Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nirvana baby to sue…

281 replies

Toffu · 25/08/2021 08:38

I’ve just read an article about the man who’s photo as a baby was used on the cover of Nevermind.

He is planning to sue the band for violating pornography laws and claims that his parents never signed a release allowing Nirvana to use the photo.

He alleges Nirvana "used child pornography depicting Spencer as an essential element of a record promotion scheme commonly utilized in the music industry to get attention, wherein album covers posed children in a sexually provocative manner to gain notoriety, drive sales, and garner media attention, and critical reviews." He says he’s suffered and will co it is to suffer lifelong damages.

While a lot of people (judging by online comments) seem to think it’s a money grab, I’m inclined to agree with him. Imagine if Michael Jackson or Take That had done this? Is it considered ok because it’s rock music, an arty shot and he’s a boy? Am I being unreasonable to think actually it’s really not ok?

OP posts:
CuriousaboutSamphire · 25/08/2021 09:42

@Heckythump1

I've never seen the album before, but from a quick google, it's quite clearly his foot not his genitals. Nothing wrong with that photo at all!
Sorry!?!?! How big do you think his left foot is??

Or do you think he jas 2 knees?

CuriousaboutSamphire · 25/08/2021 09:40

@Howshouldibehave

So, did his parents consent to the photo?
Yes. They were friends of the photographer and were there, fully consenting, apparently happy with the idea and the image.
Heckythump1 · 25/08/2021 09:40

I've never seen the album before, but from a quick google, it's quite clearly his foot not his genitals. Nothing wrong with that photo at all!

Hemingwaycat · 25/08/2021 09:40

So, did his parents consent to the photo?

Yes, they were paid $200.

Hemingwaycat · 25/08/2021 09:39

He wants money. This is from a 2016 article in Time.

Frustrated about never receiving any sort of compensation for Nevermind, Elden recently looked into pursuing legal action against Geffen Records, but was unsuccessful. “It’s hard not to get upset when you hear how much money was involved,” he says.

He also says he still lives with his parents and drives a Honda Civic. He has a large chest tattoo that says ‘Never Mind’ and he’s recreated the album cover as an adult. He isn’t mentally scarred by this, he’s broke and wants some money.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 25/08/2021 09:38

OMG!

When do we gather up all the putto and burn those dastardly paintings?

And yes... The prophesy of the baby clutching for money appears to have come true.

He had 2 choices:

Shut up and kep quiet about being the baby pictured

Shout about it and make himself known

He chose the latter, and made money, kudos from it. He is forever connected not to some shameful image but a groundbreaking album. That he wishes to reframe it as indecent is sod all to do with the intent - of the band, photographer or his parents!

How the fuck is it exploitation?

www.loudersound.com/features/why-have-facebook-banned-led-zeppelins-houses-of-the-holy-artwork

Blind Faith were 'worse' - though I like the idea that the model asked for a horse as payment!

www.vintag.es/2018/08/mariora-goschen.html

Howshouldibehave · 25/08/2021 09:37

So, did his parents consent to the photo?

category12 · 25/08/2021 09:36

I think it's weird and fucked up to look at that photo of a naked baby and say it's sexualised - it is not. It's not posed to titillate.

Being naked does not equal sexualised unless you're a bloody freak.

CatJumperTwat · 25/08/2021 09:34

I'd like to know what lifelong damages he's claiming to have suffered!

CutePanda · 25/08/2021 09:32

@TheViewFromTheCheapSeats

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/nypost.com/2016/09/23/nirvana-baby-recreates-iconic-album-cover-25-years-later/amp/

Well he’s a 2016 article showing him personally trafficking the image himself 🤷‍♀️

He’s recreated it a few times and given loads of interviews, surely if it is child peon he’s still guilty of trafficking and promoting it himself…

I agree. Why has he suddenly changed his stance? Oh wait, money.

I disagree with OP. The album cover is not sexualising a baby. If you think it is then there’s something wrong with you.

StormzyinaTCup · 25/08/2021 09:32

@TacoSunday

The prophesy of the baby clutching for money appears to have come true.
Was about to post exactly the same Tacosunday
MumofSpud · 25/08/2021 09:29

It is ironic that
a) the image is of a baby chasing money
b) he says that the image and his name are forever linked but the only reason people know it is him is that he tells people!

EmpressSuiko · 25/08/2021 09:29

@Toffu

“Someone clearly wants money and attention”

Like the band did when they used his naked photo to get these things?

I have the album, when I bought it as I teen I didn’t pay any attention to the cover, it was just a baby swimming, I bought the album for the music!

This is so clearly a money grab, if he had always voiced discomfort over the image it would be completely different but he has forced himself into the limelight over the image time and time again, he has been proud of being the baby on their album cover but now he suddenly has an issue with it?

OchNoAgain · 25/08/2021 09:28

Whilst I get it's not a competition, it feels extremely crass given the huge numbers of children involved in the making of child abuse images/sexual abuse situations that are horrific beyond the imagination of most of us. Many of them are dirt poor and being sold by their own families in order to survive. I'll reserve my sympathies for them I think. 🤷🏻‍♀️

TheViewFromTheCheapSeats · 25/08/2021 09:23

I’m surprised at the time looking back we were all immature teenagers when this came out, many friends had the poster, yet none of us actually ever seemed to notice or comment on the penis. Genuinely hadn’t really noticed it before, just that it was generally a naked baby.

EmergencyHydrangea · 25/08/2021 09:23

A naked baby is not automatically pornographic ffs!

SchrodingersImmigrant · 25/08/2021 09:23

@SmidgenofaPigeon

He’s been trying to do this for years and years hasn’t he? I guess he found a lawyer who’ll take it on.
I actually checked the date of the thread because I am pretty sure I read about this few years back
Seasonschange · 25/08/2021 09:23

@DottyHarmer

If Nirvana had been unsuccessful and faded away and Kurt Cobain still with us today living in Seattle playing in a wedding band, would the guy still be suing? That’s what I always think when people sue Disneyworld or McDonald’s. Why should your case be better because the object of your complaint is rich?

Agree too that who would recognise this guy? If he turned up on my doorstep today I’d hardly gasp and cry, “You’re that baby from Nevermind!”

If Nirvana had faded into obscurity that picture would have as well. I think it’s relevant that it’s still a very iconic imagine today.
LittleBearPad · 25/08/2021 09:23

@Blinkingheckythump

I honestly thought it was his other foot. He's just trying to get his hands on cash, which is rather funny considering the message behind the photo
Well quite!
ElliottSmithsfingers · 25/08/2021 09:22

He's drawn attention to himself for years (otherwise nobody would have known it was him) and this is a total money grab. It's a naked baby fgs, it's in the same realm as a sexual image as a breastfeeding woman i.e. not at all.

TheViewFromTheCheapSeats · 25/08/2021 09:22

@LawnFever more than twice! He first did at 10- he’s really really dined out on being the Nirvana baby!

MurielSpriggs · 25/08/2021 09:21

The music industry is awash with people who made (or whose representatives made ) bad deals for them. And also record companies who lost loads of money on projects that flopped. You sign the contract and that's that. His dad got £200 apparently, and was presumably quite happy at the time. It's not like babies were in short supply.

Wrongsideofhistorymyarse · 25/08/2021 09:21

There are issues around consent - his parents were paid for an image which has been reproduced millions of times. I'd like to think that, if this cover had been shot recently, the baby would have been wearing something.

He should be suing his parents, IMO. But I expect they don't have megabucks, hence going after Nirvana.

DottyHarmer · 25/08/2021 09:20

If Nirvana had been unsuccessful and faded away and Kurt Cobain still with us today living in Seattle playing in a wedding band, would the guy still be suing? That’s what I always think when people sue Disneyworld or McDonald’s. Why should your case be better because the object of your complaint is rich?

Agree too that who would recognise this guy? If he turned up on my doorstep today I’d hardly gasp and cry, “You’re that baby from Nevermind!”

Toffu · 25/08/2021 09:18

*twas ever thus

OP posts: