at least one person

OP posts:
EmergencyHydrangea · 25/08/2021 10:57

Yes I find a sibling relationship more forgiving and honest than friendship. We can be really blunt with each other without offence being taken. If one of us wears something which looks awful, we can just tell each other and not be offended. We can call each other up to rant about our husbands and kids without even asking how the other one is grin and we don't take offence. In a friendship though, you have to be much more careful what you say.

I do all of this with my close friends. I also have eight siblings, haven't seen any of them for years

Imnewhere1991 · 25/08/2021 10:57

@mam0918

I was an only child for a decade - I HATED it and was very maladjusted and struggled to intergrate with other kids dispite being havily socialised (sent to day care and clubs etc...).

My friends who are only children are wierd. I love them but theres zero denying they have some issue with things like sharing or not getting their own way. Of course THEY arent aware of it though and think they are acting normal like everyone else but trust me everyone else notices, without knowing you would assume they are just a bit narcassistic.

My oldest was an only child for a decade due to infertility. It was fucking awful, the world is built for 2+ child families he was often the odd one out it was horrific to watch as a parent and frustraiting too. I would have given pretty much anything to give him a sibling and I now watch my children playing together and its the greatest thing in the world.

There's too much here to unpick. Confused
mam0918 · 25/08/2021 10:56

I was an only child for a decade - I HATED it and was very maladjusted and struggled to intergrate with other kids dispite being havily socialised (sent to day care and clubs etc...).

My friends who are only children are wierd. I love them but theres zero denying they have some issue with things like sharing or not getting their own way. Of course THEY arent aware of it though and think they are acting normal like everyone else but trust me everyone else notices, without knowing you would assume they are just a bit narcassistic.

My oldest was an only child for a decade due to infertility. It was fucking awful, the world is built for 2+ child families he was often the odd one out it was horrific to watch as a parent and frustraiting too. I would have given pretty much anything to give him a sibling and I now watch my children playing together and its the greatest thing in the world.

Anordinarymum · 25/08/2021 10:55

@TheWholeJingbang

We are all valid

Love from a bossy eldest child 🙌

You are so right

As I get older I feel less valid. Nowt to do with siblings or lack of

Cocomarine · 25/08/2021 10:54

It’s all just too individual to call 🤷🏻‍♀️

Me, 1 of 5. None of us share well - we learned, you grab and you keep it. End of.

Daughter, 1 of 1. Doesn’t even need to be asked - will offer things up. Has never had something taken away by a sibling and is very free with her possessions.

But actually there are other differences.
We didn’t have much growing up - damn right we wouldn’t give up what we had. My child - has loads, doesn’t care.

Me - brought up with, “you MUST share”, seeing it as a forced and unfair thing. My child - brought up that we own our possessions and whilst it’s nice to share, we can choose. But, if there’s something we don’t want to share, we put it away. Sharing is nice, a choice, not forced.

My German friend said she found her experience moving to the U.K. with a toddler interesting. Her personal experience was that toddler parents in U.K. would wrestle toys off their upset kids to give to any demanding child who’d taken an interest. In her German group, she said the norm was to tell the interested child, “ah, but Hans has that right now - so maybe you can have it later. How about this giraffe?”

Seriouslymole · 25/08/2021 10:54

Just to add another view - I’m not an only child but my younger sibling has very severe learning disabilities. I have now to deal with his needs alongside elderly parents as well as my own family- so you know, siblings do not always equal an easier existence.

Trebormints74 · 25/08/2021 10:54

Fuck off @Fiddliestofsticks

peachgreen · 25/08/2021 10:51

Just to add, I have a sibling but my true sibling-like relationship is actually with my cousin.

Sandinmyknickers · 25/08/2021 10:51

@Fiddliestofsticks

I have 2 kids. All their friends with siblings understand the word no, and they dont storm off in a huff when they're here in a group and someone says no to their movie suggestion or game idea. All the only children are a nightmare. Never heard the word, never had to share attention, and cannot stand it when their friends say no to their movie choice.

Only children do, quite often, have different traits.

I always find it really odd that this is the stereotype. As an only child, I would say that if anything I learned to share better and at anearlier age than my peers with siblings who were always having to fight for attention, dominance, resources etc. Also, as an only, you don't have siblings to rely on to play with you, so you learn social skills likesharing and taking account of your friends' feelings early on, as otherwise you have no one to play with. Friends aren't obliged to spend time with you, unlike siblings, and can just walk away if you are a nightmare. So you learn to be a good friend and share. Not a generalisation, just one experience and some counter logic to yours.

Sounds like you just know some bad parents who have some spoiled childrenal and youve extrapolated some sort of link between that and the fact that they are onlies...

Givemebackmylilo · 25/08/2021 10:51

@Mousetown

Weird how so many people comment on the parents on only children allegedly not teaching their children how to share and be kind, but their own mothers didn’t teach them empathy and how not to be judgemental twats. 🤷‍♀️
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
FreekStar2 · 25/08/2021 10:50

Whatever your family situation is, you only ever know what you have. If you're an only child it's all you know, and vice versa. There are advantages to it and disadvantages. You might wish you had a sibling or if you have a sibling you might hate them- they might turn out to be a drug addict, a criminal, a murderer- you may fight over the inheritance, they may have married a loser who stole all their money.

There's no reason for anyone to feel guilty about having one child. They are unlikely to end up alone- they will hopefully marry and have children of their own long before you die!

TractorAndHeadphones · 25/08/2021 10:50

@spittycup

If you know how to make friends properly then they don’t come and go. They stick around. I think there is a huge divide on MN between ppl who have and know how to make friends and those who don’t and as such rely on siblings.

Never the same. If I fell out with my brother there would always be forgiveness no matter what because I only have one brother/he only had one sister. Not the same with friends.

We have the same life experience and it's irreplaceable and always worth salvaging. That's just the truth for most family

Not that friends literally come and go and I knew someone would take it the wrong way.

How do you know that it’s the truth for ‘most family’? Given the amount of threads with people going NC, people who haven’t spoken to siblings in years etc etc. Your own experiences and feelings are perfectly valid but then again so are other people’s. I’d say in Asian culture it’s probably true (because duty to family is very ingrained in the culture, even at the expense of one’s own happiness) . But not in Britain. Again I could be wrong but the point is there isn’t any evidence either way. So it’s impossible to say ‘siblings good’ full stop
Givemebackmylilo · 25/08/2021 10:49

@Comedycook

Also having siblings or not affects future generations. As I had a sibling, my DC now have cousins and we are all really close and it just adds an extra dimension to their life
5 siblings combined between DH and I.

Our DS has no siblings so that's a bit of a generalisation

Saoirse82 · 25/08/2021 10:49

@Fiddliestofsticks

I have 2 kids. All their friends with siblings understand the word no, and they dont storm off in a huff when they're here in a group and someone says no to their movie suggestion or game idea. All the only children are a nightmare. Never heard the word, never had to share attention, and cannot stand it when their friends say no to their movie choice.

Only children do, quite often, have different traits.

This is total BS! I know several only children and they are absolutely lovely. Bad behaviour is more likely down to personality or parenting rather than being an only child.
pollylocketpickedapocket · 25/08/2021 10:48

@Starjammer

Also given how many posts on here are from mothers who are beaten down by parenting, I think some people would have done well to stop at one. I'd rather parent one child well than struggle with three and be knackered and short-tempered all the time.
This.
Cocomarine · 25/08/2021 10:47

@toomuchlaundry mine is an only AND she has to deal with a step sibling and moving between homes!

Perhaps that’s compounded her already shit lonely life.

Perhaps it has counterbalanced it and provided the joy (and apparently, learning to share stuff) of a sibling…

Who knows? 😆

This week:

  • I felt sad because I went to a trampoline park with her, and I know I’m not as good a bounce companion as another 13yo
  • I mentioned to her that I’ve long been interested in fostering. She said that would be great, and when she’s 18, I should get an 8yo, because that would be cute

So - not that foster children should be treated as insta-siblings but, kind of showed she isn’t as bothered about her only status as I am! (And I’m not, massively)

Athers666 · 25/08/2021 10:47

Such an unfair stereotype that only children can't share and all those with siblings magically can. How many kids with multiple siblings can't wait their turn, snatch toys from others etc? Yes, plenty! As others have said, how they are parented is the issue, not how many brothers they've got.

Hugoslavia · 25/08/2021 10:46

I have friends who are only children and know lots of only children. I think that the biggest myth is that they grow up to be spoilt and can't share. Emphatically untrue!

Progress2019 · 25/08/2021 10:44

My husband is an only child, of not doting parents. He’s completely well rounded, has has the same best friends since he was 9, and they are part of a bigger group. He’s far more social than me, but is also happy in his own company. He’s a fantastic father to two children, adores our pets, and dealt with the death of his parents admirably. He's hard working, a great father, and does more than his share of cooking and housework.

I have brothers, and am selfish, lazy and argumentative.

Having siblings isn’t the be all and end all.

Comedycook · 25/08/2021 10:43

@spittycup

If you know how to make friends properly then they don’t come and go. They stick around. I think there is a huge divide on MN between ppl who have and know how to make friends and those who don’t and as such rely on siblings.

Never the same. If I fell out with my brother there would always be forgiveness no matter what because I only have one brother/he only had one sister. Not the same with friends.

We have the same life experience and it's irreplaceable and always worth salvaging. That's just the truth for most family

Not that friends literally come and go and I knew someone would take it the wrong way.

Yes I find a sibling relationship more forgiving and honest than friendship. We can be really blunt with each other without offence being taken. If one of us wears something which looks awful, we can just tell each other and not be offended. We can call each other up to rant about our husbands and kids without even asking how the other one is Grin and we don't take offence. In a friendship though, you have to be much more careful what you say.
toomuchlaundry · 25/08/2021 10:42

@spittycup I think you are being very naive, might be the case with your sibling, but many siblings fall out and never meet again, or if they do it is acrimoniously. Siblings can come and go, just like friends

Mousetown · 25/08/2021 10:42

Weird how so many people comment on the parents on only children allegedly not teaching their children how to share and be kind, but their own mothers didn’t teach them empathy and how not to be judgemental twats. 🤷‍♀️

TractorAndHeadphones · 25/08/2021 10:41

@BackInBlackAgain

It is different though. I had 3 children who were close in age, they are all adults now and have left home. But as children they played together, on the playstation or with games.

When i turned 40 i had a DD, who is now 8 and she is the only child still living at home. She is lonely. She is bored at home. She has what she wants electronics wise, but it is human interaction she wants, i play with her and interact with her as much as i can but its not enough. She openly admits that she would have loved a sibling close in age to her. She is jealous of the close bond her older siblings have and how they had each other growing up (even though they fought like cat and dog most of the time).

Your daughter’s feelings are perfectly valid. However :
  1. She has seen a positive example of her older siblings having a close bond
  2. She doesn’t seem to have any friends

Both of which yes, understandably make her long for siblings.
But these aren’t default conditions for everybody.
Unless someone has commissioned a statistical survey and determined that the ‘majority’ of siblings would have played together etc , or that the ‘majority’ of only children are lonely there’s no decision either or.

We are all shaped by our experiences but they will only be anecdotal evidence. They can’t be used to argue for or against the general population.

DoubleShotEspresso · 25/08/2021 10:41

@Fiddliestofsticks

I have 2 kids. All their friends with siblings understand the word no, and they dont storm off in a huff when they're here in a group and someone says no to their movie suggestion or game idea. All the only children are a nightmare. Never heard the word, never had to share attention, and cannot stand it when their friends say no to their movie choice.

Only children do, quite often, have different traits.

What a fucking disgraceful post Confused
spittycup · 25/08/2021 10:40

If you know how to make friends properly then they don’t come and go. They stick around. I think there is a huge divide on MN between ppl who have and know how to make friends and those who don’t and as such rely on siblings.

Never the same. If I fell out with my brother there would always be forgiveness no matter what because I only have one brother/he only had one sister. Not the same with friends.

We have the same life experience and it's irreplaceable and always worth salvaging. That's just the truth for most family

Not that friends literally come and go and I knew someone would take it the wrong way.

Swipe left for the next trending thread